These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
YMMV: Another Code
Earworm: The music, while quite good, repeats over and over and over and over...
Iron Woobie: Ashley. She goes through a lot of emotional trauma and just keeps at it.
Moe: Ashley, especially when she's feeling sad or happy.
Nightmare Fuel: If you fail to get the good ending in Another Code, D will be doomed to haunt the island for the rest of his afterlife. He will never find out how and why he died and since it's very unlikely that anyone would ever visit Blood Edward Island after the events of this game, he will be completely alone. For all eternity. Doubles as a Player Punch, as getting the good ending can be a realGuide Dang It.
Needs More Love: If it had gotten some more in the US and Australia, they might have gotten the sequel.
Player Punch: Non-lethal version in Another Code R: You're forced turn around manually for the first time in the game rather than just pressing a button and swiveling 90 degrees to see the ghost of Matt's sister, Kelly, after he tells you to look. And then you realize that Matt doesn't realize she's dead and thinks she's really standing there.
D's fate in the bad ending when you get just how bad it is for him.
Tear Jerker: A few times, notably when Ashley's mom is revealed to be dead and the "good" ending.
Another Code R. Chapter six. Kelly. The fact they suddenly play the "reunion theme" from the first game when Matt remembers doesn't help.