The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Shortest review in this thread ever, right there.

Pagetopping makes it look like I'm pointing at empty air.

edited 19th Jun '12 12:21:58 PM by Parable

Meeble: There aren't any, so far as I know, but I don't see why information about a game that isn't Sengoku Rance matters when talking about that game. It's not really a matter of Sengoku Rance: I was surprised it wasn't cut in the first place. I just don't see why we're reversing a decision that was already made when no new information about it has come up. If, for example, someone had forgotten or lied about the game's content and there was pedo stuff, that'd be different, but since the information is the same reversing the decision doesn't seem right.

During the course of reviewing the franchise as a whole, including Sengoku Rance, I came to the conclusion that I made the wrong call originally. It was one of the first decisions I made as a panel member, and one that I probably didn't take enough time to fully consider. No one else in that thread was to blame, the fault was purely mine.

I messed up, made a mistake, and feel the need to correct that mistake. I don't see how that's any different from reversing myself after making a bad decision based on false/missing information.

On this I only speak for myself... if the other panel members feel differently, and the page stays, then that's fine.

That's honestly the best explanation I can give.

edited 19th Jun '12 12:45:41 PM by Meeble

Okay, is anyone here familiar with Daiteikoku? Going by our page and its entry on the AlicesoftWiki, it seems somewhat audacious, but not really such as to be flaggable.

edited 19th Jun '12 1:05:14 PM by Komodin

Don't know much about it, but FWIW, here is the VNDB page.

OK, I've gone down the Decisions and Announcements post and added a note with a link to that on the accessible discussion pages of the works that were cut, cutlisted a few missed subpages on these cut works and spotted a page-blanker. I'll go down the forum next, followed by the other pages in that post.

I'm the one who flagged Daiteikoku. I figured I might as well because:

1. Every other Alicesoft game we have a page on has been reviewed.
2. It's in the same series as Big Bang Age and Daiakuji, the former of which has been cut and the latter likely will be.
3. A lot of the CG is porn, including a lot of rape.

edited 19th Jun '12 1:22:35 PM by KuroBaraHime

OK so has anyone played this one?

@5554 The other two games in the series are Daiakuji, which has one demon vote for being pedobait; and Big Bang Age, which was cut for being pedobait. There are several suspiciously young girls on the character page, but I haven't played the game. VNDB has a 'loli herione' tag. Honestly, I'd just like to wipe all of Alicesoft's games off the wiki at this point, since none of them have passed the P5 test.

edited 19th Jun '12 1:25:58 PM by OjamajoLimePie

Do they involve any underage(-looking) individuals?

Yeah, there's a few girls that I'd guess were in their young teens. If they're not supposed to be, they're definitely short, flat-chested, with a young-drawn face.

Actually, Atlach=Nacha will probably pass. Ironically, it's the one Alicesoft game we have a page on with no English patch or one being worked on.

edited 19th Jun '12 1:32:20 PM by KuroBaraHime

I know these characters are main heroines: Katherine Retia

Just keep the page for it and remove the Alicesoft page?

edited 19th Jun '12 1:39:46 PM by OjamajoLimePie

Meeble: I'm afraid I can't support that kind of thinking. It seems make it so decisions aren't really finalized in any sense and can be easily changed. If no new information has come up, it shouldn't be back up for review.

Technically, I don't believe Daiakuji and Big Bang Age were in the same continuity, they were just similar. Daiteikoku pretty much can't be in the same continuity as Big Bang Age from what I know of it. As far as adult content goes, it's probably somewhere along the lines of the other Alicesoft stuff we've reviewed. I don't know if it has any underaged content.

^^ The latter looks old enough. I don't know about the first girl.

edited 19th Jun '12 1:38:56 PM by Arha

What about these? Mirja Femu Beko

...Please tell me they're not involved in any of the sex scenes...

When did Komo become a ninja?

edited 19th Jun '12 2:06:21 PM by TheFoxsCloak

5562:Know what? I would devilhead Daiteikoku if I could simply because you can bang a Hitler expy. No game in the universe should let you do that!

edited 19th Jun '12 2:06:24 PM by Sachiko

Yeah, those two look too young.

I'm sorry, but being able to literally Screw Hitler is not a criteria for deletion.

I know, I'm just having my 'WTF Japan!' moment of the day.

Both the girls in 5564 have sex scenes. I'm guessing that probably just about every female character in the game does.

... Welp.

Ladies and Gentlemen, do you know what time it is?

... Well?

Eeyup! It's Devilhead Time. Guess who's our lucky boy gonna be today...

Hopefully not the main character's daughter. She looks like a five year old. Not that some of the girls who do get H-scenes are any better. Did I ever mention that I reeeeeeally don't like Alicesoft?

edited 19th Jun '12 2:19:49 PM by OjamajoLimePie

Sachiko:go to the IJAM thread on WTFfanfiction if you want more WTF moments.

edited 19th Jun '12 2:17:55 PM by TheOneWhoTropes

I can see why...