Ho Yay: X-Men

aka: X-Men
"It is a little bit of a mini-tragedy that him and Magneto don't, you know, have sex and become married and become best friends."
James McAvoy shares his thoughts on Charles / Erik

Well, what do you expect from a comic about a small minority generally indistinguishable at first glance, often not knowing their own identities until puberty or later, loathed by large parts of society?

    open/close all folders 

    Comic Books 
  • In The Seventies and The Eighties, X-Men's Mystique and her "friend" Destiny fell into this trope — with comics now subject to fewer restrictions, however, current references to Destiny (still posthumous after twenty years!) make no attempt to hide that she and Mystique were lovers. Late in Chris Claremont's first run on the series, he has the Shadow King refer to Destiny as Mystique's "leman", an archaic term for lover, paramour, or spouse. (Thank you, gayleague.org.)
    • It was actually Claremont's plan at one point to reveal that Mystique was not Nightcrawler's mother, but his father, having impregnated Destiny while in the form of a man. The editors nixed this idea. But considering the enraged reaction of the fans to the revelation of Kurt's real father, it has been suggested that it be retconned to the truth.
  • In various incarnations of the X-Men, there is definite... chemistry between Professor X and Magneto, even to the point of them cracking open a bottle of red wine and discussing philosophy on their(!) balcony in Excalibur, series 2 issue 2. Charles has agreed to help Erik rebuild Genosha, so the two find it beneficial to SHARE A HOUSE! We get many scenes of domestic bliss with the two, such as Erik cooking breakfast for both of them.
    • In fact, in the final episode of the X-Men animated series, Jean asks "Did you love Charles Xavier?"; Erik's response is to be outraged that she could doubt it.
    • In the Ultimate universe, Professor Xavier says outright that he left his wife and family to be with Erik. Plus, caption box dialogue saying they were closer than brothers because of their uber-powers.
    • Their flashback with kid-Jean in the third movie is pretty close to a couple considering adopting a child. Sir Ian McKellen and James McAvoy both ship it. The latter referred to First Class as a love story and... well, just check out that quote at the top.
      • And the part in First Class where Erik is practically cuddling him. Okay, it loses something because Charles has just gotten the injury that will put him in a wheelchair forever, and it was Erik's (accidental) fault, but it still has the highest "are you sure he's not the love interest?" quotient in the movieverse.
    • Though the druggie psycho Magneto of the "Planet X" arc was retconned into being an impostor in an Author's Saving Throw, he was intended to be the real Magneto when it was written... so you gotta wonder why Mags, while in full-on baby-eating mode, saw fit to not kill Xavier, but instead... keep him unconscious and naked in a tank of something-or-other. (It's totally transparent, too. Magneto has an unobstructed view of Charles' ass.) He planned to release him once all humans are wiped out, and was looking forward to Charles someday looking over the new world and agreeing with him. At his most whacked-out, Mags still wanted to live happily ever after with Charles. Post-retcon, we can say the impostor got at least one thing right.
    • Professor X has referred to them as being "two sides of the same soul." That's right, they may or may not be literal soulmates.
    • There's a 2012 story in Uncanny X-Men featuring the last two members of a species called the Apex. One of them is a benevolent yet often condescending scientist. The other is an arrogant, vengeful man grieving for his people. They've been torn apart by the latter's madness and their differing ideas about how to care for the legacy of their species. They are also in love. Sound like anyone we know?
      • Of course, they've also been shown to have female love interests in the comics, cartoons and cinema (Xavier with Moira MacTaggert, Gabrielle Haller, Amelia Voght and Lilandra, Magneto with his first wife, Polaris' mother, Lee Forrester and Rogue) so perhaps Ambiguously Bi is a better fit.
    • This poll by ComicsAlliance.com asks, "Who Should Magneto Hook Up with in His Last Days?", and the current leader is Charles Xavier, who has so far earned a whopping 94%! Some of the comments at the bottom of the article basically express that this contest is totally unfair for the other four female candidates.
      "Yesterday [...] an overwhelming majority voted for Charles Xavier, to the point where it just seemed like we needn't have bothered including anyone else."
  • The Claremont-written novelization of the third X-Men movie had Iceman giving Angel his codename because of his unnatural beauty, which he goes on about in narration for some time. Of course, canonically, Angel is just that angelic-looking (even if not every comic artist manages to pull it off.)
    • Chris Claremont was frankly somewhat notorious for slipping this in where he got a chance (and we love him for it. Among other things.) One theory among old-timers about the whole Storm/Forge thing was that the editors freaked over the level of Les Yay in Ororo's night on the town with Yukio (not to mention the former's makeover) and told the man to write in a male love interest ASAP.
      • If so, it didn't stop the subtext; in a later annual Storm's heart's desire is to run away with Yukio.
      • This became canon in an issue of Black Panther. A scene depicted all of Storm's major romantic and sexual partners. Guess who was among them.
  • And then there was Dani and Rahne in New Mutants. This page lists some of the alleged Subtext, make of them what you will.
    • Dani does have the superpower of mentally bonding with animals and Rahne is a werewolf. Still...
    • This is pretty clear: Dani: '-you're not alone. Moira loves you, and I-' Rahne: 'I know. But that doesn't make me ache any the less.'
  • Whenever I read New Mutants issues by Claremont, I have the feeling that Illyana crushes on Kitty, and Warlock on Cypher. The latter also works on the last New Mutants series.
    • Although Warlock belongs to an asexually reproducing race and thus is a "he" only by default.
    • Don't forget Kitty and Rachel. In Claremont's later run on Uncanny, when Rachel discovers that Colossus is back with Kitty, she storms out of their (Kitty and Rachel's) shared room and acts all mopey and depressed.
    • And let's not forget the overly friendly way she hugs Kitty in the X-Women one-shot. Guess who wrote said one-shot.
    • Warlock's love for Cypher played a part in the sad story of Earth-8545, where Warlock fused with Doug Ramsey in a last-ditch attempt to cure him of the Legacy Virus - and instead ended up turning almost every human and mutant on the planet into cyber-zombies.
    • "I love you and you are breaking my heart." - it's pretty much explicit with Warlock/Cypher upon Doug's return from the dead although not in a sexual manner.
  • Wolverine/Gambit and Wolverine/Cyclops is lampshaded by Emma Frost, who in one issue comments on how Wolverine and Cyclops have a "Rad Bromance."
    • And of course, Nightcrawler addresses Wolverine as "liebchen" in a recent issue. http://asylums.insanejournal.com/scans_daily/351609.html#cutid1
    • And there's Beast addressing Nightcrawler in the same way in #502...
    • Speaking of Nightcrawler he has routinely referred to Colossus by German pet names.
      • And their girlfriends have complained that on double dates they often spend more time talking to and about each other than them.
    • Both completely destroy the het pairings of the parties involved, with Wolverine/Cyclops being the 'if I can't get you I'll get your girl' example and Wolverine/Gambit both spurning Rogue.
      • Let's not forget that these three can be a threesome as well.
      • It's incredibly to easy to look at the relationship Gambit and Wolverine have with X-23 as Has Two Daddies.
      • And as if there's not enough subtext for Wolvie and Cyke, in All-New X-Men #20, Tyke expresses an attraction to X-23, despite already knowing that Laura is Logan's Opposite-Sex Clone. This has not gone without a lampshade.
  • Wolverine is walking Slash Fic fodder. He seems to get scenes of chemistry with every other X-Man, male or female, ranging from the standard Ho Yay (in the forms of Colossus and Nightcrawler) to varying shades of Slap-Slap-Kiss (Magneto and Gambit) to I Love You Because I Can't Control You (mostly in his relations with Cyclops).
  • While it could be interpreted as the actions of two men who have known each other since they were teenagers, Angel does seem pretty fond of randomly picking Cyclops up and flying off with him, and Cyclops seems more prone to affectionate physical contact with Warren, and to smiling. Also behold Old Married Couple Angel and Cyclops: [1]
  • Speaking of Claremont and Les Yay, let's not forget Spider-Woman (Jessica Drew) and Lindsey McCabe.
    • Or Jessica Drew and Carol Danvers. Or Kitty and her many predatory older women. Or... you know, let's just not forget Claremont and leave it at that.
    • Or Jessica Drew and Sybil Dvorak, or Jessica Drew and Nekra Sinclair...
  • And, more recently, the Psylocke miniseries starts with Dazzler riding around on the back of Betsy's motorcycle. Later, when he's trying to persuade Betsy to kill him, Matsu'o threatens:
    "I won't stop. Your brother. Warren Worthington. Alison Blaire... anyone and everyone you care about will die."
    • Just to be clear, that's her twin brother (with whom she is naturally extremely close), the man with whom she was canonically in love for years (and who a large section of the fandom thought she was going to marry), and... the lady she's just started hanging around with, for the first time since they were both written by Chris Claremont.
    • Madelyne Pryor(the Red Queen) kidnaps Psylocke and places her mind in her original body which was brought back from the dead under the Red Queen's control. The brainwashed Psylocke is forced to fight Dazzler who uses her powers to blow half her face off. Psylocke manages to gain control and stab herself with her psychic knife killing her old body. Dazzler goes to her now cradling her body saying "No, no, c'mon baby girl, hold on." Luckily Betsy returns to her Japanese body.
  • When Rob Liefield and Fabian Nicieza wrote X-Force in the 90s, it was a catalog of testosterone, with Shatterstar, the Mojoverse warrior who was interested only in fighting. When Nicieza took over after Liefeld left, Shatterstar began figuring outt human emotions and struck up a friendship with fellow teammate Rictor. Jeph Loeb took that one step further, giving Shatterstar a very obvious crush on Rictor and developing a subtext between the two men that eventually became difficult to ignore and a LGBT Fanbase ensued (detailed extensively here). Years later, Peter David writing X-Factor reunited the pair and had them become a canon couple, to the disapproval of Liefield who said that his vision of Shatterstar was as a 'gladiator' and 'Spartan', apparently precluding him from homosexuality.
    • I guess Liefeld knows about as much about the Spartans as he does human anatomy.
  • In a 2005 story (Rogue vol. 3 #7-12) Tony Bedard established that back in the really old days (the flashback part of the story is set before Sunfire's first appearance, X-Men #64 (1970)) a 17-year-old Rogue was really close friends with a memory-stealing female mutant called Blindspot who also happens to be immune to her absorption power. To this day Blindspot loves to cuddle up with one of Rogue's old costumes, and at the end of the story Rogue gives her the one she then was wearing in return for having her memories restored.
  • The 2010 X-Women one shot by Claremont was written just so he could make it clear that Emma Frost, Rogue, Psylocke, Kitty Pryde and Rachel Summers are all lesbian/bisexual. The whole comic from start to finish is panel after panel of poses, lines of dialogue, scenes, and character moments that make it clear ALL these characters fancy the pants of each other and are shagging like bunnies when the "Camera" is off them.
    • The art was by famed erotic artist Milo Manara. He can't not draw women that way!
  • The Colleen Coover back-up strips from X-Men: First Class were noted for some subtle Les Yay between Jean Grey and Wanda Maximoff. The fact that Coover herself is an out bisexual and was best known for girl-girl erotic comics previously didn't hurt.
  • In The Nineties, the X-Men were a metaphor for being gay. There was even a mutant AIDS.
    • Maybe even now. Matt Fraction made them live near San Francisco...
    • The X-Men made San Francisco a temporary base in the early days when they couldn't go back to Xavier's mansion for a while. And this back in the '80s.
    • "You didn't ask so I didn't tell," anyone? (X-Men: First Class)
  • Young girl mutant Bling, looking back on almost being devoured alive by the vampiric mutant Emplate in X-Men Legacy #230:
    Bling: Well, you know, it had its upside. [...] Having Rogue come riding to the rescue, and sweep me up in her womanly arms? Kind of hot.
  • In the recent X-23 comics, fandom went crazy over this little scene between Jubilee,who happens to be a vampire (better than it sounds) and X-23. X-23 and Jubilee. And this. Nicknamed appropriately, the "vampire Lesbian scene". Although the writers seem to be genre savvy, since they have Jubilee claim she was merely acting under the influence of her vampire instincts...sure.
    • Truly genre savvy writers would have known that excuse would convince no-one.
    • Some suspect X-23 had a little unrequited crush on Dust. Look at the lengths she went to in order to keep the bigoted Striker from killing Dust during the Purifiers' post-M Day attack on the school. More recently, when Dust and Laura were reunited in Avengers Academy's "A vs. X" arc, Laura makes an awkward attempt to compliment Dust; throughout the arc, their relationship is one of the side-conflicts that must be resolved.
    • Her relationship with Academy member Finesse edges this at points, especially as both are unemotionally devoid Bosom Buddies who bond over fighting and analyzing. The relationship goes sour and their final talk in Academy almost reads like a sorrow filled break up, with X-23 walking away from Finesse saying she felt betrayed by her actions.
    • As noted above, Laura gets to add a massive load of fuel to the fire over Wolverine and Cyclops just by existing, when the time-displaced teenaged Cyclops is revealed to be attracted to her.
    • On Jubilee's part there's Daria from the Operation: Zero Tolerance storyline, who betrays Bastion after being swayed by Jubilee's determination and her kindness following Daria's discovery that she was really a Prime Sentinel. Might seem standard except for the parts where Daria admires Jubilee's gutsiness with phrases like "God, I love this girl" or her constant staring at Jubilee over the monitors. In the most recent Adjectiveless series there's bisexual mutant Bling who outright admits her crush on Jubilee and even kisses her (though whether Jubilee returns her feelings remains to be seen).
  • Kitty Pryde has been mentioned on this page already, but this troper believes special mention must be made of her relationship with Storm. The older woman is the only person in the X-Universe who actually calls her "Kitten" as a term of endearment, and the troper can attest to there being at least one fanfic out there dedicated to Ororo seeing Kitty as more than "the daughter she never had" (which is the type of relationship they share in canon).
    • Then there's the Mutant X short series where Ororo is a vampire who turns Kitty (and Forge) into her slaves.
  • In X-Men Unlimited issue 22, Marrow gets downright poetic about Kitty Pryde's loveliness (before throwing a dead rat into her lap.) As a Morlock, it's supposed to be jealousy of/distate for one of the "pretty" mutants who have it so easy, but that comes off as an Informed Attribute as it's very understated and Kitty's beauty and perfection is emphasized a great deal (the entire story is seen through Marrow's eyes.) The entire portion of the issue that isn't devoted to heroing is Marrow acting like a child teasing her crush while thinking about how lovely and perfect Kitty is.
  • So, in summary, Logan is the person most affected by the death of Nightcrawler, he keeps a photograph of their happy days in his pocket, he said how much he misses him, looks at a photograph of him before heading out on one of his missions with X-Force, and hits Dark Beast for attacking a Kurt alternative. Then he puts Kurt and Jean Grey on the same level, said how much he loves his voice, called AOA! Kurt "elf", without really doing it on purpose and, at an earlier stage, has let his school be invaded by horrible blue dwarfs, only because they vaguely look like Kurt.
  • Kurt has descended to earth to help Wolverine with his fight against devils. Not protecting Wolverine is not an option.
  • Psylocke and Fantomex started out as a fairly ordinary relationship - he fell in love with her, they slept together, he got his heart ripped out by a supervillain and died. Of course, this being comics, he came back. But he came back as three people, all of them still in love with her, and one of them a woman.
    • Notably, each one gained different aspects of his original person, and while Betsy starts to date one, she finds that he's merely an asshole due to only getting the Jerk part of the originals Jerk with a Heart of Gold personality. After they break up, the female Fantomex clone approaches her, and the two quickly realize that the aspects of him that Betsy was in love with were the ones she got. It's at this point it's no longer subtext.
  • Iceman and Beast also get this every now and then.
  • Being an out lesbian it's only natural that Karma gets this a lot. As far as named characters go there was Kitty Pryde in the Mechanix miniseries written by Chris Claremont. Then there was Luna De Paula, coffeehouse barista in New Mutants and New X-Men: Academy X. Most recently it was Shi'ar warrior Warbird in Astonishing X-Men. It gets kind of amusing with the fact that, despite being one of Marvel's most prominent gay characters, none of them have gone anywhere and in fact outside of a one page one night stand in the Brubaker/Fraction run of Uncanny she's had zero romantic relationships. Her seeming failure of a love life is part of the reason why some fans like to say that "being Karma is suffering".

  • Because of lines like this, people seem to see Boom Boom and Magma's relationship in X-Men: Evolution as pretty much Romantic Two-Girl Friendship:
    Tabby: Do I know what my girl needs, or what?
    • The Brotherhood itself was one big Ho Yay orgy with four boys living in a house together with only one girl. Of particular note was Lance and Pietro.
      • After Pietro betrays the Brotherhood, they are sent by Gambit to rescue him. Lance says "I can't wait till I get my hands on Pietro." I bet you can't.
    • Scott and Kurt don't escape either. Especially since in one episode, Kurt embraces Scott in order to teleport him out of the way of a falling object.
      • Evan, while filming Kurt and Scott washing Scott's car together (yes): "Scott can be pretty stiff, but Kurt usually takes care of that." Cue Spit Take.
      • The episode where they had to share a room, and Scott leaves that room in the morning absolutely COVERED in patches of blue fur.
      • Kurt to Scott: "You really are ashamed of me!"
    • Scott and Lance. More Ho Yay than their usual Foe Yay when Lance joined the X-Men in one episode.
    • There are also Kitty and Rogue (and their famous dance scene), Rogue and Jean, and the lesbian orgy that is the "On the Wild Side" montage with Jean and Amara grinding on each other.
    • Wolverine and Captain America, in a really sweet, sad kinda way.
    • The first scene Angel and Gambit have together is a shirtless Angel walking in on Gambit, who just broke in to his house, and asking him if he"likes what he sees". Wow...
    • Then once Angel gets to the Institute, Kitty and Amara are spying on him. Bobby sneaks up behind, asks them if they're "checking him out". Once they leave, he takes their place, even sneaking closer for a better look (my shipping goggle may have been on when I saw this episode though).
    • Ta-da! More Foe Yay really, but still ... just take a look.
    • "Dark Horizon" had Magneto carrying Xavier around and looking really worried about him. Xavier does not object.
    • Also in "Dark Horizon", Wolverine and Sabertooth tend to act like a couple who went through a really bad break-up.
  • Take one good look at the average episode of the '90s cartoon and it's possible to interpret Wolverine as flirting with every male character present, provided you squint a bit in the case of Professor X.
    • In particular, the animated series created the character of Morph, whose relationship with Wolverine is...noticeably slashy. (Randomly, this caries over and is even surpassed in the comic book adaptation of the show, which simultaneously ups the suggestiveness of their relationship and completely removes their friendship. Despite the fact that their deep friendship is needed for Wolverine's behavior to make any level of sense...)
    • It would be remiss to not mention just how near-canon Rogue/Storm is. Heck, the first time we ever see Rogue's 'dere' side is when she's worrying that Storm's been crushed by debris. We don't see her express that amount of emotional attachment to her canonical love interest Gambit until nearly six episodes later.
    • Not to mention Magneto. He had a fair number of Foe Yay occasionally bordering on regular Ho Yay moments with Xavier, while his near-infinite patience with Magneto's villainy and the respect the two men hold for one another can't help but remind viewers of similar relationships. Somewhat Hilarious in Hindsight seeing as as several years on, openly gay actor Ian McKellen was cast as Magneto in the live-action films.
    Jean: (to Magneto) How much do you love Charles Xavier?
  • In Wolverine and the X-Men we have scenes of Rogue and Domino hand holding, looking into each other's eyes, and when Rogue goes to rejoin the X-Men... Domino looks like she was about to convince Rogue to stay with the Brotherhood with a kiss...
    • And as usual Xavier and Magneto have their moments: when Magneto found an injured Xavier unconscious on the shores of Genosha he took Xavier in and put him on life support, looking upon him with great concern when the X-Men caught up with them. Additionally in flashbacks after Magneto cedes defeat to Xavier in allowing a young Jean Grey to stay with Xavier's X-Men, there's a certain suggestiveness to the way they smile and trade barbs with each other after the battle, a certain flirtation almost, if you will, as if between old lovers.

  • X-Men: First Class: Charles and Erik. James McAvoy wasn't kidding when he called it a love story. This is confirmed by co-screenwriters Ashley Miller and Zack Stentz in the "Second Genesis" featurette which was included on the DVD/Blu-Ray release:
    Miller: The story between Charles and Erik is on some level this tragic romance. You gotta arrange the other elements in that way, too.
    Stentz: Yeah, in this case you have Hank and you have Raven who end up being kind of the B-story version of the same thing you're seeing playing out with Charles and Erik. It's the making and breaking of a relationship.
    • In the rare "Magneto the Survivor" featurette (the password to view the video is xmfc), First Class producer Simon Kinberg refers to Professor X's and Magneto's separation as a divorce when he discusses their older counterparts.
      "What I love between Ian [McKellen] and Patrick [Stewart] in X1, 2, 3 is the sense that they're disappointed in each other. They actually wish that the other one would just come back to them, come back to their side, you know, 'we could be so great together.' It really is a post-divorce story. Understanding the origin of their conflict was the thing that was most interesting to me in this film. Understanding the beginning of their political fissure and their emotional fissure."
    • When Erik magnetizes himself to the hull of the Blackbird to protect Charles as the plane is spinning out of the control... well, their bodies are right on top of each other and they're both screaming, plus Charles is gripping very tightly to Erik's wrist...
    • At the strip club, Charles and Erik are very comfortable lying in a bed together. They spend half of the time looking into each other's eyes instead of the scantily-clad women.
    • In a deleted scene, Charles projects Erik in drag (yes, you read that correctly) and remarks, "You've never looked more beautiful, darling." There are a million other things Charles could've conjured with his mind to make Angel giggle, and creating an image of his best friend in make-up, with a ginger wig, dressed in a sparkly blue miniskirt, fishnet stockings and go-go boots is, uh... unusually kinky.
      • The "It's good isn't it?" just beforehand. Technically, he's talking about his telepathy, but really Charles, you do seem a bit too pleased with yourself.
    • Even though they've only known each other for a couple of days, the oh-so serious Erik feels comfortable enough around the charming Charles that he calls the telepath "adorable" when the latter tries the Cerebro machine for the first time. In the entire X-Men movie franchise, the dour Magneto never teases another male character for his cuteness, which goes to show how unique his affection for Professor X is.
    • Erik tells Emma that he wants her on his team to fill the "gap in [his] life" left by Xavier (who, it is important to note, he has only known for a few months tops).
    • There's such a ridiculous amount of Ho Yay in this movie, that by the end it almost feels like Charles is cheating on Erik when he kisses Moira (and Erik is cheating on Charles when he kisses Raven). Certainly the fact that Erik was absolutely hell-bent on turning those missiles on the Soviet and American fleets, and the only thing that stops him is Charles getting shot, whereupon he falls to his knees in abject horror, cradles his friend in his arms, and forgets the thousands of soldiers just off the coast doesn't help things! And that's just one example.
    • Erik ferociously barks, "I SAID BACK OFF!!!" to the youngsters like a predator who wants to defend its wounded mate. If Charles was indeed dying, Erik would selfishly be the only one who could say goodbye to him—even Raven (whom Magneto respects more than the other mutants present) isn't "allowed" to be near her adoptive brother.
    • As blatantly homoerotic as the entire film is, the scene where Charles uncovers the happiest memory in Erik's mind, which results in Erik shedding a Single Tear and Charles wiping away one from his own cheek, takes the cake.
      Erik: What did you do to me?
      Charles: I accessed the brightest corner of your memory system. It's a very beautiful memory, Erik. Thank you.
      • Note that this is the only time in the entire franchise we see stoic, grim Erik give a full, honest smile and actually laugh.
    • When they first meet, Charles hugs a drowning Erik in an attempt to calm the other man down.
    • In the truck where Charles mentally renders his team invisible to the Soviet soldiers, Erik's hand is on the inside of his friend's thigh.
    • Just as Moira and her team are about to ditch Erik at the residence of the Soviet official after he becomes a security risk, Charles bluntly tells her, "I'm sorry, I can't leave him," and runs off after Erik.
    • "Rage and Serenity" from the soundtrack is practically a Love Theme for Charles and Erik because it's a combination of their own individual Leitmotifs. This essay explains in more detail what makes the piece so poignant.
      "...at 0:42, a small melodic motif is introduced, which seems to generally be used as Charles' theme in the film. This continues to play as Charles acts as a mentor and friend to Erik, showing him the memory, and telling him to try again.

      At 1:19 in the song, Erik's theme comes in. Now, Erik has two themes: a calmer, somewhat arpeggiated electric guitar riff, and a more intense "Magneto" theme, generally used when he is doing something violent. The one used here is the calmer one. However, instead of taking over the music entirely, the guitar actually plays the theme in counterpoint to Charles' theme, not sacrificing its unique timbre, but still blending in with the orchestra to create an amazing sound. The song builds to a climax as Erik finally moves the dish, and then fades away gently as Erik smiles and laughs, and Charles pats him on the back proudly.

      This, more than anything, really enforces the metaphor that Erik and Charles are Rage and Serenity. They have their individual strengths and advantages, but they are stronger when working together to reach a single goal. And working together doesn't erase either of their individual qualities—Erik is still Rage and Charles is still Serenity, just as the guitar is still a guitar and the orchestra is still an orchestra. Together, they create something new and better, something more than a sum of its parts, as the popular saying goes. That's why the relationship between Charles and Erik is so powerful, and why this scene is so emotionally charged—they were practically made for each other, each perfectly complementing the other."
    • The USA Network's commercial for First Class's Blu-Ray/DVD release includes this cheeky line: "Unfortunately, [Charles and Erik] working together to prevent nuclear Armageddon was not great for their relationship."
    • ''First Class'' could've been marketed as a family comedy about two foster dads (the nurturing Team Mom Charles and the "tough love" Team Dad Erik) trying to raise several rowdy teenagers, and it wouldn't be far from the truth.
    • In this crossover parody between First Class and Casino Royale (which is appropriate because XMFC was inspired by '60s-era James Bond films), Erik Lehnsherr is 007, Moira MacTaggert is M, Sebastian Shaw is Le Chiffre, and Charles Xavier is... you guessed it, Vesper Lynd— Bond's love interest—who, like Charles, has access to money and also harbours a strong aversion towards violence. While it's odd hearing Professor X with a woman's voice, his character is nevertheless well-suited for Vesper's role.
    • Hell, for that matter, James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender. While doing interviews promoting the film, they sang to each other and talked about how they would fly all over the world spreading love to the hapless populace if they had super powers. McAvoy even "confesses" that he and Fassbender have done the horizontal limbo.
      Interviewer: What is the most common question you are asked?
      James McAvoy: How many times did you have sex with Michael Fassbender?
      Interviewer: That is the question. And what is the answer?
      McAvoy: Four.
      Interviewer: Extraordinary chemistry between you and Michael [Fassbender]. Can you talk a little about how you developed that onscreen?
      James McAvoy: We had sex every morning, and that helped make the chemistry!
      Interviewer: I know a lot of the fans loved in First Class the relationship between you and Mr. Fassbender, Charles and Erik, there was an intimate moment or two, there was a connection, do we finally get to see them kiss?
      James McAvoy: (laughs) Air kiss. Air kissing and Eskimo kiss.
      Interviewer: You know if you're air-kissing, he could use his weight to pull you closer.
      James McAvoy: (laughs) It's good, he could try, certainly buy me dinner a few times first.
      Interviewer: I know a lot of the fans [..] responded very well to the bromance, the masculine friendship, the intimacy that you shared with James McAvoy on the screen the last time. I asked him any chance of a kiss, and he seems willing if you're game.
      Michael Fassbender: (sings) Sometimes when we touch, the honesty is too much... (laughs)
      Interviewer: I'm welling up! That's an emotional moment.
    • British TV host Graham Norton had a lot of fun showing McAvoy and Fassbender Cherik fanart and fanfiction.
    • Darwin and Alex Summers have their little moments. There is a scene where Darwin places his hand on Alex's stomach, and just a few seconds before Darwin dies, who does he reach out to? Alex.
    • On the villainous side, the Azazel/Riptide pairing is as popular as Azazel/Mystique.
  • X-Men: Days of Future Past has both past Charles/Erik and future Charles/Erik moments.
    • Younger Charles becomes agitated by the mere mention of Erik. Erik is affected by Charles as well.
      Charles: YOU ABANDONED ME!!! You took her away, and YOU ABANDONED ME!!!
      • It really says something when that was the first thing he said when blinded by emotion. Xavier then brings up Raven, his sister figure... before bringing up Erik abandoning him again. It's pretty clear who's more important to him.
      • And after they've had a huge shouting match during which Erik rages so hard he almost crashes their plane, Erik looks contrite after Charles storms off to sit next to Hank in the co-pilot's seat. In their next scene, Erik attempts to persuade Charles into a quiet game of chess as a peace offering. A section of their dialogue has shades of a Double Entendre.
      Charles: It's been a while since I've played.
      Erik: I'll go easy on you.
    • Logan outright refers to Erik as "someone he [Charles] loved" when trying to convince Charles to go and find him. Although it's possible he was referring to Mystique, they were talking about Erik at the time, and it's left deliberately ambiguous.
      Logan: The professor I knew would never turn his back on someone who lost their path, especially someone he loved.
    • When Logan asks Hank as to why Charles is in such bad shape, Hank lists Erik before Raven and the spinal cord injury, implying that the loss of Erik upset Charles more than the other two.
      Hank: He lost everything: Erik, Raven, his legs...
    • Not to mention them (the older future versions) holding hands when they think they're both about to die.
      Magneto: All those years we wasted fighting each other, Charles... To have a precious few of them back...
    • After Charles punches Erik very hard in the face, not only does Erik not retaliate at all (it's extremely rare for him to not respond to violence with violence), but he simply wipes his mouth where he was hit as he cheerfully greets Charles without any sarcasm. After believing for 11 years that he'd never see Charles again (and 10 of those were spent in solitary confinement), Erik is so darn grateful to be in Charles' presence once more that he isn't the least bit angry by the latter's punch.
      Erik: Good to see you, too, old friend.
    • When the guards try to shoot them in the Pentagon kitchen, Charles instinctively places his arm across Erik's chest as a protective gesture.
    • Charles letting Erik go after he's just tried to kill the president, even though Erik's not wearing the helmet and he could easily stop him. And then Erik reacts by telling Charles that the humans will kill him if they catch him before he flies away, instead of immediately going for the helmet so Charles can't get back inside his head.
    • There has been a small, but noticeable increase in "Xavierine" (Xavier/Wolverine) shippers thanks to James McAvoy and Hugh Jackman sharing a lot of screentime together. It's a Mentor Ship that works both ways because Logan counsels the younger Charles in this movie, but Professor X is Wolverine's mentor in the original trilogy.
    • Hank and Charles have pretty much isolated themselves from the outside world and are each other's Only Friend for a decade. Situational Sexuality, anyone? James McAvoy even joked about the inherent slash-iness of the two characters in this interview.
      McAvoy: Hank is my enabler and my bitch.
      • There's a brief moment in the Gag Reel on the Blu-Ray/DVD release where Nicholas Hoult lifts James (who is much shorter than his younger co-star) into his arms and performs a Bridal Carry.
  • Writer Simon Kinberg has said that X-Men: Apocalypse is the third chapter of a love story between Magneto and Professor X.
    "If First Class was Erik's story and Days of Future Past is Charles' story, then Apocalypse will be both of their stories. The first movie was about Erik becoming empowered. That's the origin story of a man's power. Days of Future Past is about a guy who is a mess, masterminding the end of this massive movie. So they are both at their peak powers at the start of Apocalypse, so Apocalypse for me is the culmination of that three-act love story."
  • X-Men: The Last Stand:
    • A Harsher in Hindsight example. After X-Men: First Class revealed that the young Xavier taught Lehnsherr how to achieve greater control over his power by finding the point between rage and serenity—the latter requires a happy memory—Magneto's line of "Charles always wanted to build bridges" as he's moving a large section of the Golden Gate Bridge seems to indicate that he's thinking about his dear old friend instead of his mother in order to attain serenity. And like his mother, Xavier—whom he loved—is now dead, so happy memories from their brief friendship in 1962 is all Magneto has left of him.
    • Ian McKellen wanted Magneto to have homosexual relationship with Professor X in this film.
      "It would be wonderful if the camera hovered over Magneto's bed to discover him making love to Professor X."

    Video Games 
  • Yes, really. In X-Men Legends II, we've got Brotherhood and X-Men working together, and when Toad talks about how Magneto should be in charge and not Xavier, Magneto said "Charles and I discuss everything before a mission." With emphasis on Xavier's name just like that. You'd have to hear it, but the way he said it sounded like the bratty kids preferring one parent's way over the other, but the other assures them that all decisions are made as a unit. In general, the arguments between the two teams in almost every cut scene make Charles and Erik seem like Mommy and Daddy to bickering siblings for the entire game. And nobody but the other calls each other by his first name (except Emma Frost at one point). It probably sounds like a Shipping Goggles-based stretch to anyone who hasn't played it, but it's unmistakable to anyone who has.