troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
This is a "Wild Mass Guess" entry, where we pull out all the sanity stops on theorizing. The regular entry on this topic is elsewhere. Please see this programme note.
Star Trek: Generations
Picard has never left the Nexus.
This is pretty straightforward. The Nexus gives its occupants everything they desire, and Picard's desire was to stop Soran. So, the Nexus granted his wish and created a simulacrum of Veridian 3, with a simulacrum of Soran, where Picard could fulfill his fantasy. Then, he wished revenge against the Borg, and his wish was granted. He also wanted the people around him to get better (LaForge to get real eyes, Riker to rekindle his relationship with Troi) and he got that wish too. He wanted a final mission with his entire crew, including members that couldn't possibly be there (like Worf), where Riker would be promoted to captain and he would stop a Romulan invasion of Federation space. He got that wish too. This would also explain the inconsistencies between the later movies and the established canon (Troi saying she never kissed Riker when he had a beard, Worf being aboard the Enterprise and saying Romulan ale is illegal, Wesley Crusher being present at the ceremony, a photograph of Picard as a bald cadet). Those are the results of events Picard either forgot or wanted to forget, made into a perceptible form by the Nexus.
  • Then explain how what we saw from the Generations onward, their uniforms, the Borg attack, the Son'a are all consistent with what we see in other Star Trek works taking place at the time.
Alternatively, Picard never entered the Nexus.
Posed by SF Debris. In his words: "After all, which is more likely; That Picard (a 74-year-old man in a nearly all-black uniform, no protection from the sun, and with no water to speak of) now has sunstroke, and believes he is teaming up with Starfleet's greatest hero, or that Picard goes to a magical land of fairy dust where all his wishes come true?"
The point of the Nexus scene was to show us Picard's hatred of his brother outweighs his love of his nephew.
At first it seemed to me that the scene in the beginning when we found at Picard's brother and nephew died in a horrible was just a throw away scene that never amounts to anything. Then I realized, no this scene was an insight into Picard's true hared of his brother, it's the only explanation. We see Picard reminisce with Troi about his family. Then Picard enters the Nexus. He has a vision of being with his family, and his nephew is there as well. Then echo-Guinan goes way out of her way to explain that he can go back to ANY point in time and effect changes. He looks longingly at his nephew and leaves to find Kirk and go back to 5 minutes ago. He expressely DID NOT go back in time enough to save the lives of his brother and nephew, even after seeing his nephew again in the Nexus. Why? Because he hated his brother just that much that he was willing to let his nephew be dead of a horrible death as long as it meant Robert was dead as well. It's like the writers went way out of their way to make that point to us the audience.

Star Trek V: The Final FrontierWMG/FilmStar Trek (2009)

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
3831
38