After Bonnie was shown to be missing his face, many videos cropped up overlapping the "Don't eat my face!" voice clips with an animation of the intact Bonnie being approached by another animatronic (usually Foxy, but ones with Mangle or Chica aren't unheard of either).
"Bonnie's left leg" has also become an inexplicably popular meme on Tumblr.
Custom Night Memes. Holy moly, the Custom Night Memes. And trust us when we say one with hundreds of distorted photos like these. These were popular as they can be back in the fandom's heyday, but have calmed down over time. Still, some of them are pretty funny to look back on!
Mangle is a yes.ExplanationScott's Mathematician's Answer to Mangle's gender. Fans have joked about its gender literally being "yes" and identified their own gender as "yes".
The Man Behind the Slaughter. ExplanationA lyric from "It's Been So Long", a song by The Living Tombstone, describes the Purple Man/William Afton as this. In 2020, the song saw a resurgence in popularity, with "The man behind the slaughter" becoming something of a Fan Nickname for the character. On top of that, memes involving turning a character purple (sometimes with black sclera and white pupils) and referring to them as "the X behind the slaughter" started appearing as well (in a similar vein to the Thanos Car meme), with an excerpt of "It's Been So Long" usually accompanying the image.
"She is such a bad bitch though!"ExplanationBlastphamousHD's reaction to a beakless Toy Chica standing in the hallway: screaming, then expressing sexual attraction to her starting with this phrase. The clip has shown up a lot in the fandom, and in some FNAF retrospectives.
Please do not draw hellspawn on your paper ExplanationA photo of a math assignment with a student's drawing of the Puppet accompanied by the teacher's thoughts on it, consisting of the above phrase. Fans have taken amusement at the idea of the Puppet being called hellspawn, as it's the closest thing the franchise has to a Big Good.
The Scoutis the bite victimExplanationIt's commonly speculated that Jeremy is the victim of the Bite of '87 due to the events of the game taking place in November of that year, and the restrictions on animatronic movement not yet being enacted. In Team Fortress 2's official webcomic, it's revealed that the Scout's real name is Jeremy, and that he will die on December 4th, 1987. Some have joked about the two being the same. Some have also made references to old Source Filmmaker animations that used Valve's character models out of context due to the lack of official or popular human models (such as the G-Man as the Purple Guy), making them Hilarious in Hindsight given this theory.
Dwayne Johnson Withered Freddy.note Several gifs of Withered Freddy making gestures similar to Dwayne Johnson, such as his raised eyebrow and pulling his glasses down have become viral memes on websites such as Twitter and YouTube.
Withered Freddy meltingnote A gif of Withered Freddy's parts melting has also become viral, usually accompanied by the "dies from cringe" meme or the Bababooey sound effect (often with farting noises included).
Balloon Boy wants your batteries.ExplanationIt's something of a running gag in the community that the main reason Balloon Boy disables your flashlight is that he really wants to steal your flashlight's batteries for some reason. For example, stealing them is Balloon Boy's explicit motivation in the second 5 AM at Freddy's video (with his word choice suggesting he eats batteries). Foxy's canon voice actor Christopher McCullough would acknowledgethe meme as a joke in response to a fight that took place during a theatrical screening of Five Nights at Freddy's (2023).
GREAT!!! (NowGet Out!]]) ExplanationThe text accompanying the pink slip you get after completing the Custom Night. Often used as a reaction image towards problematic people online, especially those somehow involved in FNAF in one way or another.