History HoYay / FullMetalAlchemist

22nd Jun '17 1:12:29 PM DeathMetalAlchemist
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** [[http://rs1017.pbsrc.com/albums/af292/Enveh2978/ling_yao.gif~c200 Then there's Ling getting touchy-feely with Ed not long after they meet.]]
22nd Jun '17 7:19:35 AM Airin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Some of the official art is rather blatant as well:[[http://icdb-images.b0.upaiyun.com/gallery/2367/32190.jpg]] [[http://i79.beon.ru/86/55/375586/70/24202570/538118.jpeg]] [[https://file2.instiz.net/data/cached_img/upload/2015011021/2015e049ec3e6083e6593574d968fe07.jpg]] [[http://s3.narvii.com/image/mcpccr7dbpje4lxvnnvoy7spckbmq32o_hq.jpg]]

to:

** Some of the official art is rather blatant as well:[[http://icdb-images.b0.upaiyun.com/gallery/2367/32190.well:[[http://www.theanimegallery.com/data/thumbs/790px/0202/tAG_202323.jpg]] [[http://i79.beon.ru/86/55/375586/70/24202570/538118.jpeg]] [[https://file2.instiz.net/data/cached_img/upload/2015011021/2015e049ec3e6083e6593574d968fe07.jpg]] [[http://s3.narvii.com/image/mcpccr7dbpje4lxvnnvoy7spckbmq32o_hq.jpg]]
20th Jun '17 1:49:37 PM Airin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Alfons Heiderich/Edward in the movie. Basically canon in the original script, where Ed was at the receiving end of both Noah's affection (more ambiguously) and Heiderich's. The booklet that comes with the special edition of the DVD even states that Alfons dies "with conflicted feelings about Edward". There's also the implication that they were sharing the bedroom (which only has one bed), given that Heiderich's clothes are in Ed's room, in addition of [[http://alfonsheiderich.tumblr.com/post/34389106366/apartment-translations this]]. Make of it what you want.

to:

** Some of the official art is rather blatant as well:[[http://icdb-images.b0.upaiyun.com/gallery/2367/32190.jpg]] [[http://i79.beon.ru/86/55/375586/70/24202570/538118.jpeg]] [[https://file2.instiz.net/data/cached_img/upload/2015011021/2015e049ec3e6083e6593574d968fe07.jpg]] [[http://s3.narvii.com/image/mcpccr7dbpje4lxvnnvoy7spckbmq32o_hq.jpg]]
* Alfons Heiderich/Edward in the movie. Basically canon in the original script, where Ed was at the receiving end of both Noah's affection (more ambiguously) and Heiderich's. The booklet that comes with the special edition of the DVD even states that Alfons dies "with conflicted feelings about towards Edward". There's also the implication that they were sharing the bedroom (which only has one bed), given that Heiderich's clothes are in Ed's room, in addition of [[http://alfonsheiderich.tumblr.com/post/34389106366/apartment-translations this]]. Make of it what you want.
18th Jun '17 11:58:22 PM Airin
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Alfons Heiderich/Edward in the movie. Basically canon in the original script, where Ed was at the receiving end of both Noah's affection (more ambiguously) and Heiderich's. The booklet that comes with the special edition of the DVD even states that Alfons dies "with conflicted feelings about Edward". There's also the implication that they were sharing the bedroom (which only has one bed), given that Heiderich's clothes are in Ed's room, in addition of [[http://alfonsheiderich.tumblr.com/post/34389106366/apartment-translations this]]. Make of it what you want.
27th Apr '17 10:01:52 PM kalanvl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The original ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'' manga (as well as its direct adaptation, ''Brotherhood'') has surprisingly little (arguably ''no'') HoYay for a shonen with a [[LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters huge]] and mostly male cast. Perhaps it's precisely this absence of [[{{canon}} deliberate]] {{subtext}} which has led the [[YaoiFangirl yaoi fangirls]] to see romantic overtones in Ed's relationship with Ling, and in Mustang's rather heartfelt reaction to Hughes' [[spoiler:death]].

to:

* The original ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'' manga (as well as its direct adaptation, ''Brotherhood'') has surprisingly little (arguably ''no'') HoYay for a shonen with a [[LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters huge]] and mostly male cast. Perhaps it's precisely this absence of [[{{canon}} deliberate]] {{subtext}} which has led the [[YaoiFangirl yaoi fangirls]] to see romantic overtones in However, Ed's relationship with Ling, and in Mustang's rather heartfelt reaction to Hughes' [[spoiler:death]].[[spoiler:death]] still add moderate HoYay fodder.
19th Mar '17 12:58:15 PM Isaac_Heller
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

* Winry and Rose, [[http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lz29srk4B51qdyi3xo1_500.png as]] [[http://31.media.tumblr.com/abbaf1ca9017b4785552419a71f1b34f/tumblr_mi4ib98BQv1qdyi3xo6_250.jpg shown]] [[http://31.media.tumblr.com/de6dd49ef89138e7e782b18be174023e/tumblr_mi4ib98BQv1qdyi3xo5_250.png here.]]
8th Aug '16 10:59:46 PM 0nyx
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Though there's still those very rare moments that could be argued as being HoYay, such as [[http://www.mangareader.net/116-5201-10/full-metal-alchemist/chapter-15.html this one]]. In all fairness the interactions between the Elrics are more "brotherly" in the manga though, not going to the full "Elricest aura" that the first anime had.
*** Or how Ed and Al are pretty much [[LivingEmotionalCrutch living emotional crutches to one another]]. Whenever the other is threatened or it looks like they're dead the other freaks out and does everything in his power to save/protect the other.



** There's also the way Roy looks at Ed when he returns and Roy says "I always knew you were alive." It's suggested that he, Winry and Al were the only characters who didn't think Ed was dead.
** Not just the movie: The only time Mustang blushes in the original series-- that's right, Mustang blushes-- was at the beginning of ep 44, after Ed and [[spoiler: the newly-Philosopher Stone'd]] Al high-tail it out of Lior. Roy delivers a very... revealing line about his relationship to the Elrics, after which Ed gets a reaction shot where his eyes go wide and then he smirks slightly, and then Roy seems to realize what he just said.



* There's also a little bit of this between Ed and [[IdenticalStranger Alphonse Heiderich]], particularly in the moment before Ed [[spoiler: returns to Amestris]] when Alphonse takes his hand and makes him promise never to forget him. It's also implied earlier that they share a dresser and maybe even a room. It isn't much, but it's enough to make them one of the more popular [[SlashFic slash]] ships among fans of the first anime.

to:

* There's also a little bit of this between Ed and [[IdenticalStranger Alphonse Heiderich]], particularly in the moment before Ed [[spoiler: returns to Amestris]] when Alphonse takes his hand and makes him promise never to forget him. It's also implied earlier that they share a dresser and maybe even a room. It isn't much, but it's enough to make them one of the more popular [[SlashFic slash]] ships among fans of the first anime.
14th Jul '16 2:26:21 PM AnneOfCleves
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** End of ep. 48 is also a bit shippy, though some are split on whether it's promoting Roy/Ed, Roy/Maes, or Elricest. Roy and Ed talk about how they're sacrificing everything they've earned in the name of Hughes and Al (respectively), but there's an overwhelming sense of ItHasBeenAnHonor and Roy finally seeing Ed as not a child whose innocence he wants to protect as much as possible, but as an equal. Likewise, Ed sees the Roy behind the "Bastard Colonel" facade. They both admit they're NotSoDifferent, and it's telling that this moment comes at their last possible meeting, when they both know they might be going to their deaths."

to:

** End of ep. 48 is also a bit shippy, though some are split on whether it's promoting Roy/Ed, Roy/Maes, or Elricest. Roy and Ed talk about how they're sacrificing everything they've earned in the name of Hughes and Al (respectively), but there's an overwhelming sense of ItHasBeenAnHonor and Roy finally seeing Ed as not a child whose innocence he wants to protect as much as possible, but as an equal. Likewise, Ed sees the Roy behind the "Bastard Colonel" facade. They both admit they're NotSoDifferent, and it's telling that this moment comes at their last possible meeting, when they both know they might be going to their deaths."
14th Jul '16 2:24:08 PM AnneOfCleves
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** There's also the way Roy looks at Ed when he returns and Roy says "I always knew you were alive." It's suggested that he and Al were the only characters who didn't think Ed was dead; even Winry seemed to have given up hope.

to:

** There's also the way Roy looks at Ed when he returns and Roy says "I always knew you were alive." It's suggested that he he, Winry and Al were the only characters who didn't think Ed was dead; even Winry seemed to have given up hope.dead.
1st May '16 10:13:26 AM ilovehirohamada
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** End of ep. 48 is also a bit shippy, though some are split on whether it's promoting Roy/Ed, Roy/Maes, or Elricest. Roy and Ed talk about how they're sacrificing everything they've earned in the name of Hughes and Al (respectively), but there's an overwhelming sense of ItHasBeenAnHonor and Roy finally seeing Ed as not a child whose innocence he wants to protect as much as possible, but as an equal. Likewise, Ed sees the Roy behind the "Bastard Colonel" facade. They both admit they're NotSoDifferent, and it's telling that this moment comes at their last possible meeting, when they both know they might be going to their deaths.
** Ed certainly spends a lot of time thinking about Roy's "cocky smile" and "witty remarks" in the anime. "I can just see his smug face now..." We know you can, dear.
** Vic/Ed saying "Roy Mustang is dead sexy...in a miniskirt!"
* Winry, Scheska. Good god, they wander the world together, have romantic strolls along riverbanks at sunset, and have the TomboyAndGirlyGirl thing going on, and basically ignore what love interests they have to spend all their time together.

to:

** End of ep. 48 is also a bit shippy, though some are split on whether it's promoting Roy/Ed, Roy/Maes, or Elricest. Roy and Ed talk about how they're sacrificing everything they've earned in the name of Hughes and Al (respectively), but there's an overwhelming sense of ItHasBeenAnHonor and Roy finally seeing Ed as not a child whose innocence he wants to protect as much as possible, but as an equal. Likewise, Ed sees the Roy behind the "Bastard Colonel" facade. They both admit they're NotSoDifferent, and it's telling that this moment comes at their last possible meeting, when they both know they might be going to their deaths.
** Ed certainly spends a lot of time thinking about Roy's "cocky smile" and "witty remarks" in the anime. "I can just see his smug face now..." We know you can, dear.
** Vic/Ed saying "Roy Mustang is dead sexy...in a miniskirt!"
deaths."
* Winry, Scheska. Good god, God, they wander the world together, have romantic strolls along riverbanks at sunset, and have the TomboyAndGirlyGirl thing going on, and basically ignore what love interests they have to spend all their time together.



* Don't forget the extent that Ed and Al go to protect and just stay with each other. [[spoiler:Even ditching Winry in the movie.]]
** In the anime Ed "has something he's been meaning to tell Al for a long time" but didn't because he was "afraid of how he would react". Love confession!
*** In the English dub Al saying that he [[AccidentalInnuendo doesn't remember what Ed's skin feels like]].



* There's also a little bit of this between Ed and [[IdenticalStranger Alfons Heiderich]], particularly in the moment before Ed [[spoiler: returns to Amestris]] when Alfons takes his hand and makes him promise never to forget him. It's also implied earlier that they share a dresser and maybe even a room. It isn't much, but it's enough to make them one of the more popular [[SlashFic slash]] ships among fans of the first anime.

to:

* There's also a little bit of this between Ed and [[IdenticalStranger Alfons Alphonse Heiderich]], particularly in the moment before Ed [[spoiler: returns to Amestris]] when Alfons Alphonse takes his hand and makes him promise never to forget him. It's also implied earlier that they share a dresser and maybe even a room. It isn't much, but it's enough to make them one of the more popular [[SlashFic slash]] ships among fans of the first anime.
This list shows the last 10 events of 56. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=HoYay.FullMetalAlchemist