YMMV: Justice League 3000

  • Author's Saving Throw: The announcement that Booster Gold and Ted Kord's Blue Beetle will be joining the book, and that it takes place not in Prime Earth but a variation on New Earth, has been met with high praise in comparison to the Darker and Edgier tone that has been given to the book to that point.
    • The revelation that this is not the future of Prime Earth leave it open for the Legion of Super-Heroes to reappear.
  • Epileptic Trees: From the moment the character designs were unveiled, fans began speculating that Wonder Woman and the Flash were the absent-since-Flashpoint Donna Troy and Wally West purely because the Flash had red hair and green eyes, two of Wally's distinctive characteristics.
  • Replacement Scrappy: How many Legion fans view the team and the entire book, replacing a long running team with a multitude of characterization, storylines, and more than a few POC and LGBT characters in its roster, for another Justice League knock-off title during a time when DC is becoming over-saturated with them.
  • Unfortunate Implications: The handling of Guy Gardener's situation has been accused of transphobia, primarily due to the Critical Research Failure that suggests that having female hormones alone would make him behave like a female (and think like one) despite identifying as male; that his constant shock at this is Played for Laughs does not help things in the least.
  • What an Idiot: Superman refuses to listen to the fact that he can't fly now, despite the Wonder Twins, the other members of the Justice League, and personal experience telling him so.