Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AllTakeAndNoGive

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This pays Spike back for his earlier relationship with Harmony, whose final speech to him is roughly "[[LoveMartyr I thought if I gave and gave and gave you'd come around.]] Maybe be a little nicer, instead of treating me like your dog. But then I realized you're the dog."

to:

** This pays Spike back may be LaserGuidedKarma for his Spike's earlier relationship with Harmony, whose final speech to him is roughly "[[LoveMartyr I thought if I gave and gave and gave you'd come around.]] Maybe be a little nicer, instead of treating me like your dog. But then I realized you're the dog."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I assume? This should probably be clarified.


* A bit of a disturbing one from ''{{Bleach}}'' is Orihime's relationship with her dead brother. First, it started as the first type, where Orihime was the Taker, while her brother was the Giver, though it is justified, with her brother dying when she was young and she had no other family or friends. But when she became friends with Tatsuki and developed a crush on Ichigo, their roles switched and he thought Orihime didn't pay as much attention to him as she used to. He wasn't pleased at all.

to:

* A bit of a disturbing one from ''{{Bleach}}'' is Orihime's relationship with her dead undead brother. First, it started as the first type, where Orihime was the Taker, while her brother was the Giver, though it is justified, with her brother dying when she was young and she had no other family or friends. But when she became friends with Tatsuki and developed a crush on Ichigo, their roles switched and he thought Orihime didn't pay as much attention to him as she used to. He wasn't pleased at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In StephenKing's ''TheStand'', his own mother calls Larry Underwood a "taker", which he remembers many times.

to:

* In StephenKing's ''TheStand'', his own mother calls Larry Underwood a "taker", which he remembers comes back to haunt him many times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The other variant is a bit more disturbing. Rather than the Taker being in charge, it's the Giver who is in control. It's not that they're [[ChronicHeroSyndrome pathologically compelled]] to [[GoodSamaritan generosity]], but a deep desire to [[ControlFreak control]] and even ''own'' the Taker... so they work to make them completely psychologically and physically dependent, and may in fact cripple their ability to do some (or all) things. This is the hallmark of MyBelovedSmother, who may impair or retard their child's growth to keep them [[MommasBoy dependent.]] If romantic, the Giver may be a StalkerWithACrush who has managed to start a relationship with their target and then proceeded to demolish their self esteem in the guise of "helping" them. Expect them to say "I did it AllForYou". If the Taker should realize this and work up the resolve to break the cycle, the Giver [[AxeCrazy will not be pleased]].

to:

The other variant is a bit more disturbing. Rather than the Taker being in charge, it's the Giver who is in control. It's not that they're [[ChronicHeroSyndrome pathologically compelled]] to [[GoodSamaritan generosity]], but a deep desire to [[ControlFreak control]] and even ''own'' the Taker... so they work to make them completely psychologically and physically dependent, and may in fact cripple their ability to do some (or all) things. This is the hallmark of MyBelovedSmother, who may impair or retard their child's growth to keep them [[MommasBoy dependent.]] If romantic, the Giver may be a StalkerWithACrush who has managed to start a relationship with their target and then proceeded to demolish their self esteem in the guise of "helping" them. Expect them to say "I did it AllForYou". AllForYou", and justify alienating the Taker from past friends because "TheyWereHoldingYouBack." If the Taker should realize this and work up the resolve to break the cycle, the Giver [[AxeCrazy will not be pleased]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: VideoGames]]

* In the DotHackGUGames trilogy, [[spoiler:Sakaki]] is revealed to be the "controlling giver" type towards [[spoiler:Atoli]] when he crosses the MoralEventHorizon. He even delivers the classic line of accusing his victim of being "all take" and twists the knife in her low self-worth to convince her to only rely on him for emotional support. To put this in perspective, he got his hooks into the poor girl [[spoiler:when he met her on a suicide website]]! What a creep!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* A criticism cited against [[AvatarTheLastAirbender Aang/Katara]] is that Aang seems to be more willing to take affection and compromise from Katara than return it. [[YourMileageMayVary And that is]] [[{{Shipping}} all we shall]] [[InternetBackdraft say about that.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The middle ground is akin to TheMasochismTango, both the Giver and the Taker are in a deeply co-dependent relationship they can't break out of. Maybe they're a Sugar Daddy and a shop happy floozy, a parent who can't stand to say "no" and an emotionally needy SpoiledBrat, or an indulgent monarch raising RoyalBrats. In all variations, both participants will be unwilling or unable to identify and leave or change the relationship.

to:

The middle ground is akin to TheMasochismTango, both the Giver and the Taker are in a deeply co-dependent relationship they can't break out of. Maybe they're a Sugar Daddy and a shop happy floozy, a parent who can't stand to say "no" and an emotionally needy SpoiledBrat, or an indulgent monarch raising RoyalBrats. In all variations, both participants will be unwilling or unable to leave, change or even identify and leave or change the relationship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This is basically ''TheGivingTree'' in a nutshell, plus some ''{{Glurge}}''.

to:

* This is basically ''TheGivingTree'' in a nutshell, plus some ''{{Glurge}}''.{{Glurge}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This pays Spike back for his earlier relationship with Harmony, whose final speech to him is roughly "I thought if I gave and gave and gave you'd come around. Maybe be a little nicer, instead of treating me like your dog. But then I realised you're the dog."

to:

** This pays Spike back for his earlier relationship with Harmony, whose final speech to him is roughly "I "[[LoveMartyr I thought if I gave and gave and gave you'd come around. around.]] Maybe be a little nicer, instead of treating me like your dog. But then I realised realized you're the dog."




to:

* On ''VeronicaMars'', the titular character often slips into this, particularly with respect to her friend Wallace. Veronica falls into the Type 1 version, as the "Taker", with Wallace being the "Giver." It gets to the point where [[WhatTheHellHero she gets rightfully called out on it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''PiratesOfTheCaribbean'': "Take what you can!" "Give nothing back!"
** That one's actually justified, considering that they're pirates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That one's actually justified, considering that they're pirates.

Added: 162

Changed: 32

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A bit of a disturbing one from ''{{Bleach}}'' is Orihime's relationship with her dead brother. First, it started as the first type, where Orihime was the Taker, while her brother was the Giver, though it is justified, with her brother dying when she was young and she had no other family or friends. But when she became friends with Tatsuki and developed a crush on Ichigo, their roles switched and Orihime didn't pay as much attention to her brother. He wasn't pleased at all.

to:

* A bit of a disturbing one from ''{{Bleach}}'' is Orihime's relationship with her dead brother. First, it started as the first type, where Orihime was the Taker, while her brother was the Giver, though it is justified, with her brother dying when she was young and she had no other family or friends. But when she became friends with Tatsuki and developed a crush on Ichigo, their roles switched and he thought Orihime didn't pay as much attention to her brother.him as she used to. He wasn't pleased at all.


Added DiffLines:

** And it turned out that Orihime told him a lot about her friends and her crush in order to reassure him that she's doing fine and he shouldn't worry about her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Bella Swan in ''Twilight'' swerves between both of the examples. On one hand, she seems to depend on Edward as her source of livelihood (bribing her into college, getting her expensive stuff, etc) as well as a way to become a beautiful and immortal vampire. On the other hand, [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation some could see]] it as Bella ''using'' Edward as a means to become rich and beautiful and immortal.

to:

* Bella Swan in ''Twilight'' swerves between both of the examples. On one hand, she seems to depend on Edward as her source of livelihood (bribing her into college, getting her expensive stuff, etc) as well as a way to become a beautiful and immortal vampire. On the other hand, [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation some could see]] it as Bella ''using'' Edward as a means to become rich and beautiful and immortal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''King K.Rool''': "It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack for taking everything I want and giving nothing ---->back!"

to:

-->'''King K.Rool''': "It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack for taking everything I want and giving nothing ---->back!" back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**King K.Rool: "It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack for taking everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

**King -->'''King K.Rool: Rool''': "It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack for taking everything I want and giving nothing back!" ---->back!"

Changed: 55

Removed: 52

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> King K.Rool: "It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack for taking
-----> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

--> King **King K.Rool: "It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack for taking
----->
taking everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

----> -----> everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-----> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

-----> ----> everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->-- everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

--->-- -----> everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-----> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

-----> --->-- everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---------> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

---------> -----> everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


------------------> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

------------------> ---------> everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

--> ------------------> everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

--> --> everything I want and giving nothing back!"

Added: 54

Changed: 67

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->"It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack... for taking everything I want and giving nothing back!"

to:

->"It's --> King K.Rool: "It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack... knack for taking taking
-->
everything I want and giving nothing back!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One line from a song in [[Series/DonkeyKongCountry]] pretty much says it all.

to:

* One line from a song in [[Series/DonkeyKongCountry]] ''DonkeyKongCountry'' pretty much says it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One line from a song in [[Series\''DonkeyKongCountry'']] pretty much says it all.

to:

* One line from a song in [[Series\''DonkeyKongCountry'']] [[Series/DonkeyKongCountry]] pretty much says it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One line from a song in [[Series/''DonkeyKongCountry'']] pretty much says it all.

to:

* One line from a song in [[Series/''DonkeyKongCountry'']] [[Series\''DonkeyKongCountry'']] pretty much says it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One line from a song in [[Series: ''DonkeyKongCountry'']] pretty much says it all.

to:

* One line from a song in [[Series: ''DonkeyKongCountry'']] [[Series/''DonkeyKongCountry'']] pretty much says it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* One line from a song in [[Series: ''DonkeyKongCountry'']] pretty much says it all.
->"It's great to be a king. I seem to have a knack... for taking everything I want and giving nothing back!"

Top