Does Not Illustrate: Slap Slap Kiss

As the caption indicates, the image on Slap-Slap-Kiss is actually an example of its counterpart trope, Kiss-Kiss-Slap. So I suggest we move it there.

I think it sits in the middle of both. Not sure what to do with it.

It's more of a case of Slap Kiss Slap Kiss Slap Kiss Slap Kiss Slap.

Maybe the last two panels of this?

Well, Kiss-Kiss-Slap doesn't even have an image. I definitely think the current should be moved over there.

The Donald Duck isn't clearly either one. I say drop it or take away the last panel. The suggestion makes her look intentionally crazy instead of emotionally impulsive. Maybe that can still count but I don't think it looks as good.

Neither pair is this exactly, but roughly: Pabels 1 and 2 are Slap-Slap-Kiss, and Panels 2 and 3 are Kiss-Kiss-Slap. Either way it should lose one panel.

edited 27th Apr '13 10:20:07 PM by rodneyAnonymous

I like that idea: put frame 1 and 2 on the first trope, frame 2 and 3 on the second.

I'm asking the rest of the staff for opinions, considering it's playing around with the "one unique pic per trope page" rule...myself, I don't have an issue with the suggestion.

That was not my suggestion.

Maybe that's not the way you meant it but unless we have something better for either then I think we should go for it unless it breaks the "one unique pic per trope page" rule.

Whilst page pics should usually be unique because (a) it makes the wiki more interesting and (b) the same pic probably doesn't fit equally well on two pages, I think having corresponding images can be fun. This would be more overlap than other times (which I can't name off the top of my head), but that's part of the point.

What response I got was supportive, so if spreading the pic out over the two pages is the consensus decision, then it's fine.

In regards to corresponding images, that's what's happened with Mistaken for Cheating and O.O.C. Is Serious Business since they're taken from the same sequence in Questionable Content.

edited 29th Apr '13 3:54:02 AM by Willbyr

I think it works. It's not like the tropes are entirely unrelated, and the image does highlight somewhat different aspects. This is a case where order makes all the difference, and that is the difference.

Bump; any other thoughts on the proposal?

One last bump; if there aren't any serious objections or other suggestions then I'll go ahead and split the pics out per the suggestion.

Hearing nothing, I've split the pics over the two pages and tagged each accordingly. Add captions if you want them; locking up.