Useful Notes: All the Little Germanies

aka: Prussia And All That Lot
Die Gedanken sind frei

What is the German’s fatherland?
Is it Prussia, is it Swabia?
Is it where the grapes glow on the Rhine?
Is it where the gull moves on the Belt?
Oh no! oh no! oh no! oh no!
His fatherland must be greater!
19th-century German patriotic song

When Francis II abdicated as Holy Roman Emperor in 1806 and assumed the title of Francis I of the Empire of Austria, the implied acceptance of the death of the Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation, though dictated by Napoleon, was simply a recognition of reality. Napoleon, however, having shattered German unity legally, ironically went a good way toward re-establishing it politically by amalgamating the tiny imperial states into larger units; Bavaria and Württemberg became Kingdoms on January 1, 1806, Saxony followed on December 20, and Westphalia was created as a Kingdom for Napoleon's youngest brother Jérôme in 1807. After the fall of Napoleon, the Congress of Vienna in 1815 ratified most of Napoleon's foundations (Westphalia being a notable exception) while restoring some of the larger earlier units such as Hanover (now also raised to a Kingdom). Prussia increased dramatically in size, having been awarded substantial territories in the Rhineland, in recognition of the magnitude of her efforts against Napoleon - and of her army.note  After the Empire itself ceased, the run-up to the establishment of the Deutsches Reich may be considered the period of All the Little Germanies (or, as the Germans called it, the 'Biedermeier' period).

The powerful nineteenth century impulse toward Nationalism spurred efforts to secure the establishment of a single German nation. Nevertheless, the desire for peace of Germans exhausted by a quarter century of war, the fears of German Catholics of a too dominant Protestant Prussia and of German Protestants of a too dominant Catholic Austria, and the unwillingness of foreign powers such as England, Russia, and France to see the emergence of a powerful Central European empire, were exploited by unscrupulous ministers (such as the Anglo-Irish Castlereagh, the Russian Nesselrode, the wily Frenchman Talleyrand, the Prussian Hardenberg, and the influential Austrian Metternich) to promote the interests of their own sovereigns. Metternich, to maintain the ''status quo'' in Germany and Europe, would not hesitate to encourage the use of trickery and repression.

The Romantic impulse, which in the Revolutionary and Napoleonic periods had encouraged innovation, was channeled in All the Little Germanies into a powerful nostalgia for the past. The time of the Hohenstaufen was exalted as Germany's Golden Age, the exploration of traditional culture in the form of folk-lore and folk-music was encouraged as the proper expression of nationalist sentiments, and religion took on the style, if not the substance, of Roman Catholicism, even among Protestants such as the painter Caspar David Friedrich. (A particular embodiment of this impulse was the recommencement, with the warm approval of Frederick William IV of Prussia, of construction on the Catholic cathedral of Köln, abandoned in the sixteenth century.) However, at the same time the German states did make significant progress in other fields, notably in science, education, and industry. On the economic front, Prussia took the lead in replacing the outmoded forms (guilds, privileged enterprises etc.) with capitalist free enterprise and the removal of inner-Prussian and inner-German customs barriers. By 1854 most of the territories that would form the German Empire of 1871 (with the exception of Schleswig-Holstein, Mecklenburg and the Hanseatic cities) had joined the Prussian-led Deutsche Zollverein (customs union). Thus the economic union preceded the political one.

However, an intense desire for political unity remained, coupled with an increasingly passionate rebelliousness against the despotism, not only of the German princes, but of the growing class of wealthy industrialists. The year 1848 would see wide-spread Revolution throughout Germany, spearheaded by the numerous student societies (Burschenschaften) followed by widespread and brutal repression. Nevertheless, the dream of a united Germany lived on.

North German unity, at least, would be achieved when the Prussian prime-minister, Otto von Bismarck-Schönhausen (after victory in the Austro-Prussian War of 1866 effectively diminished Austrian influence among the German states) took advantage of the German nationalist sentiment inspired by Prussia's successful war with France in 1870 to have the William I of Prussia crowned German Emperor at Versailles in 1871. Substantial bribes to various South German sovereigns and ministers (many of whom were, in any case, more nervous of Austria than of a more distant Prussia) secured the acquiescence of Catholic Germany. The Second Reich had begun.

In popular culture, the unrest of this time period is all but ignored. All the Little Germanies, so far as fiction is concerned, is pure Gemüthlichkeit, with lots of diplomats waltzing in embroidered tailcoats and silk stockings, Burschen dueling (as often with large Steins of Pilsner as with sabres), mob-capped grandmothers telling fairy tales, blue-eyed peasant maidens singing folk songs (especially Die Lorelei note ), and dozens of aristocratic Uhlans and Hussars in multi-colored uniforms to woo them.

Tropes associated with All The Little Germanies include:

  • Arranged Marriage: Royalty would give away whole countries as dowries here. Of course, sometimes the country was smaller than a city...but it's the status that counts.
  • Chew Toy: Germany isn't really the country you think of as a Chew Toy. But because of its disunity and its unpleasant position right in the middle of Europe between-well-everyone, it ended up as the traditional battleground of Europe. This spurred along the desire to create Imperial Germany.
    • Interestingly, during that time German soldiers tended to be respected greatly but most German states, because of their small size were despised and wars between great powers often centered on making puppets out of them.
  • Dichter And Denker
  • Private Military Contractors: This area was famous for this. With the complex proviso that many were regular soldiers rented out for a war their ruler had no interest in but money rather then consciously being mercenaries themselves.
  • Ruritania
  • Spare To The Throne: If anyone had a princeling they couldn't figure out what to do with they dumped him here. If one of the royal families here had one of these they dumped them somewhere else. As a result, almost every monarchy in Europe had/has some minor German prince in the ancestry—if indeed the royal family wasn't a cadet branch of some German state or other.
    • Britain was particularly fond of marrying German princelings. From the accession of George I until quite recently, the British monarchs fairly consistently married only German consorts, with the occasional Dane for flavour—and the Danish monarchs had been marrying lots of Germans, too. It wasn't until HM The Queen's own father, George VI, that anyone with a good chance at the throne married a British subject (George, or rather Prince Albert at the time, quite famously married the Scottish earl's daughter Elizabeth Bowes-Lyon, known affectionately as the Queen Mum), and even then Prince Albert was seen as a preferred but unlikely candidate. Things went right back to form for HM The Queen, who married Prince Philip of Greece and Denmark (the Greek royals are actually a junior branch of a German ducal house, albeit one whose ancestral territory was near Denmark, had inherited Denmark first, and had come to consider themselves Danish), but since then the heirs to the throne have married British commoners or minor nobility (Catherine "Kate" Middleton, and Lady Diana Spencernote  and Camilla Parker-Bowles,note  respectively).

Works associated with All The Little Germanies:

Depictions in fiction:

  • Thomas Mann's Buddenbrooks chronicles the downfall of wealthy a bourgeois family of an unnamed city that has to be Mann's native Lübeck from 1835 to 1877.
  • Victoria: An Empire Under the Sun: Sizable part of both Victorias is about supporting, slowing down or outright stopping German unification, depending on country player picked.
  • The 1632 series drops, via Alien Space Bats screwing around with the space-time continuum as art, a West Virginia coal mining town from the 20th century into the middle of the Germanies during the Thirty Years' War. In various places it's discussed how the "Germany" that the West Virginians know is nowhere near as singular in the 17th century, with one of the goals of their leader, Michael Stearns, being to head off the history that lead to the formation of a Germany that would eventually evolve into Nazi Germany.

Alternative Title(s):

Prussia And All That Lot, The German Confederation, All The Little Germanies, German Confederation