History YMMV / MagicaMadokaVeneficusPuella

* MagnificentBastard: [[spoiler:[=KyuBey=] is back, and so is his foresight and penchant for making underailable plans.]]

* TheWoobie: [[spoiler: [=VPuniverse=]!Madoka who gets dropped in the canonverse and contracts to save canonSayaka, going through the same hellish time loops Homura went through. At least she has the [=VPuniverse=]!Homura for support.]]
* JustForFun/XMeetsY: ''Madoka Magica'' meets ''{{Fanfic/Nobody Dies}}''.

* TheWoobie: [[spoiler: [=VPuniverse=]!Madoka who gets dropped in the canonverse and contracts to save canonSayaka, going through the same hellish time loops Homura went through. At least she has the [=VPuniverse=]!Homura for support.]]

* CompleteMonster: [=TorBey=]. Unlike [=KyuBey=], he skips the turning-little-girls-into-liches part of ThePlan and goes straight to turning them into [[EldritchAbomination Witches]], downright lying to them to do so. Even worse, some of the witches attempt to revert back into their human form, which nearly always worsens their situation, creating more negative energy for him to collect.

* UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:[[BreakTheCutie Sayaka's life got shittier before?]] ]]
** It's arguably an example of the [[BalanceBetweenGoodAndEvil conversation of despair]] theme in the original series, with a bit of Junko's FamilyUnfriendlyAesop about recovering faster when you're young.

* UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:[[BreakTheCutie Sayaka's life got shittier before?]]

* CompleteMonster: [=TorBey=]. Unlike [=KyuBey=], he skips the turning-little-girls-into-liches part of the plan and goes straight to turning them into [[EldritchAbomination Witches]], downright lying to them to do so. Even worse, some of the witches attempt to revert back into their human form, which nearly always worsens their situation, creating more negative energy for him to collect.
* CrackPairing: [[spoiler: Mami/Kazuko]] [[FlatWhat What.]]

* MemeticBadass: Homura may or may not be heading this way, after gunning down a very, ''''very'''' large number of [=TorBeys=]. Without powers.
** And now she's taken to running around with a pair of magical guns, KO'ing people in her sleep, and terrifying the general population with but a simmering glare.
* UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:[[BreakTheCutie Sayaka's life got shittier before?]] [[SarcasmMode That makes everything better!]] [[CrapsackWorld Here, anyways.]]]]

* TheWoobie: [[WordOfGod I don't know about you guys,]] but I think that [[IronWoobie Homura qualifies for this.]]
** [[spoiler: [=VPuniverse=]!Madoka who gets dropped in the canonverse and contracts to save canonSayaka, going through the same hellish time loops Homura went through. At least she has the [=VPuniverse=]!Homura for support.]]

*** The author's predictive powers can be pretty mystifying. How did the author know that [[spoiler: Airi]] was a WhiteHairedPrettyGirl? (Her hair color was confirmed in a piece of official artwork released with Volume 2 of ''Kazumi'', a short time after the character appeared).

*** The author's predictive powers can be pretty mystifying. How the heck did the author know that [[spoiler: Airi]] was a WhiteHairedPrettyGirl? (Her hair color was confirmed in a piece of official artwork released with Volume 2 of ''Kazumi'', a short time after the character appeared).

* HilariousInHindsight: Before Chapter 6 of the fic, ''PuellaMagiOrikoMagica'' was unreleased, and in fact it was still assumed Oriko [[CoversAlwaysLie was the green haired girl on the cover]]. The funny part comes with recent ''Oriko Magica'' spoilers, which show that [[spoiler: the fanfic's references to some sort of horrible incident involving Oriko ''were remarkably prescient.'']]

** A BlackComedy variant. Chapter 6 of ''PuellaMagiKazumiMagica'' has [[spoiler: what is essentially ''a near-Remnant''.]]

* HighOctaneNightmareFuel: Wouldn't be ''Madoka Magica'' without it.

* CompleteMonster: [=TorBey=]. Unlike [=KyuBey=], he skips the turning-little-girls-into-liches part of the plan and goes straight to turning them into [[{{CosmicHorror}} Witches]], downright lying to them to do so. Even worse, some of the witches attempt to revert back into their human form, which nearly always worsens their situation, creating more negative energy for him to collect.