Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheThrawnTrilogy

Go To

OR

Added: 50

Changed: 56

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Nearly all of the iconic lines from the movie trilogy find their way into the books. Admiral Ackbar even announces a trap!

to:

** Nearly all of the iconic lines from the movie trilogy find their way into the books. Admiral Ackbar even announces books, sometimes with slight changes.
--->'''Admiral Ackbar:''' It appears to be
a trap!trap.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AffablyEvil: Thrawn. Debatable with Pellaeon, since he became a pretty LawfulGood guy later on.

to:

* AffablyEvil: Thrawn. Debatable with Pellaeon, since he became a pretty LawfulGood good guy later on.

Added: 128

Removed: 142

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultFear: "Thrawn would smile, and speak politely, and ''take her children away.''" Of course, Leia is [[MamaBear not having any of that]].


Added DiffLines:

* MamaBear: "Thrawn would smile, and speak politely, and ''take her children away.''" Of course, Leia is not having any of that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking cec with page text; not mine

Added DiffLines:

* CovertEmergencyCall: During ''The Last Command'', Talon Karrde is held at gunpoint at the helm of his ship, but he's able to covertly flash the ship's landing lights on and off, drawing the attention of people nearby. For bonus points, he then tricks his captor into believing that one of the light controls is a DeadMansSwitch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This trilogy was one of the cornerstones of the now non-canon ''Legends'', being the first major work set after ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' (five years after to be exact), the first truly ''popular'' entry of the franchise since ''Return of the Jedi'', and serving as the introduction of some of the most beloved figures in ''Legends'' canon, like [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Grand_Admiral Grand Admiral]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Mitth%27raw%27nuruodo Thrawn]], [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Mara_Jade_Skywalker Mara Jade]], [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Gilad_Pellaeon Gilad Pellaeon]] and [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Talon_Karrde Talon Karrde]]. For a long, long time, many fans considered them to be the honorary Episodes VII, VIII and IX, and when the actual movies were announced, initial speculation was intense about whether or not they would adapt parts or all of this story.[[note]]As it would turn out, they seemed to be trying to do the exact ''opposite'' of everything this trilogy did.[[/note]]

Ironically given the BigBad is an alien, this trilogy introduced a slightly more human Galactic Empire--still certainly villainous but no longer a ZeroPercentApprovalRating organization. In movie terms it is somewhat closer to Admiral Piett and Captain Needa than Darth Vader and Grand Moff Tarkin. Thrawn himself (the aforementioned alien BigBad) was certainly a MagnificentBastard of the highest caliber, one whom the reader did not hesitate in respecting. The trilogy also reflected the RealLife movement into the Information Age, with Thrawn (and Karrde opposite him) being able to [[HyperAwareness connect esoteric and obscure bits of data together into a much larger picture]]. Thrawn in particular was able to practice an [[SherlockScan almost obscene version of psychoanalysis]] on people and cultures by studying their artwork, using it to identify weaknesses in their thinking or perception patterns, and then exploiting said weaknesses in devastating ways. The trilogy, as implied by its name, concerns the adventures of the New Republic, particularly Luke, Han and Leia, to deal with Thrawn's plans, leadership and genius.

to:

This trilogy was one of the cornerstones of the now non-canon ''Legends'', being the first major work set after ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' (five years after to be exact), the first truly ''popular'' popular entry of the franchise since ''Return of the Jedi'', and serving as the introduction of some of the most beloved figures in ''Legends'' canon, like [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Grand_Admiral Grand Admiral]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Mitth%27raw%27nuruodo Thrawn]], [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Mara_Jade_Skywalker Mara Jade]], [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Gilad_Pellaeon Gilad Pellaeon]] and [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Talon_Karrde Talon Karrde]]. For a long, long time, Back before [[Film/TheForceAwakens the]] [[Film/TheLastJedi Sequel]] [[Film/TheRiseOfSkywalker Trilogy]] was made, many fans considered them these stories to be the honorary Episodes VII, VIII closet thing to an ''Episode VII'', ''Episode VIII'', and IX, and when the actual movies were announced, initial speculation was intense about whether or not ''Episode IX'' that they would adapt parts or all of this story.[[note]]As it would turn out, they seemed to be trying to do the exact ''opposite'' of everything this trilogy did.[[/note]]

Ironically given
ever get. Years later, these stories are still regarded highly despite showing their age in some places.

Given
the BigBad is an alien, this trilogy introduced a slightly more human Galactic Empire--still Empire -- still certainly villainous villainous, but no longer a ZeroPercentApprovalRating organization. In movie terms terms, it is somewhat closer to Admiral Piett and Captain Needa than Darth Vader and Grand Moff Tarkin. Thrawn himself (the aforementioned alien BigBad) was certainly a MagnificentBastard of the highest caliber, one whom the reader did not hesitate in respecting. The trilogy also reflected the RealLife movement into the Information Age, with Thrawn (and Karrde opposite him) being able to [[HyperAwareness connect esoteric and obscure bits of data together into a much larger picture]]. Thrawn in particular was able to practice an [[SherlockScan almost obscene version of psychoanalysis]] on people and cultures by studying their artwork, using it to identify weaknesses in their thinking or perception patterns, and then exploiting said weaknesses in devastating ways. The trilogy, as implied by its name, concerns the adventures of the New Republic, particularly Luke, Han and Leia, to deal with Thrawn's plans, leadership and genius.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''From the very first chapter of ''Heir to the Empire'':''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, letting C'baoth [[spoiler: live after the battle over Coruscant. He never does anything else for them, and Thrawn has no plans for him in the near future, not to mention the fact that he has Force-nullifying animals on-board his ship.]]

to:

** Also, letting Letting C'baoth [[spoiler: live after the battle over Coruscant. He never does anything else for them, and Thrawn has no plans for him in the near future, not to mention the fact that he has Force-nullifying animals on-board his ship.]]



** All of the Heroes and New Republic command are fully aware of the fact that Thrawn's Delta Source has compromised The former Imperial Capital. Instead of moving their military operations to another location to kill the intellgence leak, they continue to utilize the imperial capital and hope they'll stumble across Delta Source sooner or later.

to:

** All of the Heroes heroes and New Republic command are fully aware of the fact that Thrawn's Delta Source has compromised The the former Imperial Capital. capital. Instead of moving their military operations to another location to kill the intellgence intelligence leak, they continue to utilize the imperial Imperial capital and hope they'll stumble across Delta Source sooner or later.

Added: 581

Removed: 577

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TheParalyzer:
** Zahn introduces the Stokhli Spray Stick, an unconventional weapon which can both stun people and also allow one to play at being Franchise/SpiderMan. The Noghri use it when trying to capture a pregnant Leia because the stun setting on normal Star Wars blasters have a better than fifty-fifty shot of inducing a miscarriage and Thrawn wants the kids alive.
** The conventional stun-setting blasters appear in "The Last Command" when the Imperials can't use the kill setting for fear of hitting the nearby cloning equipment. Lando and Chewie have fewer compunctions.



* StunGuns:
** Zahn introduces the Stokhli Spray Stick, an unconventional weapon which can both stun people and also allow one to play at being Franchise/SpiderMan. The Noghri use it when trying to capture a pregnant Leia because the stun setting on normal Star Wars blasters have a better than fifty-fifty shot of inducing a miscarriage and Thrawn wants the kids alive.
** The conventional stun-setting blasters appear in "The Last Command" when the Imperials can't use the kill setting for fear of hitting the nearby cloning equipment. Lando and Chewie have fewer compunctions.

Changed: 196

Removed: 138

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removing examples referencing other examples above or below it


* EntertaininglyWrong: For all of Thrawn's reputation of AwesomenessByAnalysis, he does make a major miscalculation with a logical-yet-incorrect conclusion in the second book regarding Khabarakh's whereabouts during the month since the first book. Most of what goes wrong for Thrawn later on is a result of this error snowballing into disaster. The most plausible explanation for this error was that Thrawn didn't know that Leia and Luke were in fact Vader's children (see above). Without that key piece of information, drawing the proper conclusion would've been all but ''impossible''. However, later EU authors have had trouble deciding whether that fact was common knowledge or not.

to:

* EntertaininglyWrong: For all of Thrawn's reputation of AwesomenessByAnalysis, he does make a major miscalculation with a logical-yet-incorrect conclusion in the second book regarding Khabarakh's whereabouts during the month since the first book. Most of what goes wrong for Thrawn later on is a result of this error snowballing into disaster. The most plausible explanation for this error was that Thrawn didn't know that Leia and Luke were in fact Vader's children (see above).children. Without that key piece of information, drawing the proper conclusion would've been all but ''impossible''. However, later EU authors have had trouble deciding whether that fact was common knowledge or not.



*** Firstly in the opening pages of ''Heir to the Empire'' when the ''Chimaera'' is attacked by four Rebel assault frigates and three squadrons of X-wings. Pellaeon thinks those odds are badly in the Republic's favor and prepares to retreat, but Thrawn displays his art-derived tactical genius and defeats them (see DoABarrelRoll above). Besides this, it also establishes that Thrawn represents the turn of the tide for the Empire and they are no longer in decline and running from fights.

to:

*** Firstly in the opening pages of ''Heir to the Empire'' when the ''Chimaera'' is attacked by four Rebel assault frigates and three squadrons of X-wings. Pellaeon thinks those odds are badly in the Republic's favor and prepares to retreat, but Thrawn displays his art-derived tactical genius and defeats them (see DoABarrelRoll above).them. Besides this, it also establishes that Thrawn represents the turn of the tide for the Empire and they are no longer in decline and running from fights.



** Not directly stated, but this is a major undertone between Thrawn and Niles Ferrier. The latter often screws up his assigned tasks due to his SmallNameBigEgo tendencies, and the former displays barely-concealed contempt for him. [[spoiler:When discussing the idea to frame Karrde (see below), Thrawn outlines a plan that minimizes Ferrier's direct involvement, while shooting down all of Ferrier's suggestions as stupid. And of course, the plan fails due to Ferrier being unable to keep his mouth shut.]]

to:

** Not directly stated, but this is a major undertone between Thrawn and Niles Ferrier. The latter often screws up his assigned tasks due to his SmallNameBigEgo tendencies, and the former displays barely-concealed contempt for him. [[spoiler:When discussing the idea to frame Karrde (see below), Karrde, Thrawn outlines a plan that minimizes Ferrier's direct involvement, while shooting down all of Ferrier's suggestions as stupid. And of course, the plan fails due to Ferrier being unable to keep his mouth shut.]]



* MindRape: C'baoth is a ''very bad man''. See the spoilered part of CharmPerson, above. [[spoiler:He starts off using his powers to enforce obedience through fear, but very quickly grows a taste for just hollowing out people's minds and replacing them with his own thoughts and whims.]]

to:

* MindRape: C'baoth is a ''very bad man''. See the spoilered part of CharmPerson, above. [[spoiler:He starts off using his powers to enforce obedience through fear, but very quickly grows a taste for just hollowing out people's minds and replacing them with his own thoughts and whims.]]



* OutGambitted: The Battle of Bilbringi. See KansasCityShuffle.

to:

* %%* OutGambitted: The Battle of Bilbringi. See KansasCityShuffle.



* {{Pun}}: The names of Karrde's ships: ''Wild Karrde'', ''Lastri's Ort'', ''Starry Ice'', ''Etherway'', ''Amanda Follow'', ''Dawn Beat''.



* PungeonMaster: Through Talon Karrde, Timothy Zahn is one. The names of Karrde's ships (see above) are all clever puns and/or wordplay, and Zahn himself couldn't resist adding in a few puns (like the slave circuit "beckon call" a pun on the term "beck and call," which is exactly what it puts your ship on).

to:

* PungeonMaster: Through Talon Karrde, Timothy Zahn is one. The names of Karrde's ships (see above) (''Wild Karrde'', ''Lastri's Ort'', ''Starry Ice'', ''Etherway'', ''Amanda Follow'', and ''Dawn Beat'') are all clever puns and/or wordplay, and Zahn himself couldn't resist adding in a few puns (like the slave circuit "beckon call" a pun on the term "beck and call," which is exactly what it puts your ship on).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not part of the quote.


* ALighterShadeOfBlack: Thrawn, at least by this point, is not a good person: he has absolutely no qualms about betraying Mara to get to Karrde in ''Dark Force Rising'', kidnapping someone's children and delivering them to be corrupted by an AxCrazy clone, and his military strategy involves growing his own [[CloningBlues slave soldiers by the thousands]] and throwing them at the Republic. But unlike most imperials, he's not a CardCarryingVillain.
--> Thrawn was respected and trusted. Thrawn used a small measure of fear, certainly: the Grand Admiral realized that [[YouHaveFailedMe fear of failure]] was a powerful motivating force in a military the size of the Empire. But Thrawn's ability to invoke a sense of ''pride'' in his troops was his most powerful asset. Palpatine inspired arrogance and callousness in his officers; Thrawn made his men proud to be Imperial soldiers. Thrawn's officers would have willingly died for the Grand Admiral. There is also a practical reason for this in that by the time the Thrawn trilogy took place the Empire no longer [[WeHaveReserves had endless reserves]] of beings and equipment, meaning the Empire could not recklessly throw away the lives of its soldiers.

to:

* ALighterShadeOfBlack: Thrawn, at least by this point, is not a good person: he has absolutely no qualms about betraying Mara to get to Karrde in ''Dark Force Rising'', kidnapping someone's children and delivering them to be corrupted by an AxCrazy clone, and his military strategy involves growing his own [[CloningBlues slave soldiers by the thousands]] and throwing them at the Republic. But unlike most imperials, he's not a CardCarryingVillain.
CardCarryingVillain. There is also a practical reason for this in that by the time the Thrawn trilogy took place the Empire no longer [[WeHaveReserves had endless reserves]] of beings and equipment, meaning the Empire could not recklessly throw away the lives of its soldiers.
--> Thrawn was respected and trusted. Thrawn used a small measure of fear, certainly: the Grand Admiral realized that [[YouHaveFailedMe fear of failure]] was a powerful motivating force in a military the size of the Empire. But Thrawn's ability to invoke a sense of ''pride'' in his troops was his most powerful asset. Palpatine inspired arrogance and callousness in his officers; Thrawn made his men proud to be Imperial soldiers. Thrawn's officers would have willingly died for the Grand Admiral. There is also a practical reason for this in that by the time the Thrawn trilogy took place the Empire no longer [[WeHaveReserves had endless reserves]] of beings and equipment, meaning the Empire could not recklessly throw away the lives of its soldiers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* INeverSaidItWasPoison: [[TooDumbToLive Niles Ferrier]]. [[spoiler: Ferrier had paid off an Imperial lieutenant and his squad to attack a meeting of smugglers where Talon Karrde was trying to convince them to band together and help the New Republic against the Empire, so Ferrier could infiltrate them more deeply. Thrawn had specifically ordered the local Imperial garrison to leave the meeting alone, knowing the smugglers would refuse Karrde and go their own ways, but after some of them are killed in the Imperial attack, the smugglers ''do'' band together. Thrawn has Ferrier plant data in Karrde's ship at the start of the next meeting, implicating Karrde as the one who hired the Imperials. The ruse falls apart when Ferrier drops the name of the Lieutenant in question without having heard anyone mention it, though beforehand the others were already starting to question the story due to Ferrier's shifty behavior.]]

to:

* INeverSaidItWasPoison: [[TooDumbToLive Niles Ferrier]]. [[spoiler: Ferrier had paid off an Imperial lieutenant and his squad to attack a meeting of smugglers where Talon Karrde was trying to convince them to band together and help the New Republic against the Empire, so Ferrier could [[EngineeredHeroics play a key role in thwarting the attack]] and infiltrate them more deeply. Thrawn had specifically ordered the local Imperial garrison to leave the meeting alone, knowing the smugglers would refuse Karrde and go their own ways, but after some of them are killed in the Imperial attack, the smugglers ''do'' band together. Thrawn has Ferrier plant data in Karrde's ship at the start of the next meeting, implicating Karrde as the one who hired the Imperials. The ruse falls apart when Ferrier drops the name of the Lieutenant in question without having heard anyone mention it, though beforehand the others were already starting to question the story due to Ferrier's shifty behavior.]]

Changed: 1175

Removed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* TheDogBitesBack: The Noghri.

to:

%%* * TheDogBitesBack: The Noghri.Noghri, [[spoiler:after learning the Empire bound them in indentured servitude for forty-four years, paced the decontamination efforts to a virtual standstill ''and'' made the whole toxic rain situation worse as part of securing the Noghri's service, wait for precisely the opportune moment to turn on the Empire and reveal how bad an idea pissing off the Noghri is.]]



%%* FireForgedFriends: Luke and Mara at the end of ''The Last Command''.

to:

%%* * FireForgedFriends: Luke and Mara at the end of ''The Last Command''.Command''. Having gone through all the experiences they've shared and having the lies the Emperor constructed around Mara shattered leaves remarkably chummy, considering Mara started the books wanting nothing more than to murder Luke.



%%* HappilyMarried: Han and Leia.

to:

%%* * HappilyMarried: Han and Leia.Leia were married at some point between ''Return of the Jedi'' and now. The work the New Republic requires of them is a strain on their relationship, but they weather it remarkably well.



%%* MindRape:
%%** C'baoth is a ''very bad man''. See the spoilered part of CharmPerson, above.
%%** Also, ''Film/AttackOfTheClones'' and ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'' turn Yoda's duel with the Dark Jedi from Bpfassh into this.

to:

%%* MindRape:
%%**
* MindRape: C'baoth is a ''very bad man''. See the spoilered part of CharmPerson, above.
%%** Also, ''Film/AttackOfTheClones''
above. [[spoiler:He starts off using his powers to enforce obedience through fear, but very quickly grows a taste for just hollowing out people's minds and ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'' turn Yoda's duel replacing them with the Dark Jedi from Bpfassh into this.his own thoughts and whims.]]



%%* PanickyExpectantFather: Han, of all people, in ''The Last Command''.

to:

%%* * PanickyExpectantFather: Han, of all people, in ''The Last Command''.Command''. He's nervous and fluttery around Leia who, after hours of labor, would really like to just have this done with by now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* TheChessmaster: Grand Admiral Thrawn.

to:

%%* * TheChessmaster: Grand Admiral Thrawn.Thrawn. While his opponents admit that not everything that happens in the galaxy is part of his all-encompassing plot, enough of it is that he's got them not only jumping at shadows, but more often then not at the specific shadows he ''wants'' them jumping at.



%%* CommanderContrarian: Pellaeon is a positive example.

to:

%%* * CommanderContrarian: Pellaeon is a positive example.example, questioning Thrawn's conclusions and plans not because he has no faith in his CO, but because Thrawn loves having someone try and poke holes in his reasoning. If they fail, the reasoning is sound. If they succeed, he needs to reevaluate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** All of the Heroes and New Republic command are fully aware of the fact that Thrawn's Delta Source has compromised The former Imperial Capital. Instead of moving their military operations to another location to kill the intellgence leak, they continue to utilize the imperial capital and hope they'll stumble across Delta Source sooner or later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> Luke might have TheForce, and [[MauveShirt Irenez]] might be able to climb stairs without getting winded; but [Han] would bet heavily that he could outdo both of them in sheer chicanery.

to:

--> Luke might have TheForce, the Force, and [[MauveShirt Irenez]] might be able to climb stairs without getting winded; but [Han] would bet heavily that he could outdo both of them in sheer chicanery.

Added: 160

Changed: 257

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InterserviceRivalry: Some members of the Imperial Army look down upon their naval counterparts, feeling them afraid to leave their ships and face real combat.



--> Thrawn was respected and trusted. Thrawn used a small measure of fear, certainly: the Grand Admiral realized that [[YouHaveFailedMe fear of failure]] was a powerful motivating force in a military the size of the Empire. But Thrawn's ability to invoke a sense of ''pride'' in his troops was his most powerful asset. Palpatine inspired arrogance and callousness in his officers; Thrawn made his men proud to be Imperial soldiers. Thrawn's officers would have willingly died for the Grand Admiral.

to:

--> Thrawn was respected and trusted. Thrawn used a small measure of fear, certainly: the Grand Admiral realized that [[YouHaveFailedMe fear of failure]] was a powerful motivating force in a military the size of the Empire. But Thrawn's ability to invoke a sense of ''pride'' in his troops was his most powerful asset. Palpatine inspired arrogance and callousness in his officers; Thrawn made his men proud to be Imperial soldiers. Thrawn's officers would have willingly died for the Grand Admiral. There is also a practical reason for this in that by the time the Thrawn trilogy took place the Empire no longer [[WeHaveReserves had endless reserves]] of beings and equipment, meaning the Empire could not recklessly throw away the lives of its soldiers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Despite Honoghr, the trope is played straight with the titular planet of Endor. Leia stops by to meet a contact at one point, yet no mention of any damage to the moon. (The books note, with the above scenario, that it's mostly Clone Wars era ships that had a lot of toxic chemicals that could ruin an environment if a ship crashed. That said the primary argument regarding the classic Endor holocaust argument is the sheer ''size'' of the Death Star and the debris resultant from its destruction.) In orbit ''around'' the moon, of course, is a bit of a different story, and for a different reason...

to:

** Despite Honoghr, the trope is played straight with the titular planet of Endor. Leia stops by to meet a contact at one point, yet no mention of any damage to the moon. (The books note, with the above scenario, that it's mostly Clone Wars era ships that had a lot of toxic chemicals that could ruin an environment if a ship crashed. That said the primary argument regarding the classic Endor holocaust argument is the sheer ''size'' of the Death Star and the debris resultant from its destruction.) In orbit ''around'' the moon, of course, is a bit of a [[FantasticFallout different story, story]], and for a different reason...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 262

Removed: 270

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Tuckerization}}: Garm Bel Iblis's lieutenants were named by Zahn after people he admired. The 20th Anniversary edition's annotations reveals that there are ''dozens'' of these friend names tucked into place names and company names as well as character names.




* {{Tuckerization}}: Garm Bel Iblis's lieutenants as well were named by Zahn after people he admired. The 20th Anniversary edition's annotations reveals that there are ''dozens'' of these friend names tucked into place names and company names as well as character names.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* {{Tuckerization}}: Garm Bel Iblis's lieutenants as well were named by Zahn after people he admired. The 20th Anniversary edition's annotations reveals that there are ''dozens'' of these friend names tucked into place names and company names as well as character names.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


** Pellaeon is depicted as clean shaven in the comic adaptation and there is no mention of facial hair in the novels. Practically [[http://chinese-starwars.com/jediarchive/expanduniverse/donald/donald/24_captain_pellaeon.jpg every]] [[http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/f/f3/GiladPellaeon.JPG picture]] [[http://starwarsgalaxies.station.sony.com/images/features/general/PellaeonTournamentPack.jpg and]] [[http://images.wikia.com/starwars/images/6/69/PellaeonYVW.jpg description]] [[http://www.imperialchicks.com/profiles/images/Grand_Admiral_Pellaeon2.jpg since]] (including [[Literature/HandOfThrawn Zahn's later books]]) have described Pellaeon as having a [[BadassMustache distinctive bushy mustache]] to the extent that at least one unnamed Imperial officer in a later comic was thought to be him just because he had a bushy mustache.

to:

** Pellaeon is depicted as clean shaven in the comic adaptation and there is no mention of facial hair in the novels. Practically [[http://chinese-starwars.com/jediarchive/expanduniverse/donald/donald/24_captain_pellaeon.jpg every]] [[http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/f/f3/GiladPellaeon.JPG picture]] [[http://starwarsgalaxies.station.sony.com/images/features/general/PellaeonTournamentPack.jpg and]] [[http://images.wikia.com/starwars/images/6/69/PellaeonYVW.jpg description]] [[http://www.imperialchicks.com/profiles/images/Grand_Admiral_Pellaeon2.jpg since]] (including [[Literature/HandOfThrawn Zahn's later books]]) have described Pellaeon as having a [[BadassMustache distinctive bushy mustache]] mustache to the extent that at least one unnamed Imperial officer in a later comic was thought to be him just because he had a bushy mustache.

Added: 2467

Changed: 881

Removed: 2437

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Sci Fi Writers Have No Sense Of Scale is the index-I'm breaking this up into separate entries. Writers Cannot Do Math is on writers' math errors as well: the example doesn't fit but there's another which does I'm replacing it with.


* SciFiWritersHave/NoSenseOfDistance:
** Averted as much as is possible for ''Franchise/StarWars'': realizing that the galaxy has over a ''million'' inhabited worlds, Zahn (unlike some other ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' writers) doesn't recycle locations from the films without good reason. And at those times when the heroes know they need to find something on an unfamiliar world, they don't act like knowing what planet it's on will make things easy. Planets are ''big''.
** He also realize that a light-year is an enormous distance; when Luke's X-Wing is determined to be somewhere within a light-year of Thrawn's Star Destroyer, Thrawn hires mercenaries to find it since it would take too long to search for themselves. Just because hyperdrive allows ''traveling'' along such a distance very rapidly doesn't mean that finding a 40-foot ship in a cubic light year is an easy prospect.
** Zahn also employs a notable {{Retcon}} to correct one particularly egregious instance of this trope from the original series. When Luke returns to Dagobah to search the old site of Yoda's hut, he finds (to his surprise) that he has absolutely no problem landing on the planet this time, and wonders if he originally crashed on Dagobah in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'' because Yoda intentionally pulled his X-Wing to the surface with the Force. For confused fans, this finally explains how Luke managed to "accidentally" stumble upon Yoda's dwelling when he had never even been to Dagobah before: Yoda sensed his presence and guided him there.
* SciFiWritersHave/NoSenseOfUnits:
** Played straight in the numbers of ships aspect, which was apparent in the original trilogy. For the size of the galaxy, the 200 ship strong ''Katana'' ''Dreadnaught''-class Heavy Cruiser fleet should barely be considered a ''picket'' force, much less one that could turn the tables in a galaxy spanning war. Later sources clarify that at this point, the Republic and the Empire are almost perfectly matched in terms of materiel. The ''Katana'' fleet might not be much, but it's just enough to free up some other ships that are needed elsewhere, [[UnstableEquilibrium which will gradually lead to a snowballing effect and an insurmountable advantage]].
** Also, while bringing roughly 180 of the ''Katana'' fleet ships into his service did allow Thrawn to go more heavily on the offensive, it didn't ''decisively'' change the balance of power. Just tipped the scales slightly in the Empire's favor.



* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale:
** Averted as much as is possible for ''Franchise/StarWars'': realizing that the galaxy has over a ''million'' inhabited worlds, Zahn (unlike some other ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' writers) doesn't recycle locations from the films without good reason. And at those times when the heroes know they need to find something on an unfamiliar world, they don't act like knowing what planet it's on will make things easy. Planets are ''big''.
** He also realize that a light-year is an enormous distance; when Luke's X-Wing is determined to be somewhere within a light-year of Thrawn's Star Destroyer, Thrawn hires mercenaries to find it since it would take too long to search for themselves. Just because hyperdrive allows ''traveling'' along such a distance very rapidly doesn't mean that finding a 40-foot ship in a cubic light year is an easy prospect.
** However played straight in the numbers of ships aspect, which was apparent in the original trilogy. For the size of the galaxy, the 200 ship strong ''Katana'' ''Dreadnaught''-class Heavy Cruiser fleet should barely be considered a ''picket'' force, much less one that could turn the tables in a galaxy spanning war. Later sources clarify that at this point, the Republic and the Empire are almost perfectly matched in terms of materiel. The ''Katana'' fleet might not be much, but it's just enough to free up some other ships that are needed elsewhere, [[UnstableEquilibrium which will gradually lead to a snowballing effect and an insurmountable advantage]].
*** Also, while bringing roughly 180 of the ''Katana'' fleet ships into his service did allow Thrawn to go more heavily on the offensive, it didn't ''decisively'' change the balance of power. Just tipped the scales slightly in the Empire's favor.
** Zahn also employs a notable {{Retcon}} to correct one particularly egregious instance of this trope from the original series. When Luke returns to Dagobah to search the old site of Yoda's hut, he finds (to his surprise) that he has absolutely no problem landing on the planet this time, and wonders if he originally crashed on Dagobah in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'' because Yoda intentionally pulled his X-Wing to the surface with the Force. For confused fans, this finally explains how Luke managed to "accidentally" stumble upon Yoda's dwelling when he had never even been to Dagobah before: Yoda sensed his presence and guided him there.



* WritersCannotDoMath: The ''Katana'' fleet that is supposed to be a very big deal in the war between the Republic and the Empire is probably too small to play this role credibly. It's described as roughly 200 fairly small spaceships, which even together are unlikely to be a match for even one of the big Imperial battleships from the movies (such as Vader's flagship).

to:

* WritersCannotDoMath: The ''Katana'' fleet that is supposed to be There's a very big deal plot hole where Darth Vader was involved in a plot-critical event 44 years before the war between present day of the Republic story. Luke and Leia, at this stage, cannot be any older than 28, meaning Anakin Skywalker would have had to have been Darth Vader ''sixteen years'' before his children were born. While this preceded the release of the prequel trilogy which obsoleted a lot of what Creator/TimothyZahn had based his writing on (particularly the nature of the Clone Wars and the Empire is probably too small to play this role credibly. It's described as roughly 200 fairly small spaceships, which even together are unlikely to be a match for even one fall of the big Imperial battleships from Old Republic), he apparently just didn't consider the movies (such as Vader's flagship).ramifications of the plot point on the family timeline (never mind that this meant Vader would presumably have had to have been a Dark Jedi for at least 16 years ''before'' being crippled and turned into a cyborg).

Changed: 195

Removed: 185

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SherlockScan: Thrawn does this with art, deducing facts not about the artist, but their entire culture.
** Even to specific individuals... by studying art a specific person collects (Karrde/Bel Iblis) or has made (Ackbar), Thrawn can deduce how that person will respond to various tactics.

to:

* SherlockScan: Thrawn does this with art, deducing facts not about the artist, but their entire culture.
** Even to
culture. This even works for specific individuals... by studying art a specific person collects (Karrde/Bel Iblis) or has made (Ackbar), Thrawn can deduce how that person will respond to various tactics.

Added: 658

Changed: 656

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PerspectiveMagic: Thrawn uses several of his [[StealthInSpace cloaked ships]] in conjunction with the ''Chimaera'' to pull this off as one of his "superweapons." The cloaked vessels were in a direct line between the ''Chimaera'' and its target, just below the planet's shields, firing when the former's lasers hit said shields. To the defenders, it looks as though the ''Chimaera'''s lasers went [[ArmorPiercingAttack straight through]]. Thrawn carefully chooses the places where he uses this trick, only targeting planets where he expects the locals to be so astonished by the "impossible" attack that they'll surrender without taking the time to analyze what's happening.

to:

* PerspectiveMagic: PerspectiveMagic:
**
Thrawn uses several of his [[StealthInSpace cloaked ships]] in conjunction with the ''Chimaera'' to pull this off as one of his "superweapons." The cloaked vessels were in a direct line between the ''Chimaera'' and its target, just below the planet's shields, firing when the former's lasers hit said shields. To the defenders, it looks as though the ''Chimaera'''s lasers went [[ArmorPiercingAttack straight through]]. Thrawn carefully chooses the places where he uses this trick, only targeting planets where he expects the locals to be so astonished by the "impossible" attack that they'll surrender without taking the time to analyze what's happening.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MindRape:
** C'baoth is a ''very bad man''. See the spoilered part of CharmPerson, above.
** Also, ''Film/AttackOfTheClones'' and ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'' turn Yoda's duel with the Dark Jedi from Bpfassh into this.

to:

* %%* MindRape:
** %%** C'baoth is a ''very bad man''. See the spoilered part of CharmPerson, above.
** %%** Also, ''Film/AttackOfTheClones'' and ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'' turn Yoda's duel with the Dark Jedi from Bpfassh into this.



* PanickyExpectantFather: Han, of all people, in ''The Last Command''.

to:

* %%* PanickyExpectantFather: Han, of all people, in ''The Last Command''.

Added: 77

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IWantThemAlive: "...if possible. If not... If not, [[PragmaticVillainy I'll understand]]."

to:

* IWantThemAlive: IWantThemAlive:
**
"...if possible. If not... If not, [[PragmaticVillainy I'll understand]]."

Added: 514

Changed: 511

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IDontPayYouToThink: In ''The Last Command'', Fingal and Governor Staffa of Berchest have a chat after they spot Luke Skywalker poking around on the planet. Fingal asks Staffa if he thinks that Skywalker saw the special transport they were using to carry clones for the Empire and Staffa replies that of course he saw it, wondering if Fingal thought Skywalker was hanging around for his health. At this, Fingal comments "I only thought..." only to be cut off by Staffa telling him to not think, as he isn't properly equipped for it.

to:

* IDontPayYouToThink: IDontPayYouToThink:
**
In ''The Last Command'', Fingal and Governor Staffa of Berchest have a chat after they spot Luke Skywalker poking around on the planet. Fingal asks Staffa if he thinks that Skywalker saw the special transport they were using to carry clones for the Empire and Staffa replies that of course he saw it, wondering if Fingal thought Skywalker was hanging around for his health. At this, Fingal comments "I only thought..." only to be cut off by Staffa telling him to not think, as he isn't properly equipped for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Thrawn sends C'Baoth leave with General Covell and his handpicked best troops aboard a ship with no supervision and no ysalamiri. It does not end well for Covell. Particularly glaring because C'Baoth abused this power before... right in front of Thrawn... repeatedly!

to:

** Thrawn sends C'Baoth to leave with General Covell and his handpicked best troops aboard a ship with no supervision and no ysalamiri. It does not end well for Covell. Particularly glaring because C'Baoth abused this power before... right in front of Thrawn... repeatedly!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HappilyMarried: Han and Leia.

to:

* %%* HappilyMarried: Han and Leia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FireForgedFriends: Luke and Mara at the end of ''The Last Command''.

to:

* %%* FireForgedFriends: Luke and Mara at the end of ''The Last Command''.

Top