NSFW/Image Macro (CROWNER): Tabletop Game.Tomb Of Horrors

CLOSED

Image	Votes		Voters
New cover w/tomb◊	+8	-2	: Cobra Prime, Septimus Heap, Another Duck, Telcontar, Willbyr, nitrokitty, Ghilz	: Noaqiyeum, justanid
Classic moment #1◊	+5	-2	: Cobra Prime, Noaqiyeum, Ghilz, justanid	: Septimus Heap, Willbyr
New cover w/classic face◊	+3	-4	: Septimus Heap, Telcontar, nitrokitty	: Cobra Prime, Noaqiyeum, Ghilz, justanid
Classic moment #2◊	+3	-5	: Cobra Prime, nitrokitty, Ghilz	: Septimus Heap, Another Duck, Telcontar, Willbyr, Noaqiyeum
Original cover #1◊	+3	-6	: nitrokitty, Another Duck, tbarrie	: Septimus Heap, Willbyr, Noaqiyeum, Ghilz
Original cover #2◊	0	-7	: N/A	: Septimus Heap, Another Duck, Telcontar, Willbyr, nitrokitty, Noaqiyeum, Ghilz

edited 4th Apr '13 6:16:07 AM by Willbyr

You're right; pulling, and adding a note to the page.

I can't look at the D&D link right now, so: Is there a cover art for this expansion that we could put up? If so, and it's decent quality, I say put it up and we can knock this one out easy-peasy.

edited 26th Mar '13 2:01:40 PM by Willbyr

The original covers are◊ firmly meh◊

Of course there's the◊ versions◊ from other editions, since To H is a classic.

EDIT: Oooh, found an image that covers a classic moment of the tomb: 1◊ 2◊

edited 26th Mar '13 6:14:04 PM by Ghilz

I like the new cover and the "classic moment" 1.

Either of the newer covers work for me...the rest can go on an Image Links page.

Here is the second cover (which includes the "classic moment" face), a little larger (350 tall):

edited 26th Mar '13 6:54:26 PM by rodneyAnonymous

Works fine for me.

Personally it's probably my least favorite. I admit the reasons may not resonate to someone who doesn't know To H that well, but the tomb's fame comes from its Malevolent Architecture. The dungeon is the enemy. Really, to the point that when combat does erupt, it's almost a relief because its less dangerous than anything else: The traps, the Schmuck Bait, the puzzles, etc... This is a dungeon where you can lose your entire party just opening the first door. There's not that many monsters in the Tomb, and with the exception of Arcerak, the boss of the dungeon (Who is not the one on the picture), none of those monsters are what makes the Tomb a module so remembered and liked it's been reprinted and ported in all 4 editions of D&D.

edited 26th Mar '13 7:40:35 PM by Ghilz

I actually prefer the other of those two covers, between the two. But Ghilz's argument also sounds plausible.

^ Ghilz meant the other cover is better, too, I think.

Yup. Like that one, or either of the faces

Oh, my mistake - I thought you were arguing for one of the classic moments pictures specifically. :P

Moved to OP.

edited 30th Mar '13 2:31:44 PM by Willbyr

Classic Moment 1 & 2, New Cover with Tomb

New Cover with face

Neutral: Original covers

edited 28th Mar '13 7:25:52 AM by CobraPrime

on both new covers, on all others.

: New cover w/tomb.

Neutral: Classic moment #1, New cover w/face.

: Everything else.

edited 28th Mar '13 7:42:51 AM by AnotherDuck

Logged to here.

: Both new covers.

: Original cover #2 and classic moment #2.

Both new and classic moment 2

Old covers

Meh: The rest.

edited 28th Mar '13 10:48:18 AM by nitrokitty

Logged to here.

: New cover with tomb, Classic Moment #1

: Everything else

Logged.

Logged.

edited 28th Mar '13 2:18:02 PM by Willbyr

New cover with tomb, Classic Moment #1, Classic Moment 2

Everything else.

edited 28th Mar '13 2:11:02 PM by Ghilz

Bump for the weekend.