The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

The bit I figured was problematic was the fact that Shiina ends up having sex (and becoming pregnant) with whatshisface (who dies from radiation, but it's that kind of series)

What chapter of what series?

I went and flagged Nocturnal Illusion. Haven't examined the game and don't want to, but reviews suggest it's porn with epigraphs and a plot that doesn't really make sense except to set up fantasy-world scenarios in which Coitus Ensues. The reviewer on Something Awful noted that the underage sex scenes (which offended him deeply) were removed in one version, but it's easy to doubt the morals of a game in which "the only times [the protagonist] actually appears in the game are in occasional glimpses of his often-transparent erection" (to quote another review).

Someone who's played this game (or is willing to play it) should write it up in the standard VN format here.

edited 23rd Jun '12 2:06:57 PM by Prfnoff

Alright, I looked though the resolved list and got any missed sub-pages of cut pages cut. Expect for YMMV.Variable Geo and Ai No Kusabi's pages since those are up for vote again.

Also got VideoGame.Rance since that seemed to the decision. Sengoku Rance and Rance Quest are still up for vote.

@animeg 3282: He is referring to narutaru the event in question is at the end of chapter 66.

The manga Sundome was voted on to be cut for porn, but I flipped though about 100 pages of it and didn't see anything more explicit than the odd nipple here and there. Does anyone know about this?

Perhaps it exists through all of it. How many pages?

GIS without safe search turns up some questionable content, also the page is still up.

edited 23rd Jun '12 3:13:06 PM by Shadis

More importantly, someone jumped the gun there. It's resolved, but not done, not cut and not tagged on the discussion page.

I'll cutlist it.

edited 23rd Jun '12 3:24:04 PM by SeptimusHeap

It's 76 chapters long, and each chapter is about 20 pages, so about 1520 pages long. I flipped though another random chapter. It was more questionable, but still no explicit genitals or sex. Is this really cut-worthy?

By the way, I also went though and cutlisted any redirects to cut pages.

edited 23rd Jun '12 3:23:43 PM by KuroBaraHime

May not be cutworthy. Presuming it had an actual plot besides setting up for offscreen sex or something.

Just looked at the voting tool Fan Vid/Touhou has been flagged with one vote to cut,

the page has a nsfw warning for some videos but that means the page just needs cleaning right?

New thing flagged. Kanojo no Kagi wo Akeru Houhou.

From the same author as Chu-Bra? Wasn't that the one about the underwear design club or something similar?

Yeah that the one about the middle school girls in an underwear club.

Checking Kanojo out... Pantyshot sequence, two imagine spots of sex (boobs in full view, genitals are obscured), an un-Panty Shot, one more (actual detail is barbie-doll'd and mostly covered by skirt conveniently blown by the wind, but still), extended masturbation scene (even if it's again obscured... oh wait, on the last page of it it's only covered by her hands), two more pantyless shots (one is a full blown view of barbiedoll'd ass).

And that's just the first chapter.

6 pages of fluff like cover, contents and scanlator credits, 10 safe pages, 16 ecchi/porny pages.

edited 23rd Jun '12 5:10:24 PM by Adannor

That one was freaking weird. It was half pedo-pandering and half information brochure about underwear.

I just read 3 chapters of Sundome and... I don't think this is pornographic enough to be cut.

edited 23rd Jun '12 5:00:58 PM by KuroBaraHime

RE Kanojo whatever: What's the age of the characters?

^Couldn't find any statements of it. Doesn't look especially young to me, though.

Second chapter, the girl again loses her panties and masturbates using the male leads knee.

"Plot" seems to be just a build up to that routine of Going Commando, getting wet and getting off =_=

Adannor, would you mind PM'ing me a link to the Kanojo whatever? I have a feeling it will be cut and dry like Aki Sora was, this will just help it go a little faster.

edited 23rd Jun '12 5:28:03 PM by Discar

They seem to be about Japanese High School age so 16-18.

Well, at least it isn't middle-school like that other one, although the content seems to be racier.

PM'd. Those two chapters are the only ones to be found anywhere on the net.

...huh. Easy, yes, but not in the direction I thought. It's basically a high school sex comedy. Not really my taste, but still, not porn.

That being said, at only two chapters, its perfectly possible for it to get worse. So although I'm voting angel now, if it goes full-on porn in later chapters (and if it's brought to my attention; I'm not bookmarking this), then I'll switch votes.