Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DiaryOfAWimpyKid

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the first and second DOAWK books, it's implied that Greg was forced to write in his journal by his mom. However, Greg's on his eleventh journal now(the twelfth being released on November 2017). What happened then?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He's a middle school kid and it was just two or three splotches of paint; I doubt he'd have gotten arrested once they determined it was him. Heck, when he explains exactly what happened to the principal, the principal basically says "you should have told me sooner" and gives him a comparatively light punishment (makes him clean the paint off with inefficient tools). If the police had been the ones to track him down, chances are they'd do what most police do in situations like this: explain it to the kid's parents and let them handle it.

to:

** He's a middle school kid and it was just two or three splotches of paint; I doubt he'd have gotten arrested once they determined it was him. Heck, when he explains exactly what happened to the principal, the principal basically says "you should have told me sooner" and gives him a comparatively light punishment (makes him clean the paint off with inefficient tools). If the police had been the ones to track him down, chances are they'd do what most police do in situations like this: explain it to the kid's parents and let them handle it.it.
* If the school sent home a list of items to bring to Hardscrabble Farms, why didn't it mention a blanket and pillow?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Greg had gotten arrested in ''Cabin Fever'', would he have gotten a trial and been able to defend himself by saying the neon green paint was not his fault, but it was rainy when the posters were put up?

to:

* If Greg had gotten arrested in ''Cabin Fever'', would he have gotten a trial and been able to defend himself by saying the neon green paint was not his fault, but it was rainy when the posters were put up?up?
** He's a middle school kid and it was just two or three splotches of paint; I doubt he'd have gotten arrested once they determined it was him. Heck, when he explains exactly what happened to the principal, the principal basically says "you should have told me sooner" and gives him a comparatively light punishment (makes him clean the paint off with inefficient tools). If the police had been the ones to track him down, chances are they'd do what most police do in situations like this: explain it to the kid's parents and let them handle it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He was also panicking at the time and may have misspelled it accidentally. Face it, even in the Wimpy Kid world, ''nobody'' who can drive a van and made it to high school is gonna not know how to spell "door".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Greg had gotten arrested in ''Cabin Fever'', would he have gotten a trial and been able to defend himself by saying the white paint was not his fault, but it was rainy when the posters were put up?

to:

* If Greg had gotten arrested in ''Cabin Fever'', would he have gotten a trial and been able to defend himself by saying the white neon green paint was not his fault, but it was rainy when the posters were put up?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe some kids got sick and couldn't make it, but the parents decided to go anyway just to be nice.


Added DiffLines:

** A commercial stops making an impression if you just see it again and again year after year. It's better to make a new one. And the repetition of the same basic script is actually pretty realistic--Sunny Delight commercials are one real-life example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Two things: One, he probably doesn't close the door all the way (so the dog an push in - most bedroom doors open ''into'' the room) and two, it's possible that his parents see the dog outside the door and let the dog in.


Added DiffLines:

*** Cross contamination, food going ''bad''?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Usually, if a site asks for the parent's email, it's usually first asked when you register (You see this in literally every browser online game, like Animal Jam or Club Penguin.) so Greg would need the email even to have an account.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of two options: 1) Rowley's AmbiguousDisorder has prompted the school to go against the idea of editing it, whilst ignoring Greg's egomaniac tendencies and possible sociopathy. 2) [[ButtMonkey It's Greg.]] The laws of physics would bend just to '''humiliate the kid.'''

to:

** One of two options: 1) Rowley's AmbiguousDisorder has prompted the school to go against the idea of editing it, whilst ignoring Greg's egomaniac tendencies and possible sociopathy. 2) [[ButtMonkey It's Greg.]] The laws of physics would bend just to '''humiliate the kid.''''''
*If Greg had gotten arrested in ''Cabin Fever'', would he have gotten a trial and been able to defend himself by saying the white paint was not his fault, but it was rainy when the posters were put up?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of two options: 1) Rowley's AmbiguousDisorder has prompted the school to go against the idea of editing it, whilst ignoring Greg's egomaniac tendencies possible sociopathy. 2) [[ButtMonkey It's Greg.]] The laws of physics would bend just to '''humiliate the kid.'''

to:

** One of two options: 1) Rowley's AmbiguousDisorder has prompted the school to go against the idea of editing it, whilst ignoring Greg's egomaniac tendencies and possible sociopathy. 2) [[ButtMonkey It's Greg.]] The laws of physics would bend just to '''humiliate the kid.'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why was Greg's "creighton the cretin" comic edited so much, but Rowley's "Zoo-Wee Mama's" wasn't edited at all?

to:

* Why was Greg's "creighton the cretin" comic edited so much, but Rowley's "Zoo-Wee Mama's" wasn't edited at all?all?
** One of two options: 1) Rowley's AmbiguousDisorder has prompted the school to go against the idea of editing it, whilst ignoring Greg's egomaniac tendencies possible sociopathy. 2) [[ButtMonkey It's Greg.]] The laws of physics would bend just to '''humiliate the kid.'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How can Roderick call himself a rocker and not know how to spell "door", as in "TheDoors"!

to:

* How can Roderick call himself a rocker and not know how to spell "door", as in "TheDoors"!"Music/TheDoors"!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** A shut door isn't the same as a locked door.



** Maybe they believe there's no risk of spreading diseases as long as the leftovers are heated properly.

to:

** Maybe they believe there's no risk of spreading diseases as long as the leftovers are heated properly.properly.
* Why was Greg's "creighton the cretin" comic edited so much, but Rowley's "Zoo-Wee Mama's" wasn't edited at all?

Added: 105

Changed: 276

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He might just type very slowly and his parents decided it's be easier if someone else did it.

to:

** He might just type very slowly and slowly. It's pretty certain that he hasn't put much effort into learning to type, so his typing skills are most likely limited to using the hunt-and-peck method extremely slowly. It's also possible that his horrible spelling skills slow him down further. This makes his parents decided decide it's be easier if someone else did it.does it for him.



** Alternatively, Rodricks parents did try to wake him up, but he managed to sleep through all of their attempts so they stopped trying

to:

** Alternatively, Rodricks Rodrick's parents did try to wake him up, but he managed to sleep through all of their attempts so they stopped trying



** like all sites such as these, yes there is a password recovery system - however remember that Greg is an UnreliableNarrator - he probably doesn't state it because he doesn't ''know'' that it has a Password Recovery system. Alternatively, it might require an email address from his parents - meaning he'll have to ask them.
* I know that Greg is an UnreliableNarrator, but they use all the leftovers that the kids don't eat. Doesn't this strike ''anyone'' as unsanitary?!

to:

** like Like all sites such as these, yes there is a password recovery system - however however, remember that Greg is an UnreliableNarrator - he probably doesn't state it because he doesn't ''know'' that it has a Password Recovery system. Alternatively, it might require an email address from his parents - meaning he'll have to ask them.
* I know that Greg is an UnreliableNarrator, but they use all the leftovers that the kids don't eat. Doesn't this strike ''anyone'' as unsanitary?!unsanitary?!
** Maybe they believe there's no risk of spreading diseases as long as the leftovers are heated properly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** The kids are away for the night, surely some parents would use the opportunity to watch a movie, have a romantic dinner, something, anything having a kid present would prevent or impede.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** like all sites such as these, yes there is a password recovery system - however remember that Greg is an UnreliableNarrator - he probably doesn't state it because he doesn't ''know'' that it has a Password Recovery system. Alternatively, it might require an email address from his parents - meaning he'll have to ask them.

to:

** like all sites such as these, yes there is a password recovery system - however remember that Greg is an UnreliableNarrator - he probably doesn't state it because he doesn't ''know'' that it has a Password Recovery system. Alternatively, it might require an email address from his parents - meaning he'll have to ask them.them.
* I know that Greg is an UnreliableNarrator, but they use all the leftovers that the kids don't eat. Doesn't this strike ''anyone'' as unsanitary?!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively, Rodricks parents did try to wake him up, but he managed to sleep through all of their attempts until they gave up

to:

** Alternatively, Rodricks parents did try to wake him up, but he managed to sleep through all of their attempts until so they gave up stopped trying

Added: 131

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some schools give a four-day weekend over fall, either Monday-Tuesday or Thursday-Friday is off. It could have been during a fall recess - Greg doesn't state specifically ''when'' this happened, only that it was "last fall", so this could have been a "Fall recess". Not only that, but it's likely that, since Greg is an UnreliableNarrator, he left a few things out - As the person above said, you have to remember just ''who'' these parents are, but it's possible their dad didn't throw Rodrick out of bed because Rodrick was sick, and they didn't tell Greg or Manny. (What reason do they have to want to do ''ANYTHING'' with Rodrick anyway?)

to:

** Some schools give a four-day weekend over fall, either Monday-Tuesday or Thursday-Friday is off. It could have been during a fall recess - Greg doesn't state specifically ''when'' this happened, only that it was "last fall", so this could have been a "Fall recess". Not only that, but it's likely that, since Greg is an UnreliableNarrator, he left a few things out - As the person above said, you have to remember just ''who'' these parents are, but it's possible their dad didn't throw Rodrick out of bed because Rodrick was sick, and they didn't tell Greg or Manny. (What reason do they have to want to do ''ANYTHING'' with Rodrick anyway?) anyway?)
** Alternatively, Rodricks parents did try to wake him up, but he managed to sleep through all of their attempts until they gave up
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** 2015 shows sthe return of measles caused by the autism scare. So... still don't believe me that they probably thought Greg would become autistic if he was vaccinated?

Added: 176

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If DOAWK takes place in the modern era, then they probably didn't for fear Greg would become autistic. If anything, I'm surprised Greg and others went through Preschool, kindergarten, ''and'' elementary school ''without'' getting Chicken Pox.

to:

** If DOAWK takes place in the modern era, then they probably didn't for fear Greg would become autistic. If anything, I'm surprised Greg and others went through Preschool, kindergarten, ''and'' elementary school ''without'' getting Chicken Pox.
*** I'm in 8th grade and I've never gotten the Chicken
Pox. AcquiredPoisonImmunity Or Luck. I've been around tons of sick people and never got anymore sick then I've ever been.

Added: 466

Changed: 655

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In book 6, Manny changes Greg's Net Kritterz password so he can't get into his account. Shouldn't the site have a password recovery system?

to:

** Some schools give a four-day weekend over fall, either Monday-Tuesday or Thursday-Friday is off. It could have been during a fall recess - Greg doesn't state specifically ''when'' this happened, only that it was "last fall", so this could have been a "Fall recess". Not only that, but it's likely that, since Greg is an UnreliableNarrator, he left a few things out - As the person above said, you have to remember just ''who'' these parents are, but it's possible their dad didn't throw Rodrick out of bed because Rodrick was sick, and they didn't tell Greg or Manny. (What reason do they have to want to do ''ANYTHING'' with Rodrick anyway?)
* In book 6, Manny changes Greg's Net Kritterz password so he can't get into his account. Shouldn't the site have a password recovery system?system?
** like all sites such as these, yes there is a password recovery system - however remember that Greg is an UnreliableNarrator - he probably doesn't state it because he doesn't ''know'' that it has a Password Recovery system. Alternatively, it might require an email address from his parents - meaning he'll have to ask them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Greg himself lampshaded this in the book, saying that he didn't know you could GET chicken pox anymore, if that makes you feel better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It is possible that the door doesn't lock.



** You're forgetting ''who'' these parents are.

to:

** You're forgetting ''who'' these parents are.are.
* In book 6, Manny changes Greg's Net Kritterz password so he can't get into his account. Shouldn't the site have a password recovery system?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For the last one, it'd be rather hard for him not to notice at some point. If there was nothing else to alert him to it through the week, he'd at least realize it when the weekend comes and he still thinks it's a school day.

to:

** For the last one, it'd be rather hard for him not to notice at some point. If there was nothing else to alert him to it through the week, he'd at least realize it when the weekend comes and he still thinks it's a school day.day.
** You're forgetting ''who'' these parents are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Greg's claim that the longest Rodrick has slept is 36 hours seems very implausible. Lets check some facts: Considering how much their Dad despises laziness from his sons, it doesn't seem likely that Frank would let Rodrick sleep that long and would wake him up around hour 13 at the most. Then it's shown Rodrick asking where Monday Night Football is after he wakes up, so we can assume he sleeps from a Sunday night all the way until Tuesday morning. Since he's wondering where Monday Night Football is, this clearly happened in Fall, hence school is in session. Did Susan and Frank actually let Rodrick miss school just so he could sleep? If they tried to wake him up to no avail, shouldn't they think something was wrong with him and they would call someone? Unless of course this was a Holiday Weekend like Columbus Day. Which brings me to my final and most important point: What kind of asshole parents don't immediately tell their son that he slept through an entire day of his life?????? What if he never noticed??? Would they ever have told him??? Ugh.

to:

* Greg's claim that the longest Rodrick has slept is 36 hours seems very implausible. Lets check some facts: Considering how much their Dad despises laziness from his sons, it doesn't seem likely that Frank would let Rodrick sleep that long and would wake him up around hour 13 at the most. Then it's shown Rodrick asking where Monday Night Football is after he wakes up, so we can assume he sleeps from a Sunday night all the way until Tuesday morning. Since he's wondering where Monday Night Football is, this clearly happened in Fall, hence school is in session. Did Susan and Frank actually let Rodrick miss school just so he could sleep? If they tried to wake him up to no avail, shouldn't they think something was wrong with him and they would call someone? Unless of course this was a Holiday Weekend like Columbus Day. Which brings me to my final and most important point: What kind of asshole parents don't immediately tell their son that he slept through an entire day of his life?????? What if he never noticed??? Would they ever have told him??? Ugh.Ugh.
** For the last one, it'd be rather hard for him not to notice at some point. If there was nothing else to alert him to it through the week, he'd at least realize it when the weekend comes and he still thinks it's a school day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Addition


* Why doesn't Greg just keep his bedroom door shut so the dog can't get to his bed?

to:

* Why doesn't Greg just keep his bedroom door shut so the dog can't get to his bed?bed?
* Greg's claim that the longest Rodrick has slept is 36 hours seems very implausible. Lets check some facts: Considering how much their Dad despises laziness from his sons, it doesn't seem likely that Frank would let Rodrick sleep that long and would wake him up around hour 13 at the most. Then it's shown Rodrick asking where Monday Night Football is after he wakes up, so we can assume he sleeps from a Sunday night all the way until Tuesday morning. Since he's wondering where Monday Night Football is, this clearly happened in Fall, hence school is in session. Did Susan and Frank actually let Rodrick miss school just so he could sleep? If they tried to wake him up to no avail, shouldn't they think something was wrong with him and they would call someone? Unless of course this was a Holiday Weekend like Columbus Day. Which brings me to my final and most important point: What kind of asshole parents don't immediately tell their son that he slept through an entire day of his life?????? What if he never noticed??? Would they ever have told him??? Ugh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He might just type very slowly and his parents decided it's be easier if someone else did it.

to:

** He might just type very slowly and his parents decided it's be easier if someone else did it.it.
* Why doesn't Greg just keep his bedroom door shut so the dog can't get to his bed?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****** Around the time Greg was young, it would have been during that paranoia where people '''a)''' didn't know Autism was something you were born with and '''b)''' read the InsaneTrollLogic that said Vaccines caused autism. Given how stupid the adults are as someone else mentioned, that's probably why Greg wasn't vaccinated - they probably ''believed it''.


Added DiffLines:

** Her parents [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney are rich]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** Besides, autism is something you're born with, not something you can catch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is Rodrick we're talking about. He probably knows how to type at least basically, but acts like he doesn't so that his dad will do it for him.

to:

** This is Rodrick we're talking about. He probably knows how to type at least basically, but acts like he doesn't so that his dad will do it for him.him.
** He might just type very slowly and his parents decided it's be easier if someone else did it.

Top