Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
[[quoteright:245:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/246full_natutulog_pa_ang_diyos_poster.jpg]]
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
de-wicked
Deleted line(s) 29 (click to see context) :
* ForWantOfANail: The Ramirez are completely negligent of Gillian. Patria treats her more like a house slave than a daughter but you are reminded that they're not really related. Had they treated even their own flesh and blood like the way they treat Gillian, Bernardo and Patria would've been considered unacceptable parents and much more outright evil characters, only to be forgiven this time because Gillian's not their real child and are pining for the love of their real son, Andrew.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* BewareTheNiceOnes: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian, [[spoiler:she slaps Patria and screams about it to her face afterwards because Patria was especially cruel to Gillian]]. This action notably shocked everyone in the room.
Deleted line(s) 39 (click to see context) :
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian, [[spoiler:she slaps Patria and screams about it to her face afterwards because Patria was especially cruel to Gillian]]. This action notably shocked everyone in the room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 39 (click to see context) from:
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian, [[spoiler:she slaps Patria, knowing well about the way he treated all that time and screams about it to her face]]. It even shocked her husband to the point of holding her shoulders down lest she got more incensed.
to:
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian, [[spoiler:she slaps Patria, knowing well about the way he treated all that time Patria and screams about it to her face]]. It even face afterwards because Patria was especially cruel to Gillian]]. This action notably shocked her husband to everyone in the point of holding her shoulders down lest she got more incensed.room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 36 (click to see context) from:
* MamaBear[=/=]PapaWolf: The Ramirez' act like this every time they see their son in trouble, to the point of blaming Gillian for something that was clearly his fault just to protect him.
to:
* MamaBear[=/=]PapaWolf: The Ramirez' act like this every time they see their son in trouble, to the point of blaming Gillian for something that was clearly his fault just to protect him. Obviously, it's the rare instance in which this is portrayed negatively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
de-wicked
Deleted line(s) 35 (click to see context) :
* KickTheSonOfABitch: The entire scene with [[spoiler:Gillian beating Lani in the shower]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 10 (click to see context) from:
* AbusiveParents: Gillian's parents, especially her mother. Sure, Patria knows that that's not her real daughter and it's understandable how upsetting it must've been to give up her biological child, but the beatings she gave the poor girl was still uncalled for. Their worst came into head when after Andrew attempted to feel her up and Gillian is obliged to say what happened, they gang up on her back home and Bernardo is the first to hit her before proceeding to give her a verbal lashing.
to:
* AbusiveParents: Gillian's parents, "parents", especially her mother. Sure, Patria knows that that's not her real daughter and it's understandable how upsetting it must've been to give up her biological child, but the beatings she gave the poor girl was still uncalled for. Their worst came into head when after Andrew attempted to feel her up and Gillian is obliged to say what happened, they gang up on her back home and Bernardo is the first to hit her before proceeding to give her a verbal lashing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 35,37 (click to see context) :
%%* {{Jerkass}}: Andrew.
%%** Gillian's parents, Patria and Bernardo.
%%** Lani, her younger sister.
%%** Gillian's parents, Patria and Bernardo.
%%** Lani, her younger sister.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Natutulog Pa Ang Diyos'' (lit. ''God Is Still Sleeping'') is a 1988 Filipino drama film directed by Lino Brocka, based on the original novel of the same name by Ruben R. Marcelino. The film stars Lorna Tolentino, Ricky Davao, Gary Valenciano, Gina Pareño, Dante Rivero, Ricky Belmonte and Maria Zobel.
to:
''Natutulog Pa Ang Diyos'' (lit. ''God Is Still Sleeping'') is a 1988 Filipino drama film directed by Lino Brocka, Creator/LinoBrocka, based on the original novel of the same name by Ruben R. Marcelino. The film stars Lorna Tolentino, Ricky Davao, Gary Valenciano, Gina Pareño, Dante Rivero, Ricky Belmonte and Maria Zobel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Incest Is Relative is an index, not a trope
Changed line(s) 35,38 (click to see context) from:
* IncestIsRelative: Mr. Velasco gave Andrew the choice whether to live with his real parents or stay with them under the condition that he comes to love and welcome Gillian as his sister. Nobody seems to comment on his actions towards her prior to everyone knowing the truth (i.e. peeping at her in the shower, trying to kiss her while doing laundry, and the climax in which he [[spoiler:attempted to rape her). Fortunately, he chose the former]].
* {{Jerkass}}: Andrew.
** Gillian's parents, Patria and Bernardo.
** Lani, her younger sister.
* {{Jerkass}}: Andrew.
** Gillian's parents, Patria and Bernardo.
** Lani, her younger sister.
to:
*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,6 (click to see context) from:
''Natutulog Pa Ang Diyos'' (lit. ''God Is Still Sleeping'') is a 1988 Filipino drama film based on the original novel of the same name by Ruben R. Marcelino.
Patria Ramirez and and their boss's wife Rose Velasco give birth together during a dark and stormy night while driving towards the hospital. The midwife makes it clear that he has a son while the other had a daughter. To ensure that their son will have a better life and not having to suffer poverty and hardship like they did, [[SwitchedAtBirth he decides to give the son to Rose, making her and their boss think that she had given birth to a boy]], eventually Christened as "Andrew", while only he and his wife know about this. As a result, the children grow distant from their families and out of frustration of having to give up her real child, resorts to maltreating Gillian, the Velasco's real child. However, the children who were not aware of being switched at birth find themselves drawn closer to each other's respective parents. Gillian finds comfort with Andrew's mother and vice versa. She eventually finds comfort with Mark, a rich suitor. Jealous of Gillian's new found attention, Andrew decides to force himself on Gillian, an act which leads to the revelation of the secret of their parentage.
Patria Ramirez and and their boss's wife Rose Velasco give birth together during a dark and stormy night while driving towards the hospital. The midwife makes it clear that he has a son while the other had a daughter. To ensure that their son will have a better life and not having to suffer poverty and hardship like they did, [[SwitchedAtBirth he decides to give the son to Rose, making her and their boss think that she had given birth to a boy]], eventually Christened as "Andrew", while only he and his wife know about this. As a result, the children grow distant from their families and out of frustration of having to give up her real child, resorts to maltreating Gillian, the Velasco's real child. However, the children who were not aware of being switched at birth find themselves drawn closer to each other's respective parents. Gillian finds comfort with Andrew's mother and vice versa. She eventually finds comfort with Mark, a rich suitor. Jealous of Gillian's new found attention, Andrew decides to force himself on Gillian, an act which leads to the revelation of the secret of their parentage.
to:
''Natutulog Pa Ang Diyos'' (lit. ''God Is Still Sleeping'') is a 1988 Filipino drama film directed by Lino Brocka, based on the original novel of the same name by Ruben R. Marcelino.
Marcelino. The film stars Lorna Tolentino, Ricky Davao, Gary Valenciano, Gina Pareño, Dante Rivero, Ricky Belmonte and Maria Zobel.
Patria Ramirez (Pareño) and and their boss's wife Rose Velasco (Zobel) give birth together during a dark and stormy night while driving towards the hospital. The midwife makes it clear that he has a son while the other had a daughter. To ensure that their son will have a better life and not having to suffer poverty and hardship like theydid, did, Bernardo (Rivero) decides to [[SwitchedAtBirth he decides to give the son to Rose, making her and their boss think that she had given birth to a boy]], eventually Christened as "Andrew", "Andrew" (Davao), while only he and his wife know about this. As a result, the children grow distant from their families and out of frustration of having to give up her real child, resorts to maltreating Gillian, Gillian (Tolentino), the Velasco's real child. However, the children who were not aware of being switched at birth find themselves drawn closer to each other's respective parents. Gillian finds comfort with Andrew's mother and vice versa. She eventually finds comfort with Mark, Mark (Valenciano), a rich suitor. Jealous of Gillian's new found attention, Andrew decides to force himself on Gillian, an act which leads to the revelation of the secret of their parentage.
Patria Ramirez (Pareño) and and their boss's wife Rose Velasco (Zobel) give birth together during a dark and stormy night while driving towards the hospital. The midwife makes it clear that he has a son while the other had a daughter. To ensure that their son will have a better life and not having to suffer poverty and hardship like they
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 14 (click to see context) from:
* BigScrewedUpFamily: The Ramirez', to dramatic effect. The parents beat the eldest and intentionally ignore her, the second daughter is a whiny brat that inherited the mother's negative qualities, and the youngest son is forced to have no say about the abuse they hand out to Gilliana and even gets beaten as well for trying to interfere.
to:
* BigScrewedUpFamily: BigScrewedUpFamily:
** The Ramirez', to dramatic effect. The parents beat the eldest and intentionally ignore her, the second daughter is a whiny brat that inherited the mother's negative qualities, and the youngest son is forced to have no say about the abuse they hand out toGilliana Gillian and even gets beaten as well for trying to interfere.
** The Ramirez', to dramatic effect. The parents beat the eldest and intentionally ignore her, the second daughter is a whiny brat that inherited the mother's negative qualities, and the youngest son is forced to have no say about the abuse they hand out to
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 21 (click to see context) :
* DumbMuscle: Andrew. He exercises, sure, but could never get the upper hand when it comes to hand to hand combat.
Added DiffLines:
* MusclesAreMeaningless: Andrew. He exercises, sure, but is overpowered by the less-imposing Mark.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 10 (click to see context) :
* TheEighties
Changed line(s) 12 (click to see context) from:
* ArsonMurderAndLifesaving: {{Inverted}}. [[spoiler: Mrs. Velasco first insisted they accept her payment for having raised Gillian. Then she delivers an open-palmed slap to Patria for all the pain and suffering they gave her]].
to:
* ArsonMurderAndLifesaving: {{Inverted}}. [[spoiler: Mrs.[[spoiler:Mrs. Velasco first insisted they accept her payment for having raised Gillian. Then she delivers an open-palmed slap to Patria for all the pain and suffering they gave her]].
Changed line(s) 14 (click to see context) from:
** [[spoiler: The moment Gillian figured out that Lani had thrown away Mark's presents for her incurred her wrath. [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge The results are not pretty]]]].
to:
** [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The moment Gillian figured out that Lani had thrown away Mark's presents for her incurred her wrath. [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge The results are not pretty]]]].
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
* TheDogBitesBack: It was the last straw for Gillian when she found out Lani decided to not let her know about the chocolates that Mark brought for her [Gillian] and [[spoiler: quickly proceeds to torment her in the shower while at the same time, makes her confess about stealing the jewelry her mother planned on selling herself]].
to:
* TheDogBitesBack: It was the last straw for Gillian when she found out Lani decided to not let her know about the chocolates that Mark brought for her [Gillian] and [[spoiler: quickly [[spoiler:quickly proceeds to torment her in the shower while at the same time, makes her confess about stealing the jewelry her mother planned on selling herself]].
Changed line(s) 23,24 (click to see context) from:
* EarnYourHappyEnding: [[spoiler: The truth was out and Gillian and Andrew are back in their rightful families. Gillian also married Mark by the end]].
* EasilyForgiven: Subverted. [[spoiler: Bernardo begs for Gillian to forgive him and Patria for treating her so horribly after they put her back to her rightful parents. She then runs off, explaining to Mark that she's not yet ready to do so because she put up with their abuse for so long and needed some time to think about it. They're still invited to her wedding in the end, though]].
* EasilyForgiven: Subverted. [[spoiler: Bernardo begs for Gillian to forgive him and Patria for treating her so horribly after they put her back to her rightful parents. She then runs off, explaining to Mark that she's not yet ready to do so because she put up with their abuse for so long and needed some time to think about it. They're still invited to her wedding in the end, though]].
to:
* EarnYourHappyEnding: [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The truth was out and Gillian and Andrew are back in their rightful families. Gillian also married Mark by the end]].
* EasilyForgiven: Subverted.[[spoiler: Bernardo [[spoiler:Bernardo begs for Gillian to forgive him and Patria for treating her so horribly after they put her back to her rightful parents. She then runs off, explaining to Mark that she's not yet ready to do so because she put up with their abuse for so long and needed some time to think about it. They're still invited to her wedding in the end, though]].
* EasilyForgiven: Subverted.
Changed line(s) 27 (click to see context) from:
* FilmOfTheBook
to:
* FilmOfTheBookFilmOfTheBook: Based on an original novel by Ruben R. Marcelino.
Changed line(s) 30 (click to see context) from:
* FreudianExcuse: Your husband forcing you to give up your first-born son and to be quiet about it can practically excuse your maltreatment of the "daughter" you never even had in the first place.
to:
* FreudianExcuse: Your husband forcing you to give up your first-born son and to be quiet about it can practically ''somewhat'' excuse your maltreatment of the "daughter" you never even had in the first place.
Changed line(s) 32 (click to see context) from:
* GoodParents: Rose Velasco is the only decent parent seen for the most part, and genuinely loved Andrew [[spoiler: and still does even after knowing that he was not their real son]]. Before that, she never beat him and even when she didn't know yet that Gillian was her real daughter, she treated her much more tenderly as if she was her own.
to:
* GoodParents: Rose Velasco is the only decent parent seen for the most part, and genuinely loved Andrew [[spoiler: and [[spoiler:and still does even after knowing that he was not their real son]]. Before that, she never beat him and even when she didn't know yet that Gillian was her real daughter, she treated her much more tenderly as if she was her own.
Changed line(s) 34,36 (click to see context) from:
* GrewASpine: Gillian, after meeting Mark who advises her to at least fight back. Notoriously cemented when [[spoiler: she beats Lani, having deceived her for the last time when she purposely hid the fact about Mark coming to their house to give Gillian flowers and a box of chocolates]].
* GroinAttack: [[spoiler: Gillian does this to Andrew to get out of having him force himself on her]].
* IncestIsRelative: Mr. Velasco gave Andrew the choice whether to live with his real parents or stay with them under the condition that he comes to love and welcome Gillian as his sister. Nobody seems to comment on his actions towards her prior to everyone knowing the truth (i.e. peeping at her in the shower, trying to kiss her while doing laundry, and the climax in which he [[spoiler: attempted to rape her). Fortunately, he chose the former]].
* GroinAttack: [[spoiler: Gillian does this to Andrew to get out of having him force himself on her]].
* IncestIsRelative: Mr. Velasco gave Andrew the choice whether to live with his real parents or stay with them under the condition that he comes to love and welcome Gillian as his sister. Nobody seems to comment on his actions towards her prior to everyone knowing the truth (i.e. peeping at her in the shower, trying to kiss her while doing laundry, and the climax in which he [[spoiler: attempted to rape her). Fortunately, he chose the former]].
to:
* GrewASpine: Gillian, after meeting Mark who advises her to at least fight back. Notoriously cemented when [[spoiler: she [[spoiler:she beats Lani, having deceived her for the last time when she purposely hid the fact about Mark coming to their house to give Gillian flowers and a box of chocolates]].
* GroinAttack:[[spoiler: Gillian [[spoiler:Gillian does this to Andrew to get out of having him force himself on her]].
* IncestIsRelative: Mr. Velasco gave Andrew the choice whether to live with his real parents or stay with them under the condition that he comes to love and welcome Gillian as his sister. Nobody seems to comment on his actions towards her prior to everyone knowing the truth (i.e. peeping at her in the shower, trying to kiss her while doing laundry, and the climax in which he[[spoiler: attempted [[spoiler:attempted to rape her). Fortunately, he chose the former]].
* GroinAttack:
* IncestIsRelative: Mr. Velasco gave Andrew the choice whether to live with his real parents or stay with them under the condition that he comes to love and welcome Gillian as his sister. Nobody seems to comment on his actions towards her prior to everyone knowing the truth (i.e. peeping at her in the shower, trying to kiss her while doing laundry, and the climax in which he
Changed line(s) 40 (click to see context) from:
* KickTheSonOfABitch: The entire scene with [[spoiler: Gillian beating Lani in the shower]].
to:
* KickTheSonOfABitch: The entire scene with [[spoiler: Gillian [[spoiler:Gillian beating Lani in the shower]].
Changed line(s) 43,45 (click to see context) from:
* AMinorKidroduction
* NiceGuy: Mark, notably. Gillian's "younger brother" Boy as well given that he's the only one in the family that didn't treat her like dirt, to the point of protecting her when their mother gets too out of hand with beating her.
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian, [[spoiler: she slaps Patria, knowing well about the way he treated all that time and screams about it to her face]]. It even shocked her husband to the point of holding her shoulders down lest she got more incensed.
* NiceGuy: Mark, notably. Gillian's "younger brother" Boy as well given that he's the only one in the family that didn't treat her like dirt, to the point of protecting her when their mother gets too out of hand with beating her.
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian, [[spoiler: she slaps Patria, knowing well about the way he treated all that time and screams about it to her face]]. It even shocked her husband to the point of holding her shoulders down lest she got more incensed.
to:
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian,
Changed line(s) 48 (click to see context) from:
* PrecisionFStrike: Bernardo fed up with the way Andrew is treating him decides to deliver the news that goes by the line "This fucking old man is your father" (note that this quote is obviously translated for convenience).
to:
* PrecisionFStrike: Bernardo fed up with the way Andrew is treating him decides to deliver the news that goes by the line "This fucking old man is your father" (note that this quote is obviously translated father".[[labelnote:*]](translated for convenience). the readers' convenience)[[/labelnote]]
Changed line(s) 50 (click to see context) from:
* TheReveal: [[spoiler: The birthmark both Bernardo and Andrew have on their feet as a damning evidence to confirm who's child is whom]].
to:
* TheReveal: [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The birthmark both Bernardo and Andrew have on their feet as a damning evidence to confirm who's child is whom]].
Changed line(s) 52 (click to see context) from:
* SpoiledBrat: Andrew, as a kid. He doesn't grow out of it unfortunately, making him a [[BrattyTeenageDaughter Bratty]] [[SpearCounterpart Young Adult Son]] later. [[spoiler: Only until the end was when he realized his mistakes]].
to:
* SpoiledBrat: Andrew, as a kid. He doesn't grow out of it unfortunately, making him a [[BrattyTeenageDaughter Bratty]] [[SpearCounterpart Young Adult Son]] later. [[spoiler: Only [[spoiler:Only until the end was when he realized his mistakes]].
Changed line(s) 55 (click to see context) from:
* TookALevelInBadass: [[spoiler: Gillian beating Lani for not telling her about Mark's presents for her and for having been terribly {{Misblamed}} for stealing the jewelry]].
to:
* TookALevelInBadass: [[spoiler: Gillian [[spoiler:Gillian beating Lani for not telling her about Mark's presents for her and for having been terribly {{Misblamed}} blamed for stealing the jewelry]].
Changed line(s) 57 (click to see context) from:
* WouldHurtAChild: Patria's treatment of Gillian, to an infuriating degree.
to:
* WouldHurtAChild: Patria's treatment of young Gillian, to an infuriating degree.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
'''''Natutulog Pa Ang Diyos''''' (lit. ''God Is Still Sleeping'') is a 1988 Filipino drama film based on the original novel of the same name by Ruben R. Marcelino.
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* TheEighties
Deleted line(s) 11 (click to see context) :
** A justified case with Andrew's father because his son has almost no ambition and talks back. Even lampshaded by the mother at one point which implied, while she doesn't like him to be seen hurt, she's not disapproving of her husbands way of disciplining him either.
Deleted line(s) 21 (click to see context) :
* DidNotThinkThisThrough: The baby switch. Only Mrs. Velasco was unconscious enough to be unaware of the true gender of the baby she gave birth to, but Patria wasn't, meaning Bernardo didn't know the consequences of having to forcefully separate a child from a mother who was clearly against it. See WhatTheHellHero.
Changed line(s) 26,27 (click to see context) from:
* TheEighties
* EvenEvilHasStandards: He may not be a complete monster, but Bernardo is apparently not okay with Patria forcing Gillian to work at the club to be a call girl and calls her out on it for doing so, telling her not to make her go back there again. Understandable considering that Patria used to work there herself as shown in the beginning and he never really accepted the kind of work she did even back then.
* EvenEvilHasStandards: He may not be a complete monster, but Bernardo is apparently not okay with Patria forcing Gillian to work at the club to be a call girl and calls her out on it for doing so, telling her not to make her go back there again. Understandable considering that Patria used to work there herself as shown in the beginning and he never really accepted the kind of work she did even back then.
to:
Deleted line(s) 53 (click to see context) :
* SanitySlippage: Not much, but Patria is right to the point of breaking a nerve the more she beat and shouted Gillian. Still forced to keep quiet about the switch doesn't help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleted line(s) 56 (click to see context) :
* SpoiledSweet: Mark, a rich suitor that upon seeing Gillian being forced into working at the club, decides to get her as far away from the place as possible. He proves to be of help later on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
''Natutulog Pa Ang Diyos'' (lit. ''God Is Still Sleeping'') is a 1988 Filipino drama film based on the original novel of the same name by Ruben R. Marcelino.
to:
'''''Natutulog Pa Ang
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ScreamingBirth: Rose gives birth this way in a stretched-out scene. Averted with Patria who, while obviously in pain from labor, gives birth much more quietly alongside the screaming Rose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* {{Foil}}: The Ramirez parents to the Velasco parents. Both don't get along with their children, but the former's horrible treatment of their mostly timid daughter contrasts with the latter's much more sensible disciplining of their out of control son.
** Gillian's parents, Patria and Bernardo.
** Lani, her younger sister.
** Lani, her younger sister.
Changed line(s) 51 (click to see context) from:
* SwitchedAtBirth: The main premise of the film. Later {{deconstructed}}.
to:
* SwitchedAtBirth: The main premise of the film. Later {{deconstructed}}.
Deleted line(s) 54 (click to see context) :
* WhatTheHellHero: Maybe "hero" is no way to put him, but Bernardo switching the babies at birth still counts. What's worse, Patria knows that she gave birth to a boy and cannot be fooled. No amount of pleading from her would change his mind though and as the years went by, she becomes emotionally unstable, taking her frustrations out on her "supposed" daughter by beating her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
'''''Natutulog Pa Ang Diyos''''' (lit. ''God Is Still Sleeping'') is a 1988 Filipino drama film based on the original novel of the same name by Ruben R. Marcelino.
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 10 (click to see context) :
* AMinorKidroduction.
Added DiffLines:
* AMinorKidroduction
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 36 (click to see context) from:
* IncestIsRelative: Mr. Velasco gave Andrew the choice whether to live with his real parents or stay with them under the condition that he comes to love and welcome Gillian as his sister. Nobody seems to comment on his actions towards her prior to everyone knowing the truth (i.e. peeping at her in the shower, trying to kiss her while doing laundry, and the climax in which he [[spoiler: attempted to rape her]]). Fortunately, he chose the former]].
to:
* IncestIsRelative: Mr. Velasco gave Andrew the choice whether to live with his real parents or stay with them under the condition that he comes to love and welcome Gillian as his sister. Nobody seems to comment on his actions towards her prior to everyone knowing the truth (i.e. peeping at her in the shower, trying to kiss her while doing laundry, and the climax in which he [[spoiler: attempted to rape her]]).her). Fortunately, he chose the former]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* EasilyForgiven: Subverted. [[spoiler: Bernardo begs for Gillian to forgive him and Patria for treating her so horribly after they put her back to her rightful parents. She then runs off, explaining to Mark that she's not yet ready to do so because she put up with their abuse for so long and needed some time to think about it. They're still invited to her wedding in the end, though]].
Deleted line(s) 25 (click to see context) :
* EasilyForgiven: Subverted. [[spoiler: Bernardo begs for Gillian to forgive him and Patria for treating her so horribly after they put her back to her rightful parents. She then runs off, explaining to Mark that she's not yet ready to do so because she put up with their abuse for so long and needed some time to think about it. They're still invited to her wedding in the end, though]].
Added DiffLines:
* IncestIsRelative: Mr. Velasco gave Andrew the choice whether to live with his real parents or stay with them under the condition that he comes to love and welcome Gillian as his sister. Nobody seems to comment on his actions towards her prior to everyone knowing the truth (i.e. peeping at her in the shower, trying to kiss her while doing laundry, and the climax in which he [[spoiler: attempted to rape her]]). Fortunately, he chose the former]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* LukeIAmYourFather: A PrecisionFStrike variant as quoted on the said trope below.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 11 (click to see context) from:
* ArsonMurderAndLifeSaving: {{Inverted}}. [[spoiler: Mrs. Velasco first insisted they accept her payment for having raised Gillian. Then she delivers an open-palmed slap to Patria for all the pain and suffering they gave her]].
to:
* ArsonMurderAndLifeSaving: ArsonMurderAndLifesaving: {{Inverted}}. [[spoiler: Mrs. Velasco first insisted they accept her payment for having raised Gillian. Then she delivers an open-palmed slap to Patria for all the pain and suffering they gave her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* ArsonMurderAndLifeSaving: {{Inverted}}. [[spoiler: Mrs. Velasco first insisted they accept her payment for having raised Gillian. Then she delivers an open-palmed slap to Patria for all the pain and suffering they gave her]].
* BerserkButton: Both Andrew's real parents won't stand by seeing Andrew offended or in trouble. They take it out on Gillian, as a result, especially if she was involved in said trouble.
** [[spoiler: The moment Gillian figured out that Lani had thrown away Mark's presents for her incurred her wrath. [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge The results are not pretty]]]].
* BigScrewedUpFamily: The Ramirez', to dramatic effect. The parents beat the eldest and intentionally ignore her, the second daughter is a whiny brat that inherited the mother's negative qualities, and the youngest son is forced to have no say about the abuse they hand out to Gilliana and even gets beaten as well for trying to interfere.
** The Velasco's are a downplayed version because of only having one child and said child being rather lazy and back sasses results in a fight between father and son with the mother standing on the sidelines.
* BerserkButton: Both Andrew's real parents won't stand by seeing Andrew offended or in trouble. They take it out on Gillian, as a result, especially if she was involved in said trouble.
** [[spoiler: The moment Gillian figured out that Lani had thrown away Mark's presents for her incurred her wrath. [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge The results are not pretty]]]].
* BigScrewedUpFamily: The Ramirez', to dramatic effect. The parents beat the eldest and intentionally ignore her, the second daughter is a whiny brat that inherited the mother's negative qualities, and the youngest son is forced to have no say about the abuse they hand out to Gilliana and even gets beaten as well for trying to interfere.
** The Velasco's are a downplayed version because of only having one child and said child being rather lazy and back sasses results in a fight between father and son with the mother standing on the sidelines.
* DidNotThinkThisThrough: The baby switch. Only Mrs. Velasco was unconscious enough to be unaware of the true gender of the baby she gave birth to, but Patria wasn't, meaning Bernardo didn't know the consequences of having to forcefully separate a child from a mother who was clearly against it. See WhatTheHellHero.
Deleted line(s) 16 (click to see context) :
* DidNotThinkThisThrough: The baby switch. Only Mrs. Velasco was unconscious enough to be unaware of the true gender of the baby she gave birth to, but Patria wasn't. See WhatTheHellHero.
* ForWantOfANail: The Ramirez are completely negligent of Gillian. Patria treats her more like a house slave than a daughter but you are reminded that they're not really related. Had they treated even their own flesh and blood like the way they treat Gillian, Bernardo and Patria would've been considered unacceptable parents and much more outright evil characters, only to be forgiven this time because Gillian's not their real child and are pining for the love of their real son, Andrew.
* GrewASpine: Gillian, after meeting Mark who advises her to at least fight back. Notoriously cemented when [[spoiler: she beats Lani, having deceived her for the last time when she purposely hid the fact about Mark coming to their house to give Gillian flowers and a box of chocolates]].
Changed line(s) 30 (click to see context) from:
* MamaBear[=/=]PapaWolf: The Ramirez' act like this every time they see their son in trouble, to the point of blaming Gillian for something that was clearly his fault.
to:
* KickTheSonOfABitch: The entire scene with [[spoiler: Gillian beating Lani in the shower]].
* MamaBear[=/=]PapaWolf: The Ramirez' act like this every time they see their son in trouble, to the point of blaming Gillian for something that was clearly hisfault.fault just to protect him.
* NiceGuy: Mark, notably. Gillian's "younger brother" Boy as well given that he's the only one in the family that didn't treat her like dirt, to the point of protecting her when their mother gets too out of hand with beating her.
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian, [[spoiler: she slaps Patria, knowing well about the way he treated all that time and screams about it to her face]]. It even shocked her husband to the point of holding her shoulders down lest she got more incensed.
* MamaBear[=/=]PapaWolf: The Ramirez' act like this every time they see their son in trouble, to the point of blaming Gillian for something that was clearly his
* NiceGuy: Mark, notably. Gillian's "younger brother" Boy as well given that he's the only one in the family that didn't treat her like dirt, to the point of protecting her when their mother gets too out of hand with beating her.
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Mrs. Rose Velasco for the most part in the movie is very timid and soft-spoken, never raising her hand to the point of pacifism. Yet after truth came out and pays the Ramirez' out of the kindness of her heart for raising Gillian, [[spoiler: she slaps Patria, knowing well about the way he treated all that time and screams about it to her face]]. It even shocked her husband to the point of holding her shoulders down lest she got more incensed.
* PrecisionFStrike: Bernardo fed up with the way Andrew is treating him decides to deliver the news that goes by the line "This fucking old man is your father" (note that this quote is obviously translated for convenience).
* SanitySlippage: Not much, but Patria is right to the point of breaking a nerve the more she beat and shouted Gillian. Still forced to keep quiet about the switch doesn't help.
* TokenGoodTeammate: Boy, of the entire Ramirez family.
Changed line(s) 39 (click to see context) from:
* WhatTheHellHero: Maybe "hero" is no way to put it, but Bernardo switching the babies at birth was the most terrible thing he had done. What's worse, Patria knows that she gave birth to a boy and cannot be fooled. No amount of pleading from her would change his mind though and as the years went by, she becomes emotionally unstable, taking her frustrations out on her "supposed" daughter by beating her.
to:
* WhatTheHellHero: Maybe "hero" is no way to put it, him, but Bernardo switching the babies at birth was the most terrible thing he had done.still counts. What's worse, Patria knows that she gave birth to a boy and cannot be fooled. No amount of pleading from her would change his mind though and as the years went by, she becomes emotionally unstable, taking her frustrations out on her "supposed" daughter by beating her.
Added DiffLines:
* WouldHurtAChild: Patria's treatment of Gillian, to an infuriating degree.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
Patria Ramirez and and their boss's wife Rose Velasco give birth together during a dark and stormy night while driving towards the hospital. The midwife makes it clear that he has a son while the other had a daughter. To ensure that their son will have a better life, he decides to give the son to Rose, making her and their boss think that she had given birth to a boy, eventually Christened as "Andrew", while only he and his wife know about this. As a result, the children grow distant from their families and out of frustration of having to give up her real child, resorts to maltreating Gillian, the Velasco's real child. However, the children who were not aware of being switched at birth find themselves drawn closer to each other's respective parents. Gillian finds comfort with Andrew's mother and vice versa. She eventually finds comfort with Mark, a rich suitor. Jealous of Gillian's new found attention, Andrew decides to force himself on Gillian, an act which leads to the revelation of the secret of their parentage.
to:
Patria Ramirez and and their boss's wife Rose Velasco give birth together during a dark and stormy night while driving towards the hospital. The midwife makes it clear that he has a son while the other had a daughter. To ensure that their son will have a better life, life and not having to suffer poverty and hardship like they did, [[SwitchedAtBirth he decides to give the son to Rose, making her and their boss think that she had given birth to a boy, boy]], eventually Christened as "Andrew", while only he and his wife know about this. As a result, the children grow distant from their families and out of frustration of having to give up her real child, resorts to maltreating Gillian, the Velasco's real child. However, the children who were not aware of being switched at birth find themselves drawn closer to each other's respective parents. Gillian finds comfort with Andrew's mother and vice versa. She eventually finds comfort with Mark, a rich suitor. Jealous of Gillian's new found attention, Andrew decides to force himself on Gillian, an act which leads to the revelation of the secret of their parentage.
Changed line(s) 27 (click to see context) from:
** The Velasco parents in general. Because Andrew is a spoiled, irresponsible {{jerkass}} of a son that talks back to his father and refuses to do better in his studies, you can't blame Mike for having to lay a hand upon him at least once. And he never beats him senselessly, [[AbusiveParents unlike Patria towards Gillian]].
to:
** The Velasco parents in general. general, including the father. Because Andrew is a spoiled, irresponsible {{jerkass}} of a son that talks back to his father and refuses to do better in his studies, you can't blame Mike for having to lay a hand upon hit him at least once. And when he does, it's never beats him senselessly, [[AbusiveParents unlike Patria towards Gillian]].
Added DiffLines:
* TheReveal: [[spoiler: The birthmark both Bernardo and Andrew have on their feet as a damning evidence to confirm who's child is whom]].
Added DiffLines:
* SwitchedAtBirth: The main premise of the film. Later {{deconstructed}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* MamaBear[=/=]PapaWolf: The Ramirez' act like this every time they see their son in trouble, to the point of blaming Gillian for something that was clearly his fault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
'''''Natutulog Pa Ang Diyos''''' (lit. ''God Is Still Sleeping'') is a 1988 Filipino drama film based on the original novel of the same name by Ruben R. Marcelino.
Patria Ramirez and and their boss's wife Rose Velasco give birth together during a dark and stormy night while driving towards the hospital. The midwife makes it clear that he has a son while the other had a daughter. To ensure that their son will have a better life, he decides to give the son to Rose, making her and their boss think that she had given birth to a boy, eventually Christened as "Andrew", while only he and his wife know about this. As a result, the children grow distant from their families and out of frustration of having to give up her real child, resorts to maltreating Gillian, the Velasco's real child. However, the children who were not aware of being switched at birth find themselves drawn closer to each other's respective parents. Gillian finds comfort with Andrew's mother and vice versa. She eventually finds comfort with Mark, a rich suitor. Jealous of Gillian's new found attention, Andrew decides to force himself on Gillian, an act which leads to the revelation of the secret of their parentage.
It was remade in 2007 as a TV series entitled ''Natutulog Ba Ang Diyos?'' (lit. ''[[QuestioningTitle Is God Still Sleeping?]]'')
----
!!Provides examples of:
* AbusiveParents: Gillian's parents, especially her mother. Sure, Patria knows that that's not her real daughter and it's understandable how upsetting it must've been to give up her biological child, but the beatings she gave the poor girl was still uncalled for. Their worst came into head when after Andrew attempted to feel her up and Gillian is obliged to say what happened, they gang up on her back home and Bernardo is the first to hit her before proceeding to give her a verbal lashing.
** A justified case with Andrew's father because his son has almost no ambition and talks back. Even lampshaded by the mother at one point which implied, while she doesn't like him to be seen hurt, she's not disapproving of her husbands way of disciplining him either.
* AMinorKidroduction.
* BigSisterBully: Inverted. Lani is one of the causes of Gillian's suffering, like whining to her about not ironing her uniform and other things she supposedly forgot to do for her. If anything, she plays the trope straight with her treatment towards her younger brother, Boy.
* BrattyHalfPint: The young Andrew.
* BrattyTeenageDaughter: Lani, oh so much. She takes her mouthiness after her mother.
* CurbStompBattle: Any fight with Andrew results into this. He always ended up losing..
* TheDogBitesBack: It was the last straw for Gillian when she found out Lani decided to not let her know about the chocolates that Mark brought for her [Gillian] and [[spoiler: quickly proceeds to torment her in the shower while at the same time, makes her confess about stealing the jewelry her mother planned on selling herself]].
* DidNotThinkThisThrough: The baby switch. Only Mrs. Velasco was unconscious enough to be unaware of the true gender of the baby she gave birth to, but Patria wasn't. See WhatTheHellHero.
* DumbMuscle: Andrew. He exercises, sure, but could never get the upper hand when it comes to hand to hand combat.
* EarnYourHappyEnding: [[spoiler: The truth was out and Gillian and Andrew are back in their rightful families. Gillian also married Mark by the end]].
* TheEighties
* EasilyForgiven: Subverted. [[spoiler: Bernardo begs for Gillian to forgive him and Patria for treating her so horribly after they put her back to her rightful parents. She then runs off, explaining to Mark that she's not yet ready to do so because she put up with their abuse for so long and needed some time to think about it. They're still invited to her wedding in the end, though]].
* EvenEvilHasStandards: He may not be a complete monster, but Bernardo is apparently not okay with Patria forcing Gillian to work at the club to be a call girl and calls her out on it for doing so, telling her not to make her go back there again. Understandable considering that Patria used to work there herself as shown in the beginning and he never really accepted the kind of work she did even back then.
* FairytaleWeddingDress: [[spoiler: Gillian when she was marrying Mark. The gown she wore, even by the standards of the 80s, couldn't get any more ambitious than that]].
* FilmOfTheBook
* FreudianExcuse: Your husband forcing you to give up your first-born son and to be quiet about it can practically excuse your maltreatment of the "daughter" you never even had in the first place.
* FreudianSlip: Patria delves into this several times, especially her [[ParentalFavoritism treatment towards Andrew]] and when introducing Boy as a baby, she almost said he's his brother.
* GoodParents: Rose Velasco is the only decent parent seen for the most part, and genuinely loved Andrew [[spoiler: and still does even after knowing that he was not their real son]]. Before that, she never beat him and even when she didn't know yet that Gillian was her real daughter, she treated her much more tenderly as if she was her own.
** The Velasco parents in general. Because Andrew is a spoiled, irresponsible {{jerkass}} of a son that talks back to his father and refuses to do better in his studies, you can't blame Mike for having to lay a hand upon him at least once. And he never beats him senselessly, [[AbusiveParents unlike Patria towards Gillian]].
* GroinAttack: [[spoiler: Gillian does this to Andrew to get out of having him force himself on her]].
* {{Jerkass}}: Andrew.
* ParentalNeglect: Her treatment of Gillian when ''not'' physically abusing her. As a baby though, she deliberately distanced herself from her.
* PetTheDog: Bernardo and Patria still have a soft spot for their biological son, Andrew, even when they saw that he's turning out to be a SpoiledBrat, which worries them to no end, especially Bernardo who saw that he's not turning out the way they'd hoped.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Mr. and Mrs. Velasco.
* SpoiledBrat: Andrew, as a kid. He doesn't grow out of it unfortunately, making him a [[BrattyTeenageDaughter Bratty]] [[SpearCounterpart Young Adult Son]] later. [[spoiler: Only until the end was when he realized his mistakes]].
* SpoiledSweet: Mark, a rich suitor that upon seeing Gillian being forced into working at the club, decides to get her as far away from the place as possible. He proves to be of help later on.
* TookALevelInBadass: [[spoiler: Gillian beating Lani for not telling her about Mark's presents for her and for having been terribly {{Misblamed}} for stealing the jewelry]].
* WhatTheHellHero: Maybe "hero" is no way to put it, but Bernardo switching the babies at birth was the most terrible thing he had done. What's worse, Patria knows that she gave birth to a boy and cannot be fooled. No amount of pleading from her would change his mind though and as the years went by, she becomes emotionally unstable, taking her frustrations out on her "supposed" daughter by beating her.
* WhoNamesTheirKidDude: Boy, Gillian's younger "brother".
----
Patria Ramirez and and their boss's wife Rose Velasco give birth together during a dark and stormy night while driving towards the hospital. The midwife makes it clear that he has a son while the other had a daughter. To ensure that their son will have a better life, he decides to give the son to Rose, making her and their boss think that she had given birth to a boy, eventually Christened as "Andrew", while only he and his wife know about this. As a result, the children grow distant from their families and out of frustration of having to give up her real child, resorts to maltreating Gillian, the Velasco's real child. However, the children who were not aware of being switched at birth find themselves drawn closer to each other's respective parents. Gillian finds comfort with Andrew's mother and vice versa. She eventually finds comfort with Mark, a rich suitor. Jealous of Gillian's new found attention, Andrew decides to force himself on Gillian, an act which leads to the revelation of the secret of their parentage.
It was remade in 2007 as a TV series entitled ''Natutulog Ba Ang Diyos?'' (lit. ''[[QuestioningTitle Is God Still Sleeping?]]'')
----
!!Provides examples of:
* AbusiveParents: Gillian's parents, especially her mother. Sure, Patria knows that that's not her real daughter and it's understandable how upsetting it must've been to give up her biological child, but the beatings she gave the poor girl was still uncalled for. Their worst came into head when after Andrew attempted to feel her up and Gillian is obliged to say what happened, they gang up on her back home and Bernardo is the first to hit her before proceeding to give her a verbal lashing.
** A justified case with Andrew's father because his son has almost no ambition and talks back. Even lampshaded by the mother at one point which implied, while she doesn't like him to be seen hurt, she's not disapproving of her husbands way of disciplining him either.
* AMinorKidroduction.
* BigSisterBully: Inverted. Lani is one of the causes of Gillian's suffering, like whining to her about not ironing her uniform and other things she supposedly forgot to do for her. If anything, she plays the trope straight with her treatment towards her younger brother, Boy.
* BrattyHalfPint: The young Andrew.
* BrattyTeenageDaughter: Lani, oh so much. She takes her mouthiness after her mother.
* CurbStompBattle: Any fight with Andrew results into this. He always ended up losing..
* TheDogBitesBack: It was the last straw for Gillian when she found out Lani decided to not let her know about the chocolates that Mark brought for her [Gillian] and [[spoiler: quickly proceeds to torment her in the shower while at the same time, makes her confess about stealing the jewelry her mother planned on selling herself]].
* DidNotThinkThisThrough: The baby switch. Only Mrs. Velasco was unconscious enough to be unaware of the true gender of the baby she gave birth to, but Patria wasn't. See WhatTheHellHero.
* DumbMuscle: Andrew. He exercises, sure, but could never get the upper hand when it comes to hand to hand combat.
* EarnYourHappyEnding: [[spoiler: The truth was out and Gillian and Andrew are back in their rightful families. Gillian also married Mark by the end]].
* TheEighties
* EasilyForgiven: Subverted. [[spoiler: Bernardo begs for Gillian to forgive him and Patria for treating her so horribly after they put her back to her rightful parents. She then runs off, explaining to Mark that she's not yet ready to do so because she put up with their abuse for so long and needed some time to think about it. They're still invited to her wedding in the end, though]].
* EvenEvilHasStandards: He may not be a complete monster, but Bernardo is apparently not okay with Patria forcing Gillian to work at the club to be a call girl and calls her out on it for doing so, telling her not to make her go back there again. Understandable considering that Patria used to work there herself as shown in the beginning and he never really accepted the kind of work she did even back then.
* FairytaleWeddingDress: [[spoiler: Gillian when she was marrying Mark. The gown she wore, even by the standards of the 80s, couldn't get any more ambitious than that]].
* FilmOfTheBook
* FreudianExcuse: Your husband forcing you to give up your first-born son and to be quiet about it can practically excuse your maltreatment of the "daughter" you never even had in the first place.
* FreudianSlip: Patria delves into this several times, especially her [[ParentalFavoritism treatment towards Andrew]] and when introducing Boy as a baby, she almost said he's his brother.
* GoodParents: Rose Velasco is the only decent parent seen for the most part, and genuinely loved Andrew [[spoiler: and still does even after knowing that he was not their real son]]. Before that, she never beat him and even when she didn't know yet that Gillian was her real daughter, she treated her much more tenderly as if she was her own.
** The Velasco parents in general. Because Andrew is a spoiled, irresponsible {{jerkass}} of a son that talks back to his father and refuses to do better in his studies, you can't blame Mike for having to lay a hand upon him at least once. And he never beats him senselessly, [[AbusiveParents unlike Patria towards Gillian]].
* GroinAttack: [[spoiler: Gillian does this to Andrew to get out of having him force himself on her]].
* {{Jerkass}}: Andrew.
* ParentalNeglect: Her treatment of Gillian when ''not'' physically abusing her. As a baby though, she deliberately distanced herself from her.
* PetTheDog: Bernardo and Patria still have a soft spot for their biological son, Andrew, even when they saw that he's turning out to be a SpoiledBrat, which worries them to no end, especially Bernardo who saw that he's not turning out the way they'd hoped.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Mr. and Mrs. Velasco.
* SpoiledBrat: Andrew, as a kid. He doesn't grow out of it unfortunately, making him a [[BrattyTeenageDaughter Bratty]] [[SpearCounterpart Young Adult Son]] later. [[spoiler: Only until the end was when he realized his mistakes]].
* SpoiledSweet: Mark, a rich suitor that upon seeing Gillian being forced into working at the club, decides to get her as far away from the place as possible. He proves to be of help later on.
* TookALevelInBadass: [[spoiler: Gillian beating Lani for not telling her about Mark's presents for her and for having been terribly {{Misblamed}} for stealing the jewelry]].
* WhatTheHellHero: Maybe "hero" is no way to put it, but Bernardo switching the babies at birth was the most terrible thing he had done. What's worse, Patria knows that she gave birth to a boy and cannot be fooled. No amount of pleading from her would change his mind though and as the years went by, she becomes emotionally unstable, taking her frustrations out on her "supposed" daughter by beating her.
* WhoNamesTheirKidDude: Boy, Gillian's younger "brother".
----