Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / WorstAid

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When the example from ''Film/PodPeople'' appeared, with the one character falling off a cliff, being picked up by the legs and shoulders, and then half a bottle of whiskey being poured down her throat, the bots accompanied it by crunching noises and riffs like, "Quick! Move her spine around a lot!"

to:

** When the example from ''Film/PodPeople'' appeared, with the one character falling off a cliff, being picked up by the legs and shoulders, shoulders ("Quick, let's ''fold'' her"), and then half a bottle of whiskey being poured down her throat, the bots accompanied it by crunching noises and riffs like, "Quick! Move her spine around a lot!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the manga version of ''Literature/CirqueDuFreak'', a woman gets her arm torn off by a wolfman and in an instant, it gets reattached despite the amount of blood she just lost.

to:

* In the manga version of ''Literature/CirqueDuFreak'', ''[[Literature/TheSagaOfDarrenShan Cirque du Freak]]'', a woman gets her arm torn off by a wolfman and in an instant, it gets reattached despite the amount of blood she just lost.



* In ''LightNovel/TheGardenOfSinners'' the flashback scene after Shiki is hit by a car and visibly thrown several feet in the air shows her on a stretcher being taken from the ambulance to the hospital without any sort of backboard under her or collar/padding to restrain her head, which visibly moves as they're wheeling her in. The accident alone was bad enough since the scenario ''heavily'' suggests spinal injury, and she's lucky she wasn't permanently paralyzed because of additional trauma from not having her cervical spine stabilized. What's even worse is that the accident had a witness who went with them and presumably told them what happened, but even if they didn't have a witness medical personnel are ''always'' supposed to assume potential spinal/neck injury until it can be definitively ruled out, and neglecting to use a backboard/spine collar on someone in a scenario like that is an automatic fail on most certification exams for emergency medical workers. What makes this even stranger is that the stretcher clearly has places to attach head restraints on it that aren't used, and [[{{Creator/Ufotable}} the animation studio]] who made the film is usually fairly spot on with these things.

to:

* In ''LightNovel/TheGardenOfSinners'' ''Literature/TheGardenOfSinners'', the flashback scene after Shiki is hit by a car and visibly thrown several feet in the air shows her on a stretcher being taken from the ambulance to the hospital without any sort of backboard under her or collar/padding to restrain her head, which visibly moves as they're wheeling her in. The accident alone was bad enough since the scenario ''heavily'' suggests spinal injury, and she's lucky she wasn't permanently paralyzed because of additional trauma from not having her cervical spine stabilized. What's even worse is that the accident had a witness who went with them and presumably told them what happened, but even if they didn't have a witness medical personnel are ''always'' supposed to assume potential spinal/neck injury until it can be definitively ruled out, and neglecting to use a backboard/spine collar on someone in a scenario like that is an automatic fail on most certification exams for emergency medical workers. What makes this even stranger is that the stretcher clearly has places to attach head restraints on it that aren't used, and [[{{Creator/Ufotable}} the animation studio]] who made the film is usually fairly spot on with these things.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the live-action film version of ''Film/InspectorGadget'', an early trailer shows him going into arrest during the transformation surgery. How does the doctor revive him? He slaps him! The scene didn't make the final film; although obviously meant to be PlayedForLaughs, Disney probably considered it a bit too much for the intended audience.

to:

* In the live-action film version of ''Film/InspectorGadget'', an An early trailer for ''Film/InspectorGadget1999'' shows him Gadget going into arrest during the transformation surgery. How does the doctor revive him? He slaps him! [[MissingTrailerScene The scene didn't make the final film; film]]; although obviously meant to be PlayedForLaughs, Disney probably considered it a bit too much for the intended audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/{{Arknights}}'': Due to her tendency to get into fights and losing her medical bag, [[DrJerk Gavial]] often knocks out her patients with a very hard hit to the head, dubbed "Gaviallic kinetic anesthesia".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WebVideo/MadBecauseSmall'', a RunningGag in the series is someone asking for some Tums whenever they're ImpaledWithExtremePredjudice. Alphinaud points out in one instance that it doesn't work like that. Another portion has the main character, "Baby", ask for 10ccs of "Tetracortolmethodone" when Y'shtola is struck down by Zenos; the very next scene has "Baby" ask what they meant when they said they were taking her medical license.

to:

* In ''WebVideo/MadBecauseSmall'', a RunningGag in the series is someone asking for some Tums whenever they're ImpaledWithExtremePredjudice.ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice. Alphinaud points out in one instance that it doesn't work like that. Another portion has the main character, "Baby", ask for 10ccs of "Tetracortolmethodone" when Y'shtola is struck down by Zenos; the very next scene has "Baby" ask what they meant when they said they were taking her medical license.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''WebVideo/MadBecauseSmall'', a RunningGag in the series is someone asking for some Tums whenever they're ImpaledWithExtremePredjudice. Alphinaud points out in one instance that it doesn't work like that. Another portion has the main character, "Baby", ask for 10ccs of "Tetracortolmethodone" when Y'shtola is struck down by Zenos; the very next scene has "Baby" ask what they meant when they said they were taking her medical license.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added an example from Helluva Boss.

Added DiffLines:

* A minor case in ''WebAnimation/HelluvaBoss''. In the episode ''[[Recap.HelluvaBossS1E1MurderFamily Murder Family]],'' Blitzo is shot in the arm by the target after their assassination mission goes awry. After the situation has been dealt with, Moxxie helps Blitzo off the ground ''by his injured arm.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/MyHeartCantBeatUnlessYouTellItTo'': Dwight pulls out a screwdriver that Eduardo drove into his leg. Later, Jessie pulls a knife out of her belly. [[spoiler: Treated realistically in both cases. He walks with a limp for the rest of the movie and she dies.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The use message for Doc Galaktik's Vitality Serum in ''VideoGame/KingdomOfLoathing'' lampshades the game's use of this trope in the name of RuleOfFun:
-->You open the bottle of vitality serum, and chug the contents. That is probably not the correct dosage, but who wants half-empty serum bottles clogging up their inventory?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Critical Research Failure is a disambiguation page


* After the arguably [[{{Narm}} narmy]] and AxCrazy Craig Toomey of Stephen King's ''Film/TheLangoliers'' stabs [[spoiler:[[CreepyChild Dinah]]]] in the chest and firmly crosses the DespairEventHorizon ([[MoralEventHorizon along with other ones]]), one of the passengers on the plane says that he has experience with this kind of thing. What does he decide to do? Pull the knife out. Yep. You've gotta wonder who is responsible for the CriticalResearchFailure — the writers of the film, or [[DanBrowned the guy who clearly didn't pay attention to the sources he used]], assuming they were at all credible. In any case, it turns out to be the worst aid of all because [[spoiler:Dinah dies]] right after a lengthy conversation with Laurel about how while she never had the operation that would have given her sight, she got what she wanted because she [[SeeingThroughAnothersEyes saw through]] [[AxCrazy Mister Toomey's]] [[ThroughTheEyesOfMadness eyes.]] She adds that even dead things were beautiful.

to:

* After the arguably [[{{Narm}} narmy]] and AxCrazy Craig Toomey of Stephen King's ''Film/TheLangoliers'' stabs [[spoiler:[[CreepyChild Dinah]]]] in the chest and firmly crosses the DespairEventHorizon ([[MoralEventHorizon along with other ones]]), one of the passengers on the plane says that he has experience with this kind of thing. What does he decide to do? Pull the knife out. Yep. You've gotta wonder who is responsible for the CriticalResearchFailure — the writers of the film, or [[DanBrowned the guy who clearly didn't pay attention to the sources he used]], assuming they were at all credible. In any case, it turns out to be the worst aid of all because [[spoiler:Dinah dies]] right after a lengthy conversation with Laurel about how while she never had the operation that would have given her sight, she got what she wanted because she [[SeeingThroughAnothersEyes saw through]] [[AxCrazy Mister Toomey's]] [[ThroughTheEyesOfMadness eyes.]] She adds that even dead things were beautiful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/SweetHome'': A self-inflicted version; Sang-wook "bandages" a wound with ''duct tape''. In real life, this is a ''terrible'' idea. Setting aside the fact the tape is covered with god alone knows how many germs, removing it would just tear the wound open again.

to:

* ''Series/SweetHome'': ''Series/SweetHome2020'': A self-inflicted version; Sang-wook "bandages" a wound with ''duct tape''. In real life, this is a ''terrible'' idea. Setting aside the fact the tape is covered with god alone knows how many germs, removing it would just tear the wound open again.

Changed: 133

Removed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Slapping the back of a choking person while they are upright; gravity may cause the object to slip further down the windpipe. While this was standard practice before the Heimlich maneuver, there’s a reason it eventually fell out of favor.
** That reason being Henry Heimlich’s relentless self promotion, not any scientific evidence. The American Red Cross and a number of organization recommend back blows and abdominal thrusts for choking rescue.

to:

* Slapping the back of a choking person while they are upright; gravity may cause the object to slip further down the windpipe. While this was standard practice before the Heimlich maneuver, there’s a reason it eventually fell out of favor.
** That reason being Henry Heimlich’s relentless self promotion, not any scientific evidence. The American Red Cross and a number of organization recommend
If you are going to administer back blows and abdominal thrusts for choking rescue. make sure they are leaning forward first.

Added: 855

Removed: 855

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averting this is actually a plot point in the first case of ''[[VisualNovel/TheGreatAceAttorney The Great Ace Attorney 2: Resolve]]''. Susato (disguised as the lawyer "Ryutaro" in order to defend her friend) suggests that the defendant, who has been accused of stabbing the victim, might have been removing the knife from the victim in a photo. As the defendant is a medical student, it is pointed out that she would never be stupid enough to do that as it would simply cause more danger to the victim. However, it turns out she actually ''was'' trying to remove the knife because she thought there was an extremely deadly poison (it wasn't and she had ingested the poison beforehand) on it and was willing to risk the victim bleeding out, potentially leaving enough time for professionals to arrive, rather than letting her immediately die from poison.



* Averting this is actually a plot point in the first case of ''[[VisualNovel/TheGreatAceAttorney The Great Ace Attorney 2: Resolve]]''. Susato (disguised as the lawyer "Ryutaro" in order to defend her friend) suggests that the defendant, who has been accused of stabbing the victim, might have been removing the knife from the victim in a photo. As the defendant is a medical student, it is pointed out that she would never be stupid enough to do that as it would simply cause more danger to the victim. However, it turns out she actually ''was'' trying to remove the knife because she thought there was an extremely deadly poison (it wasn't and she had ingested the poison beforehand) on it and was willing to risk the victim bleeding out, potentially leaving enough time for professionals to arrive, rather than letting her immediately die from poison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Heimlich

Added DiffLines:

**That reason being Henry Heimlich’s relentless self promotion, not any scientific evidence. The American Red Cross and a number of organization recommend back blows and abdominal thrusts for choking rescue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Machinima/RedVsBlue'':

to:

* ''Machinima/RedVsBlue'':''WebAnimation/RedVsBlue'':

Added: 180

Removed: 181

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved a manga example to Anime/Manga section


* In the manga version of ''Literature/CirqueDuFreak'', a woman gets her arm torn off by a wolfman and in an instant, it gets reattached despite the amount of blood she just lost.



* In the manga version of ''Literature/CirqueDuFreak'', a woman gets her arm teared off by a wolfman and in a instant, it gets reattached despite the amount of blood she just lost.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/HouseOfTheDragon'': While the Maesters of Westeros know a lot of good medicine for their medieval setting, they still rely on some treatments we now know as outdated or even harmful to the patient.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
know about medicine before making blanket statements about medicine please


* In ''Film/JacobsLadder'', Jacob is given an ice bath when he has a high fever. Cold baths do more harm than good for fevers.

to:

* In Zigzagged in ''Film/JacobsLadder'', Jacob is given an ice bath when he has a high fever. Cold baths do more harm than good for fevers.fevers, but a fever that has gotten advanced enough to cause internal damage will sometimes be cooled down with an ice bath so that the patient doesn't die.

Added: 855

Changed: 5

Removed: 852

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averting this is actually a plot point in the first case of ''[[VisualNovel/TheGreatAceAttorney The Great Ace Attorney Resolve]]''. Susato (disguised as the lawyer "Ryutaro" in order to defend her friend) suggests that the defendant, who has been accused of stabbing the victim, might have been removing the knife from the victim in a photo. As the defendant is a medical student, it is pointed out that she would never be stupid enough to do that as it would simply cause more danger to the victim. However, it turns out she actually ''was'' trying to remove the knife because she thought there was an extremely deadly poison (it wasn't and she had ingested the poison beforehand) on it and was willing to risk the victim bleeding out, potentially leaving enough time for professionals to arrive, rather than letting her immediately die from poison.



* ''VideoGame/{{The Getaway}}'' is a particularly fine example. You've been shot multiple times? No problem! Just lean on this wall for a bit. It even launders clothes.

to:

* ''VideoGame/{{The Getaway}}'' ''VideoGame/TheGetaway'' is a particularly fine example. You've been shot multiple times? No problem! Just lean on this wall for a bit. It even launders clothes.


Added DiffLines:

* Averting this is actually a plot point in the first case of ''[[VisualNovel/TheGreatAceAttorney The Great Ace Attorney 2: Resolve]]''. Susato (disguised as the lawyer "Ryutaro" in order to defend her friend) suggests that the defendant, who has been accused of stabbing the victim, might have been removing the knife from the victim in a photo. As the defendant is a medical student, it is pointed out that she would never be stupid enough to do that as it would simply cause more danger to the victim. However, it turns out she actually ''was'' trying to remove the knife because she thought there was an extremely deadly poison (it wasn't and she had ingested the poison beforehand) on it and was willing to risk the victim bleeding out, potentially leaving enough time for professionals to arrive, rather than letting her immediately die from poison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Music Videos]]
* The video for "Emotion in Motion" by Creator/RicOcasek features Ric pouring an unidentified pink liquid into an unconscious woman's mouth. Luckily, it turns out to be a potion that wakes her instantly, but that's just sheer luck given the "unidentified" part. No wonder Ric admitted he had a hard time keeping a straight face while filming that video.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Played for laughs in ''VideoGame/Deadpool'', where Deadpool attempts to revive an unconscious Wolverine (who has a HealingFactor and is thus at no danger of permanent damage) with repeated "Miracle Bitchslaps to the face." It doesn't work, though you can earn an Achievement by hitting him enough.

to:

* Played for laughs in ''VideoGame/Deadpool'', ''VideoGame/Deadpool2013'', where Deadpool attempts to revive an unconscious Wolverine (who has a HealingFactor and is thus at no danger of permanent damage) with repeated "Miracle Bitchslaps to the face." It doesn't work, though you can earn an Achievement by hitting him enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Played for laughs in ''VideoGame/Deadpool (2013)'', where Deadpool attempts to revive an unconscious Wolverine (who has a HealingFactor and is thus at no danger of permanent damage) with repeated "Miracle Bitchslaps to the face." It doesn't work, though you can earn an Achievement by hitting him enough.

to:

* Played for laughs in ''VideoGame/Deadpool (2013)'', ''VideoGame/Deadpool'', where Deadpool attempts to revive an unconscious Wolverine (who has a HealingFactor and is thus at no danger of permanent damage) with repeated "Miracle Bitchslaps to the face." It doesn't work, though you can earn an Achievement by hitting him enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Played for laughs in ''VideoGame/Deadpool (2013)'', where Deadpool attempts to revive an unconscious Wolverine (who has a HealingFactor and is thus at no danger of permanent damage) with repeated "Miracle Bitchslaps to the face." It doesn't work, though you can earn an Achievement by hitting him enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Invoked and averted in The Moon By Night by ''Creator/MadeleineLEngle''. 11-year-old Suzy, whose father is a doctor and who aspires to be a doctor herself, witnesses a kid fall and cut her arm at the playground. She applies direct pressure while waiting for someone to fetch her father with the first-aid kid. The kid's mom starts screaming at her to use a tourniquet, but Suzy refuses because she knows better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also in one of the later books, Carlisle uses a tourniquet on Bella. Could be argued as Justified because Carlisle originally qualified as a doctor centuries ago, but since he still works as a doctor, you'd think he'd have had to do some continuing education at some point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
You Keep Using That Word is only about characters being called out In Universe for misusing a word.


* In one episode of ''WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy'', Peter gets his CPR card and HilarityEnsues. Upon witnessing a minor fender-bender in which both men quickly check for injuries and find that they're both perfectly okay, he introduces himself as "Peter Griffin, [[YouKeepUsingThatWord CPR]]" and begins unnecessarily performing the procedure on one of the men before attempting to remove his pants because he "need[s] to see if you soiled yourself." His CPR card is quickly revoked.

to:

* In one episode of ''WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy'', Peter gets his CPR card and HilarityEnsues. Upon witnessing a minor fender-bender in which both men quickly check for injuries and find that they're both perfectly okay, he introduces himself as "Peter Griffin, [[YouKeepUsingThatWord CPR]]" CPR" and begins unnecessarily performing the procedure on one of the men before attempting to remove his pants because he "need[s] to see if you soiled yourself." His CPR card is quickly revoked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Done deliberately by German university students trying to gain a DuelingScar. Some are known to deliberately sew up their injuries incorrectly in order to aggravate the wound and make the scar more noticeable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoSanAndreas,'' the medical personnel can magical revive people who died from gunfire, explosions, and fire just with CPR, and have the balls to do it in an area an insane gunman (I.E. you) is still shooting up. That pales in comparison to all the people they '''run over''' in their pursuit of saving a single life.

to:

* In ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoSanAndreas,'' the medical personnel can magical magically revive people who died from gunfire, explosions, and fire just with CPR, and have the balls to do it in an area an insane gunman (I.E. you) is still shooting up. That pales in comparison to all the people they '''run over''' in their pursuit of saving a single life.



* This is sadly TruthInTelevision, and happens many times, from negligent medical personnel to well meaning but ultimately clueless Samaritans.

to:

* This is sadly TruthInTelevision, and happens many times, from negligent medical personnel to well meaning well-meaning but ultimately clueless Samaritans.



** Later, UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt decided to ''leave the bullet in'' after somebody tried to assassinate him, remembering that taking it out killed Garfield, surmising (correctly) that the absence of BloodFromTheMouth meant he was alright (the bullet had struck his metal glasses case and the notes to the speech he was going to give). He was also just that badass. He gave his speech anyway while lightly bleeding into his shirt (starting by saying "Ladies and Gentlemen, I don't know whether you fully understand that I have just been shot, but it takes more than that to kill a Bull Moose"), ''then'' sought medical treatment.

to:

** Later, UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt decided to ''leave the bullet in'' after somebody tried to assassinate him, remembering that taking it out killed Garfield, surmising (correctly) that the absence of BloodFromTheMouth meant he was alright (the ([[PocketProtector the bullet had struck his metal glasses case and the notes to the speech he was going to give).give]]). He was also just that badass. He gave his speech anyway while lightly bleeding into his shirt (starting by saying "Ladies and Gentlemen, I don't know whether you fully understand that I have just been shot, but it takes more than that to kill a Bull Moose"), ''then'' sought medical treatment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also CPRCleanPrettyReliable, DeathByAmbulance, MagicalDefibrillator, SuckOutThePoison, WeHaveToGetTheBulletOut, ShotToTheHeart, {{Flatline}}, HarmfulHealing, HealItWithFire, MeatgrinderSurgery, LodgedBladeRemoval,and ArtisticLicenseMedicine; compare AnnoyingArrows.

to:

See also CPRCleanPrettyReliable, DeathByAmbulance, MagicalDefibrillator, SuckOutThePoison, WeHaveToGetTheBulletOut, ShotToTheHeart, {{Flatline}}, HarmfulHealing, HealItWithFire, MeatgrinderSurgery, LodgedBladeRemoval,and LodgedBladeRemoval, and ArtisticLicenseMedicine; compare AnnoyingArrows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
New trope, more fitting


* [[LodgedBladeRecycling Removing impaling foreign objects from wounds]]. Generally they've smashed all the bits they're going to smash, and are now acting as a plug on the wound — and an infection can be fought off with antibiotics at the hospital. Pull the plug, and you may be dead in minutes. Barbed weapons might tear more flesh, and if they don't, you're unlikely to be able to pull it out at the exact angle it went in.

to:

* [[LodgedBladeRecycling [[LodgedBladeRemoval Removing impaling foreign objects from wounds]]. Generally they've smashed all the bits they're going to smash, and are now acting as a plug on the wound — and an infection can be fought off with antibiotics at the hospital. Pull the plug, and you may be dead in minutes. Barbed weapons might tear more flesh, and if they don't, you're unlikely to be able to pull it out at the exact angle it went in.

Top