Changed w/o discussion: Western Animation.All Dogs Go To Heaven

Forgive me if this looks a little weird; this is literally my first time creating an Image Pickin' thread. Anyway...

On All Dogs Go to Heaven, the page image was removed. The only reason given by the Troper who removed the image, enya, was, and I quote, "1. not the movie poster. 2. you silly sallies". I don't remember there being a discussion about it. Was the removal legitimate?

It probably should've had an IP thread made, but it's not a very good pic to start with.

Still not worth a pull, and being a (movie) poster in in no way an requirement.

(and frankly if one pulls an image for "1. not the movie poster." one should add the movie poster.)

edited 8th Jun '14 11:05:50 PM by m8e

Poster image◊ without the text.

4 is the best one I see here, for the glowing colours if nothing else.

That is good.

Here's an uncropped version: http://www.impawards.com/1989/all_dogs_go_to_heaven.html

Clock is set.

I'm good with either 4 or 7.

I lean toward 4.

I say 4 as well.

I prefer 7, but either works.

OP: Does not look weird. Thanks.

Crowner: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/ImagePickin/AllDogsGo?open=all#o7q6ivkz

edited 1st Jul '14 2:27:32 AM by rodneyAnonymous

Hooked.

The reason I linked to the full poster concerns the fact that the cropped version posted doesn't show Charlie's halo.

Added a different crop of the poster:

That's got a good composition.

That's the best one overall.

Perfect.

Yes.

Bump for votes; if the ratio holds steady or improves I'll call this tomorrow.

This is ready to call. I've swapped in the new pic, culled the caption, and tagged the page. Add a caption if you want one; locking up in the meantime.