Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / StrawCharacter

Go To

OR

Changed: 268

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''Literature/StarshipTroopers,'' Heinlein jumps to the opposite end of the spectrum, advocating disenfranchisement of all non-veterans, but also corporal punishment for minor crimes, along with ''capital'' punishment for violent crimes or homicide, even by insane persons. This is all justified with various arguments claiming that anything less would coddle people and lead to higher crime rates (he compares it with training dogs) and any opposing views are strawman versions of themselves.

to:

** In ''Literature/StarshipTroopers,'' Heinlein jumps to the opposite end of the spectrum, advocating disenfranchisement of all non-veterans, but also corporal punishment for minor crimes, along with ''capital'' punishment for violent crimes or homicide, even by insane persons. This is all justified with various arguments claiming that anything less would coddle people and lead to higher crime rates (he compares it with training dogs) and any opposing views are strawman versions of themselves. It doesn't help that in-universe characters that advocate these views are teachers, and so any opposition comes from their students who naturally can't offer any serious opposition; and also claim their philosophy has been mathematically proven to close the argument.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Unsurprisingly, conservative pundit Ben Shapiro includes this in his book, ''True Allegiance''. Levon Williams is a black "race hustler" who stages the police killing of a black child in order to gain power. His in-universe arguments about black communities' relationship with the police are basically presented as posturing for the cameras - which is the only way the author attempts to dismiss them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mr. Birling from ''An Inspector Calls'' is a prime example of a British conservative straw man. J.B. Priestly gives the audience no doubt that he is wrong about everything, including his political and social views.

to:

* Mr. Birling from ''An Inspector Calls'' ''Theatre/AnInspectorCalls'' is a prime example of a British conservative straw man. J.B. Priestly gives the audience no doubt that he is wrong about everything, including his political and social views.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeteronormativeCrusader: A homophobic activist who sees any sexuality other than straight to be wicked and vile and is determined to [[BuryYourGays kill]] or [[CureYourGays cure]] everyone who is gay.

to:

* HeteronormativeCrusader: A homophobic activist who sees any sexuality other than straight to be wicked and vile and is determined to [[BuryYourGays kill]] or [[CureYourGays cure]] everyone who is gay. Has a high chance of [[YouAreWhatYouHate secretly being]] [[ArmoredClosetGay gay themselves]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"a let's play that happened one time" isn't really appropriate to put here if you don't say who the let's player is....


* A LetsPlay of "Life and Death 2: The brain", the Lets player does a subdural Hematoma operation...and intentionally holds the suction pump in the brain too long so part of the brain is sucked out. The player then proceeded to say "Oh, she was a Tea Party candidate! She wasn't going to need ''THAT''!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When they do take shots at conservatives, it's usually white alpha-male wannabe stereotypes with no real authority such as Mr. Garrison, Jimbo & Ned and a group of men (and one woman who wishes she was a man) with anger problems, the latter of whom were just insecure about their small penises.

to:

** When they do take shots at conservatives, it's usually white alpha-male wannabe stereotypes with no real authority such as Mr. Garrison, Jimbo & Ned and a group of men (and one woman who wishes she was a man) with anger problems, the latter of whom were just insecure about their small penises. Mr. White in later seasons was a ConspiracyTheorist and strawman for the American far-right, lampooning conspiracy theories like [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_genocide_conspiracy_theory white genocide]] and [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QAnon QAnon]]. [[spoiler: Like Al Gore, [[TheCuckoolanderWasRight he's eventually proven right]] as his [[RageAgainstTheAuthor claims of "two guys running the show"]] were referring to Creator/TreyParkerAndMattStone themselves.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Clyde in ''WesternAnimation/SouthParkPostCovid'' is a parody of [[UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic COVID]] vaccine skeptics, as his adamant refusal to get the vaccine for no discernable reason makes him TheMillstone as the entire town is placed under martial law because of it. At one point he screams at the others that his "body is a temple" [[{{hypocrite}} moments after accepting what he thought was cocaine from Wendy]].

to:

** Clyde in ''WesternAnimation/SouthParkPostCovid'' is a parody of [[UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic COVID]] vaccine skeptics, as his adamant refusal to get the vaccine for no discernable reason makes him TheMillstone as the entire town is placed under martial law because of it. At one point he screams at the others that his "body is a temple" [[{{hypocrite}} moments after accepting what he thought was cocaine from Wendy]]. [[spoiler: The punchline? His adamant refusal was the result of a [[StableTimeLoop bootstrap paradox]], with the "expert" he cited being his own future self.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Clyde in ''WesternAnimation/SouthParkPostCovid'' is a parody of [[UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic COVID]] vaccine skeptics, as his adamant refusal to get the vaccine for no discernable reason makes him TheMillstone as the entire town is placed under martial law because of it. At one point he screams at the others that his "body is a temple" [[{{hypocrite}} moments after accepting what he thought was cocaine from Wendy]].

Added: 163

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[index]]



* FoxNewsLiberal: A political character who is used to present the illusion of ideological balance in a work whose political slant is strongly the other direction.




to:

[[/index]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WebVideo/TheNostalgiaCritic'' has Peter Soulless, a studio executive who only cares about making money and doesn't care about how much he changes about ''Film/TheCatInTheHat'' from its source material as long as it earns a lot of money.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Much like how Mike “Meathead” Stivic filled this role on All In The Family, more often than not, Stan’s daughter Hayley fills out the role of the straw man liberal. As a character, she tends to alternate between a well meaning, socially conscious liberal who tries to do the right thing but goes about it the wrong way, to a self righteous shrill know nothing know it all soapbox Sadie who opposes various causes just because her dad supports them and for a desire to appear to have the moral high ground. A glaring example of this is her hypocrisy with men. She has no problem whatsoever casually dumping men for any and all reasons and has done so at the drop of a hat, expecting them to “get over it”. However, the minute SHE is the one dumped, all sanity and logic go flying out the window and she goes on an insane violence spree.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Felt like I created a Sinkhole


->''[[IResembleThatRemark (Stan shoots Brian in the leg)]]''

to:

->''[[IResembleThatRemark (Stan ->''(Stan shoots Brian in the leg)]]''leg)''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''(Stan shoots Brian in the leg)''

to:

->''(Stan ->''[[IResembleThatRemark (Stan shoots Brian in the leg)''leg)]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''Literature/StrangerInAStrangeLand'', Heinlein once again goes back to libertarian views involving a rich and famous MarySue writer/doctor/lawyer, protecting an even ''more'' rich and famous MarySue Martian/Changeling/cult-leader from a human society of fascist politicians and religious fanatics who want to stop/control/kill him -- sort of an interplanetary version of ''Atlas Shrugged,'' along with arguments comparing humans to monkeys and God.

to:

** In ''Literature/StrangerInAStrangeLand'', Heinlein once again goes back to libertarian views involving a rich and famous MarySue writer/doctor/lawyer, protecting an even ''more'' rich and famous MarySue Martian/Changeling/cult-leader from a human society of fascist politicians and religious fanatics who want to stop/control/kill him -- sort of an interplanetary version of ''Atlas Shrugged,'' along with arguments comparing humans to monkeys and God.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Gates from ''ComicBook/{{Legion of Super-Heroes}}'' is an interesting example. He was one of the very few free thinkers among [[BeePeople his race]], who all shared the same opinions. He's basically a socialist, openly suspicious of authority figures, with most of his dialogue being him complaining about the "capitalist police state" and "teenage death squad" he's been forcibly drafted into. While most of his appearances involve making fun of extreme beliefs in one way or another, writers have consistently treated him as a sympathetic three-dimensional character.

to:

* Gates from ''ComicBook/{{Legion of Super-Heroes}}'' ''ComicBook/LegionOfSuperHeroes'' is an interesting example. He was one of the very few free thinkers among [[BeePeople his race]], who all shared the same opinions. He's basically a socialist, openly suspicious of authority figures, with most of his dialogue being him complaining about the "capitalist police state" and "teenage death squad" he's been forcibly drafted into. While most of his appearances involve making fun of extreme beliefs in one way or another, writers have consistently treated him as a sympathetic three-dimensional character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WebVideo/EpicRapBattlesOfHistory'': The series has a slight but obvious left bend which is occasionally more critical of right-leaning people than those on the left. It's treatment of Bill O'Reilly, in which brags about how evil he is and how black his heart is, however, verges into an outright strawman.

to:

* ''WebVideo/EpicRapBattlesOfHistory'': The series has a slight but obvious left bend which is occasionally more critical of right-leaning people than those on the left. It's Its treatment of Bill O'Reilly, in which brags about how evil he is and how black his heart is, however, verges into an outright strawman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/RedPlanet'' features a straw man atheist geneticist who offers no coherent support for his disbelief when debating with other characters. On the opposite site of the equation there is a straw man religious old man, who ''also'' offers no coherent support for his spirituality, while expecting others to share it. Curiously, they get along just fine.

to:

* ''Film/RedPlanet'' features a straw man atheist geneticist who offers no coherent support for his disbelief when debating with other characters. On the opposite site side of the equation there is a straw man religious old man, who ''also'' offers no coherent support for his spirituality, while expecting others to share it. Curiously, they get along just fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/RedPlanet'' features a straw man atheist geneticist who offers no coherent support for his disbelief when debating with other characters.

to:

* ''Film/RedPlanet'' features a straw man atheist geneticist who offers no coherent support for his disbelief when debating with other characters. On the opposite site of the equation there is a straw man religious old man, who ''also'' offers no coherent support for his spirituality, while expecting others to share it. Curiously, they get along just fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WebVideo/SomeMoreNews'' has recurring character Warmbo, a literal puppet operated by News Dude Cody Johnston. Warmbo is basically a ''Sesame Street'' character shilling for a mainstream political party, relentlessly cheery about the good things Democrats do when they're in power ([[TautologicalTemplar which are good]] ''[[TautologicalTemplar because]]'' [[TautologicalTemplar Democrats do them]]) while being upset about the bad things Republicans do when they're in power (which are bad ''because'' Republicans do them... Even if they're good when Democrats do them). His status as a strawman is discussed and deconstructed in his first appearance, with the News Dude pointing out that Warmbo, while extremely exaggerated, resembles much of the U.S. electorate in that he isn't really deeply engaged in politics day-to-day or has a clearly defined ideology. He has no personal stake in many of the issues, beyond wanting to see 'his side' win, and as such doesn't really care when Democrats carry on with the same destructive policies they inherit from previous Republican administrations.

to:

* ''WebVideo/SomeMoreNews'' has recurring character Warmbo, a literal puppet operated by News Dude Cody Johnston. Warmbo is basically a ''Sesame Street'' character shilling for a mainstream political party, relentlessly cheery about the good things Democrats do when they're in power ([[TautologicalTemplar which are good]] ''[[TautologicalTemplar because]]'' [[TautologicalTemplar Democrats do them]]) while being upset about the bad things Republicans do when they're in power (which are bad ''because'' Republicans do them... Even if they're good when Democrats do them). His status as a strawman is discussed and deconstructed in his first appearance, with the News Dude pointing out that Warmbo, while extremely exaggerated, resembles much of the U.S. electorate in that he isn't really deeply engaged in politics day-to-day or has a clearly defined ideology. He has no personal stake in many of the issues, beyond wanting to see 'his side' win, win and for things to stay his idea of normal, and as such doesn't really care when Democrats carry on with the same destructive policies they inherit from previous Republican administrations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WebVideo/SomeMoreNews'' has recurring character Warmbo, a literal puppet operated by News Dude Cody Johnston. Warmbo is basically a ''Sesame Street'' character shilling for a mainstream political party, relentlessly cheery about the good things Democrats do when they're in power ([[TautologicalTemplar which are good]] ''[[TautologicalTemplar because]]'' [[TautologicalTemplar Democrats do them]]) while being upset about the bad things Republicans do when they're in power (which are bad ''because'' Republicans do them... Even if they're good when Democrats do them). His status as a strawman is discussed and deconstructed in his first appearance, with the News Dude pointing out that Warmbo, while extremely exaggerated, resembles much of the U.S. electorate in that he isn't really deeply engaged in politics day-to-day or has a clearly defined ideology. He has no personal stake in many of the issues, beyond wanting to see 'his side' win, and as such doesn't really care when Democrats carry on with the same destructive policies they inherit from previous Republican administrations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAuto'' franchise often features conservative politicians as [[RightWingMilitiaFanatic murderous fascists]] [[ANaziByAnyOtherName in all but name]], while liberals are portrayed as [[DramaQueen touchy-feely]] [[BombThrowingAnarchists pseudo-anarchists]] who are in it just to gain some moral superiority. [[WordOfGod Dan Hauser actually complained]] that since ''GTA V'', and particularly after the highly-contentious U.S. Presidential Election of 2016, real-life politicians have become too similar to the games' parodies, making it hard to parody them without harboring UnfortunateImplications (and entering "DudeNotFunny territory") instead of just poking fun at the most ideologically-charged aspects of the UsefulNotes/AmericanPoliticalSystem through a British lens (the UsefulNotes/BritishPoliticalSystem was traditionally more inclined to consensus-building, given its parliamentary/multi-party nature). Because of this, Hauser says that Rockstar does not plan on making or releasing ''GTA 6'' at least until after UsefulNotes/DonaldTrump leaves the White House.

to:

* The ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAuto'' franchise often features conservative politicians as [[RightWingMilitiaFanatic murderous fascists]] [[ANaziByAnyOtherName in all but name]], while liberals are portrayed as [[DramaQueen touchy-feely]] [[BombThrowingAnarchists pseudo-anarchists]] who are in it just to gain some moral superiority. [[WordOfGod Dan Hauser actually complained]] that since ''GTA V'', and particularly after the highly-contentious U.S. Presidential Election of 2016, real-life politicians have become too similar to the games' parodies, making it hard to parody them without harboring UnfortunateImplications (and entering "DudeNotFunny territory") instead of just poking fun at the most ideologically-charged aspects of the UsefulNotes/AmericanPoliticalSystem through a British lens (the UsefulNotes/BritishPoliticalSystem was traditionally more inclined to consensus-building, given its parliamentary/multi-party nature). Because of this, Hauser says that Rockstar does not plan on making or releasing ''GTA 6'' at least until after UsefulNotes/DonaldTrump leaves the White House. Since Trump's departure, the game itself is still being developed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* Creator/AynRand, as a WriterOnBoard promoting her philosophy of Objectivism, generally made the villains of her fictional works [=Strawman=] Socialists. In particular, not only does ''Literature/AtlasShrugged'' have lots and lots of [=Strawman=] Socialist villains, but their political beliefs are repeatedly blamed for every single disaster that happens in the story. In one episode, a passenger train is held up just short of a tunnel unsuitable for its steam locomotive but is ordered to proceed nevertheless by a corrupt politician who is late for a rally and unwilling to wait for a diesel locomotive to carry the train through the tunnel. This means death for every passenger on board -- WhatASenselessWasteOfHumanLife, right? No -- the [=Strawman=] Political beliefs of the doomed passengers are illustrated to show how their catastrophic demise was justified because they were allegedly each NotSoDifferent than the politician. Even worse is ''Anthem'', where the [=Strawman=] Socialists have eliminated the use of the word "I" in favor of "We," where everyone sobs themselves to sleep in despair, and where the protagonist is ostracized after rediscovering electric lighting both for stepping out of his assigned role as a janitor and for threatening the jobs of candlestick makers.

to:

* Creator/AynRand, as a WriterOnBoard promoting her philosophy of Objectivism, generally made the villains of her fictional works [=Strawman=] Socialists. In particular, not only does ''Literature/AtlasShrugged'' have lots and lots of [=Strawman=] Socialist villains, but their political beliefs are repeatedly blamed for every single disaster that happens in the story. In one episode, a passenger train is held up just short of a tunnel unsuitable for its steam locomotive but is ordered to proceed nevertheless by a corrupt politician who is late for a rally and unwilling to wait for a diesel locomotive to carry the train through the tunnel. This means death for every passenger on board -- WhatASenselessWasteOfHumanLife, right? No -- the [=Strawman=] Political beliefs of the doomed passengers are illustrated to show how their catastrophic demise was justified because they were allegedly each NotSoDifferent no different than the politician. Even worse is ''Anthem'', where the [=Strawman=] Socialists have eliminated the use of the word "I" in favor of "We," where everyone sobs themselves to sleep in despair, and where the protagonist is ostracized after rediscovering electric lighting both for stepping out of his assigned role as a janitor and for threatening the jobs of candlestick makers.



* ''Literature/TheCandidatesBasedOnATrueCountry'' focuses on the two candidates for the US Presidency: Democrat Harry Pinko, who is a self-obsessed slacker who just wants get elected so he can {{Troll}} rich people, and Republican Skip [=LaDouche=], a [[GunNut trigger-happy]] former CorruptCorporateExecutive. [[NotSoDifferent Both of them are shameless hypocrites who are only in it for their own benefit and amusement.]] Their respective campaign managers are, in many ways, even ''worse.''

to:

* ''Literature/TheCandidatesBasedOnATrueCountry'' focuses on the two candidates for the US Presidency: Democrat Harry Pinko, who is a self-obsessed slacker who just wants get elected so he can {{Troll}} rich people, and Republican Skip [=LaDouche=], a [[GunNut trigger-happy]] former CorruptCorporateExecutive. [[NotSoDifferent Both of them are shameless hypocrites who are only in it for their own benefit and amusement.]] amusement. Their respective campaign managers are, in many ways, even ''worse.''

Added: 267

Changed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Hal Jordan was portrayed as a straw conservative in the famed ''Franchise/GreenLantern[=/=]Comicbook/GreenArrow'' series from the '70s. Most stories involved Hal acting like a JerkAss and spouting off conservative talking points, [[AnAesop only to be taught a lesson about racism, sexism or classism by the end of the issue]]. Perhaps most notable would be John Stewart's debut issue. Hal is basically called a racist by one of the Guardians of the Universe after he bashes Stewart for standing up to a bigoted police officer. Guy Gardner would qualify as well in TheNineties.

to:

* Hal Jordan was portrayed as a straw conservative in the famed ''Franchise/GreenLantern[=/=]Comicbook/GreenArrow'' series from the '70s. Most stories involved Hal acting like a JerkAss and spouting off conservative talking points, [[AnAesop only to be taught a lesson about racism, sexism or classism by the end of the issue]]. Perhaps most notable would be John Stewart's debut issue. Hal is basically called a racist by one of the Guardians of the Universe after he bashes Stewart for standing up to a bigoted police officer.
**
Guy Gardner would qualify as well in TheNineties.TheNineties. Essentially he took over from Hal as the strawman conservative of the DC Universe during that period of time, although Gardner's cartoonish chauvinism made Jordan's righ wing tendencies seem like moderate centrism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''The New Statesman'' featured a scathing parody of the Thatcher ministry, particularly in its depiction of Alan B'Stard.

to:

* ''The New Statesman'' ''Series/TheNewStatesman'' featured a scathing parody of the Thatcher ministry, particularly in its depiction of Alan B'Stard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* While ''Webcomic/LeagueOfSuperRedundantHeroes'' is focused on the antics of the resident superhero population, it also has the occasional political comic. American conservatives are usually portrayed in one of two categories. The rich ones are {{Corrupt Corporate Executive}}s who lie to and manipulate their followers while ruining the world for their own profit. The poor ones are mad {{Conspiracy Theorist}}s who are completely detached from reality. All of them demonize and persecute liberals while ranting about threats that don't actually exist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TalesOfTheBountyHunters'': Boba Fett gets portrayed as one of the extremely conservative variety. He doesn't have a single vice, because he considers them an insult to the flesh. He considers sex between those not married to be immoral - that includes rape, too. When Leia tried offering to pay him to get her and her friends out, he flat out refused, saying that the rebels were morally wrong. Apparently, he supports the Empire because it permits civilization to exist, never mind that it's an empire that commits genocide. He hates Han's guts because Han breaks laws, and Fett finds the idea of breaking laws to be offensive. Never mind that Fett murders people, and takes bounties set by the notorious gangster Jabba (who Han began as a smuggler for). He laughs off the Dark Side as Jedi superstition, which becomes hilarious in hindsight, because for all his hatred of Jedi, his lifestyle is much the kind that the Jedi Order would have considered ideal (not to mention making him a FlatEarthAtheist type given other material shows Vader once Force choked him--or [[WatsonianVsDoylist can be]] a ContinuitySnarl).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The article on Louder with Crowder has been cut because it has been addressed that Steven Crowder is a bigot and has used his show as a platform to spread racist and homophobic rhetoric.


* ''WebVideo/LouderWithCrowder'':
** Crowder will sometimes perform humorous sketches featuring a strawman of a lefty.
** Crowder's "Change My Mind" segments usually have him discussing a political issue with random 19-year-old lefty college kids who don't have a firm grasp of the subject and easily fall into the debate traps he's planned out beforehand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlondeRepublicanSexKitten: An attractive female conversative used to demonstrate that they're not all old white men.

to:

* BlondeRepublicanSexKitten: An attractive female conversative conservative used to demonstrate that they're not all old white men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeteronormativeCrusader: A homophobic activist who sees any sexuality other than straight to be wicked and vile.

to:

* HeteronormativeCrusader: A homophobic activist who sees any sexuality other than straight to be wicked and vile.vile and is determined to [[BuryYourGays kill]] or [[CureYourGays cure]] everyone who is gay.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MalcolmXerox: A civil rights activist who is willing to resort to extremist violence for further their cause.

to:

* MalcolmXerox: A civil rights activist who is willing to resort to extremist violence for to further their cause.

Top