main index




Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
Headscratchers: Everyman HYBRID
  • Weapons. Okay, so the crew seems to have a little bit of pocket change (not that much, but enough for what I'm thinking). Why don't they invest in some practical or heavy weaponry. Not necessarily guns, that would be a disaster waiting to happen, but c'mon. Consider the Rake, at least. How do you defend against that? Knives will do nothing to keep him from shredding you with his cursed infected claws, even if they eventually get him to back off or even kill him. Think of it this way—what would you do to defend yourself against a cougar or a bear? Because what they'd be going up against would be about as formidable in a straight fight. Something to keep it at arms reach like a spear (makeshift, probably) or a really heavy and long club sort of thing would be more effective than a knife. Though really, given the close quarters, ambushes, and paranormal surprises they face a shield of some kind might be more useful. Body armor too, it can't hurt to be paranoid. Ranged weapons would be good if they weren't so dangerous with all the mind-control reality-shifting going on. If they wanted to be really effective, a flamethrower would be good for probing freaky areas quickly (again, walking disaster). These are just some thoughts on, y'know, reasonable precautions. And I do mean reasonable—the shit they're going through is absolutely batshit ridiculously dangerous.
    • Now, granted, some or all of that would detract from the whole Cosmic Horror Story tone and everything, but given how resourceful these guys are it would probably be in character to explore the possibility. Even then, a plain old hockey stick or trash can lid wouldn't be that out-of-tone than all the knives.
  • Slender Man and the Rake, in the same story?
    • Some people think it's genius, considering that the SA thread Slenderman originated from also contained the Rake (on the same page, even, if I remember correctly).
    • Now Candle Cove's shown up and Slendy and hell, even the Rake have been a bit Out of Focus. This is getting to be a bit much for one series to conceivably handle well.
      • While I think the series is doing a good job of being unique, I agree that the Creepy Pasta buffet is getting to be a bit much. I wouldn't be surprised if they found the Grifter tape at this point.
      • This troper expects one of them to come across an old copy of Majora's Mask any day now...
      • I'm expecting them to find a video where Jessa said Candle Jack on camera and-
    • I don't see the problem. They, like, all have the exact same freaking primal creepy tone. It makes sense for them to be connected. If nothing else, they support each other's mythos pretty well as presented.
      • ...not really. Especially when the purported "Slender Man series" barely features aforementioned antagonist. HABIT pretty much took over the series entirely with the other things now being essentially irrelevant.
  • What happened to the exterminator that disappeared in Alex's room? I mean, I know, obviously, the rake killed him, but you'd think police would be suspicious at least...
  • Why would Jeff and Alex even have that recording of their mother's voice saying mundane phrases in "One Step Forward, Two Steps Back," unless they knew beforehand that she would die and they needed those mundane phrases to be recorded? And why would they record that creepy background noise under her words?
    • IIRC, Alex was just recording to use for some music. And then when they died, Alex snapped and started using the recordings as the real deal.
  • What's with the underwater clips that keep showing up in the hidden videos? I sorta feel like it's foreshadowing, but still...
    • It sure smells like foreshadowing, but like a lot of the "hidden video" footage, I don't think anyone has any flippin' idea what's going on with it, save for whacked-out theories (which for the time being is the only thing anyone can come up with).
  • Just something that popped into my head while watching Dark Harvest: did the motif of Slendy hanging bags full of people's guts from trees originate in this one, or is it older?
    • It is much older. It was one of Tall, Dark, and Scary's modus operandi from the original Something Awful forum. Except he would remove the organs, place each one in a separate bag, then return them to the body in the anatomically correct places. Except for the entrails, sometimes.
    • Wasn't there something like this in the Blair Witch Project? Which might have influenced or inspired the idea. I don't know if that would predate the above, though.
  • What happened to Damsel? It's clear she's still alive, at least, since HABIT mentioned her in ":D", and, since she's preggers with Evan's child, I don't see how they would be planning to kill her off (at least, not just yet). But her blog & twitter are dead, and she hasn't been seen in a vid for ages, soooo ... what's going on?
    • The video "Next" has her making a reappearance. And, well, let's just ain't a happy one.
  • Could someone explain where all this "HABIT is an enemy of Slender Man" theories are coming from? I've never seen HABIT being anything but helpful to Ol' Tall, Bald and Faceless.
    • It might have something to do with the 'talks' between the two on the Twitter.
      • Has it been confirmed that it was Slender Man he was talking to? I had always thought it was Corenthal.
  • This is a minor one, but while watching A Summoning, I noticed HABIT occasionally had a dual voice, I didn't notice that in his previous videos, did he always have that or was he using it here just to freak out Vince?
  • Why in the world did Evan go along with Vinny's plan to let HABIT re-possess him? Does he just not even care anymore because he's emotionally dead or something?
    • It's a combination of that and exactly what Vinny said: they are just sitting there waiting for something to happen. They want answers. And it doesn't even matter because HABIT can possess Evan AT WILL.
  • Anyone else feel like the production value's dropping? I mean the most recent videos are basically just one scene of people talking about what's going on. There's not as much trippy editing and we haven't seen The Rake in over a year. It's like they're getting sorta tired of making these, isn't it?
    • From my contact with the guys... that isn't the case at all. They love the fans and they love doing this. It's changed their lives. As for Production value... they have better cameras... and their fanbase is just as big as ever. The story they are telling requires these scenes... or they wouldn't be there. The same reason there is tons of side-content. It's not for budgets sake that those aren't shown in video form... it's for realism and it's the way they are telling the story.

Echo ChamberHeadscratchers/Web OriginalFlander's Company

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from
Privacy Policy