Suggestion: Art Shift

The current is ok but it doesnt really show off it is the same person clearly as well as doesn't have a variety of Artshifting.

How about 4 instead? [1][2][3][4]

edited 11th Feb '17 7:32:51 AM by Memers

The suggestion does make it more clear that it's the same character throughout the shifts, so I'm down with it.

The shoujo word in the caption is screwed up, though; it needs to be fixed.

edited 11th Feb '17 8:52:31 AM by Gosicrystal

Yeah that is a problem with the site I believe, I type "Shojo" and it comes out "Shōjo". It is probably trying to put in the accent "ō" in to make Shōjo, which is how you are suppose to spell it if you are not being lazy.

edited 11th Feb '17 8:58:26 AM by Memers

Suggestion looks more like Art Evolution. We want to see a sudden shift from one distinctive style to another. Current is not illustrative either.

Not really, those art styles are super distinctive and even the series that have been airing for 30 years that covered don't get that distinctive of an Art Evolution to match the fad.

We could mention its all from one episode. The first 3 were parts of one episode made in those specific artstyles just cause and the last one is from the ending done in the modern dark edgy styles.

EDIT: potentially use this as the first? this second?this as the third panel?

edited 11th Feb '17 9:12:16 AM by Memers

"We could mention its all from one episode. " — That's a qualifier

Any thoughts on the more close up versions of the art shifts?

• Order of the Stick
• Sinfest (last 2)◊

edited 12th Feb '17 5:29:32 AM by eroock

That would be better on Super-Deformed actually and I would support it there over the Hidamari Sketch one.

Also that's only 1 Art Shift.

edited 12th Feb '17 5:33:08 AM by Memers

My only concern with the OP is that it will probably cut into the examples list.

It would, but there's enough examples that I don't think it's going to make that big a difference. That said, the OP could possibly be turned into a 2 x 2 with some judicious cropping.

I agree that @10 a better illustration of Super-Deformed than the one currently on that page.

As for the OP, it'd probably need a caption to say that it's all from the same episode, otherwise it'd look like Art-Shifted Sequel. Also, if the height is an issue, just remove one of the panels.

for OP (resized in 2x2)

edited 14th Feb '17 11:56:45 AM by rafi

I agree that a 2x2 grid would be better.

17

"And this is one episode."

17 + 20 works for me.

"I am in despair, the fact that they spent the entire episode shifting my artstyle around has left me in despair!"

edited 21st Feb '17 8:06:28 PM by Memers

Okay, that's perfect.

Since we've got general consensus for the concept of the new pic and the 2x2 fits the page better, I'm going ahead and calling it. The new pic's up and tagged, and I'll add in the latest caption idea shortly. Locking up.

Old pic: