Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / DeliberateValuesDissonance

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/InTheGrimDarknessOfThe41stMillenniumNobodyBeatsGIJoe'': When the members of G.I. Joe have to pretend to be loyal citizens of the Imperium Of Man, their mission is made much harder by the Imperium's dystopian authoritarianism, religious fanaticism, distrust of artificial intelligence, and genocidal intolerance toward everything that isn't considered sufficiently human.

Added: 312

Removed: 310

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WebVideo/DreamSMP'': PlayedForLaughs in the "Tales from the SMP" episode "The Village That Went Mad". Bad hits Quackity whenever the latter gets on his nerves, which -- since they're playing husband and wife -- is assumed to be DomesticAbuse and subsequently glossed over because "it was a different time".


Added DiffLines:

* ''[[WebVideo/DreamSMP Tales from the SMP]]'': PlayedForLaughs in the episode "The Village That Went Mad". Bad hits Quackity whenever the latter gets on his nerves, which -- since they're playing husband and wife -- is assumed to be DomesticAbuse and subsequently glossed over because "it was a different time".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''WebAnimation/HazbinHotel'' fan comic ''Webcomic/RadioPride'', Alastor tries to keep his asexuality under wraps in part because it was considered "sexual dysfunction" when he was alive.

to:

* In the ''WebAnimation/HazbinHotel'' ''WesternAnimation/HazbinHotel'' fan comic ''Webcomic/RadioPride'', Alastor tries to keep his asexuality under wraps in part because it was considered "sexual dysfunction" when he was alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/8835751/2/In-Strange-Waters In Strange Waters]]'', a ''Anime/GirlsUndPanzer'', fic, it's revealed that unlike in canon, in which middle and high schoolers study on schoolships to foster a sense of independence, [[CanadaEh the Canadian government]] found that too expensive, and [[OriginalCharacter Vimy Ridge Academy]] is thus on land, albeit in the middle of nowhere.

to:

* In ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/8835751/2/In-Strange-Waters In Strange Waters]]'', a ''Anime/GirlsUndPanzer'', fic, it's revealed that unlike in canon, in which middle and high schoolers study on schoolships to foster a sense of independence, [[CanadaEh the Canadian government]] government found that too expensive, and [[OriginalCharacter Vimy Ridge Academy]] is thus on land, albeit in the middle of nowhere.

Added: 1021

Changed: 31

Removed: 1021

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WesternAnimation/BarbieInThePinkShoes'', this is seen with Albrecht and Hilarion attempting to marry Kristyn/Giselle. When told she's 17, they say that just because she's a little ''old'' doesn't mean they can't marry.



* ''Radio/OldHarrysGame'' plays with this sometimes, especially with historically "good" or "heroic" characters, almost all of whom are in hell for one reason or another. For example, Thomas Jefferson in his first appearance relates a funny anecdote about writing the Declaration of Independence, halfway through the line "We hold these truths to be self evident, that all men are created equal" his ink ran out, and he sent his slave to get more, seeing no contradiction in this. It's also implied that Jack the Ripper was Queen Victoria's nephew, and she ordered the Prime Minister to let him rampage freely, and shielded him from justice, only concerned with the shame the scandal would bring on the Royal Family, not the deaths of her subjects. It's all completely PlayedForLaughs, of course.



* ''Radio/OldHarrysGame'' plays with this sometimes, especially with historically "good" or "heroic" characters, almost all of whom are in hell for one reason or another. For example, Thomas Jefferson in his first appearance relates a funny anecdote about writing the Declaration of Independence, halfway through the line "We hold these truths to be self evident, that all men are created equal" his ink ran out, and he sent his slave to get more, seeing no contradiction in this. It's also implied that Jack the Ripper was Queen Victoria's nephew, and she ordered the Prime Minister to let him rampage freely, and shielded him from justice, only concerned with the shame the scandal would bring on the Royal Family, not the deaths of her subjects. It's all completely PlayedForLaughs, of course.



* ''Theatre/{{Heathers}}'' takes place in 1989, so obviously there's gonna be at least some of this, but the number "Dead Gay Son" qualifies as a mix of this and an in-universe case of FairForItsDay; after JD (with Veronica's help) murders {{Jerk Jock}}s Kurt Kelley and Ram Sweeney, he makes their deaths look like a suicide pact that paints them as star-crossed gay lovers, when in reality, they were homophobic perverted dudebros who JD murdered because they spread a rumor about having a threesome with his girlfriend [[DisproportionateRetribution as revenge for not letting them date-rape her]]. Because of this, Kurt and Ram's formerly quite vehemently homophobic fathers decide to stand up for gay rights in their honor, which is fine and all...but the song they sing about it posthumously {{flanderiz|ation}}es Kurt and Ram into CampGay stereotypes -- stating that they "weren't dirty, they just had flair", making references to ribbons, rhinestones, pearly necklaces and purses, deciding that Kurt and Ram must've been fans of the Village People and Judy Garland in life and just generally painting them as having extremely feminine qualities that they clearly didn't actually have when they were alive. Possibly justified, as the suicide note JD faked for Kurt and Ram painted them as having hid their "gay forbidden love" from a disapproving world, though the fact that the first assumptions their fathers make are "rhinestones, disco, pearly necklaces and Judy Garland" is still pretty telling.

to:

* ''Theatre/{{Heathers}}'' takes place in 1989, so obviously there's gonna be at least some of this, but the number "Dead Gay Son" qualifies as a mix of this and an in-universe case of FairForItsDay; after JD (with Veronica's help) murders {{Jerk Jock}}s Kurt Kelley and Ram Sweeney, he makes their deaths look like a suicide pact that paints them as star-crossed gay lovers, when in reality, they were homophobic perverted dudebros who JD murdered because they spread a rumor about having a threesome with his girlfriend [[DisproportionateRetribution as revenge for not letting them date-rape her]]. Because of this, Kurt and Ram's formerly quite vehemently homophobic fathers decide to stand up for gay rights in their honor, which is fine and all...but the song they sing about it posthumously {{flanderiz|ation}}es Kurt and Ram into CampGay stereotypes -- stating that they "weren't dirty, they just had flair", making references to ribbons, rhinestones, pearly necklaces and purses, deciding that Kurt and Ram must've been fans of the Village People Music/VillagePeople and Judy Garland Creator/JudyGarland in life and just generally painting them as having extremely feminine qualities that they clearly didn't actually have when they were alive. Possibly justified, as the suicide note JD faked for Kurt and Ram painted them as having hid their "gay forbidden love" from a disapproving world, though the fact that the first assumptions their fathers make about them are "rhinestones, disco, pearly necklaces and Judy Garland" is still pretty telling.



* ''WebVideo/AskLovecraft'': Much of the humor revolves around Lovecraft's outdated mores and sensibilities. For example, he passes out the first time he finds out [[UsefulNotes/BarackObama a black man was elected President of the United States,]] and he apparently doesn't believe [[CrossesTheLineTwice Italians have souls]].

to:

* ''WebVideo/AskLovecraft'': Much of the humor revolves around Lovecraft's outdated mores and sensibilities. For example, he passes out the first time he finds out [[UsefulNotes/BarackObama a black man man]] was elected President of the United States,]] States, and he apparently doesn't believe [[CrossesTheLineTwice Italians have souls]].



* In ''WesternAnimation/BarbieInThePinkShoes'', this is seen with Albrecht and Hilarion attempting to marry Kristyn/Giselle. When told she's 17, they say that just because she's a little ''old'' doesn't mean they can't marry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/DanganronpaParadiseLost'': The very first motive revolves entirely around the real life Japan's draconian anti-drug laws, where possession can lead to hefty prison sentences and mere accusations can result in ruined careers. More specifically, [[KillerTeddyBear Monokuma]] threatens the new cast of students with, unless somebody kills within 72 hours, exposing at least one of them as a drug dealer and addict.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The back matter in ''Comicbook/XMenNoir'' is a StylisticSuck pulp adventure story written by this universe's counterpart of Bolivar Trask, about a "superman" fighting mutants. Perhaps surprisingly, given both the racism often seen in such stories in real life and 616-Trask's FantasticRacism, the story is very clear that Nimrod and the Sentinels are superior due to being mixed race. It then explains ''exactly'' what traits they inhereted from each race, so it ''still'' comes across as pretty racist by modern standards.

to:

* The back matter in ''Comicbook/XMenNoir'' is a StylisticSuck pulp adventure story written by this universe's counterpart of Bolivar Trask, about a "superman" fighting mutants. Perhaps surprisingly, given both the racism often seen in such stories in real life and 616-Trask's FantasticRacism, the story is very clear that Nimrod and the Sentinels are superior due to being mixed race. It then explains ''exactly'' what traits they inhereted inherited from each race, so it ''still'' comes across as pretty racist by modern standards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The back matter in ''Comicbook/XMenNoir'' is a StylisticSuck pulp adventure story written by this universe's counterpart of Bolivar Trask, about a "superman" fighting mutants. Perhaps surprisingly, given both the racism often seen in such stories in real life and 616-Trask's FantasticRacism, the story is very clear that Nimrod and the Sentinels are superior due to being mixed race. It then explains ''exactly'' what traits they inhereted from each race, so it ''still'' comes across as pretty racist by modern standards.

Added: 469

Removed: 441

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It's been decided that Manhua and Manhwa examples shall be placed into their own folders. Moving example to the correct section.


* In ''Manhua/GoddessCreationSystem'', modern girl Xiaxi finds herself in ancient China as a result of Plot and finds her values clashing with the horribly entitled nobility she has to serve. Case in point, she's given a 'trial run' to see how things working before starting her mission for real and is almost immediately executed and used as fertilizer because someone used her as material for a rude joke. She herself hadn't done anything.


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Manhua]]
* In ''Manhua/GoddessCreationSystem'', modern girl Xiaxi finds herself in ancient China as a result of Plot and finds her values clashing with the horribly entitled nobility she has to serve. Case in point, she's given a 'trial run' to see how things working before starting her mission for real and is almost immediately executed and used as fertilizer because someone used her as material for a rude joke. She herself hadn't done anything.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*''Manga/HonooNoAlpenRose'': The Count's pedophilic crush on Jeudi. None of his men are surprised at it, and the characters object to it because Jeudi loves Lundi, and not because the Count is an adult while Jeudi is a child. To ham it in, he dances a waltz with her at the ball and no one finds it creepy, not even his own wife, who speaks of Jeudi like a romantic prospect to him.


Added DiffLines:

*''Manga/{{Lady}}'': Arthur and Edward refer to Lynn as "that Chinese girl". This isn't intentional racism, more like them simply not having met a Japanese person before.
** Also, [[spoiler: Duke Warbawn is pressures George to marry Madeleine to have a [[HeirClubforMen "proper heir"]] since full-English Sarah is a girl as well as sickly and half-English Lynn is the kid of "an unknown Eastern woman".]] Sexism ''and'' racism, [[SarcasmMode yay]]!

Added: 214

Removed: 171

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WebAnimation/IfDisneyCartoonsWereHistoricallyAccurate'': The entire point of the song: contrasting a Disney fantasy setting with all the unsightly details about the Middle Ages that Disney chooses to leave out.



* ''Website/{{Cracked}}'': [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwA1VeYpvaM "If Disney Cartoons Were Historically Accurate"]]. You won't see your princess the same way again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* The Entity from ''Fanfic/ThePowerOfFriendshipAndThisGunIFound'' is an ageless entity over three thousand years old, and who is strongly implied to be [[Myth/EgyptianMythology Anubis]]. He grows extremely offended when the crime procedural that Solomon is watching features a coroner more concerned with discovering the source of the victim's death than treating the body with respect, and doesn't understand modern germ theory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/21853549 Perception]]'' discusses Bajoran expectations regarding gender and sexual preferences: femininity is all about stoicism and self-confidence while masculinity is expressed through intelligence and enthusiasm. So to Kira Nerys, Worf's gayer than oil wrestling, the Vulcans' hat is being flamingly camp, and Julian Bashir is so much of a manly man he verges on TestosteronePoisoning. Jadzia is left crying from laughter after the explication.

to:

* ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/21853549 Perception]]'' discusses Bajoran expectations regarding gender and sexual preferences: femininity is all about stoicism and self-confidence while masculinity is expressed through intelligence and enthusiasm. So to Kira Nerys, Worf's gayer than oil wrestling, the Vulcans' hat is being flamingly camp, and Julian Bashir is so much of a manly man he verges on TestosteronePoisoning. Jadzia is left crying from laughter after the explication.explanation.

Changed: 33

Removed: 1768

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetizing example(s), Misplaced, moving to the correct tab


* ''ARG/WelcomeHomeClownIllustrations'': WordOfGod has this [[InvokedTrope trope invoked]] as Eddie and Frank are canonically in a romantic relationship, but due to the show airing in the late 60s-early 70s, when LGBT+ people weren't as accepted, The Playfellow Workshop could never show their relationship. The company had to resort to [[HideYourGays subtly hinting at it]] instead.

to:

* ''ARG/WelcomeHomeClownIllustrations'': WordOfGod WordOfGay has this [[InvokedTrope trope invoked]] as Eddie and Frank are canonically in a romantic relationship, but due to the show airing in the late 60s-early 70s, when LGBT+ people weren't as readily accepted, The Playfellow Workshop could never show their relationship. The company had to resort to [[HideYourGays subtly hinting at it]] instead.



* ''LetsPlay/{{Bravemule}}'': uses this in its portrayal of the dwarf culture of ''VideoGame/DwarfFortress''. The dwarves are violently isolationist, vicious, and militaristic, perceiving anything they are not familiar with as a threat and slaughtering it accordingly. This leads to the fort's downfall when Behem's deadfall trap in the trade depot causes the humans to go to war with Bravemule, and Traeme fully expects to be remembered as a hero for [[spoiler:ordering Exi to [[GodzillaThreshold breach the Underworld]] when the humans get the upper hand]]. [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking They also consider]] [[AlienGeometries octagons to be unholy]].

to:

* ''LetsPlay/{{Bravemule}}'': uses this This trope is used in its portrayal of the dwarf culture of ''VideoGame/DwarfFortress''. The dwarves are violently isolationist, vicious, and militaristic, perceiving anything they are not familiar with as a threat and slaughtering it accordingly. This leads to the fort's downfall when Behem's deadfall trap in the trade depot causes the humans to go to war with Bravemule, and Traeme fully expects to be remembered as a hero for [[spoiler:ordering Exi to [[GodzillaThreshold breach the Underworld]] when the humans get the upper hand]]. [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking They also consider]] [[AlienGeometries octagons to be unholy]].



[[folder:Literature]]
* ''Literature/ChaosFighters'': An example occurs with the various continents having different administration systems, and in particular Lefrad. [[spoiler:The Yedrei-Phlaq confrontation happened at an unspecified time prior to the start of the ''entire main series'']], which is partly [[spoiler:due to their leader trying to force their administration systems on the others (Yedrei uses monarchy while Phlaq uses democracy.]] As a result, in ''Chaos Fighters-Route of Peaks'', [[spoiler:the government of Tziac sent only ''one'' person to join the main characters' party to eliminate the mountain bandits, fearing of bringing significant casualties to the soldiers, which happened during the confrontation.]] Even other countries merely used long range weaponry to eliminate them, [[spoiler:despite sending slightly more (read: ''two'') people to aid the main characters' party]]. This also leads to another dissonance where in ''Chaos Fighters-Route of Land'', [[spoiler:''almost every country'' in Yedrei continent gave military support of various degree to help the Estau rebel pact, which is a military force to capture Lestreb from the demons' reign.]]
* ''Literature/LandGames'': The player's society is extremely imperialistic, regularly invading and conquering foreign worlds. Jayle is the only one who has a problem with this.
* ''Literature/ThreeWorldsCollide'': This is done with future social mores aren't at all like present ones, much like present ones would be almost incomprehensible to those of several hundred years in the past. A particular example is future humans' views on (legalized) rape, which are so divorced from modern mores that the latter are incomprehensible to the protagonists even after being explained.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* ''WebAnimation/CampCamp'': The Flower Scouts abide by very strict gender roles, and think girls should only be concerned with looks and boys, while guys should be rugged and manly. This goes so far, that they [[spoiler: [[KickTheDog ran off]] the much less traditional [[TomBoy Nikki]] for not conforming to their views]], leading to Neil calling them "ignorant, fucking cunts" for this attitude.

to:

* ''WebAnimation/CampCamp'': The Flower Scouts abide by very strict gender roles, and as such think that girls should only be concerned with looks and boys, boys while guys should be rugged and manly. This goes so far, that they [[spoiler: [[KickTheDog ran off]] the much less traditional [[TomBoy [[{{Tomboy}} Nikki]] for not conforming to their views]], leading to Neil calling them "ignorant, fucking cunts" for this attitude.



* ''WebAnimation/StrongBadEmail'': [[ParodiedTrope Parodied]] in the parenting where Strong Bad and the Cheat [[EggSitting take their "baby" (a zip-lok of banana pudding)]] to the King of Town's restaurant [=SteaKastle=] which hasn't been updated since the 70's featuring a high chair that's a bear trap and cigars on the kids menu. Strong Bad opts to go to a modern family day out, a vape shop that also sells hot fries.

to:

* ''WebAnimation/StrongBadEmail'': [[ParodiedTrope Parodied]] in the parenting where when Strong Bad and the Cheat decide to [[EggSitting take their "baby" (a zip-lok of banana pudding)]] to the King of Town's restaurant [=SteaKastle=] which hasn't been updated since the 70's featuring a high chair that's a bear trap and cigars on the kids menu. Strong Bad opts to go to a modern family day out, a vape shop that also sells hot fries.



[[folder:Web Original]]

to:

[[folder:Web Original]][[folder:Websites]]

Added: 3469

Changed: 2095

Removed: 2547

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetizing example(s)


[[folder:Literature]]
* ''Literature/ChaosFighters'': An example occurs with the various continents having different administration systems, and in particular Lefrad. [[spoiler:The Yedrei-Phlaq confrontation happened at an unspecified time prior to the start of the ''entire main series'']], which is partly [[spoiler:due to their leader trying to force their administration systems on the others (Yedrei uses monarchy while Phlaq uses democracy.]] As a result, in ''Chaos Fighters-Route of Peaks'', [[spoiler:the government of Tziac sent only ''one'' person to join the main characters' party to eliminate the mountain bandits, fearing of bringing significant casualties to the soldiers, which happened during the confrontation.]] Even other countries merely used long range weaponry to eliminate them, [[spoiler:despite sending slightly more (read: ''two'') people to aid the main characters' party]]. This also leads to another dissonance where in ''Chaos Fighters-Route of Land'', [[spoiler:''almost every country'' in Yedrei continent gave military support of various degree to help the Estau rebel pact, which is a military force to capture Lestreb from the demons' reign.]]
* ''Literature/LandGames'': The player's society is extremely imperialistic, regularly invading and conquering foreign worlds. Jayle is the only one who has a problem with this.
* ''Literature/ThreeWorldsCollide'': This is done with future social mores aren't at all like present ones, much like present ones would be almost incomprehensible to those of several hundred years in the past. A particular example is future humans' views on (legalized) rape, which are so divorced from modern mores that the latter are incomprehensible to the protagonists even after being explained.
[[/folder]]



* In ''WebAnimation/CampCamp'' we have the Flower Scouts, who abide by very strict gender roles; they think girls should only be concerned with looks and boys, while guys should be rugged and manly. This goes so far, that they [[spoiler: [[KickTheDog ran off]] the much less traditional [[TomBoy Nikki]] for not conforming to their views]], leading to Neil calling them "ignorant, fucking cunts" for this attitude.
* ''WebAnimation/DorisAndMaryAnneAreBreakingOutOfPrison'', set in 1922, has Doris, a white woman, be imprisoned for just nine months for [[spoiler:running over a baby]], while Mary-Anne, a black woman, be sentenced for fifty years for [[spoiler:slamming a door]].
* [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwA1VeYpvaM "If Disney Cartoons Were Historically Accurate"]] by ''Website/{{Cracked}}''. You won't see your princess the same way again.

to:

* In ''WebAnimation/CampCamp'' we have the ''WebAnimation/CampCamp'': The Flower Scouts, who Scouts abide by very strict gender roles; they roles, and think girls should only be concerned with looks and boys, while guys should be rugged and manly. This goes so far, that they [[spoiler: [[KickTheDog ran off]] the much less traditional [[TomBoy Nikki]] for not conforming to their views]], leading to Neil calling them "ignorant, fucking cunts" for this attitude.
* ''WebAnimation/DorisAndMaryAnneAreBreakingOutOfPrison'', ''WebAnimation/DorisAndMaryAnneAreBreakingOutOfPrison'': Due to being set in 1922, has Doris, a white woman, be is imprisoned for just nine months for [[spoiler:running over a baby]], while Mary-Anne, a black woman, be is sentenced for fifty years for [[spoiler:slamming a door]].
* [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwA1VeYpvaM "If Disney Cartoons Were Historically Accurate"]] by ''Website/{{Cracked}}''. You won't see your princess the same way again.
door]].



* Parodied in the ''WebAnimation/StrongBadEmail'' parenting where Strong Bad and the Cheat [[EggSitting take their "baby" (a zip-lok of banana pudding)]] to the King of Town's restaurant [=SteaKastle=] which hasn't been updated since the 70's featuring a high chair that's a bear trap and cigars on the kids menu. Strong Bad opts to go to a modern family day out, a vape shop that also sells hot fries.

to:

* Parodied ''WebAnimation/StrongBadEmail'': [[ParodiedTrope Parodied]] in the ''WebAnimation/StrongBadEmail'' parenting where Strong Bad and the Cheat [[EggSitting take their "baby" (a zip-lok of banana pudding)]] to the King of Town's restaurant [=SteaKastle=] which hasn't been updated since the 70's featuring a high chair that's a bear trap and cigars on the kids menu. Strong Bad opts to go to a modern family day out, a vape shop that also sells hot fries.



* The premise of ''WebAnimation/UnbiasedHistory'' can be summed up as this trope, PlayedForLaughs. The heroes are the {{Ancient Rom|e}}ans, with every bloody conquest of other nations, every discrimination based on gender, class, or religion, and every [[TheCaligula insane emperor]] is painted as glorious and righteous - no matter [[RefugeInAudacity how batshit]] it can be.

to:

* ''WebAnimation/UnbiasedHistory'': The premise of ''WebAnimation/UnbiasedHistory'' can be summed up as this trope, PlayedForLaughs. The heroes are the {{Ancient Rom|e}}ans, with every bloody conquest of other nations, every discrimination based on gender, class, or religion, and every [[TheCaligula insane emperor]] is painted as glorious and righteous - no matter [[RefugeInAudacity how batshit]] it can be.



* ''Webcomic/ElGoonishShive'': Occurs with Magus, who is from a parallel universe. In that universe, magic that permanently changes a person's sex is readily available, genuinely making one's sex a ''choice'' rather than something one is born with, so their views on sexism and gender roles are... different. It's noted that there is no stigma against transgender individuals or non-heterosexual romances in his world due to this magic being available. However, they fully embrace the idea that certain occupations are more suited for one sex over the other, and Magus looks down on a friend of his because she chose to pursue a career as a warrior while remaining female, saying that it's utterly absurd to make such a choice. Magus himself was born female, but changed his sex (and gender identity) upon choosing the path of a warrior, because "men make better fighters". This is rather sharply at odds with the modern Western ideal of no discrimination between the sexes regarding occupation and, despite them having no stigma against transgenderism as such, also at odds with the principle that your real gender is the one that you feel you are inside, since they think your gender should be the one that fits your job. Notably, Magus is convinced that Ellen shouldn't be a fighter and a woman, but thinks that means she shouldn't be a woman, rather than that she shouldn't be a fighter.



* ''Webcomic/ElGoonishShive'': Occurs with Magus, who is from a parallel universe. In that universe, magic that permanently changes a person's sex is readily available, genuinely making one's sex a ''choice'' rather than something one is born with, so their views on sexism and gender roles are... different. It's noted that there is no stigma against transgender individuals or non-heterosexual romances in his world due to this magic being available. However, they fully embrace the idea that certain occupations are more suited for one sex over the other, and Magus looks down on a friend of his because she chose to pursue a career as a warrior while remaining female, saying that it's utterly absurd to make such a choice. Magus himself was born female, but changed his sex (and gender identity) upon choosing the path of a warrior, because "men make better fighters". This is rather sharply at odds with the modern Western ideal of no discrimination between the sexes regarding occupation and, despite them having no stigma against transgenderism as such, also at odds with the principle that your real gender is the one that you feel you are inside, since they think your gender should be the one that fits your job. Notably, Magus is convinced that Ellen shouldn't be a fighter and a woman, but thinks that means she shouldn't be a woman, rather than that she shouldn't be a fighter.



* An example occurs in ''Literature/ChaosFighters'', particularly in Lefrad, which consists of continents has different administration systems. [[spoiler:Yedrei-Phlaq confrontation happened an unspecified time prior to the start of the ''entire main series'']], which is partly [[spoiler:due to their leader trying to force their administration systems to others (Yedrei uses monarchy while Phlaq uses democracy.]] As the result, in ''Chaos Fighters-Route of Peaks'', [[spoiler:the government of Tziac sent only ''one'' person to join the main characters' party to eliminate the mountain bandits, fearing of bringing significant casualties to the soldiers, which happened during the confrontation.]] Even other countries merely used long range weaponry to eliminate them, [[spoiler:despite sending slightly more (read: ''two'') people to aid the main characters' party]]. This also leads to another dissonance where in ''Chaos Fighters-Route of Land'', [[spoiler:''almost every country'' in Yedrei continent gave military support of various degree to help the Estau rebel pact, which is a military force to capture Lestreb from the demons' reign.]]
* ''Literature/LandGames'': The player's society is extremely imperialistic, regularly invading and conquering foreign worlds. Jayle is the only one who has a problem with this.
* ''WebVideo/Needlem0use'': This series pulls no punches in showcasing the rampant homophobia present in 1960's America, and [[spoiler:Sarah expresses concern about her and her girlfriend Lily's safety to the point where she asks Luther to watch over them]].

to:

* An example occurs in ''Literature/ChaosFighters'', particularly in Lefrad, which consists of continents has different administration systems. [[spoiler:Yedrei-Phlaq confrontation happened an unspecified time prior to ''Website/CollegeHumor'': [[https://youtu.be/HQ7mJFNkLAU In this]] sketch, the start guys want to pull pranks like in the classic 80’s movies. One of the ''entire main series'']], which is partly [[spoiler:due guys tries pointing out a lot of those pranks were basically assault battery and sexual assault and borderline rapes so they wouldn’t be a good idea to their leader trying to force their administration systems to others (Yedrei uses monarchy while Phlaq uses democracy.]] As pull in the result, in ''Chaos Fighters-Route of Peaks'', [[spoiler:the government of Tziac sent only ''one'' person to join modern age.
* ''Website/{{Cracked}}'': [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwA1VeYpvaM "If Disney Cartoons Were Historically Accurate"]]. You won't see your princess
the main characters' party to eliminate the mountain bandits, fearing of bringing significant casualties to the soldiers, which happened during the confrontation.]] Even other countries merely used long range weaponry to eliminate them, [[spoiler:despite sending slightly more (read: ''two'') people to aid the main characters' party]]. This also leads to another dissonance where in ''Chaos Fighters-Route of Land'', [[spoiler:''almost every country'' in Yedrei continent gave military support of various degree to help the Estau rebel pact, which is a military force to capture Lestreb from the demons' reign.]]
* ''Literature/LandGames'': The player's society is extremely imperialistic, regularly invading and conquering foreign worlds. Jayle is the only one who has a problem with this.
* ''WebVideo/Needlem0use'': This series pulls no punches in showcasing the rampant homophobia present in 1960's America, and [[spoiler:Sarah expresses concern about her and her girlfriend Lily's safety to the point where she asks Luther to watch over them]].
same way again.



* [[https://youtu.be/HQ7mJFNkLAU In this]] ''Website/CollegeHumor'' sketch, the guys want to pull pranks like in the classic 80’s movies. One of the guys tries pointing out a lot of those pranks were basically assault battery and sexual assault and borderline rapes so they wouldn’t be a good idea to pull in the modern age.
* This is done in ''Literature/ThreeWorldsCollide'' where future social mores aren't at all like present ones, much like present ones would be almost incomprehensible those of several hundred years in the past. A particular example is future humans' views on (legalized) rape, which are so divorced from modern mores that the latter are incomprehensible to the protagonists even after being explained.



* ''WebVideo/DreamSMP'': PlayedForLaughs in the "Tales from the SMP" episode "The Village That Went Mad". Bad hits Quackity whenever the latter gets on his nerves, which -- since they're playing husband and wife -- is assumed to be DomesticAbuse and subsequently glossed over because "it was a different time".



* ''WebVideo/DreamSMP'': PlayedForLaughs in the "Tales from the SMP" episode "The Village That Went Mad". Bad hits Quackity whenever the latter gets on his nerves, which -- since they're playing husband and wife -- is assumed to be DomesticAbuse and subsequently glossed over because "it was a different time".

to:

* ''WebVideo/DreamSMP'': PlayedForLaughs ''WebVideo/Needlem0use'': This series pulls no punches in showcasing the "Tales from rampant homophobia present in 1960's America, and [[spoiler:Sarah expresses concern about her and her girlfriend Lily's safety to the SMP" episode "The Village That Went Mad". Bad hits Quackity whenever the latter gets on his nerves, which -- since they're playing husband and wife -- is assumed point where she asks Luther to be DomesticAbuse and subsequently glossed watch over because "it was a different time".them]].

Added: 2467

Changed: 471

Removed: 2119

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetizing example(s)


[[folder:ARG]]
* ''ARG/WelcomeHomeClownIllustrations'': WordOfGod has this [[InvokedTrope trope invoked]] as Eddie and Frank are canonically in a romantic relationship, but due to the show airing in the late 60s-early 70s, when LGBT+ people weren't as accepted, The Playfellow Workshop could never show their relationship. The company had to resort to [[HideYourGays subtly hinting at it]] instead.
[[/folder]]



* ''Film/KungFury'': The film is set in the '80s and as such meant to [[InvokedTrope invoke]] feeling like a movie from that, complete with a homophobic comment early on, with the police chief saying the mayor is up his ass "like a fag on Viagra."[[note]]Which is an AnachronismStew itself, as Viagra was not manufactured until the '90s.[[/note]]



* ''Film/SpiderManTrilogy'': While an AvertedTrope in the films themselves, aside from some mild homophobia and the characters having no sympathy for those with mental disorders in the first film. [[Creator/SamRaimi Raimi]]posting is a popular meme among the films involving exaggerating how much Values Dissonance there is in his films to the point where the films would've been considered beyond unacceptable even back in 2002.



[[folder:Let's Play]]
* ''LetsPlay/{{Bravemule}}'': uses this in its portrayal of the dwarf culture of ''VideoGame/DwarfFortress''. The dwarves are violently isolationist, vicious, and militaristic, perceiving anything they are not familiar with as a threat and slaughtering it accordingly. This leads to the fort's downfall when Behem's deadfall trap in the trade depot causes the humans to go to war with Bravemule, and Traeme fully expects to be remembered as a hero for [[spoiler:ordering Exi to [[GodzillaThreshold breach the Underworld]] when the humans get the upper hand]]. [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking They also consider]] [[AlienGeometries octagons to be unholy]].
-->[[{{Understatement}} But they do not know us.]]
[[/folder]]



[[folder:Scripts]]
* ''Script/SeinfeldTheTwinTowers'': Jerry's uncle Leo says his cousin Jeffrey is a "hero" for assaulting a halal food vendor who didn't have a license, a nod to the spike in Islamophobic attacks in the days and weeks after 9/11.
[[/folder]]



* ''WesternAnimation/HazbinHotel'':
** Anchorwoman Katie Killjoy is openly homophobic. She died in 1992, some time before LGBT people were widely accepted in mainstream society.
** Niffty died in the 1950s, and still holds to the traditionalist ideas about gender roles she had when she was alive.



* Script/SeinfeldTheTwinTowers: Jerry's uncle Leo says his cousin Jeffrey is a "hero" for assaulting a halal food vendor who didn't have a license, a nod to the spike in Islamophobic attacks in the days and weeks after 9/11.



* ''ARG/WelcomeHomeClownIllustrations'': WordOfGod [[invoked]] is that Eddie and Frank are canonically in a romantic relationship, but due to the show airing in the late 60s-early 70s, when LGBT+ people weren't as accepted, The Playfellow Workshop could never show their relationship. The company had to resort to [[HideYourGays subtly hinting at it]] instead.
* [[Creator/SamRaimi Raimi]]posting is a meme involving exaggerating how much Values Dissonance there is in his ''Film/SpiderManTrilogy'' to the point where the films would've been considered beyond unacceptable even back in 2002.



* Much of the humor of ''WebVideo/AskLovecraft'' revolves around Lovecraft's outdated mores and sensibilities. For example, he passes out the first time he finds out [[UsefulNotes/BarackObama a black man was elected President of the United States,]] and he apparently doesn't believe [[CrossesTheLineTwice Italians have souls]].
* ''LetsPlay/{{Bravemule}}'' uses this in its portrayal of the dwarf culture of ''VideoGame/DwarfFortress''. The dwarves are violently isolationist, vicious, and militaristic, perceiving anything they are not familiar with as a threat and slaughtering it accordingly. This leads to the fort's downfall when Behem's deadfall trap in the trade depot causes the humans to go to war with Bravemule, and Traeme fully expects to be remembered as a hero for [[spoiler:ordering Exi to [[GodzillaThreshold breach the Underworld]] when the humans get the upper hand]]. [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking They also consider]] [[AlienGeometries octagons to be unholy]].
-->[[{{Understatement}} But they do not know us.]]

to:

* ''WebVideo/AskLovecraft'': Much of the humor of ''WebVideo/AskLovecraft'' revolves around Lovecraft's outdated mores and sensibilities. For example, he passes out the first time he finds out [[UsefulNotes/BarackObama a black man was elected President of the United States,]] and he apparently doesn't believe [[CrossesTheLineTwice Italians have souls]].
* ''LetsPlay/{{Bravemule}}'' uses this in its portrayal of the dwarf culture of ''VideoGame/DwarfFortress''. The dwarves are violently isolationist, vicious, and militaristic, perceiving anything they are not familiar with as a threat and slaughtering it accordingly. This leads to the fort's downfall when Behem's deadfall trap in the trade depot causes the humans to go to war with Bravemule, and Traeme fully expects to be remembered as a hero for [[spoiler:ordering Exi to [[GodzillaThreshold breach the Underworld]] when the humans get the upper hand]]. [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking They also consider]] [[AlienGeometries octagons to be unholy]].
-->[[{{Understatement}} But they do not know us.]]
souls]].



* ''Film/KungFury'' is set in the '80s and meant to invoke feeling like a movie from that, complete with a homophobic comment. Early on, the police chief says the mayor is up his ass "like a fag on Viagra."[[note]]Which is an AnachronismStew itself, as Viagra was not manufactured until the '90s.[[/note]]
* PlayedForLaughs in the ''[[WebVideo/DreamSMP Tales from the SMP]]'' episode "The Village That Went Mad". Bad hits Quackity whenever the latter gets on his nerves, which -- since they're playing husband and wife -- is assumed to be DomesticAbuse and subsequently glossed over because "it was a different time".

to:

* ''Film/KungFury'' is set in the '80s and meant to invoke feeling like a movie from that, complete with a homophobic comment. Early on, the police chief says the mayor is up his ass "like a fag on Viagra."[[note]]Which is an AnachronismStew itself, as Viagra was not manufactured until the '90s.[[/note]]
*
''WebVideo/DreamSMP'': PlayedForLaughs in the ''[[WebVideo/DreamSMP Tales "Tales from the SMP]]'' SMP" episode "The Village That Went Mad". Bad hits Quackity whenever the latter gets on his nerves, which -- since they're playing husband and wife -- is assumed to be DomesticAbuse and subsequently glossed over because "it was a different time".


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/HazbinHotel'':
** Anchorwoman Katie Killjoy is openly homophobic. She died in 1992, some time before LGBT people were widely accepted in mainstream society.
** Niffty died in the 1950s, and still holds to the traditionalist ideas about gender roles she had when she was alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/TheSoulmateTimeline'':
** One that is lampshaded despite all involved being from the same culture. [[Anime/PuellaMagiMadokaMagica Kyoko]] complains to Mami at one point that while she and the police who do look into Nagisa's homelife agree it is bad, it would only count as abusive in countries other than Japan. Being in Japan, they can't simply have Nagisa's mother be arrested like what happened with Yuma's mother, whose abuse passed the threshold that Japan considers child abuse. However [[BotheringByTheBook because of how Nagisa's mother really doesn't care for her that much, nothing is stopping them from letting Nagisa just stay at Mami's place and avoid her, handling the issue within the limits of their culture's values]].
** The premise of the story itself creates a less mundane version of this, being a SoulmateAUFic focusing mostly on a character whose original timeline was ''not'' this, Homura finds the way the world acts and behaves to often be strange and bizarre, and other characters find her confusion to things to be equally bizarre. Homura is the only character who even considers it a question if Soulmates are destined to fall in love, a thought that baffles and horrifies her Soulmates that she'd question if they would ever love her and seek to reassure her otherwise. Homura will also treat the entire concept as something unusual she'll use as an example of lampshading ArbitrarySkepticism akin to aliens and ghosts and being a Magical Girl, while Sayaka sees the entire thing as mundane and expected as the sky being blue and their teacher failing to keep a boyfriend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Script/SeinfeldTheTwinTowers: Jerry's uncle Leo says his cousin Jeffrey is a "hero" for assaulting a halal food vendor who didn't have a license, a nod to the spike in Islamophobic attacks in the days and weeks after 9/11.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheKingsSpeech'': The first speech therapist promotes cigarettes to calm the nerves and soothe the throat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The list of Jack Sparrow's most egregious crimes includes "Impersonating a cleric of the Church of England". Today, most peope fail to understand what the big deal is, but at the time, the CoE was responsible for a number of civic functions, including distributing poor relief and maintaining birth and death records. This, in turn, meant that impersonating a cleric was considered a form of what we would today call conspiracy to commit fraud and a variety of fraud-adjacent crimes.

to:

** The list of Jack Sparrow's most egregious crimes includes "Impersonating a cleric of the Church of England". Today, most peope fail to understand what the big deal is, but at the time, the CoE Church of England was responsible for a number of civic functions, including distributing poor relief and maintaining birth and death records. This, in turn, meant that impersonating a cleric was considered a form of what we would today call conspiracy to commit fraud and a variety of fraud-adjacent crimes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A relatively minor example of this comes up in ''Fanfic/TheNakedJedi'' as Sarza Zarazell- the only living member of the Nue Jedi, a group who seek to increase their bond with life and the Force through sexual pleasure by forsaking clothing- begins instructing her first Padwan, the Yuuzhan Vong Meelan Lah, in the ways of the Nue Jedi. While the Yuuzhan Vong no longer seek to deliberately inflict pain on themselves as part of their religion, Meelan Lah is unused to the idea of sex for pleasure rather than as a purely reproductive act, even if she is willing to learn in her role as Sarza's apprentice.

Added: 510

Changed: 1026

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Usagi himself is hardly uncontroversial, in that he has a deep and abiding loathing for non-Japanese people. Though, given that his contacts with foreigneres generally involve some combination of guns, tuberculosis and general assholery, it's quite understandable.
** While Usagi is generally an even-tempered and polite fellow, he does not hesitate to lay the smackdown on a disrespectful or disobedient peasant when the situation calls for it.

to:

** The series often plays up how devotion to your lord is supposed to take precedence above all else. In one notable instance, the villain has Usagi captured while Tomoe escapes. The villain plans to torture and mutilate Usagi unless Tomoe comes back for him. She does come back for him, but since she is immediately captured for it when she could have reported the entire operation back to her lord, she states multiple times that she should have left him for dead to let her lord know what the villain was doing. Usagi, for his part, doesn't seem too hurt whenever she says it (and even expected her to leave him to die initially.)
** Usagi himself is hardly uncontroversial, in that he has a deep and abiding loathing for non-Japanese people. Though, given that his contacts with foreigneres foreigners generally involve some combination of guns, tuberculosis and general assholery, it's quite understandable.
** While Usagi is generally an even-tempered and polite fellow, he does not hesitate to lay the smackdown on berate or even beat a disrespectful or disobedient peasant when the situation calls for it.it.
** Usagi is also deeply distrustful of Christians, and spends a lot of time wondering how a convicted criminal could be worthy of worship. While he doesn't hold any particular ill-will against them, he is also not shy about handing them over to the authorities when he finds them. Christianity, is, after all, a forbidden religion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Usagi himself is hardly uncontroversial, in that he has a deep and abiding loathing for non-Japanese people. Though, given that his contacts with foreigneres generally involve some combination of guns, tuberculosis and general assholery, it's quite understandable.
** While Usagi is generally an even-tempered and polite fellow, he does not hesitate to lay the smackdown on a disrespectful or disobedient peasant when the situation calls for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Parth Ferengi's Heart Place" uses a trip to Ferengenar to dive deeper into Ferengi dissonance with Federation values. Boimler is ensnared by Ferengi television programming, which includes shows about cops who are also landlords; he finds the concept of a "com-mer-cial" completely alien and can't believe that they can just openly lie to you about what a product does. Meanwhile, Mariner passes by a memorial to those lost in the Dominion War... which focuses mainly on their lost profit value.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Occurs several times in ''WesternAnimation/TheVentureBrothers'' in flashbacks and appearances of the old Team Venture: a giant in the team is called Humongoloid; Col. Gentleman refers to the Japanese Kano's "racial handicap"; and of course:

to:

* Occurs several times in ''WesternAnimation/TheVentureBrothers'' ''WesternAnimation/TheVentureBros'' in flashbacks and appearances of the old Team Venture: a giant in the team is called Humongoloid; Col. Gentleman refers to the Japanese Kano's "racial handicap"; and of course:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sometimes, [[ValuesDissonance morals don't travel well]]. Often, what is appropriate to one culture at a given time can be repugnant to the same culture at another, or vice versa. Thus, when depicting other cultures, a creator has to choose whether to portray them accurately or not. Many just use their own contemporary culture for [[CultureBlind everyone in the story]] for narrative reasons or just to make writing it easier, resulting in an inaccurate and/or anachronistic story. Some, however, [[ShownTheirWork research the culture]] and make an effort to reproduce the attitudes of the time and place accurately, even when they are wildly different to what the author knows or might consider sensible. Thus one ends up with a case of Deliberate Values Dissonance.

to:

Sometimes, [[ValuesDissonance morals don't travel well]]. Often, what is appropriate to one culture at a given time can be repugnant to the same culture at another, or vice versa. Thus, when depicting other cultures, a creator has to choose whether to portray them accurately or not. Many just use their own contemporary culture for [[CultureBlind everyone in the story]] story for narrative reasons or just to make writing it easier, resulting in an inaccurate and/or anachronistic story. Some, however, [[ShownTheirWork research the culture]] and make an effort to reproduce the attitudes of the time and place accurately, even when they are wildly different to what the author knows or might consider sensible. Thus one ends up with a case of Deliberate Values Dissonance.

Added: 718

Changed: 474

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''Series/StarTrekLowerDecks'' episode "The Inner Fight", after Mariner reveals to the Klingon Ma'ah why she's been on a self-destructive streak, she reveals that she participated in [[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine the Dominion War]]. Ma'ah is envious of this -- the Dominion sent many Klingon warriors to Sto-vo-kor and it would have been a glorious war to participate in. However, Mariner [[WarIsHell believes the entire thing was horrible]] and he shouldn't want to be part of it.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/StarTrekLowerDecks''
**
In the ''Series/StarTrekLowerDecks'' episode "The Inner Fight", after Mariner reveals to the Klingon Ma'ah why she's been on a self-destructive streak, she reveals that she participated in [[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine the Dominion War]]. Ma'ah is envious of this -- the Dominion sent many Klingon warriors to Sto-vo-kor and it would have been a glorious war to participate in. However, Mariner [[WarIsHell believes the entire thing was horrible]] and he shouldn't want to be part of it.it.
** In "Old Friends, New Planets", the hyper-capitalistic Ferengi [[spoiler:are revealed to have put a CashGate on ''a weapon of mass destruction'' to shut it off. This winds up killing Nick Locarno when he seemingly manages to disarm it, only to be KilledMidSentence.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Little Women 2019}}'' shows that women are not expected to work and their property goes automatically goes to their husbands.

to:

* ''Film/{{Little Women 2019}}'' shows that women are not being expected to work and their property goes going automatically goes to their husbands. Meg also never gets to become an actress because of the stigma towards the profession of acting. Aunt March compares acting to prostitution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Little Women 2019}}'' shows that women are not expected to work and any property goes automatically goes to their husbands.

to:

* ''Film/{{Little Women 2019}}'' shows that women are not expected to work and any their property goes automatically goes to their husbands.husbands.

Top