Jeremiah Riggs in Season 5, better known to Celebreality fans as "Big Rig" from Daisy of Love.
Name's the Same: Eric Watts was the big, stiff guy who can't wrestle from Tough Enough. Erik Watts was the big, stiff guy who can't wrestle from early '90s WCW. No relation.
Retroactive Recognition: Ariane gets this now having since gained a spot as one of Brodus Clay's dancers, eventually graduating to a wrestling role and landing a spot on the hit reality series Total Divas.
Star-Making Role: For Ariane (see above) and Ivelisse - who was in the company for several months as Sofia Cortez but enjoyed more high profile bookings after her release.
Troubled Production: Season 2. The training was going so badly, people theorised that "these kids aren't ready" should have been the show's tag line. And that's not to mention the debacle that was the finale.