Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / Sherlock

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Please'' [[SoCoolItsAwesome let this be true]]. A modernized version of Lupin would be epic in numerous ways... mostly [[MasterOfDisguise all the new disguises he would not have had access to in the original setting]]. The fact that Holmes (or a CaptainErsatz depending on the publisher) was used as Lupin's WorthyOpponent makes this all the more interesting.

to:

* ''Please'' [[SoCoolItsAwesome [[SugarWiki/SoCoolItsAwesome let this be true]]. A modernized version of Lupin would be epic in numerous ways... mostly [[MasterOfDisguise all the new disguises he would not have had access to in the original setting]]. The fact that Holmes (or a CaptainErsatz depending on the publisher) was used as Lupin's WorthyOpponent makes this all the more interesting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Alternatively, the command was [[DoraTheExplorer "Snipers no sniping!!]]]]

to:

[[WMG: Alternatively, the command was [[DoraTheExplorer [[WesternAnimation/DoraTheExplorer "Snipers no sniping!!]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Since [[spoiler:Redbeard is revealed to be Sherlock's childhood friend and not a dog, this is jossed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Confirmed, in both cases, it's both a sword and a gun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Adding to this for the sake of irony, he thought it was his greatest work, but it was overshadowed by the far more popular ''[[Literature/TheLostWorld Professor Challenger]]'' books, as was the rest of his work.

to:

* Adding to this for the sake of irony, he thought it was his greatest work, but it was overshadowed by the far more popular ''[[Literature/TheLostWorld ''[[Literature/TheLostWorld1912 Professor Challenger]]'' books, as was the rest of his work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[spoiler: In Eurus's trials, Sherlock calls Molly and must get her to say "I Love You." In order for her to say it, she makes him say it first. It is clear that the second time he says it, he means it to some level. She says that she has always loved him and says it back. What's more is this is the only trial that causes Sherlock to freak out, showing that he does care about her. At the end of the episode, we are briefly shown Molly entering the apartment smiling. However, the scene then cuts to Sherlock smiling as he is playing his violin with Eurus. This seems to suggest, at least to this Troper, that the two are together. However, it is left to the viewer to decide. In addition, Sherlock sends a text to someone saying "You know where to find me". This text could have been sent to Molly, so they could discuss what happened. If this were the Sherlock series finale, I would be very disappointed if they didn't end up together.}}

to:

[[spoiler: In Eurus's trials, Sherlock calls Molly and must get her to say "I Love You." In order for her to say it, she makes him say it first. It is clear that the second time he says it, he means it to some level. She says that she has always loved him and says it back. What's more is this is the only trial that causes Sherlock to freak out, showing that he does care about her. At the end of the episode, we are briefly shown Molly entering the apartment smiling. However, the scene then cuts to Sherlock smiling as he is playing his violin with Eurus. This seems to suggest, at least to this Troper, that the two are together. However, it is left to the viewer to decide. In addition, Sherlock sends a text to someone saying "You know where to find me". This text could have been sent to Molly, so they could discuss what happened. If this were the Sherlock series finale, I would be very disappointed if they didn't end up together.}}
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: [[spoiler: Sherlock and Molly]] are together at the end of the Final Problem.]]
[[spoiler: In Eurus's trials, Sherlock calls Molly and must get her to say "I Love You." In order for her to say it, she makes him say it first. It is clear that the second time he says it, he means it to some level. She says that she has always loved him and says it back. What's more is this is the only trial that causes Sherlock to freak out, showing that he does care about her. At the end of the episode, we are briefly shown Molly entering the apartment smiling. However, the scene then cuts to Sherlock smiling as he is playing his violin with Eurus. This seems to suggest, at least to this Troper, that the two are together. However, it is left to the viewer to decide. In addition, Sherlock sends a text to someone saying "You know where to find me". This text could have been sent to Molly, so they could discuss what happened. If this were the Sherlock series finale, I would be very disappointed if they didn't end up together.}}
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Irene Adler is hiding out in a nudist community]]
Where else could she wear her "battle dress" all the time and not seem out of place?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[spoiler: Jossed. She's a year younger than him]].




to:

** [[spoiler: Confirmed]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: There will be a secret fourth episode.]]
* After all, people always stop looking after three.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: "Sherrinford" is the name of the facility where Eurus has been kept for the past three decades.]]
* It's a prison or a sanitarium. When it became apparent that Eurus was dangerous, she was locked up at Sherrinford to protect people, mainly Sherlock. Mycroft isn't in direct contact with Eurus, but rather her keepers. He's unaware that Eurus has escaped, because someone at the facility is covering for her.

Added: 934

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Or...

to:

Or...



Somehow, somewhy, there is no way Mofftiss overlooked that.

to:

Somehow, somewhy, but there is no way Mofftiss overlooked that.
that.

[[WMG: Sherlock didn't make all those deductions two weeks in advance- Eurus planted the ideas in his head using the memory serum.]]
It doesn't seem like the kind of deduction even Sherlock could make- there are too many independent variables. He never actually explains his reasoning- the only explanation given for any of it is John's thinking back (through Mary) how Sherlock PROBABLY did it- and the amount of ranting he does about not being so off his head that he couldn't do this in advance seemed a bit overreacting, and said in such a way that he's not sure he believes it himself. Eurus, on the other hand, is a shadowy enough character that she could have many methods to orchestrate the situation, given the amount of Deus ex machina Mofftiss have already resorted to with her character... (I really hope this isn't true, for the record. It would mean that both major pieces of deduction in the episode are basically fake.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: "The Final Problem" is a Sherlock/Doctor Who crossover.]]
Be honest, by the end there you couldn't tell which show you were watching... Memory serum? Shapeshifting murderer? Toby Jones being creepy and sadistic?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[The twist in the third episode is that Mofftiss finally did a Sherlock/Doctor Who crossover.]]

to:

[[The [[WMG: The twist in the third episode is that Mofftiss finally did a Sherlock/Doctor Who crossover.]]



[[Eurus is Sherlock's twin sister.]]

to:

[[Eurus [[WMG: Eurus is Sherlock's twin sister.]]



[[It will be significant that Eurus is a boy's name and Sherlock is a girl's name.]]

to:

[[It [[WMG: It will be significant that Eurus is a boy's name and Sherlock is a girl's name.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Eurus isn't exactly what she seems/isn't actually their sister/something is up.]]
Partially because so much doesn't make sense (how was she able to disguise herself so well as two different women who both existed in real life, including fooling her own BROTHER into thinking she was someone else, etc), but I recognize that Mofftiss probably cooked something up- I just really don't want Eurus to be real...

[[WMG: The fake Faith was actually the one in the mortuary.]]
I know this is unlikely, but I want it to be true, so I'm running with it. Faith did come visit Sherlock, and the one in the mortuary who seemed way too calm and slick to possibly be running to the hospital to hear her father's confession is actually Eurus. She knows what Faith said to Sherlock because she had her bugged in preparation to pretend to be her.
Or...

[[WMG: There was no fake Faith.]]
Culverton Smith found out she visited him and gave her the memory drug (which he said disrupted past as well as present memories). While the drug was in her system, he also did something to change her in such a way that Sherlock thought she was someone else.
(You can tell I just don't want original!Faith to be fake....)

[[The twist in the third episode is that Mofftiss finally did a Sherlock/Doctor Who crossover.]]
Eurus is actually a shapeshifting alien and the memory serum is some kind of alien technology. Obviously, Toby Jones's character is the Doctor (actual canon!)
...nobody else getting that vibe? I honestly couldn't remember which show I was watching at the end.

[[Eurus is Sherlock's twin sister.]]
"It's never twins." Ha.

[[It will be significant that Eurus is a boy's name and Sherlock is a girl's name.]]
Somehow, somewhy, there is no way Mofftiss overlooked that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Eurus planted a bug in Sherlock's living room when she came to him [[spoiler:as "Faith"]].]]
As detailed in [[https://bemusedlybespectacled.tumblr.com/post/155755174266/the-slip-sherlock-theory this Tumblr post]]. Eurus clearly heard the ''second'' conversation between John and Mycroft (in Sherlock's flat). She had the opportunity to plant a bug while Sherlock was seeing her for her case. He might not have noticed (or noticed but not understood) because he was high off his ass.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Either way, the cabbie is probably not particular about how his 'game' works, since his death is certain be it by aneurysm or pill. He's happy to keep playing the game because of the money going to his kids.

to:

Either way, the cabbie is probably not particular about how his 'game' works, since his death is certain be it by aneurysm or pill. He's happy to keep playing the game because of the money going to his kids.h



* People have also theorized that it may refer to a city named "Hell".

to:

* People have also theorized that it may refer to a city named "Hell".
"Hell". Which was Jossed as of The Lying Detective.

Changed: 57

Removed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


"You know what happened to the other one?"
"It's never twins."
"People always give up after three."

to:

"You know what happened to the other one?"
one?" "It's never twins."
" "People always give up after three."

Added: 730

Changed: 70

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* People have also theorized that it may refer to a city named "Hell".

[[WMG: Eurus killed Redbeard.]]
From [[http://theonethinginlife.tumblr.com/post/155606378918/eurus-killed-redbeard this tumblr post]].

[[WMG: Sherrinford Holmes exists; Eurus killed him when they were young.]]
"You know what happened to the other one?"
"It's never twins."
"People always give up after three."
Eurus killed Sherrinford and was locked away when they were young, which is why Sherlock didn't recognize her. It's also why Mycroft is so closed off emotionally, and why he has problems admitting he cares about Sherlock. He even named a certain important place after Sherrinford to remind himself why he decided to be this way. The Holmes brothers do like using meaningful code words to remind themselves of things after all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* And in terms of the need to furnish a body for official purposes and assuming a closed casket or cremation...Molly's father died recently, didn't he? And didn't he [[FreudWasRight remind her a bit]] of Sherlock?

to:

* And in terms of the need to furnish a body for official purposes and assuming a closed casket or cremation...Molly's father died recently, didn't he? And didn't he [[FreudWasRight remind her a bit]] bit of Sherlock?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: [[spoiler:"Go to hell, Sherlock"]] is more literal than it seems.]]
Because it worked for ''Series/DoctorWho'' after all. In this case, however, [[spoiler:Mary isn't suggesting that Sherlock should bring her back to life]], but rather [[spoiler:that Sherlock needs to go to somewhere he, John, or Mary consider hellish in order to reconcile with John.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* This also means that Literature/SolarPons is on to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Season 4]]

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Sherlock is related to Creator/AlanTuring.]]

to:

[[WMG: Sherlock is related to Creator/AlanTuring.UsefulNotes/AlanTuring.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Badass is no longer a trope.


Why? You mean besides RuleOfCool? Alright. Sherlock is a hard person to get a long with, but Mrs. Hudson has managed to survive him and his experiements, and while she complains, she never has actually threatened to kick him out. That can easily be {{handwave}}d away by her being friends with Sherlock, but ''InUniverse'', who would belive that? Instaid, it would probably be easier to believe that she is much more {{badass}} than she appears, both by the coppers and by the people who read John's blog. [[strike: [[BlatantLies And it will have nothing to do with the]] KinkMeme [[BlatantLies where she's going to end up a ninja zombie killer somehow]].]]

to:

Why? You mean besides RuleOfCool? Alright. Sherlock is a hard person to get a long with, but Mrs. Hudson has managed to survive him and his experiements, and while she complains, she never has actually threatened to kick him out. That can easily be {{handwave}}d away by her being friends with Sherlock, but ''InUniverse'', who would belive that? Instaid, it would probably be easier to believe that she is much more {{badass}} badass than she appears, both by the coppers and by the people who read John's blog. [[strike: [[BlatantLies And it will have nothing to do with the]] KinkMeme [[BlatantLies where she's going to end up a ninja zombie killer somehow]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Additional argument



to:

* It's possible. WordOfGod was that Sherlock was going to regress some character development-wise during his travels, implying he would return more to his tactless, uncaring self from the earlier episodes. Arguably, Sherlock returned much nicer than before (his interactions with with his parents and Molly in The Empty Hearse come to mind). But it's not LyingCreator if Sherlock was on drugs the whole time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** [[RandallAndHopkirkDeceased It's been done before]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Mary is working for Mycroft in modern day]]
There's no way Mycroft didn't know who she was before Sherlock did. Word of God said Mary used to be one of Moriarty's assassins. Somehow, she left his organization, created a new identity, and avoided his detection for about three years? She's good, but not that good--she would have needed help. And who could better create an identity and make it believable and legal than Mycroft, in exchange for Mary simply keeping an eye on a doctor? Naturally, Mycroft didn't expect her to fall in love with John, but that worked out because it meant she was even closer to him. He even told Sherlock at the beginning of series three that he'd been keeping an eye on John. And that would also explain why Mycroft didn't want Sherlock getting involved with Magnussen. Mycroft wouldn't put so many important people in danger that way, so why leave Magnussen alone? Answer: he had already arranged for Mary to make the hit and he knew that Sherlock would just get in the way. Sherlock has subconsciously figured this out; it's all there in his dream.

Changed: 908

Removed: 3173

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Sebastian Moran will be revealed to be the TheManBehindTheMan.]]

Moriarty's appearance was just a simple distraction for what's to come. Jim is truly dead, but his suicide was just his way of making his right hand man take up his sword. And that man is Sebastian Moran, formerly a decorated Colonel in the Fifth Northumberland Fusiliers, a legendary assassin as well as a professional hunter, and a wartime buddy of John Watson.

Sherlock spent two years destroying Moriarty's regiment, but small pockets still remain worldwide, constantly recruiting and ready to rise at any time. Once Moriarty's sudden 'return' has shocked the country, Moran will assemble the new syndicate and send a wave of crime across the UK.

Moran, sometime along the line in his post-war job, attempted to snipe Mary when she got too close to finding out about Moriarty's identity. He wants to finish the job, but still thinks of John as a good friend, and has to keep Sherlock from finding out about his true role at all costs. So he chooses his ''own'' right hand man to appear to lead Moriarty's syndicate-John Clay, the famous bank robber, master forger, hitman and a supporter of the Waters Crime Family.

Clay, quietly getting a job as a clerk at a London post office, will secretly direct Moran's army of professional bank robbers-the Red Headed League-using the resources available to him. Made up of heavily armed former soldiers, mercenaries or hired guns and donning red balaclavas, they will carry out a series of violent bank robberies throughout England and leaving an increasingly high body count with each heist.

While Scotland Yard gets increasingly panicky about the League, Moran, with everything carefully planned, comes back into John's life. To get closer to John's loved ones, Moran will be the perfect friend of John's-a man openly tolerant of Sherlock's rudeness, standing up against Donovan's jabs and a valuable asset when the duo are in the countryside. And best of all, Mary never saw his face during his attempt on her life, so she won't recognise him. Moran will stand up for Sherlock and John and is present when Mary gives birth to her daughter. Of course, his kindness to John is genuine, but the rest is simply an act.

Soon, though, with the help of the military and Sherlock, the Red-Headed League will be brought down and John Clay is thrown into prison. The syndicate seemingly shuts down all other activities, but now focuses on one goal-kill Sherlock Holmes and Mary Watson, for once and for all. Sherlock will feel that something is off, but casts the thought of Moran being suspicious aside.

Eventually, after a tangled web of clues and seemingly solving the last mystery, Sherlock and John will return to 221B, only to be knocked out. John will wake up to find himself a prisoner in his own house, with the doors locked, Mary and Sherlock brutally beaten up, John's daughter wailing in fear, and Moran with a gun, ready to open fire. Moran will explain everything, mock a horrified Sherlock and Mary for being so trusting and prepare to kill them both slowly, leaving John and his daughter alive to watch.

From there, two things will happen. The first is that John goes into rage mode and fistfights Moran into a standstill, before finally throwing him into the hands of Scotland Yard, who will hand him over to Mycroft. The second is that John, remembering all the good times he had with Sebastian in war and in the previous season, begs Moran to show mercy. Shocked and actually moved, Moran will drop the gun, release Sherlock and Mary into a hospital and hand himself over to the police.

to:

[[WMG: Sebastian Moran Season 4 will be revealed to be the TheManBehindTheMan.]]

Moriarty's appearance was just a simple distraction for what's to come. Jim is truly dead, but his suicide was just his way of making his right hand man take up his sword. And that man is Sebastian Moran, formerly a decorated Colonel in the Fifth Northumberland Fusiliers, a legendary assassin as well as a professional hunter, and a wartime buddy of John Watson.

have Sherlock spent two years destroying Moriarty's regiment, but small pockets still remain worldwide, constantly recruiting and ready to rise at any time. Once Moriarty's sudden 'return' has shocked the country, Moran will assemble the new syndicate and send a wave of crime across the UK.

Moran, sometime along the line in his post-war job, attempted to snipe Mary when she got too close to finding out about Moriarty's identity. He wants to finish the job, but still thinks of John as a good friend, and has to keep Sherlock
suffering from finding out about his true role at all costs. So he chooses his ''own'' right hand man to appear to lead Moriarty's syndicate-John Clay, the famous bank robber, master forger, hitman and radiation poisoning or a supporter serious terminal illness of the Waters Crime Family.

Clay, quietly getting a job as a clerk at a London post office, will secretly direct Moran's army of professional bank robbers-the Red Headed League-using the resources available to him. Made up of heavily armed former soldiers, mercenaries or hired guns and donning red balaclavas, they will carry out a series of violent bank robberies throughout England and leaving an increasingly high body count with each heist.

While Scotland Yard gets increasingly panicky about the League, Moran, with everything carefully planned, comes back into John's life. To get closer to John's loved ones, Moran will be the perfect friend of John's-a man openly tolerant of Sherlock's rudeness, standing up against Donovan's jabs and a valuable asset when the duo are in the countryside. And best of all, Mary never saw his face during his attempt on her life, so she won't recognise him. Moran will stand up for Sherlock and John and is present when Mary gives birth to her daughter. Of course, his kindness to John is genuine, but the rest is simply an act.

Soon, though, with the help of the military and Sherlock, the Red-Headed League will be brought down and John Clay is thrown into prison.
some kind.]]
*
The syndicate seemingly shuts down all other activities, but now focuses on one goal-kill Sherlock Holmes and Mary Watson, for once and for all. Sherlock will feel that something is off, but casts the thought Season 4 teaser trailer showed constant shots of Moran being suspicious aside.

Eventually, after
a tangled web of clues and seemingly solving the last mystery, Sherlock and John will return to 221B, only to be knocked out. John will wake up to find himself a prisoner in his own house, with the doors locked, Mary hospital, and Sherlock brutally beaten up, John's daughter wailing in fear, looking quite pale and Moran with a gun, ready haggard, as well as what seem to open fire. Moran will explain everything, mock a horrified be burns or lesions on his hands. As well as that, Toby Jones is playing "C. Smith", who could very well be Culverton Smith. Culverton was the main villain of "The Adventure of the Dying Detective", where Sherlock apparently caught an incurable disease from Culverton's nephew and Mary for being so trusting and prepare to kill them both slowly, leaving John and his daughter alive to watch.

From there, two things will happen. The first is that John goes into rage mode and fistfights Moran into a standstill, before finally throwing him into the hands of Scotland Yard, who will hand him over to Mycroft. The second is that John, remembering all the good times he had with Sebastian in war and in the previous season, begs Moran to show mercy. Shocked and actually moved, Moran will drop the gun, release Sherlock and Mary into a hospital and hand himself over to the police.
was dying from it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


When he's not off stopping career criminals or escaping death traps as Britain's greatest assassin, OO7 bodyguards Mycroft, who is this universe's M. However, as he's frequently off on assignments overseas, Anthea, who is this universe's Moneypenny, protects Mycroft in Bond's place. Sherlock occasionally sees him and correctly deduces that he's an elite bodyguard of some sort, but Mycroft never refers to Bond by name, as part of concealing his identity.

to:

When he's not off stopping career criminals or escaping death traps as Britain's greatest assassin, OO7 [=OO7=] bodyguards Mycroft, who is this universe's M. However, as he's frequently off on assignments overseas, Anthea, who is this universe's Moneypenny, protects Mycroft in Bond's place. Sherlock occasionally sees him and correctly deduces that he's an elite bodyguard of some sort, but Mycroft never refers to Bond by name, as part of concealing his identity.

Top