Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheGoodWife

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
better example, I forgot he'd played Doran Martell


** A pre-''[[Series/TheMandalorian Mandalorian]]'' Creator/PedroPascal plays the state attorney fighting against Peter's appeal in "[[Recap/TheGoodWifeS1E08Unprepared Unprepared]]".

to:

** A pre-''[[Series/TheMandalorian Mandalorian]]'' pre-''Series/GameOfThrones'' Creator/PedroPascal plays the state attorney fighting against Peter's appeal in "[[Recap/TheGoodWifeS1E08Unprepared Unprepared]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A pre-''[[Series/TheMandalorian Mandalorian]]'' Creator/PedroPascal plays the state attorney fighting against Peter's appeal in "[[Recap/TheGoodWifeS1E08Unprepared Unprepared]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Creator/SonequaMartinGreen had a recurring role as Courtney Wells beginning in "Crash", years before her career-making role in ''Series/TheWalkingDead'' and then returning to CBS as Michael Burnham in ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''.

to:

** Creator/SonequaMartinGreen had a recurring role as Courtney Wells beginning in "Crash", years before her career-making role as Sasha Williams in ''Series/TheWalkingDead'' and then returning to CBS as Michael Burnham in ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Creator/SonequaMartinGreen had a recurring role as Courtney Wells beginning in "Crash", years before her career-making role in ''Series/TheWalkingDead'' and then returning to CBS as Michael Burnham in ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkHorse: Elsbeth Tascioni became an instant fan favorite for her quirky behaviour, NiceGirl personality and [[BunnyEarsLawyer surprising skill]] as an attorney, which lead to her returning in a bigger role on ''Series/TheGoodFight'' and, later, being given her own spin-off show, ''Elsbeth''.

to:

* EnsembleDarkHorse: Elsbeth Tascioni became an instant fan favorite for her quirky behaviour, NiceGirl personality and [[BunnyEarsLawyer surprising skill]] as an attorney, which lead to her returning in a bigger role on ''Series/TheGoodFight'' and, later, being given her own spin-off show, ''Elsbeth''.''Series/{{Elsbeth}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* MagnificentBastard:
** [[FemmeFatale Kalinda Sharma]], born [[MysteriousPast Leela Tahiri]], is Lockhart/Gardner’s investigator and plays a vital role in the vast majority of the cases the firm wins. Kalinda excels in using her charm, sexuality and acting skills to gain access to crime scenes, uncover evidence and track down witnesses. While showing UndyingLoyalty to her friends, Kalinda is [[PayEvilUntoEvil absolutely ruthless]] towards her enemies. She frames Blake Calamar for having an affair with drug kingpin Lemond Bishop’s wife, and Damien Boyle for having betrayed his former clients in the mob, forcing both men to leave town or be killed, and she is heavily implied to have murdered her abusive husband Nick Savarese. When Alicia Florrick and Cary Agos leave Lockhart/Gardner to form their own firm, Kalinda expertly [[PlayingBothSides plays both sides]], using Cary’s interest in hiring her to get a pay raise from Lockhart/Gardner, and manipulating Cary’s feelings for her to gain important information about Florrick/Agos. Kalinda brings about Bishop’s downfall by stealing the evidence needed to put him in prison from his computer, accomplishing in a matter of days what the authorities had failed to do for years, before calmly skipping town to avoid retribution. [[TheAce Unmatched in her field]], Kalinda proves her worth time and time again as one of Lockhart/Gardner’s most valuable employees, arguably even more so than their lawyers.
** [[TheDon Lemond Bishop]] is Chicago’s top drug kingpin and a top client of Lockhart/Gardner and later Florrick/Agos. A suave and eloquent man, Bishop has used his charisma and intelligence to remain one step ahead of the authorities for years, while establishing a chain of successful legitimate businesses with his drug money and making plans to retire from the game altogether. When Bishop suspects that there is a leak in Florrick/Agos, he cunningly [[FeedTheMole feeds the mole]] and correctly determines that Alicia’s phone is being tapped. Hiding a terrifying ruthlessness beneath his friendly demeanour, Bishop is implied to have ordered his wife’s death while [[MakeItLookLikeAnAccident making it look like a drug overdose]] to prevent her from gaining custody of their son in their divorce, intimidates witnesses, including his own sister, and is the only person shown to be capable of [[TheDreaded genuinely frightening]] Kalinda Sharma. When he is finally arrested, Bishop’s only concern is that [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes his son]] would have to witness this, as Bishop has endeavoured to [[EvilParentsWantGoodKids shield him from his criminal life]].
** [[AmoralAttorney Louis Canning]] is one of Lockhart/Gardner’s most frequent and brilliant adversaries. Canning defends pharmaceutical corporations from lawsuits for developing unsafe medicines, and employs many dirty tactics in court, his favorite of which is to [[DisabilityAsAnExcuseForJerkassery milk his tardive dyskinesia]] for sympathy from judges and juries. In his first appearance, despite being outargued in court, Canning gets the last laugh when he reveals that Lockhart/Gardner had underestimated the value of their case, allowing him to negotiate a settlement of less than half the lawsuit’s worth. Canning later teams up with Patti Nyholm to [[KansasCityShuffle distract]] Lockhart/Gardner with a FrivolousLawsuit and steal their top client, driving the firm into bankruptcy and almost putting them out of business altogether. Canning also schemes with David Lee to merge his firm with Lockhart/Gardner and ruin Diane’s attempts to merge with Florrick/Agos, ultimately driving Diane out of her own firm. [[AffablyEvil Effortlessly charming]] and a loving family man [[PunchClockVillain outside of his work]], Canning’s skill as an attorney is matched only by his wit and unfailing respect for Alicia’s own skills.
** Patti Nyholm is a devious and brilliant lawyer opposed to Lockhart/Gardner. A highly skilled advocate capable of going toe-to-toe with Will Gardner in court, Patti’s unsavory clients include insurance companies and hospitals refusing to provide desperately needed emergency medical care, and she often uses [[HoldingTheFloor stall tactics]] to pressure the opposition in these time-sensitive cases. When fired by her firm, Patti uses Lockhart/Gardner to bring a lawsuit against them, illegally feeding Lockhart/Gardner inside information on active cases in order to force her firm to give her job back. She is then able to return armed with inside information on future cases against Lockhart/Gardner, which Will cannot call her out for illegally using without himself admitting to perjury and risking his own disbarment. Patti later [[VillainTeamUp teams up]] with Louis Canning to steal Lockhart/Gardner’s top client. Despite appearing in only five episodes, Patti remains one of Lockhart/Gardner’s most memorable and formidable opponents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkHorse: Elsbeth Tascioni became an instant fan favorite for her quirky behaviour, NiceGirl personality and [[BunnyEarsLawyer surprising skill]] as an attorney, which lead to her returning in a bigger role on ''Series/TheGoodFight'' and, later, being given her own spin-off show, ''Elspeth''.

to:

* EnsembleDarkHorse: Elsbeth Tascioni became an instant fan favorite for her quirky behaviour, NiceGirl personality and [[BunnyEarsLawyer surprising skill]] as an attorney, which lead to her returning in a bigger role on ''Series/TheGoodFight'' and, later, being given her own spin-off show, ''Elspeth''.''Elsbeth''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When Alicia calls the judge Jason punched to ask him about what happened, he tells her that Jason is a sociopath and a ticking time-bomb who she should stay far away from. This rather ominous statement is never brought up again, even as Alicia and Jason end up becoming romantically involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Adorkable}}: For all her composure and classical beauty, whenever Alicia gets flustered or genuinely, unexpectedly happy, she shows an almost childlike glee that is very cute, as opposed to her more typical subdued sexiness.

to:

* {{Adorkable}}: For all her composure and classical beauty, whenever Alicia gets flustered or genuinely, unexpectedly happy, she shows an almost childlike glee that is very cute, as opposed to her more typical subdued sexiness.nature.



* EnsembleDarkHorse: Elsbeth Tascioni became an instant fan favorite for her quirky behaviour, NiceGirl personality and [[BunnyEarsLawyer surprising skill]] as an attorney, which lead to her returning in a bigger role on ''Series/TheGoodFight''.

to:

* EnsembleDarkHorse: Elsbeth Tascioni became an instant fan favorite for her quirky behaviour, NiceGirl personality and [[BunnyEarsLawyer surprising skill]] as an attorney, which lead to her returning in a bigger role on ''Series/TheGoodFight''.''Series/TheGoodFight'' and, later, being given her own spin-off show, ''Elspeth''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ambiguous Disorder is now Diagnosed By The Audience and goes on YMMV page

Added DiffLines:

* DiagnosedByTheAudience: Elsbeth Tascioni, [[AttentionDeficitOohShiny who's easily distracted by things surrounding her]] and led to flights of fancy by them.

Added: 939

Changed: 592

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Taye Diggs has a four episode appearance in Season 6 as a prominent lawyer who Diane wanted to bring with her as she joined Florrick-Agos. Much is made of him, and yet he disappears as suddenly as he came, without a word said about where or why he'd vanished.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: At the start of Season 7, there was a new associate at the firm who mistook Cary's attempt to bond with the younger associates as flirtation. This generated some buzz about Cary being bisexual, which, given Kalinda's departure, some fans were happy to see as a possible storyline. However, it turned out to go nowhere, and the associate disappeared for several episodes, [[spoiler: only to return, threaten to go to work with Canning, and get fired with his compatriots, with no mention of what happened between him and Cary]], effectively ending any chance of that happening.

to:

** Taye Diggs has a four episode appearance in Season 6 as a prominent lawyer who Diane wanted to bring brought with her as she joined Florrick-Agos. Much is made of him, and yet he disappears as suddenly as he came, without a word said about where or why he'd vanished.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot:
** After an entire season's worth of build up to her being elected, Alicia is forced to resign as State's Attorney before trying a single case, despite the huge story potential having her in this role could bring, especially with the potential for her to come into direct conflict with the firm she built or former clients like Lemond Bishop and Colin Sweeney.
**
At the start of Season 7, there was a new associate at the firm who mistook Cary's attempt to bond with the younger associates as flirtation. This generated some buzz about Cary being bisexual, which, given Kalinda's departure, some fans were happy to see as a possible storyline. However, it turned out to go nowhere, and the associate disappeared for several episodes, [[spoiler: only to return, threaten to go to work with Canning, and get fired with his compatriots, with no mention of what happened between him and Cary]], effectively ending any chance of that happening.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many of the secondary characters at Florrick-Agos [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without a trace]] at the start of Season 6. Most notably, Clarke Hayden's final appearance is in the Season 5 finale, while Robyn Burdine vanishes after the second episode of Season 6.

to:

** Many of the secondary characters at Florrick-Agos [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without a trace]] at the start of Season 6. Most notably, Clarke Clark Hayden's final appearance is in the Season 5 finale, while Robyn Burdine vanishes after the second episode of Season 6.

Added: 535

Changed: 373

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Several characters have been brought in with significant fanfare, only to disappear a short while later. Notably, Taye Diggs had a four episode appearance in Season 6 as a prominent lawyer who Diane wanted to bring with her as she joined Florrick-Agos. Much is made of him, and yet he disappears as suddenly as he came, without a word said about where or why he'd vanished.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Several TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter:
** Many of the secondary
characters have been brought in with significant fanfare, only to at Florrick-Agos [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without a short trace]] at the start of Season 6. Most notably, Clarke Hayden's final appearance is in the Season 5 finale, while later. Notably, Robyn Burdine vanishes after the second episode of Season 6.
**
Taye Diggs had has a four episode appearance in Season 6 as a prominent lawyer who Diane wanted to bring with her as she joined Florrick-Agos. Much is made of him, and yet he disappears as suddenly as he came, without a word said about where or why he'd vanished.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Ham Sandwich", Lemond Bishop's wife's lawyer (and implied lover) angrily confronts Bishop and accuses him of having her killed after she conveniently dies in the middle of their divorce proceedings, only for David Lee to quickly move to shut him up. Was he simply trying to silence the man making incriminatory accusations towards his client, or, in a rare PetTheDog moment, was he preventing him from revealing that he was sleeping with Bishop's wife and getting himself killed?

to:

** In "Ham Sandwich", Lemond Bishop's wife's lawyer (and implied lover) angrily confronts Bishop and accuses him of having her killed after she conveniently dies in the middle of their divorce proceedings, only for David Lee to quickly move to shut him up. Was he Lee simply trying to silence the man making incriminatory accusations towards his client, or, in a rare PetTheDog moment, was he preventing him from revealing that he was sleeping with Bishop's wife and getting himself killed?

Added: 486

Changed: 1058

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alicia Florrick. Is she a noble, hardworking, single mother who faces adversity with integrity and honesty? Or is she an inconsiderate JerkAss who believes justice is sternly the law and constantly indulges in [[KickTheDog kicking or]] [[ShootTheDog shooting the proverbial dog]]?
*** Was she really in love with Will? She seems to think so [[spoiler: after his death]], but when [[spoiler: they broke off the affair]], she tells Owen that she was mostly in love with the idea of Will. Star-crossed lovers whose timing stayed terrible, or unhappy people dreaming of their unrealistically perfect relationship?
** Anything and anyone in the wake of [[spoiler: Alicia and Cary forming their own law firm]]. Suffice to say, reactions and motivations are really anyone’s guess.

to:

** Alicia Florrick. Florrick:
***
Is she a noble, hardworking, single mother who faces adversity with integrity and honesty? Or is she an inconsiderate JerkAss who believes justice is sternly the law and constantly indulges in [[KickTheDog kicking or]] [[ShootTheDog shooting the proverbial dog]]?
*** Was she really in love with Will? She seems to think so [[spoiler: after [[spoiler:after his death]], but when [[spoiler: they [[spoiler:they broke off the affair]], she tells Owen that she was mostly in love with the idea of Will. Star-crossed lovers whose timing stayed terrible, or unhappy people dreaming of their unrealistically perfect relationship?
** Anything In "Ham Sandwich", Lemond Bishop's wife's lawyer (and implied lover) angrily confronts Bishop and anyone accuses him of having her killed after she conveniently dies in the wake middle of [[spoiler: Alicia and Cary forming their own law firm]]. Suffice divorce proceedings, only for David Lee to say, reactions quickly move to shut him up. Was he simply trying to silence the man making incriminatory accusations towards his client, or, in a rare PetTheDog moment, was he preventing him from revealing that he was sleeping with Bishop's wife and motivations are really anyone’s guess.getting himself killed?

Changed: 225

Removed: 294

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kalinda and Eli are too important to qualify


* EnsembleDarkHorse:
** Kalinda Sharma.
** Eli Gold, who kept taking on new roles that would put him in close contact with Alicia (and Peter) even after the election that introduced him was over.
** Elsbeth Tascioni has definitely turned into this, to the point where she got a significant role on ''The Good Fight''.

to:

* EnsembleDarkHorse:
** Kalinda Sharma.
** Eli Gold, who kept taking on new roles that would put him in close contact with Alicia (and Peter) even after the election that introduced him was over.
**
EnsembleDarkHorse: Elsbeth Tascioni has definitely turned into this, became an instant fan favorite for her quirky behaviour, NiceGirl personality and [[BunnyEarsLawyer surprising skill]] as an attorney, which lead to the point where she got her returning in a significant bigger role on ''The Good Fight''.''Series/TheGoodFight''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV can't be played withand Values Dissonance has a 20 year waiting period


* TooBleakStoppedCaring: [[AvertedTrope Averted]] in the critically acclaimed fifth season; one of the main draws of the season was the sudden GreyAndGrayMorality afflicting the main cast, [[spoiler: between Cary and Alicia starting their own firm and stealing Lockhart/Gardner's clients, and Will and Diane behaving more and more reprehensibly in their pursuit of revenge and trying to stay afloat in the wake of the coup]].
* ValuesDissonance: Kalinda is rather cynical about a jury consultant for using racial stereotypes, to which the rather obvious comeback is, "That’s what your firm pays me for." Honestly, you simply try to fix a jury in your favor, and ''look'' at the kind of amoral people you get.

Top