These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
One tour video shows them on a day off, building an igloo. Once they're finished, long after the sun's set, they get their instruments and play a song in it.
Matt: Why did we do this today?
Andrew: Why didn't we do this every day?
In the final lines of "Rotten Town" (which involves a chorus of voices singing the lyrics in a round, already Crowning Music of Awesome material alone), Andrew Volpe holds one last note for a total of 24 seconds. He must breathe through his ears.
Fridge Horror: "Lake Pontchartrain". When you realize that the song may not really be describing a supernatural experience, but may be a crazy story spun by a young man being interviewed about the disappearance and possible murder of his friends, it suddenly becomes a lot scarier.
Missouri and Louisiana (where the song is set) still have the Death penalty. Should the narrator be convicted for the murder of his friends, he would be executed. Now, if his story was true, there even more Fridge Horror because that would mean NO ONE would have survived that encounter, and the Lake would be free to kill even more.
Ho Yay: A video in their tour blog features them all crossdressing. At one point, Matt Palermo strokes Andrew's behind. Andrew's only reaction is to tell him to not stop.
Andrew gets up to a lot of this really. Seems like he can't go a single tour diary without making out with a bandmate's elbow onstage, or just standing around holding onto their pelvic bones..."really hard".
Misaimed Fandom: "The Horror Of Our Love" is not supposed to be romantic. It's about murder, rape, necrophilia, and cannibalism, disguised behind a sweet melody to create eerie Lyrical Dissonance. But because it sounds pretty, people think it's the sweetest love song ever. There are Youtube comments of people saying they plan to dance to this song on their wedding.
The Horror of Our Love. So Yandere and twisted it's guaranteed to create some nightmares.
Lake Pontchartrain when you realise the Fridge Horror aspect. Hell, even without that - vengeful, murderous, crawfish ghosts who comandeer radio signals and forces of nature to trick you into driving to your watery doom? Scary as shit.
Save Our City may qualify at the zombie verse, as may The Lamb and the Dragon when it describes the dying Earth.
Tear Jerker: "Morning in May", "I'll Never be Lonely Again"
"Safe in the Dark". Tim Ferrell's sister commented on a video with this: "This song is about when our dad passed away. Its not about vampires or werewolfs or boyfriends or bandmemebers dying. Its about when our dad first got sick with MG and how we dealt with it."
They Changed It, Now It Sucks: How some fans are reacting to Andrew's side project, Hot Problems, because he's writing pop songs rather than a second rock opera.