History YMMV / TotalMagicPonyIsland

** Pinkie's accidental ''[[{{FanFic/Cupcakes}} Cupcakes]]'' reference.

* CrazyAwesome: Pinkie Pie, like in the series, is insane but awesome.
* CreatorsPet: The author seems to be a Trixie fan.

* OutOfCharacter: Discord, according to the pre-readers at Equestria Daily.

* AccidentalAesop: Can be both good or bad; Gilda and Diamond Tiara were sent home because of their attitude and bullying, seemingly providing the aesop that [[CaptainObvious bullying is bad]]. However, Sweetie Belle is sent home for making one mistake that ''anypony'' could have made and wasn't even entirely her fault, which may be telling readers that you have to do everything perfectly, or everyone will hate you.

* CrowningMomentOfAwesome: [[Awesome/TotalMagicPonyIsland Has its own page.]]
* CrowningMomentOfFunny: [[Funny/TotalMagicPonyIsland Also has its own page.]]
* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: [[Heartwarming/TotalMagicPonyIsland You know the drill.]]

** [[spoiler: Trixie]] may be this, if her DarkAndTroubledPast is anything to go on.

* CompleteMonster: The only even ''remotely'' nice thing Gilda does is reluctantly congratulate Apple Bloom for pulling their team to victory in one challenge. Every other moment, she acts just as bad as in her own episode in the show, if not more so. [[spoiler: Subverted when she returns in chapter 14, as she's become a bit nicer; more of a JerkWithAHeartOfGold.]]

* AccidentalNightmareFuel: Gilda's rage during the dodgeball challenge.
** Also when [[spoiler: Trixie goes into her ThenLetMeBeEvil moment.]]
** Nightmare Moon's introduction can possibly catch some people off guard.
** The sudden reappearance of Mare Do Well. Worst part is that, so far, it doesn't seem to be one of the mane six this time...
** After [[spoiler: Silver Spoon]] is eliminated, [[spoiler: Spike]] gives a BadassBoast right before the end of the episode that is equal parts [[LetsGetDangerous awesome]] and [[ThenLetMeBeEvil scary]].
** Pinkie's accidental ''[[{{FanFic/Cupcakes}} Cupcakes]]'' reference.

* BetterThanItSounds

* CompleteMonster: The only even ''remotely'' nice thing Gilda does is reluctantly congratulate Apple Bloom for pulling their team to victory in one challenge. Every other moment, she acts just as bad as in her own episode in the show, if not more so.

* TearJerker: [[spoiler: Trixie]]'s past. As well as her breakdown after the talent show.
** [[spoiler: Apple Bloom]] being voted off without a reason, as part of [[spoiler: Trixie]]'s plan to stay safe.
** [[spoiler: Silver Spoon]] getting eliminated counts as well, especially [[spoiler: Spike's]] reaction.
** Celestia's breakdown after [[spoiler: Luna is eliminated]].
** [[spoiler: Spike's]] HeroicBSOD after being eliminated.

** The fact that the unicorns are treated as useless due to not having their magic, pegasus wings, or earth pony power seems like saying if you lose whatever you're good at, you will become completely useless to everybody around you.

** Pinkie's accidental ''[[FanFic/Cupcakes Cupcakes]]'' reference.

* TearJerker: The implications of [[spoiler: Trixie]]'s past. As well as her breakdown after the talent show.

* TheWoobie: Silver Spoon, especially during the camping challenge.
** [[spoiler: Trixie]] may be this, if her implied DarkAndTroubledPast is anything to go on.

** [[spoiler: Apple Bloom]] being voted off without a reason, as part of [[spoiler: Trixie]]'s plan to stay safe.