Follow TV Tropes

Following

History PlayingWith / SecondLawOfGenderBending

Go To

OR

Added: 220

Changed: 72

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add another defied example


* '''Defied''': "Ah hell no, I'm not trying on that dress, those things are addictive!"

to:

* '''Defied''': '''Defied''':
**
"Ah hell no, I'm not trying on that dress, those things are addictive!"addictive!"
** Alex actively refuses to use any other name or pronouns, continues to present masculine, and identifies as a trans man rather than a cis woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[AttractiveGenderBender Alex is much better-looking as Alice]], resulting in a massive boost to her popularity and self-esteem.

to:

** [[AttractiveGenderBender [[AttractiveBentGender Alex is much better-looking as Alice]], resulting in a massive boost to her popularity and self-esteem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[AttractiveGenderBender Alex is much better-looking as Alice]], resulting in a massive boost to her popularity and self-esteem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The transformation spell doesn't work unless the person transformed is ok with their new body.

Added: 205

Removed: 172

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Upon changing back to his male body, Alex's refusal to embrace this trope lets him gain a greater understanding of what transgender people go through regarding dysphoria. He swears to be a greater ally.



* Upon changing back to his male body, Alex's regusal to embrace this trope lets him gain a greater understanding of what transgender people go through regarding dysphoria.

Added: 488

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those unaffected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about herself.

to:

** Alice was transsexual transgender even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those unaffected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about herself.


Added DiffLines:

** Alex's gender identity changes alongside the sex of the body, so Alice doesn't feel dysphoria, as if she was a cis woman the entire time.


Added DiffLines:

** As would be indicated by our modern understanding of gender, Alex scoffs at the idea that he, a cis man, would ever accept being a woman just because of his physical change.


Added DiffLines:

* Upon changing back to his male body, Alex's regusal to embrace this trope lets him gain a greater understanding of what transgender people go through regarding dysphoria.

Added: 331

Changed: 211

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Reconstructed''': He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life. She agonizes about how this means she is giving up on her old, male life, only to come to terms with it by talking through it with her parents and friends.

to:

* '''Reconstructed''': '''Reconstructed''':
**
He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life. She agonizes about how this means she is giving up on her old, male life, only to come to terms with it by talking through it with her parents and friends.friends.
** The gender-bending also bends Alex's mind so that his gender identity switches to female, bypassing the dysphoria.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She becomes a he, and discovers that MenAreTheExpendableGender.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** MenAreTheExpendableGender, and she's glad to be less expendable.

to:

** MenAreTheExpendableGender, and she's glad to be less expendable.that she isn't expendable anymore.

Added: 323

Changed: 253

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Justified''': Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those unaffected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about herself.

to:

* '''Justified''': '''Justified''':
**
Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those unaffected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about herself.herself.
** MenAreTheExpendableGender, and she's glad to be less expendable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Justified''': Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those none affected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about herself.

to:

* '''Justified''': Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those none affected unaffected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Justified''': Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those none affected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about her.

to:

* '''Justified''': Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those none affected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about her.herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Justified''': Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those none affected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her.

to:

* '''Justified''': Alice was transsexual even before she acquired a full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those none affected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her, as she now has a body that really reflects how she feels about her.

Changed: 944

Removed: 35

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Straight''': [[GenderBender He becomes a she]], and she decides her life is better now.
* '''Exaggerated''': He becomes a she, and immediately swears off her old life.
* '''Downplayed''': He becomes a she and gradually comes to accept and like her new life while still feeling a little nostalgic for her past as a he.
* '''Justified''': He was transsexual even before he became a she.
* '''Inverted''': He becomes a she, and hates every second of it. She changes back at the first opportunity.

to:

* '''Straight''': [[GenderBender He Alex becomes a she]], Alice]], and she decides her life is better now.
* '''Exaggerated''': He Alex becomes a she, Alice, and immediately swears off her old life.
* '''Downplayed''': He Alex becomes a she woman and gradually comes to accept and like her new life while still feeling a little nostalgic for her past as a he.
man.
* '''Justified''': He Alice was transsexual even before he became she acquired a she.
full-fledged female body. What would be a set-back for those none affected by gender dysphoria, is actually an amazing blessing to her.
* '''Inverted''': He Alex becomes a she, woman, and hates every second of it. She "She" changes back at the first opportunity.



** He becomes a she, and enjoys it. However, in the end, she still chooses to change back.
** Alternatively, he becomes a she, and doesn't like it, even though her life has changed for the better so much that she probably ''should''.
* '''Double Subverted''': He turns into a she, but decides to change back... only to re-gender bend himself after spending a few days back in his old life.
* '''Parodied''':
** He becomes a she, and swears she hates her new life... but she's protesting just a ''wee'' bit too loudly.
** She creates a male clone of herself so she can live both lives.
* '''Zig Zagged''': He becomes a she, and spends a few years switching back and forth, keeping up a double life. His/Her closest friends are fully aware of his/her situation. In the end, s/he finds love and picks an appropriate form... or finds a gender bending boy/girlfriend.

to:

** He Alex becomes a she, Alice, and enjoys it. However, in the end, she still chooses to change back.
** Alternatively, he Alex becomes a she, Alice, and doesn't like it, even though her life has changed for the better so much that she probably ''should''.
* '''Double Subverted''': He Alex turns into a she, Alice, but decides to change back... only to re-gender bend himself after spending a few days back in his old life.
* '''Parodied''':
** He
'''Parodied''': Alex becomes a she, Alice, and swears she hates her new life... but she's protesting just a ''wee'' bit too loudly.
** She creates a male clone of herself so she can live both lives.
* '''Zig Zagged''': Zagged''':
**
He becomes a she, and spends a few years switching back and forth, keeping up a double life. His/Her closest friends are fully aware of his/her situation. In the end, s/he finds love and picks an appropriate form... or finds a gender bending boy/girlfriend.boy/girlfriend.
** Alice creates a male clone of herself so she can live both lives.



%%* '''Plotted A Good Waste''': ???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She becomes a he, and life is better for him... except for the massive bouts of dysphoria he suffers from still having his opposite gender brain. Despite "improved" circumstances, he can't reconcile with the fact that he's not who he used to be, so even then he's not living the life he wanted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Exploited wasn\'t filled in yet.


* '''Exploited''': ???

to:

* '''Exploited''': ???The [[BigBad villain]] transforms the fighter into a girl to make her physically weaker, [[BatmanGambit knowing him enough to know that]] she wouldn't want to transform back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Menstrual Menace is about supernatural horrors caused by a woman\'s period. All Periods Are PMS is about women being cranky that time of the month. See this Trope Repair Shop thread for more info. Zero Context Examples will be deleted.


** He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life... but feels like she is killing her male self by changing. Alternately, she likes her new life at first, but then encounters obstacles like the glass ceiling, the alienation of all her friends who liked her better as a man, unwanted attention from the public and the scientific community, and [[MenstrualMenace another unpleasant thing she hadn't considered.]] In the end she decides it's not worth it and changes back.

to:

** He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life... but feels like she is killing her male self by changing. Alternately, she likes her new life at first, but then encounters obstacles like the glass ceiling, the alienation of all her friends who liked her better as a man, unwanted attention from the public and the scientific community, and [[MenstrualMenace [[AllPeriodsArePMS another unpleasant thing she hadn't considered.]] In the end she decides it's not worth it and changes back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Downplayed''': ???

to:

* '''Downplayed''': ???He becomes a she and gradually comes to accept and like her new life while still feeling a little nostalgic for her past as a he.

Added: 1283

Changed: 325

Removed: 779

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added standarized \'Playing With Wiki\' template


* '''Downplayed''': ???



* '''Subverted''': He becomes a she, and enjoys it. However, in the end, she still chooses to change back.

to:

* '''Subverted''': '''Subverted''':
**
He becomes a she, and enjoys it. However, in the end, she still chooses to change back.



* '''Parodied''': He becomes a she, and swears she hates her new life... but she's protesting just a ''wee'' bit too loudly.

to:

* '''Parodied''': '''Parodied''':
**
He becomes a she, and swears she hates her new life... but she's protesting just a ''wee'' bit too loudly.



* '''Deconstructed''': He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life... but feels like she is killing her male self by changing. Alternately, she likes her new life at first, but then encounters obstacles like the glass ceiling, the alienation of all her friends who liked her better as a man, unwanted attention from the public and the scientific community, and [[MenstrualMenace another unpleasant thing she hadn't considered.]] In the end she decides it's not worth it and changes back.
** She sabotages all attempts to turn her back.
* '''Reconstructed''': He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life. She agonizes about how this means she is giving up on her old, male life, only to come to terms with it by talking through it with her parents and friends.



* '''Averted''': He turns into a she and simply does not like it. This may or may not depend on his opinion of women.

to:

* '''Averted''': '''Averted''':
**
He turns into a she and simply does not like it. This may or may not depend on his opinion of women.



* '''Enforced''': "We intentionally picked tropes to play up his masculinity and freudian issues in order to make his eventual decision to stay transgendered more powerful."

to:

* '''Enforced''': "We intentionally picked tropes to play up his masculinity and freudian Freudian issues in order to make his eventual decision to stay transgendered trans-gendered more powerful."



* '''Exploited''': ???



* '''Conversed''': "Why is it that any character in [[WhateleyUniverse Whateley]] who is turned into a girl for more than five minutes wants to stay that way?"

to:

* '''Conversed''': "Why is it that any character in [[WhateleyUniverse Whateley]] Literature/{{Whateley|Universe}} who is turned into a girl for more than five minutes wants to stay that way?"way?"
* '''Deconstructed''':
** He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life... but feels like she is killing her male self by changing. Alternately, she likes her new life at first, but then encounters obstacles like the glass ceiling, the alienation of all her friends who liked her better as a man, unwanted attention from the public and the scientific community, and [[MenstrualMenace another unpleasant thing she hadn't considered.]] In the end she decides it's not worth it and changes back.
** She sabotages all attempts to turn her back.
* '''Reconstructed''': He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life. She agonizes about how this means she is giving up on her old, male life, only to come to terms with it by talking through it with her parents and friends.



Back to SecondLawOfGenderBending

to:

Back to SecondLawOfGenderBendingSecondLawOfGenderBending
----
%% Optional items, added after Conversed, at your discretion:
%%
%%* '''Implied''': ???
%%* '''Plotted A Good Waste''': ???
%%* '''Played For Drama''': ???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She sabotages all attempts to turn her back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Played For Laughs''': She creates a male clone of herself so she can live both lives.

to:

* '''Played For Laughs''': She creates a [[OppositeSexClone male clone of herself herself]] so she can live both lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The trope is gender-neutral, so that\'s playing it straight.


** Alternatively, she becomes a he, and he decides his life is better now.

Added: 142

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I think this makes a bit more sense for subverting the trope. Everything\'s set up for the Second Law to kick in... but it doesn\'t.


* '''Subverted''': He becomes a she, and enjoys it. However, in the end, she still changes back.

to:

* '''Subverted''': He becomes a she, and enjoys it. However, in the end, she still changes back.chooses to change back.
** Alternatively, he becomes a she, and doesn't like it, even though her life has changed for the better so much that she probably ''should''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She creates a male clone of herself so she can live both lives.


Added DiffLines:

* '''Played For Laughs''': She creates a male clone of herself so she can live both lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alternatively, He does not turn into a she at all, even though events in the story suggest that he should.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Deconstructed''': He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life... but feels like she is killing her male self by changing.

to:

* '''Deconstructed''': He becomes a she, and discovers she likes her new life... but feels like she is killing her male self by changing. Alternately, she likes her new life at first, but then encounters obstacles like the glass ceiling, the alienation of all her friends who liked her better as a man, unwanted attention from the public and the scientific community, and [[MenstrualMenace another unpleasant thing she hadn't considered.]] In the end she decides it's not worth it and changes back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Far more plausible.


* '''Justified''': He was an ugly {{Gonk}} when male, she's a breathtaking beauty.

to:

* '''Justified''': He was an ugly {{Gonk}} when male, she's transsexual even before he became a breathtaking beauty.she.

Top