Poor Image: Sweet Tooth

Quality is iffy at best, and it shouldn't be too hard to replace. I like this one.

Proposed replacement is an improvement, quality-wise.

Works for me.

It's a lateral move for content, quality is a boost so it's a for me.

I like the current one better even if it have a lower image quality. The OP is just a 'sweet' themed image with some girl, and the pink hearts doesn't help.

And the current is better than the suggestion why? I am not seeing it.

Basically, what I'm seeing is a lot of hearts and a girl posing with cupcakes.

I see that, plus a spoon, in the current too. Same for lu's suggestion, except for the dirty mouth instead of a spoon.

The suggestion has higher quality, but I find the current more interesting and makes it clearer that it's a character who really like sweets rather than someone just being cute.

edited 4th Dec '13 12:23:41 PM by AnotherDuck

I think you want "The suggestion has higher quality..."

I think you want to refresh the page before making a response.

Here's a higher quality version of the current:

Honestly, the clutter in the replacement suggestion leads me to it; the improved version of the current gets my .

The simple quality swap looks good to me.

Suger monster◊

Licking candy off lips◊

Homer binge◊

Homer and Donut doll◊

And the classic Homer enjoying Hell◊

While the suggested quality improvement for the current is higher-quality, I can't help but think it looks a bit vertically-stretched (or horizontally-squished, depending on your vantage point).

edited 4th Dec '13 10:03:08 PM by ShadowHog

It does seem compressed, but that may just be due to the screen cap from either a standard or widescreen tv.

Out of all the suggestions for 14, I think 14.1 was the one that worked and would say it's better than what's there now and better than the retouched version of it. 14.2 is a stock image so an immediate no, 14.3 has too many things which aren't sugary, 14.4 is nice but doesn't tell the trope and 14.5 is okay but blurriness counts against it.

edited 5th Dec '13 12:15:06 AM by treelo

For now, 14.1 is my ultimate choice.

However, had I realized 14.2 was Stock, I wouldn't have listed it.

Its easy to find "sugar only" versions of 14.3 if you so desire.

And 14.5 is from the early days so... here is the toy◊ and a better yet, copyrighted cell◊

Homer's Land of Chocolate◊ hallucination.

Homer on a doughnut cake

Some pretty good options across the thread, might need to take it to a crowner but damn if it isn't so heavy on Homer's trademark food and general gluttony. The idea for the images is good but he doesn't represent Sweet Tooth to me, he's just a Big Eater and sweet foods are still food, not that he has a specific character-driven reason to like sweet stuff in general.

edited 5th Dec '13 1:49:18 AM by treelo

None of the Homer pics work for me, and I don't really like the Ranma pic because she looks more disgusted than excited (in my opinion, anyway). More suggestions: [1]◊[2]◊[3]◊[4]◊

20.2 gets broken by the forum, 20.3 doesn't lead to the image it should. Other than that, some are good but not topping 14.1 for me, definitely needs a crowner.

Your coffee beans on your teacup are showing

GIS for candy addiction, fix, sugar rush, etc. 1◊, 2◊, 3◊. 4◊

This topic is pretty hard to avoid stock images for.

edited 5th Dec '13 3:55:53 AM by Paktra

I'll be clear, NO to 22.3 but 22.1 and 22.4 are good.

Okay, crowner has been made, waiting for a hook and I might have missed a few suggestions but 17 is an awful lot so...

edited 5th Dec '13 4:41:44 AM by treelo

Crowner's hooked.

Gotta say, that Peppermint Patty pic is kinda gross.

edited 5th Dec '13 8:55:26 PM by Willbyr

Gotta say that both "Donut Hell" images are very close to the pic on Unishment.