Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / TheWizardOfOz

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Did I make that typo?


[[WMG: The Wicked Witch's is a fire elemental, and this is the reason why water melts her.]]

to:

[[WMG: The Wicked Witch's Witch is a fire elemental, and this is the reason why water melts her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


When the shoes brought Dorothy back to the real world, she fell asleep, leading to the apparent AllJustADream ending. A side effect of the magic is that not only does Dorothy come home, but her family and friends' memory of her having been missing is erased, and they think they just found Dorothy unconscious after the cyclone passed. Yet if this is true, then how to explain the dream-like moment in the cyclone when Miss Gulch turns into a wicked witch? It's simple. "Almira Gulch" was just a pseudonym used by the Wicked Witch of the East, who liked to fly out of Oz now and then, disguise herself as a normal woman, and cause trouble for unsuspecting people ForTheEvulz. When the cyclone blows Dorothy toward Oz, Gulch follows her but is crushed by the house. This also explains how ''Film/ReturnToOz'' could work and why Toto was never in any danger again.

to:

When the shoes brought Dorothy back to the real world, she fell asleep, leading to the apparent AllJustADream ending. A side effect of the magic is that not only does Dorothy come home, but her family and friends' memory of her having been missing is erased, and they think they just found Dorothy her unconscious after the cyclone passed. Yet if this is true, then how to explain the dream-like moment in the cyclone when Miss Gulch turns into a wicked witch? It's simple. "Almira Gulch" was just a pseudonym used by the Wicked Witch of the East, who liked to fly out of Oz now and then, disguise herself as a normal woman, and cause trouble for unsuspecting people ForTheEvulz. When the cyclone blows Dorothy toward Oz, Gulch follows her but is crushed by the house. This also explains how ''Film/ReturnToOz'' could work and why Toto was never in any danger again.

Added: 446

Changed: 698

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Gulch follows Dorothy but is crushed by the house. When the shoes brought Dorothy back to the real world, she fell asleep, leading to the apparent AllJustADream ending. This also explains how ''Film/ReturnToOz'' could work and why Toto was never in any danger again.

to:

Gulch follows Dorothy but is crushed by the house. When the shoes brought Dorothy back to the real world, she fell asleep, leading to the apparent AllJustADream ending. A side effect of the magic is that not only does Dorothy come home, but her family and friends' memory of her having been missing is erased, and they think they just found Dorothy unconscious after the cyclone passed. Yet if this is true, then how to explain the dream-like moment in the cyclone when Miss Gulch turns into a wicked witch? It's simple. "Almira Gulch" was just a pseudonym used by the Wicked Witch of the East, who liked to fly out of Oz now and then, disguise herself as a normal woman, and cause trouble for unsuspecting people ForTheEvulz. When the cyclone blows Dorothy toward Oz, Gulch follows her but is crushed by the house. This also explains how ''Film/ReturnToOz'' could work and why Toto was never in any danger again.
again.

[[WMG: If the above is true, then Dorothy, Uncle Henry, Aunt Em and Toto will all eventually travel to Oz and settle there permanently, as in the original book series.]]
Hunk, Hickory and Zeke will probably come too, since they're like honorary family to the Gales. When they meet the Scarecrow, the Tin Man and the Cowardly Lion, they'll be amazed to meet non-human creatures who are so similar to themselves, and they'll all become good friends.

Added: 773

Changed: 707

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Oz is at a "higher level of reality," as theorized by Timothy Leary, and Dorothy is there in a lucid dream from a very precise head injury. The Oz characters look like people she knows not because they're part of the dream, but because each of them is the Higher Truth or Realer Self of that Kansan. This is what kills Miss Gulch -- the Witch is Gulch's shriveled soul, and destroying it destroys her. (This is true of Toto, too. It's the hyper-real Toto that accompanies her in Oz while the real Toto remains on Earth. A domesticated dog is enough of a person to have a soul, and a dog is honest about itself so its soul and body look the same.)

Yes, this does mean one could perform very efficient assassinations by traveling to Oz and murdering the Ozite corresponding to your target. Perhaps this is what Professor Marvel is working on; if he's a government agent it would explain both his behavior, oddly responsible and compassionate for a criminal, and the prominence of his soul-self in Oz.

to:

* Oz is at a "higher level of reality," as theorized by Timothy Leary, and Dorothy is there in a lucid dream from a very precise head injury. The Oz characters look like people she knows not because they're part of the dream, but because each of them is the Higher Truth or Realer Self of that Kansan. This is what kills Miss Gulch -- the Witch is Gulch's shriveled soul, and destroying it destroys her. (This is true of Toto, too. It's the hyper-real Toto that accompanies her in Oz while the real Toto remains on Earth. A domesticated dog is enough of a person to have a soul, and a dog is honest about itself so its soul and body look the same.)

) Yes, this does mean one could perform very efficient assassinations by traveling to Oz and murdering the Ozite corresponding to your target. Perhaps this is what Professor Marvel is working on; if he's a government agent it would explain both his behavior, oddly responsible and compassionate for a criminal, and the prominence of his soul-self in Oz.Oz.

[[WMG: The Wicked Witch's is a fire elemental, and this is the reason why water melts her.]]
* This is also suggested under AlternateCharacterInterpretation on the movie's YMMV page. The Witch is associated with fire throughout the movie. She appears and disappears in bursts of smoke or flames, and she writes "Surrender Dorothy" in words of smoke in the sky. It's only natural that a creature of fire like she is should be destroyed by water, just like fire itself.

[[WMG: Dorothy's parents were killed in a fire.]]
* If Oz is AllJustADream, then this would explain the Wicked Witch's fire powers. Dorothy was probably very little when it happened and may or may not remember it, but regardless, her parents' deaths have left her with a fear of fire, which is why fire is associated both with the Witch and with the Wizard's frightening giant head form in her dream.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The is [=WMG=] of [[Film/TheWizardOfOz the movie]]; see WMG/LandOfOz and WMG/TheWonderfulWizardOfOz for theories about the original books by Frank Baum.


to:

The is [=WMG=] of [[Film/TheWizardOfOz the movie]]; see WMG/LandOfOz and WMG/TheWonderfulWizardOfOz for theories about the original books by Frank Baum.

Baum





to:

** According to Christian teachings, any insult would do. Jesus says in Matthew 21 that even an insult could get someone in very serious trouble. (Source: This troper is Christian) Still, as mean as Miss Gulch is, saying "too good a Christian" to do something isn't exactly a good Christian thing to do, but I digress.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Glinda, the so-called "Good Witch of the North," clearly has weather-control powers. She summons Dorothy's house from Kansas with a tornado and drops it on the Witch of the East, killing her. Glinda then gives the Ruby Slippers to Dorothy; these slippers can teleport the wearer anywhere she wants. Naturally, Glinda refuses to disclose this information to Dorothy until the end.

The Witch of the West shows up and demands to know who murdered her sister and tries to claim her sister's slippers as her rightful property. Glinda coldly rebuffs her and threatens to kill her with another dropped house. She then sends Dorothy on an unnecessary errand to the Wizard of Oz.

The Wizard figures that Dorothy is a tool of Glinda and sends her to fight and kill a far superior opponent, hoping the Witch of the West will do her in. This fails when Dorothy's companions break into the Witch's home and murder her by accident. Glinda then causes the Wizard's balloon to go out of control and blow away, getting him out of the picture. Since we never hear from the Witch of the South, we can only assume that Glinda got rid of her some other way. This leaves Glinda as the only remaining powerful entity in all of Oz. She installs the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Lion as puppet rulers and sends Dorothy home. Glinda now has control over all of Oz, including the Emerald City's lucrative opium (poppy) trade. JustAsPlanned.

to:

Glinda, the so-called "Good Witch of the North," clearly has weather-control powers. She summons Dorothy's house from Kansas with a tornado and drops it on the Wicked Witch of the East, killing her. Glinda then gives the Ruby Slippers to Dorothy; these slippers can teleport the wearer anywhere she wants. Naturally, Glinda refuses to disclose this information to Dorothy until the end.

The Wicked Witch of the West shows up and demands to know who murdered her sister and tries to claim her sister's slippers as her rightful property. Glinda coldly rebuffs her and threatens to kill her with another dropped house. She then sends Dorothy on an unnecessary errand to the Wizard of Oz.

The Wizard figures that Dorothy is a tool of Glinda and sends her to fight and kill a far superior opponent, hoping the Witch of the West will do her in. This fails when Dorothy's companions break into the Witch's home and murder her by accident. Glinda then causes the Wizard's balloon to go out of control and blow away, getting him out of the picture. Since we never hear from the Good Witch of the South, we can only assume that Glinda got rid of her some other way. This leaves Glinda as the only remaining powerful entity in all of Oz. She installs the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Lion as puppet rulers and sends Dorothy home. Glinda now has control over all of Oz, including the Emerald City's lucrative opium (poppy) trade. JustAsPlanned.



* The Witch of the West was still clearly willing to kill Dorothy to get her hands on the shoes. Even if they were rightfully hers, that's a bit excessive.
** But Glinda still knowingly set Dorothy up as her fall-girl. Whether the Witch of the West was willing to kill Dorothy or not, Dorothy wouldn't be in danger without Glinda putting her there.

to:

* The Wicked Witch of the West was still clearly willing to kill Dorothy to get her hands on the shoes. Even if they were rightfully hers, that's a bit excessive.
** But Glinda still knowingly set Dorothy up as her fall-girl. Whether the Wicked Witch of the West was willing to kill Dorothy or not, Dorothy wouldn't be in danger without Glinda putting her there.



* Also, where is the Witch of the South?

to:

* Also, where is the Good Witch of the South?



* Just one little thing: Dorothy murdered neither witch, accidentally or otherwise. "Accidental murder" can only come under specific circumstances, such as "felony murder" and intending to cause severe injury, doing something clearly dangerous, and inadvertently killing a person. Dorothy was inside the house being carried by the tornado, and had no control over it. (The [=WWoE=] was TooDumbToLive, flying on her broomstick next to a tornado, cackling for all she was worth.) Dorothy's killing of the [=WWoW=] was unpredictable from a person in Dorothy's position: water caused the [=WWoW=] to melt???

to:

* Just one little thing: Dorothy murdered neither witch, accidentally or otherwise. "Accidental murder" can only come under specific circumstances, such as "felony murder" and intending to cause severe injury, doing something clearly dangerous, and inadvertently killing a person. Dorothy was inside the house being carried by the tornado, and had no control over it. (The [=WWoE=] [=Wicked Witch of the East=] was TooDumbToLive, flying on her broomstick next to a tornado, cackling for all she was worth.) Dorothy's killing of the [=WWoW=] [=Wicked Witch of the West=] was unpredictable from a person in Dorothy's position: water caused the [=WWoW=] to melt???



[[WMG: Witches are not weak to water, but to houses]]
Forget the WeaksauceWeakness. The Witch of the East died from being hit by a house. In the land of Oz, water is made up of tiny houses, which combined to slowly churn the Witch of the West into a liquid state.

to:

[[WMG: Witches are not weak to water, but to houses]]
'''houses''']]
Forget the WeaksauceWeakness. The Wicked Witch of the East died from being hit by a house. In the land of Oz, water is made up of tiny houses, which combined to slowly churn the Wicked Witch of the West into a liquid state.



Assuming everyone is immortal in Oz [[AndIMustScream no matter how dead they seem]], like in the books, he's pretty much never called in. When he ''is'' called in, he either says "yep, they're dead" and that they [[Film/ThePrincessBride were only mostly dead]] in the event of a revival, says "nope, they're not dead" in the case that the body kicks back, and "not are they only merely dead, they're really most sincerely dead" in the rare event that something he knows can't be revived from happens (like a witch getting watered) or he is better off with them DeaderThanDead and doesn't want to risk them being healed ([[FateWorseThanDeath like when a maniacal despot who made his life miserable has a house fall on her, and is incapable of kicking back because of full-body paralysis]]).

to:

Assuming everyone is immortal in Oz [[AndIMustScream no matter how however dead they seem]], like in the books, he's pretty much never called in. When he ''is'' called in, he either says "yep, they're dead" and that they [[Film/ThePrincessBride were only mostly dead]] in the event of a revival, says "nope, they're not dead" in the case that the body kicks back, and "not are they only merely dead, they're really most sincerely dead" in the rare event that something he knows can't be revived from happens (like a witch getting watered) or he is better off with them DeaderThanDead and doesn't want to risk them being healed ([[FateWorseThanDeath like when a maniacal despot who made his life miserable has a house fall on her, and is incapable of kicking back because of full-body paralysis]]).



[[WMG: The Wicked Witch Is A Winkie Like Her Guards]]

to:

[[WMG: The Wicked Witch Is A is a Winkie Like Her like her Guards]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Dorothy is the first incarnation of LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya ]]

to:

[[WMG: Dorothy is the first incarnation of LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya Literature/HaruhiSuzumiya ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Alternately, she's not dead. Instead, she moved away because her house was destroyed by the tornado. Her only bright side is no longer having to deal with Toto.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Toto's fine. Miss Gulch was killed in the tornado and is no longer a threat.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Because I can.

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Oz is hyper-real]]
* Oz is at a "higher level of reality," as theorized by Timothy Leary, and Dorothy is there in a lucid dream from a very precise head injury. The Oz characters look like people she knows not because they're part of the dream, but because each of them is the Higher Truth or Realer Self of that Kansan. This is what kills Miss Gulch -- the Witch is Gulch's shriveled soul, and destroying it destroys her. (This is true of Toto, too. It's the hyper-real Toto that accompanies her in Oz while the real Toto remains on Earth. A domesticated dog is enough of a person to have a soul, and a dog is honest about itself so its soul and body look the same.)

Yes, this does mean one could perform very efficient assassinations by traveling to Oz and murdering the Ozite corresponding to your target. Perhaps this is what Professor Marvel is working on; if he's a government agent it would explain both his behavior, oddly responsible and compassionate for a criminal, and the prominence of his soul-self in Oz.

Added: 451

Changed: 343

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* To reword that, Dorothy's exposure to dust, debris, and being hit on the head almost killed her, and Oz was a Near-Death-Experience. The entire thing was her brain creating a hallucination of sorts (like how sometimes people who have Near Death Experiences say they saw a light, heaven, or hell, or at least how they imagine it to be) which was all representative of her brain struggling to get her to wake up. It also showed her what could be her eternal reward, which is colorful and full of adventure, unlike Kansas. She really was dying the whole time, and if she had utterly lost her will to live, and stayed in Oz, and died in the real world.

to:

* To reword that, Dorothy's exposure to dust, debris, and being hit on the head almost killed her, and Oz was a Near-Death-Experience. near-death experience. The entire thing was her brain creating either a genuine vision of the afterlife (or a hallucination of sorts (like how sometimes people who have Near Death Experiences say they same if you think near-death experiences are all created by the brain). She saw a light, heaven, or hell, or at least how they imagine it to be) which was all representative of her brain struggling to get her to wake up. It also showed her what could be her eternal reward, which is colorful and full of adventure, unlike Kansas. She But she really was dying the whole time, and if she had utterly lost her will chosen to live, and stayed stay in Oz, and Oz she would have died in the real world.


Added DiffLines:

--> ''It wasn't a dream. It was a place. I remember some of it wasn't very nice, but most of it was beautiful! But all the same, all I kept saying to everyone was "I want to go home," and they sent me home.'' Many people describe their own near-death experiences in similar terms.
*** This is the opposite of the way it is in the books, where Aunt Em ''does'' come to believe her, and Uncle Henry is the one who thinks Dorothy simply has vivid dreams.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Hence her green skin a big hooked nose.

to:

* Hence her green skin a and big hooked nose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Dorothy therefore, would be the Good Witch of the South, a literal AngelUnaware.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The Wicked Witch Is A Winkie Like Her Guards]]
* Hence her green skin a big hooked nose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Gulch follows Dorothy but is crushed by the house. When the shoes brought Dorothy back to the real world, she fell asleep, leading to the apparent AllJustADream ending. This also explains how {{Return to Oz}} could work and why Toto was never in any danger again.

to:

Gulch follows Dorothy but is crushed by the house. When the shoes brought Dorothy back to the real world, she fell asleep, leading to the apparent AllJustADream ending. This also explains how {{Return to Oz}} ''Film/ReturnToOz'' could work and why Toto was never in any danger again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThePlan certainly isn't perfect. According to {{Return to Oz}}, the Ruby Slippers ended up in the hands of the Nome King, who used their power to take over Oz. Presumably, Glinda was executed when the Emerald City fell. Even after Oz is restored, her secrets are concealed by the new ruler, Ozma, for her own purposes.

to:

* ThePlan certainly isn't perfect. According to {{Return to Oz}}, ''Film/ReturnToOz'', the Ruby Slippers ended up in the hands of the Nome King, who used their power to take over Oz. Presumably, Glinda was executed when the Emerald City fell. Even after Oz is restored, her secrets are concealed by the new ruler, Ozma, for her own purposes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The alleged "secret ending", according to many discussion boards including [[http://message.snopes.com/showthread.php?t=74320 Snopes]], allegedly shows the ruby slippers still on Dorothy's feet as she lies in bed. Another rumor dating from the late '40s has Dorothy saying "There's no place like home", and the camera pans down from her face to show the ruby slippers under the bed. Apparently these rumors are very convincing, to the point that people swear they saw it at least once, similar to the "I saw the baby!" claims made by people who saw ''RosemarysBaby''.

to:

* The alleged "secret ending", according to many discussion boards including [[http://message.snopes.com/showthread.php?t=74320 Snopes]], allegedly shows the ruby slippers still on Dorothy's feet as she lies in bed. Another rumor dating from the late '40s has Dorothy saying "There's no place like home", and the camera pans down from her face to show the ruby slippers under the bed. Apparently these rumors are very convincing, to the point that people swear they saw it at least once, similar to the "I saw the baby!" claims made by people who saw ''RosemarysBaby''.''Film/RosemarysBaby''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That's a complex theory, filled with in-depth symbolism. It also depends on the idea that Japan surrendered first in WW2. As it turned out, Germany was defeated earlier.

to:

** That's a complex theory, filled with in-depth symbolism. It also depends on the idea that Japan surrendered first in WW2.[=WW2=]. As it turned out, Germany was defeated earlier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The entire film is a [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotDidactic pre-emptive allegory]] of WorldWarTwo and its lasting effects]]

to:

[[WMG: The entire film is a [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotDidactic pre-emptive allegory]] of WorldWarTwo UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and its lasting effects]]



* The Emerald City is the dream of a post-Depression prosperous future, and the Wizard is FDR (who unintentionally abandons Dorothy/America in her time of need). The poppy field represents WorldWarOne, whose status as the "war to end all wars" lulled the major world powers into a false sense of security. (Also note Flanders Fields.)

to:

* The Emerald City is the dream of a post-Depression prosperous future, and the Wizard is FDR (who unintentionally abandons Dorothy/America in her time of need). The poppy field represents WorldWarOne, UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, whose status as the "war to end all wars" lulled the major world powers into a false sense of security. (Also note Flanders Fields.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Dorothy and Tin Man were in a relationship.]]
Despite the fact most people assumed Scarecrow/Hunk was supposedly Dorothy's love interest in the film especially as she said she will miss him most of all Tin Man was actually Dorothy's boyfriend as there are a few clues that back it up. Most of the time the gang are together Dorothy is usually seen walking or running beside Tin Man. At one point in the haunted forest before the attack of the flying monkeys Dorothy is seen holding to Tin Man's arm. During If I only had a heart Dorothy gives him a smile. And let's not forget Tin Man was sobbing over Dorothy's welfare especially when she was affected by the poppies and being held prisoner by the Witch of the West. It may be possible Dorothy had a crush on Scarecrow and tried to make him jealous however.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I've been watching that movie for nearly 45 years, and I always read that as Em refraining from calling Gulch a "bitch", or even "cunt". But that's just me.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[Literature/{{Wicked}} This theory sounds familiar. I wonder, where have I heard it before?]]

to:

** * [[Literature/{{Wicked}} This theory sounds familiar. I wonder, where have I heard it before?]]




to:

* Just one little thing: Dorothy murdered neither witch, accidentally or otherwise. "Accidental murder" can only come under specific circumstances, such as "felony murder" and intending to cause severe injury, doing something clearly dangerous, and inadvertently killing a person. Dorothy was inside the house being carried by the tornado, and had no control over it. (The [=WWoE=] was TooDumbToLive, flying on her broomstick next to a tornado, cackling for all she was worth.) Dorothy's killing of the [=WWoW=] was unpredictable from a person in Dorothy's position: water caused the [=WWoW=] to melt???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The is [=WMG=] of [[Film/TheWizardOfOz the movie]]; see WMG/LandOfOz entry for theories about the original books by Frank Baum.


to:

The is [=WMG=] of [[Film/TheWizardOfOz the movie]]; see WMG/LandOfOz entry and WMG/TheWonderfulWizardOfOz for theories about the original books by Frank Baum.

Added: 165

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Emerald City is the dream of a post-Depression prosperous future, and the Wizard is FDR (who unintentionally abandons Dorothy/America in her time of need). The poppy field represents WorldWarOne, whose status as the "war to end all wars" lulled the major world powers into a false sense of security.

to:

* The Emerald City is the dream of a post-Depression prosperous future, and the Wizard is FDR (who unintentionally abandons Dorothy/America in her time of need). The poppy field represents WorldWarOne, whose status as the "war to end all wars" lulled the major world powers into a false sense of security. (Also note Flanders Fields.)


Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: If the Good Witch of the North had been a separate character as in the book...]]
...[[AndYouWereThere she would have been played by Clara Blandick (Aunt Em)]].

Added: 312

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Or, the Wizard got his position by finding out the Wicked Witch of the South's {{Weaksauce Weakness} and killing her. With a powerful 'magician' and an open position, Glinda decided to let the Wizard take the role of the Good Wizard of the South.

to:

* Or, the Wizard got his position by finding out the Wicked Witch of the South's {{Weaksauce Weakness} WeaksauceWeakness and killing her. With a powerful 'magician' and an open position, Glinda decided to let the Wizard take the role of the Good Wizard of the South.


Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The Witch of the South is Dorothy's "Oz Counterpart".]]
Hey, if Professor Marvel, Hunk, Zeke, Hickory, and Miss Gulch have "Oz Counterparts", why not Dorothy herself? Plus, it would explain why the people of Oz think Dorothy is a witch when they first see her-they mistake her for a different (real) witch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Strongly supported by the lyrics: "Just then, the Witch, to satisfy an itch, went flying on her broomstick, thumbing for a hitch—''and oh, what happened then was rich!''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Auntie Em was "too good a Christian" to tell Miss Gulch to "go to hell"]
Aunt Em was going to tell Miss Gulch to go to hell after she took Toto. But a good Christian wouldn't wish that on anyone. Miss Gulch realized it, explaining her look of shock.]]

to:

[[WMG: Auntie Em was "too good a Christian" to tell Miss Gulch to "go to hell"]
hell"]]
Aunt Em was going to tell Miss Gulch to go to hell after she took Toto. But a good Christian wouldn't wish that on anyone. Miss Gulch realized it, explaining her look of shock.]]
shock.



What happened to set her off? Dorothy's dog chases Miss Gulch's cat (a spinster's favourite companion) in Miss Gulch's own yard. Then, Toto bites Miss Gulch. Miss Gulch is legally in the right, and being a none-too-nice woman, decides to avenge herself and her cat. So she visits the Gales, and immune to Dorothy's pleas. Right? Wrong!

to:

What happened to set her off? Dorothy's dog chases Miss Gulch's cat (a spinster's favourite companion) in Miss Gulch's own yard. Then, Toto bites Miss Gulch. Miss Gulch is legally in the right, and being a none-too-nice woman, decides to avenge herself and her cat. So she visits the Gales, and is completely immune to Dorothy's pleas. Right? Wrong!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Auntie Em was "too good a Christian" to tell Miss Gulch to "go to hell"]
Aunt Em was going to tell Miss Gulch to go to hell after she took Toto. But a good Christian wouldn't wish that on anyone. Miss Gulch realized it, explaining her look of shock.]]


Added DiffLines:

* In real life, coroners are often doctors or lawyers. The coroner is actually a/the Munchkin doctor. There's no proof that the Munchkin village comprises the entire population of Munchkinland.


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Lollipop Guild is actually the Munchkin answer to the Boy Scouts. The Lullaby League is their answer to the Girl Guides. Notice how all the members seem to be kids.]]


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Toto's fine. Miss Gulch relented after Dorothy was injured in the Tornado]]
Unlike the Wicked Witches, the real life Miss Gulch isn't a monster. She's a rich spinster who (according to Aunt Em) owns half the county and, unpleasantly, likes to throw her weight around.

What happened to set her off? Dorothy's dog chases Miss Gulch's cat (a spinster's favourite companion) in Miss Gulch's own yard. Then, Toto bites Miss Gulch. Miss Gulch is legally in the right, and being a none-too-nice woman, decides to avenge herself and her cat. So she visits the Gales, and immune to Dorothy's pleas. Right? Wrong!

Miss Gulch isn't cackling with glee. She's showing hard, cold, stubbornness. She's shocked when Aunt Em insults her. Later, when she's cycling home, she's not happy. It's more a look of grim determination. Her conscience's bothering her, but she's too stubborn to relent.

Miss Gulch left way before Dorothy. There's no reason to suggest she would have been fool enough to go out in the storm after she discovered Toto's escape. But she would have heard that Dorothy suffered a concussion and was knocked unconscious. That's enough to have her relent. Getting even with a biting dog is one thing. But to raise your hand against a girl who has very nearly died?

Either she sends a letter outright, wishing Dorothy well and saying that she didn't want Toto destroyed. Or, she pretends to forget about the matter entirely - and never again goes after the dog.

Top