- Definitely, Jane Smith's death in the wake of the Summer 2011 event "Speak Up." Not to mention some of the threads... *sniffle*
- Klaus Wulfenbach cutting up his not!son, Hiccup. It Makes Sense in Context.
- Practically all of this post. It's basically a What If? about what the characters would do if they managed to find a way back.
Tear Jerker / Mayfield
What, you thought this was all about horror?