Idiot Plot

"The Idiot Plot, of course, is any plot that would be resolved in five minutes if everyone in the story were not an idiot."
Roger Ebert in his review of Narrow Margin (1990)

Originated by SF author James Blish and popularized by film critic Roger Ebert during his review of the remake of Narrow Margin, this trope is a term for a Plot that hangs together only because the main characters behave like idiots. A single intelligent move or question by any of the characters, and all problems would be resolved. It's not so bad if the characters are supposed to be acting like idiots, but it's very bad if the Idiot Plot depends on a character suddenly acting stupid enough for the Plot to work.

Even worse than that is "second-order idiot plot", in which the plot can only function if the world population suddenly loses about 50 IQ points. In fact, author Damon Knight originally coined the term "second-order idiot plot" to refer to a science fiction story that features a fictional society that can only exist if everyone living there is an idiot.

Idiot plots can often be avoided with a simple wave of the hand. If the audience would have spent the entire story wondering why the hero didn't try some obvious tactic, a hand wave at the beginning of the story as to why that wouldn't work would prevent an idiot plot, regardless of how contrived the excuse was. However, if the hand wave is bad, it may actually create a new obvious solution just as bad as the original.

It is important to note that this is not always a bad thing, and is sometimes the entire point of the story. Part of what can make a drama so dramatic or a tragedy so tragic is that the characters could truly have avoided it if they had acted rationally instead of irrationally. Likewise, this is frequently Played for Laughs in a comedy. And sometimes it's just a case of Reality Is Unrealistic; many real-world problems, viewed from a distance, can seem like Idiot Plots themselves. That said, calling real life people idiots is easy Flame Bait so No Real Life Examples, Please!


Alternative Title(s): Stupid Mistakes Plot