Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs East Meets West! Let's Read Sailor Moon: American Kitsune!!
Psyga3152012-04-13 09:36:17

Go To


Catch the Moon! Another Prophecy About The Moon!!

"Also, is anyone planning on liveblogging Sailor Moon: American Kitsune?"

Hello everyone, Psyga315 here again. Now I have read a lot of summeries for bad fan fics, My Immortal, Light And Dark The Adventures Of Dark Yagami, My Inner Life, and the like, but I had never seen something as legendary as American Kitsune. To put simply, it used to be the quoted example for Canon Defilement. Yep, not My Immortal or any of the others, this fan fic was the one that won that trope page’s spotlight. Let me count the fan fic’s major crimes before we get to the reason why I wanted to live blog it. First, we have said defilement. For those who don’t know, David Gonterman, author of American Kitsune, retconned Serena into David’s (our hero for the story) sister via squicky means. Second, David kills a homosexual character and then does a speech that most people sum up as homophobic. These two flaws in the story seem to be the main reason why he was made infamous in the Sailor Moon fan base (which ironically, is infamous for killing off Darien and making Sailor Uranus a full out boy in most of the early fanfiction). Not to mention the obvious flaw for any fan fiction: The Mary Sue. I don’t think I need to explain what a Mary Sue is because chances are, you already know.

So, why do I want to live blog it? Well, after hearing so much about it, Bile Fascination kicked in. I found the text and I wasn’t turned off from it. The only time I was turned off was at the beginning, which was confusing at first, but after a Dramatic Reading, I got it and moved on. I read all the way up to chapter 6, the halfway mark. I figured that I might as well finish reading it, and I would finish it by live blogging it. So, without further to do, let’s read American Kitsune.

Part One of Eleven

We open in Saint Louis where the Mighty Morphin Power Rangers, Masked Rider, and the VR Troopers are at a Youth United Nations place where they are joined by David “Davey”*

Kintobor (Yes, You read right, Davey’s last name was Kintobor. It’s no coincidence neither) who had just killed the Piasa Monster. What is the Piasa Monster, you may ask? Well, this story is actually part of an arc Gonterman made. This Piasa Monster incident was a prequel to both this, and Blood and Metal, a Sonic The Hedgehog fan fic. You can read it here. This is sort of like reading a comic book, then seeing some dialogue with a star attached to it. Then a small caption refers the star to another comic book that people have to read in order to get the dialogue. It’s peeving to me because I’d like to stick to this one and not focus on the other two.

So we flash back to Davey confronting Portwood, a history teacher who shot off Davey’s arm. He delivers a speech that reminds me of Goku’s speech towards Freeza after he defeats him in his Super Sayian form. Not in a bad way, mind you, as it does seem to set up what kind of morals Davey has. There is also a scene where he refuses to accept a key to the city and states that the reason why he did that was that he did not wanted to be viewed as its superhero after the crap he has been through. Wow. I am impressed so far.

Somewhere around here is where I got a little confused. See, between the Piasa Monster and American Kitsune, Davey lived another life on Mobius (yes, THAT Mobius. Told you the Kintobor thing was no coincidence) much like how the Penvensie Siblings lived their life in Narnia. Zordon and his bud, Old Man Coyote (I assume it’s The Space Coyote) are trying to dearchive his past life in poor Davey’s head. This apparently has Davey unlock the power to become a Kitsune. So yes, Davey gained the power to morph into the Nine-Tailed Demon Fox. Oh how I wish. Oh, and he is also a cyborg from that whole Piasa incident. So there’s this vision in which the moon will fall on Davey some day. Great. He’s going to have to learn that Song of Time.

And so Davey wakes up to see his friend, Edward, who (I think) also lived his life on Mobius Narnia-style. Oh, and Edward has like, two thousand personalities in his head. So wait, does that mean that somewhere in his head, a certain Edward is in there? So they talk about that moon vision and they see something, or someone, fall. Davey turns on some Powered Armor (which he says is not Power Rangers inspired but instead Masters Of The Maze inspired, and since I have never heard of that show and the only suit I saw was some knight armor and the picture is obscured, I’m just gonna go ahead and say it’s something like Kamen Rider Birth) and rescues the someone. There is this fun exchange about the Prophecy Twist ("Wow, the moon did fall on us!" "Yeah, Sailor Moon!") as we see Sailor Moon looking damaged. She makes a redneck joke and passes out. Davey and Edward decide to take her inside.

That is how the first chapter ends. Personally, I found it a tad confusing, though it might be because I did not read the other two stories. As I said, this nearly turned me off had it not been for the Dramatic Reading immediately starting Chapter 2 soon after. So this is where the post ends.

Comments

Morgikit Since: Dec, 1969
Sep 9th 2012 at 5:50:59 PM
I don't think Gonterman meant to suggest that Davey was killing the gay zombies. Just that homosexuals (much like porno fans and...people who make fun of his work) are violent and irrational and must be dealt with roughly so they don't hurt themselves or others. And are diseased perverts. Plus the reference to AIDS...you know what? It's still bullshit.

Also the whole "killing Zoicite because he flirted with him and made everyone think he was gay" thing...reminds me too much of a case in recent years. Fortunately the fic isn't much longer.
Psyga315 Since: Dec, 1969
Sep 11th 2012 at 1:58:04 PM
Yeah, I kind of figured that, but it's still stupid considering that the Luna Card was modified to pass through humans harmlessly, and so using it to knock them out wouldn't make much sense. And using the Bloody Card, last I checked, was very, very violent and even Serena asked Davey not to use it because of it. That and they didn't want the Lovely Angels finding and gunning them down.
Morgikit Since: Dec, 1969
Sep 11th 2012 at 5:07:27 PM
Never seen Dirty Pair, but that makes sense. I don't want you to think I'm trying to defend this crap; it's quite horrific.

Also, if he was trying to work Japanese mythology in, why not use Inari (a goddess associated with spirit foxes) instead of this made up Queen Kitsune character? Didn't do the research?
Psyga315 Since: Dec, 1969
Sep 15th 2012 at 7:33:59 PM
Yeah, I'm probably going to say that. However, this being the internet in the 90's, I'm surprised that he knows what a Kitsune was back in the day. Nowadays people point to Naruto when they hear the word Kitsune, hence my Hilarious in Hindsight comment.

I'd take a stretch and say that the internet was just getting broken in by the time this fanfiction was made, so even if there were sources of Inari now, chances are that there weren't back in the day. I can also blame The Theme Park Version or Common Knowledge, since Kitsunes are more easier to know than Inari (I mean, this is the first time I heard of her), especially since, again, one of the most influential anime heroes has a Kitsune living inside him.
Top