Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TheManIsStickingItToTheMan

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Interestingly, the one critic who pointed this out on RottenTomatoes got almost nothing but hatred for it in the comments section.

to:

** Interestingly, the one critic who pointed this out on RottenTomatoes got almost [[InternetBackdraft nothing but hatred for it in the comments section.section]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [=McDonalds=] ran a series of ads in New Zealand for its new "Lamb Burger", one of which had a man complain about how New Zealand is now overrun by overseas influences, such as American TV shows and European cars, until he is told that [=McDonalds=] now offer Lamb Burger. All this, coming from an American franchise. Indeed, [=McDonalds=] in particular is a prime focal point for the ambivalence harbored toward American consumer culture by foreigners, such as in the case of the French embracing [=McDonalds=] (it's been in Paris since at least the 1980s) but insisting on [[PulpFiction "Frenchifying" its menu]].

to:

* [=McDonalds=] ran a series of ads in New Zealand for its new "Lamb Burger", one of which had a man complain about how New Zealand is now overrun by overseas influences, such as American TV shows and European cars, until he is told that [=McDonalds=] now offer Lamb Burger. All this, coming from an American franchise. Indeed, [=McDonalds=] in particular is a prime focal point for the ambivalence harbored toward American consumer culture by foreigners, such as in the case of the French embracing [=McDonalds=] (it's been in Paris since at least the 1980s) but insisting on [[PulpFiction [[Film/PulpFiction "Frenchifying" its menu]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheAdjustmentBureau'' references this when Norris, a Senatorial candidate, admits that despite his small-town anti-conformist tone has his entire appearance dictated by careful studies from large corporations to find what will get the best reaction from the population.

to:

* ''TheAdjustmentBureau'' references this when Norris, a Senatorial candidate, admits that despite his small-town anti-conformist tone he has his entire appearance dictated by careful studies from large corporations to find what will get the best reaction from the population.



* LawAndOrderSpecialVictimsUnit: Detective John Munch is an avid conspiracy theorist and actively voices suspicion of all branches of government, including the justice system of which he is a part.

to:

* LawAndOrderSpecialVictimsUnit: Detective John Munch is an avid conspiracy theorist and actively voices suspicion of all branches of government, including the justice system of which he is a part.part (also TruthInTelevision for Richard Belzer, the actor who plays him, who really is TheConspiracyTheorist, yet is employed by "the system" that is Hollywood).



** Fox News and Fox's entertainment division are generally masters of this trope. ''The Simpsons'' show has been making fun of its home network and lambasting Murdoch as a right-wing fascist "billionaire tyrant" since long before he even launched Fox News. So far, Fox's network of affiliates and Murdoch himself seem to be taking all of this in stride, and why not? For all the viewer ratings they've got and as much money as they're making, they're probably laughing all the way to the bank and know they already got a lot of enemies.

to:

** Fox News and Fox's entertainment division are generally masters of this trope. ''The Simpsons'' show has been making fun of its home network and lambasting Murdoch as a right-wing fascist "billionaire tyrant" since long before he even launched Fox News. So far, Fox's network of affiliates and Murdoch himself seem to be taking all of this in stride, and why not? For all the viewer ratings they've got and as much money as they're making, they're probably laughing all the way to the bank and know they already got have a lot of enemies.

Changed: 5

Removed: 610

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut this: it wreaks of Writer On Board.


May come about as the result of two competing incompatible functions of "The Man". For instance, "The Man" is often as representative of censorship and regulation. A company that makes billions out of manufactured edgy and offensive content would thus call upon people to "stand up" against censorship groups. However, being motivated by profit rather than altruism is also a characteristic of "The Man". (Think of it as the not-too-crucial distinction between traditional conservatism and libertarian conservatism, which at the end of the day tend to go hand in hand, [[AmericanPoliticalSystem at least in American culture]].)

to:

May come about as the result of two competing incompatible functions of "The Man". For instance, "The Man" is often seen as representative of censorship and regulation. A company that makes billions out of manufactured edgy and offensive content would thus call upon people to "stand up" against censorship groups. However, being motivated by profit rather than altruism is also a characteristic of "The Man". (Think of it as the not-too-crucial distinction between traditional conservatism and libertarian conservatism, which at the end of the day tend to go hand in hand, [[AmericanPoliticalSystem at least in American culture]].)



Anyway, creativity is an inherently anti-authoritarian function; it's even subtly subversive against nature itself, since the ''[[GratuitousFrench auteur]]'' essentially "plays God." And, as was previously implied, capitalist democracy is the best social vehicle for disseminating creative products. Communist and fascist societies, after all, invariably insist that art must serve government propaganda above all else, while anarchist societies (an oxymoron if there ever was one) regard the very idea of art - and arguably even entertainment itself - as inherently "bourgeois" and thus counterrevolutionary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, the soda companies ''aren't'' telling us what size to buy - though, of course, they do want us all to buy the jumbo size.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Also can refer to any commercial that attacks its general field, but claims ''they'' are rooting for the underdog, and are taking a stand against the greed of all the others. So give them your money. See: Lawyers, car salesmen, phone providers, etc. There is conspicuous consumption at work here.

to:

Also can refer to any commercial that attacks its general field, but claims ''they'' are rooting for the underdog, and are taking a stand against the greed of all the others. [[BrokenAesop So give them your money. money.]] See: Lawyers, car salesmen, phone providers, etc. There is conspicuous consumption at work here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* "Uniform" by BlocParty is about, in its own words, "Commerce dressed up as rebellion".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ever since New York initiated the 16 ounce soda ban, every soda corporation in the city has joined forces for an advertising campaign on each delivery truck reading, quote-unquote, "Don't let bureaucrats tell you what size beverage to buy." Complete with a sillhouetted figure raising a fist in defiance, with a soda bottle in his clenched hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The campaign itself {{Lampshaded}} and [[{{Parody}} Parodied]] this trope, rather than played it straight. The campaign assumed that the Gen-X market believed they were being exploited and manipulated by advertising in general, and so was simply transparent about it.

to:

** The campaign itself {{Lampshaded}} and [[{{Parody}} Parodied]] this trope, rather than played it straight. The campaign assumed that the Gen-X market believed they were being exploited and manipulated by advertising in general, and so was simply [[AtLeastIAdmitIt transparent about it.it]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Am I overdoing the pseudo-relevant quote-commentaries?

Added DiffLines:

-->'''WebVideo/ToddInTheShadows''': Are they expecting Hannah Montana fans, who probably love malls, who probably watched this movie in a mall, to sit there and be shouting "Yeah, down with malls!"?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Reminiscent of the commentaries on the film 'The Corporation'' in the above section is the quote, variously attributed to Lenin or Stalin, which goes something like "the capitalists will sell us the rope by which we will hang them."

to:

* Reminiscent of the commentaries on the film 'The Corporation'' in the above section is the quote, variously attributed to Lenin or Stalin, which goes something like "the capitalists will sell us the rope by which we will hang them."" Perhaps indicating the use of this trope as potential for subverting the system?

Added: 249

Changed: 24

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----

to:

[[folder:Real Life]]
* Reminiscent of the commentaries on the film 'The Corporation'' in the above section is the quote, variously attributed to Lenin or Stalin, which goes something like "the capitalists will sell us the rope by which we will hang them."
[[/folder]]

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [=McDonalds=] ran a series of ads in New Zealand for its new "Lamb Burger", one of which had a man complain about how New Zealand is now overrun by overseas influences, such as American TV shows and European cars, until he is told that [=McDonalds=] now offer Lamb Burger. All this, coming from an American franchise.

to:

* [=McDonalds=] ran a series of ads in New Zealand for its new "Lamb Burger", one of which had a man complain about how New Zealand is now overrun by overseas influences, such as American TV shows and European cars, until he is told that [=McDonalds=] now offer Lamb Burger. All this, coming from an American franchise. Indeed, [=McDonalds=] in particular is a prime focal point for the ambivalence harbored toward American consumer culture by foreigners, such as in the case of the French embracing [=McDonalds=] (it's been in Paris since at least the 1980s) but insisting on [[PulpFiction "Frenchifying" its menu]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Anyway, creativity is an inherently anti-authoritarian function; it's even subtly subversive against nature itself, since the ''auteur'' essentially "plays God." And, as was previously implied, capitalist democracy is the best social vehicle for disseminating creative products. Communist and fascist societies, after all, invariably insist that art must serve government propaganda above all else, while anarchist societies (an oxymoron if there ever was one) regard the very idea of art - and arguably even entertainment itself - as inherently "bourgeois" and thus counterrevolutionary.

to:

Anyway, creativity is an inherently anti-authoritarian function; it's even subtly subversive against nature itself, since the ''auteur'' ''[[GratuitousFrench auteur]]'' essentially "plays God." And, as was previously implied, capitalist democracy is the best social vehicle for disseminating creative products. Communist and fascist societies, after all, invariably insist that art must serve government propaganda above all else, while anarchist societies (an oxymoron if there ever was one) regard the very idea of art - and arguably even entertainment itself - as inherently "bourgeois" and thus counterrevolutionary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Remember, that TropesAreNotBad. While there is inevitably going to be some inherent hypocrisy in almost any well known media talking out against The Man, it's also because of The Man that these works gets such wide coverage in the first place. Furthermore, the creative minds behind many of these works aren't always part of the establishment. While some given corporation may be happy to let itself be insulted as long as they profit, the people who write those insults in the first place aren't necessarily part of the problem they criticize. Writers subject to excessive amounts of ExecutiveMeddling have just as much a grudge against their corporate overlords as do most people.

to:

Remember, Remember that TropesAreNotBad. While there is inevitably going to be some inherent hypocrisy in almost any well known media talking out against The Man, it's also because of The Man that these works gets such wide coverage in the first place. Furthermore, the creative minds behind many of these works aren't always part of the establishment. While some given corporation may be happy to let itself be insulted as long as they profit, the people who write those insults in the first place aren't necessarily part of the problem they criticize. Writers subject to excessive amounts of ExecutiveMeddling have just as much of a grudge against their corporate overlords as do most people.
people.

Anyway, creativity is an inherently anti-authoritarian function; it's even subtly subversive against nature itself, since the ''auteur'' essentially "plays God." And, as was previously implied, capitalist democracy is the best social vehicle for disseminating creative products. Communist and fascist societies, after all, invariably insist that art must serve government propaganda above all else, while anarchist societies (an oxymoron if there ever was one) regard the very idea of art - and arguably even entertainment itself - as inherently "bourgeois" and thus counterrevolutionary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


May come about as the result of two competing incompatible functions of "The Man". For instance, "The Man" is often as representative of censorship and regulation. A company that makes billions out of manufactured edgy and offensive content would thus call upon people to "stand up" against censorship groups. However, being motivated by profit rather than altruism is also a characteristic of "The Man". (Think of it as the not-too-crucial distinction between traditional conservatism and libertarian conservatism, which at the end of the day tend to go hand in hand, at least in American culture.)

to:

May come about as the result of two competing incompatible functions of "The Man". For instance, "The Man" is often as representative of censorship and regulation. A company that makes billions out of manufactured edgy and offensive content would thus call upon people to "stand up" against censorship groups. However, being motivated by profit rather than altruism is also a characteristic of "The Man". (Think of it as the not-too-crucial distinction between traditional conservatism and libertarian conservatism, which at the end of the day tend to go hand in hand, [[AmericanPoliticalSystem at least in American culture.culture]].)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The 1994 movie ''TheChase'' provides an excellent example of the two incarnations of "The Man" coming into conflict, with the film - completely without irony - intrinsically claiming that the "hip" Man is somehow less of a Man than the stodgy old corporate Man. Kristy Swanson is the daughter of a mega-successful California businessman. After she is kidnapped by a desperate prison escapee (played by CharlieSheen) and finds herself [[StockholmSyndrome slowly falling in love with him]], she decides she's had enough of her father trying to control her life. Long story short, the couple abscond to Mexico...and how do they "rebel" when they get there? [[PerpetualTourist They lie on the beach and drink margaritas]] - something the girl's father most likely did a lot of in private himself.

to:

* The 1994 movie ''TheChase'' provides an excellent example of the two incarnations of "The Man" coming into conflict, with the film - completely without irony - intrinsically claiming that the "hip" Man is somehow less of a Man than the stodgy old corporate Man. Kristy Swanson is the daughter of a mega-successful California businessman. After she is kidnapped by a desperate prison escapee (played by CharlieSheen) and finds herself [[StockholmSyndrome slowly falling in love with him]], she decides she's had enough of her father trying to control her life. Long story short, the couple abscond to Mexico...and how do they "rebel" when they get there? [[PerpetualTourist They lie on the beach and drink margaritas]] - something the girl's father most likely did a lot of in private himself. (To its credit, ''The Chase'' doesn't try to come off as anything other than escapist entertainment, making its "message" a SpoofAesop.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


May come about as the result of two competing incompatible functions of "The Man". For instance, "The Man" is often as representative of censorship and regulation. A company that makes billions out of manufactured edgy and offensive content would thus call upon people to "stand up" against censorship groups. However, being motivated by profit rather than altruism is also a characteristic of "The Man". (Think of it as the not-too-crucial distinction between traditional conservatism and libertarian conservatism, which at the end of the day tend to go hand in hand.)

to:

May come about as the result of two competing incompatible functions of "The Man". For instance, "The Man" is often as representative of censorship and regulation. A company that makes billions out of manufactured edgy and offensive content would thus call upon people to "stand up" against censorship groups. However, being motivated by profit rather than altruism is also a characteristic of "The Man". (Think of it as the not-too-crucial distinction between traditional conservatism and libertarian conservatism, which at the end of the day tend to go hand in hand.hand, at least in American culture.)

Changed: 90

Removed: 69

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''7-Up's'' short-lived "Are You An Un?" ad depicted their competitors as Orwellian overlords hunting down the "Uns," people who thought for themselves by drinking...7-Up. Viewers saw right through it, and it was soon pulled.

to:

* ''7-Up's'' 7-Up's short-lived "Are You An Un?" ad depicted their competitors as Orwellian overlords hunting down the "Uns," people who thought for themselves by drinking...7-Up. Viewers saw right through it, and it was soon pulled.



* In 2004, a short-lived ad campaign for ''V -- The Ultimate Variety Show'' appeared in at least one Las Vegas freebie magazine (publications left in hotel rooms, etc. for tourists), encouraging potential theatergoers to "Dare to be different" and choose this show over Blue Man Group, CirqueDuSoleil, and/or Celine Dion. It even had a cartoon illustration with a black sheep choosing the variety show while tons of white sheep chose the others. (The show is a B-list, low-budget production compared to those A-list ones, so the ad was assuming the target audience did not know that...)

to:

* In 2004, a short-lived ad campaign for ''V -- The Ultimate Variety Show'' appeared in at least one Las Vegas freebie magazine (publications left in hotel rooms, etc. for tourists), encouraging potential theatergoers to "Dare to be different" and choose this show over Blue Man Group, CirqueDuSoleil, Music/BlueManGroup, Creator/CirqueDuSoleil, and/or Celine Dion. It even had a cartoon illustration with a black sheep choosing the variety show while tons of white sheep chose the others. (The The show is a B-list, low-budget production compared to those A-list ones, so the ad was assuming the target audience did not know that...)



** Also an example of this trope by being on {{MTV}}.
*** {{MTV}} does have something of a reputation for being this trope.

to:

** Also an example of this trope by being on {{MTV}}.
*** {{MTV}}
{{MTV}}, which does have something of a reputation for being ''being'' this trope.



----

to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Tom Wolfe called this "radical chic."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The entire history of this phenomenon - at least in America - is traced by economist Thomas Frank in his book ''The Conquest of Cool''. Frank points out that the "do-what-you-wanna-do" philosophy of TheSixties was actually an aesthetic crafted by ''MadMen''-style Madison Avenue types. That's right: the "cultural revolution" that supposedly turned everything we knew about the world completely upside-down was the handiwork of middle-class kids aping the consumer culture of the guys in suits they claimed to despise.

Added: 794

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HannahMontana: TheMovie. The main antagonist of the film wants to build a mall. That's right, the corporate manufactured, MerchandiseDriven, fashion obsessed, consumistic Hannah Montana is telling us that malls are bad.

to:

* HannahMontana: TheMovie. The main antagonist of the film wants to build a mall. That's right, the corporate manufactured, corporate-manufactured, MerchandiseDriven, fashion obsessed, consumistic fashion-obsessed, consumeristic Hannah Montana is telling us that malls are bad.bad.
* The 1994 movie ''TheChase'' provides an excellent example of the two incarnations of "The Man" coming into conflict, with the film - completely without irony - intrinsically claiming that the "hip" Man is somehow less of a Man than the stodgy old corporate Man. Kristy Swanson is the daughter of a mega-successful California businessman. After she is kidnapped by a desperate prison escapee (played by CharlieSheen) and finds herself [[StockholmSyndrome slowly falling in love with him]], she decides she's had enough of her father trying to control her life. Long story short, the couple abscond to Mexico...and how do they "rebel" when they get there? [[PerpetualTourist They lie on the beach and drink margaritas]] - something the girl's father most likely did a lot of in private himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The phrase "flaming youth" itself evokes the decadence of the RoaringTwenties, which were arguably a textbook example of this trope as well. Dressing in "flapper" fashions and listening and/or dancing to [[TheNewRockAndRoll jazz music]], viewed by both fans and critics as barbaric and subversive at the time, were in fact enjoyed the most by NouveauRiche types who wanted first and foremost to make lots of money, not change the culture.

to:

** The phrase "flaming youth" itself evokes the decadence of the RoaringTwenties, which were arguably a textbook example of this trope as well. Dressing in "flapper" fashions and listening and/or dancing to [[TheNewRockAndRoll jazz music]], viewed by both fans and critics as barbaric and subversive at the time, were in fact enjoyed the most prominently by NouveauRiche types who wanted first and foremost to make lots of money, not change the culture.culture. (See ''TheGreatGatsby''.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The phrase "flaming youth" itself evokes the decadence of the RoaringTwenties, which were arguably a textbook example of this trope as well. Dressing in "flapper" fashions and listening and/or dancing to [[TheNewRockAndRoll jazz music]], viewed by both fans and critics as barbaric and subversive at the time, were in fact enjoyed the most by NouveauRiche types who wanted first and foremost to make lots of money, not change the culture.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They probably meant: "Don't be like all those drugged-out kids out there, because you're morally superior to them." Not only an arrogant point of view, but pretty cynical as well. (More recent ads evoke the same theme, with their "Above the Influence" slogan.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


May come about as the result of two competing incompatible functions of "The Man". For instance, "The Man" is often as representative of censorship and regulation. A company that makes billions out of manufactured edgy and offensive content would thus call upon people to "stand up" against censorship groups. However, being motivated by profit rather than altruism is also a characteristic of "The Man".

to:

May come about as the result of two competing incompatible functions of "The Man". For instance, "The Man" is often as representative of censorship and regulation. A company that makes billions out of manufactured edgy and offensive content would thus call upon people to "stand up" against censorship groups. However, being motivated by profit rather than altruism is also a characteristic of "The Man".
Man". (Think of it as the not-too-crucial distinction between traditional conservatism and libertarian conservatism, which at the end of the day tend to go hand in hand.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The antithesis of the BandwagonTechnique, and often used by competitors of companies that can use said technique. Tends to invoke the RuleAbidingRebel, since by nature they're telling you to rebel by joining a status quo. For the record, {{Hipster}}s tend to not merely fall for this sort of trick, they often seem to eagerly seek it out just to swallow it, as the proverb goes, "hook, line and sinker", and they '''hate''' being called out on this hypocrisy, often trying to cop-out by claiming to only be embracing it 'sarcastically' even though their act doesn't fool anyone, except [[WhatAnIdiot these people]]

to:

The antithesis of the BandwagonTechnique, and often used by competitors of companies that can use said technique. Tends to invoke the RuleAbidingRebel, since by nature they're telling you to rebel by joining a status quo. For the record, {{Hipster}}s tend to not merely fall for this sort of trick, they often seem to eagerly seek it out just to swallow it, as the proverb goes, "hook, line and sinker", and they '''hate''' being called out on this hypocrisy, often trying to cop-out by claiming to only be embracing it 'sarcastically' 'sarcastically', even though their act doesn't fool anyone, except [[WhatAnIdiot these people]]
anyone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not an example


* LadyGaga and her admittedly brilliant StealthParody of the pop industry kind of fails when [[NominalParody you remember how rich she's getting from doing it]]. Although, she does ''claim'' to be [[DoingItForTheArt functionally broke from putting all her own money back into her productions.]]

to:

* LadyGaga and her admittedly brilliant StealthParody of the pop industry kind of fails when [[NominalParody you remember how rich she's getting from doing it]].it. Although, she does ''claim'' to be [[DoingItForTheArt functionally broke from putting all her own money back into her productions.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The film adaptation of ''VForVendetta'' popularized the use of Guy Fawkes masks to protest authority. [[http://newsfeed.time.com/2011/08/29/how-time-warner-profits-from-the-anonymous-hackers/ The Time Warner corporation makes a lot of money off of selling those masks]]. Not to mention how much [[VigilanteMan Anonymous]] likes them as well.

to:

* The film adaptation of ''VForVendetta'' ''Film/VForVendetta'' popularized the use of Guy Fawkes masks to protest authority. [[http://newsfeed.time.com/2011/08/29/how-time-warner-profits-from-the-anonymous-hackers/ The Time Warner corporation makes a lot of money off of selling those masks]]. Not to mention how much [[VigilanteMan Anonymous]] likes them as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HannahMontana: TheMovie. The main antagonist of the film wants to build a mall. That's right, the corporate manufactured, MerchandiseDriven, fashion obsessed, consumistic Hannah Montana is telling us that malls are bad.

Top