Playing With / Tautological Templar

Basic Trope: Somebody who believes that they are good, and that makes everything they do good by default.
  • Straight: The Lawful Stupid Tomoe knows that she's one of the good guys — she's a soldier for justice! And that means she does nothing but good deeds, and punishes the baddies! Even that puppy was evil!
  • Exaggerated:
    • As a devoted soldier of The Empire, Tomoe is perfectly willing to Save the World by curbstomping it into submission wherever necessary, fully convinced that it's okay because she and her friends are pillars of truth and light.
    • Tomoe is a villain who somehow believes herself to be both an All-Loving Hero and Incorruptible Pure Pureness.
  • Downplayed: Tomoe is somewhat a good person at heart, although in a pragmatic manner. Because of this, she knows that everything she does is right, no matter how harsh her actions can be.
  • Justified:
    • Tomoe was raised to believe this.
    • Good is a cosmic force that is not connected to any sort of moral obligations. Furthermore, certain races and jobs (such as "soldiers for justice") are considered to be aligned to Good, and thus get to exploit this cosmic force for their own reasons. Anything these Good people do must, by definition, be Good.
    • Tomoe is that crazy.
  • Inverted: Naoya is convinced that he is evil and everything he does is evil by default, despite how he's been singlehandedly defending his hometown from The Empire, keeping everyone he knows safe, and rescuing kittens from trees in his spare time.
  • Subverted: Despite her devotion to the cause, Tomoe balks when charged to torch the village of Bloomton. After all, even if some of them might be harboring members of La Résistance, what about all the innocents living there...?
  • Double Subverted: However, she's easily convinced that everyone in Bloomton is in on the rebellion's charade, and as a guardian of justice, it's her duty to punish them—!
  • Parodied:
  • Zig Zagged: Tomoe swings back and forth between assuming everything she does is naturally good and questioning the purity of her actions.
  • Averted: When people accuse Tomoe of being evil she only agrees with them and tells them they're probably right.
  • Enforced: ???
  • Lampshaded: What the Hell, Hero?
  • Invoked: From a young age, Tomoe is told by her mentor that she is inherently pure and just, and will become an unstoppable force for good in the future. He deliberately teaches her this in order to raise an unquestionably loyal soldier convinced of her moral superiority.
  • Exploited: The Big Bad uses More Than Mind Control on Tomoe to avoid her coming after him.
  • Defied: Tomoe knows she's done evil and Wangsts about the Dirty Business she's had to do in the name of the greater good.
  • Discussed: "Why do people praise her as a hero? She's a murderer!"
  • Conversed: "Looks like the writers couldn't think of a philosophy for the villain more complicated than 'I'm right because I say I am'."
  • Deconstructed: Tomoe's beliefs are the lynchpin to her sanity. Her entire identity and sense of self-worth is built around the idea that everything she does is ultimately 'good'; she simply can't second-guess herself, for fear that those insecurities and doubts will prove overwhelming. Even when confronted with seemingly undeniable proof that her actions have had terrible, evil consequences, she retreats further into denial and mental instability. Eventually, this leads to General Kaizo to put her down when she started becoming a threat to the empire's plans.
  • Reconstructed: Tomoe is confronted with her evil deeds and at first has a Freak Out! but ultimately dismisses those heretics who would try to undermine her beliefs and cause such doubts. They are the evil ones! They don't understand true justice!
  • Played For Laughs: After destroying a village to take out a monster Tomoe asks the surviving citizens if they think she's a "great hero or the GREATEST hero?" "...I'll put you down for great."
  • Played For Drama:

Back to Tautological Templar