Eye Scream is surprisingly frequent in My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic. It's always Played for Laughs, though.
- In the episode "Swarm of the Century", Rarity finds out how parasprites reproduce when one barfs a glob of brown slime into her eye... which then pulls itself off of her eye and becomes a new parasprite.
- In the episode "Green Isn't Your Color", Twilight Sparkle accidentally pokes herself in the eye while swearing to keep Fluttershy's displeasure with her modeling career a secret.Twilight Sparkle: Cross my heart and hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my... AUGH!
- In "Sisterhooves Social", Granny Smith accidentally pokes herself in the eye with a megaphone when her rocking chair swings too much.
- Twilight gets another one in "It's About Time" when she accidentally looks into the sun with her telescope. This one results in an "emergency" Eyepatch of Power, courtesy of Pinkie Pie.
- Pinkie herself gets one in "A Friend In Deed". Although nothing actually happens to her eye, seeing the eyeball poke through a keyhole and look around is definitely cringe-worthy, especially when it gets snagged and Pinkie has to forcibly yank it back out.
- In "Hurricane Fluttershy", Rainbow Dash crash lands and has a head-on collision with a tree, which results in her eyes popping out from the other side. The creaky sound as she tries to pull herself free is pretty squicky by itself.
- In "Keep Calm and Flutter On", Discord pulls his eyes out when making a pun about rolling his eyes.
- Narrowly averted in "Testing, Testing, 1, 2, 3", where Twilight Sparkle catches Rainbow Dash's spitwad a few inches away from her eye. Twilight angrily points out that if she didn't catch it, she could have been blinded.
- In "The Lost Treasure of Griffonstone", Gilda's grandfather is blind in the left eye with a long scar running across it, hinting it was clawed or scratched out in the past.
- In "The Crystalling, Part 1", Baby Flurry Heart climbs onto Pinkie Pie's face and pokes her hoof in her eye, but Pinkie doesn't even flinch.
- Near the end of "To Where and Back Again - Part 1", Discord's eyes stretch out of their sockets while he looks for Fluttershy.
