Page Restoration Petitions

I agree, if the anime gets a page, it should stay locked and the manga stuff should be cut from it. The manga sexualizes Lotte in ways the anime just doesn't. There's no close up shots proving she's not wearing panties. There's no having her look at porn accidentally. The anime took out the paedobait in the manga.

The page if it is allowed must be locked though. I don't see any way around that.

edited 1st May '12 9:07:05 AM by shimaspawn

To be frank, I don't really care what happens to the work page. I just want some decision to be made so that we can move on to other stuff that needs attention.

@Shima It's all Played for Comedy, but I can see your point. Just as long as the banner is gone, I'll be happy. Sigh, Poe's Law is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

CthulhuTech has been cut after a unanimous decision that it's not porn. I'm not sure why, so I'm assuming it was an accident.

edited 1st May '12 9:25:59 AM by Arha

What does Poes law have to do with anything?

It's on the list of restored works next to Lolita, so I assume it was cut before review and will come back soon.

Indeed. The cutmasters got to it before the reviewers did.

The page in question still has a redlink, but the edit page button is now open. Running the page through the Wayback Machine has not given me anything. Does Fast Eddie still have the source for the page?

Are you talking about TabletopGame.Cthulhu Tech? It was just recently namespaced, the entire page content is in the history. It's still locked, though.

Strange. The link the 5P provided on the thread listing decisions is TabletopGames.Cthulhu Tech, which is not locked.

That's a typo. The namespace is Tabletop Game/. The trope is Tabletop Games.

edited 1st May '12 11:04:21 AM by lebrel

Well, someone needs to inform the 5P, then! Because I've copied the source onto my clipboard and want to restore this so that it can get its cleanup and lock.

edited 1st May '12 11:07:47 AM by TwoGunAngel

The P5 can't do anything about that. Only moderators edit that post. I made it Tabletop Game. Is it right now? I'll put it back if it's locked.

The link in the "decisions" post is now correct.

The page's still locked though. Only the mods can edit it. Who wants to do the honors?

I put it back.

Excellent. Re-added the entry on the Tabletop Games index page so that it shows up on the bottom (though to tell you the truth, it was already on there — I just needed to do a no-changes edit on the page).

edited 1st May '12 11:22:00 AM by TwoGunAngel

Cthulhu Tech should be restored, but not locked. It may need some cleanup though. I believe all four of us voted it "not porn."

For what it's worth, consider this my petition to restore Comics Nix. His oeuvre is so transparently designed as comedy, so insanely dedicated to Crossing the Line Twice and Refuge in Audacity, that it arguably merits the same kind of slack we'd cut for a show like Drawn Together, or a guy like Andy Kaufman.

EDIT: Wrong thread.

edited 2nd May '12 1:12:24 PM by HamburgerTime

edited 2nd May '12 1:13:06 PM by KaiserMazoku

edited 2nd May '12 1:14:02 PM by HamburgerTime

Neeever mind.

edited 2nd May '12 1:15:51 PM by Arha

Too early, sorry.

edited 3rd May '12 6:43:35 PM by HersheleOstropoler