Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / LegendsOfTheFall

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LongHairIsFeminine: Susannah. Her hair is ultra long.

to:

* LongHairIsFeminine: Susannah. Her hair is ultra long. Subverted with Tristan--his long hair makes him more manly.

Added: 333

Removed: 342

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoomMagnet: Tristan. Everyone he loved died young. According to One Stab:
-->I thought Tristan would never live to be an old man. I was wrong about that. I was wrong about many things. It was those who loved him most who died young. He was a rock they broke themselves against [[FailureHero however much he tried to protect them]].



* WalkingDisasterArea: Tristan. Everyone he loved died young. According to One Stab:
-->I thought Tristan would never live to be an old man. I was wrong about that. I was wrong about many things. It was those who loved him most who died young. He was a rock they broke themselves against [[FailureHero however much he tried to protect them]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BadassGrandpa: Col. Ludlow, who was already a RetiredBadass, comes to help his son Tristan while facing O'Banion and the sheriff. Adding to the coolness is the combination of his BadassBeard and BadassLongcoat. [[spoiler:He hides a shotgun under his coat and kills O'Banion]]. All while recovering from a stroke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOut: [[spoiler:Samuel's]] senseless death mirrors that of ''Film/{{Gallipoli}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HowTheMightyHaveFallen: [[spoiler:Colonel Ludlow is laid down by a stroke, enfeebled and unable to speak, using a chalkboard around his neck to communicate. However, he recovers enough to stand up fearlessly to Irish mobsters and give ''them'' pause, making it a DefiedTrope in the end.]]

Changed: 74

Removed: 76

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Invoked InUniverse by the narrator on [[spoiler:elderly Tristan's DefiantToTheEnd death fighting with the bear he'd maimed when he was young.]]

to:

* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Invoked InUniverse by the narrator on [[spoiler:elderly Tristan's DefiantToTheEnd death fighting with the bear he'd maimed when he was young.young, made more awesome by the fact that he was probably around 75 at the time.]]



** Made more awesome by the fact that he was probably around 75 at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DistantFinale: [[spoiler:Tristan]] dies long after the events of the story sometime in TheSixties.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FamousLastWords: “Tristan!!!!.” Samuel.
** “ I think you missed a bump, Stab.” Isabel II.
** Now, John T.......” Sheriff Tynert.
** “Pick Him up and put him in the car.” John T. O’Banion.
** Sometimes I dream that I’m the mother of your children. I wanted her to die.” Susannah
** “ What’s going on here??!!!!” James T. O’Banion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The First World War scenes are set in the Second Battle of Ypres which occurred in April 1915. A title card proclaims the date as February. (At that time the Canadian Division, depicted in the film, had not yet fought a major battle.) Weapons and equipment worn by the extras are more correct for 1916 or later - in February-April 1915, the Canadians in France were wearing Canadian pattern uniforms, leather Oliver pattern web gear, and using the Ross rifle. The film shows them in British uniforms, gear and with Lee Enfield weapons, which would all be correct if the film took place a year or so later.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The First World War scenes are set in the Second Battle of Ypres which occurred in April 1915. A title card proclaims the date as February. (At that time the Canadian Division, depicted in the film, had not yet fought a major battle.) Weapons and equipment worn by the extras are more correct for 1916 or later - in February-April 1915, the Canadians in France were wearing Canadian pattern uniforms, leather Oliver pattern web gear, and using the Ross rifle. The film shows them in British uniforms, gear uniforms and gear, with Lee Enfield weapons, which would all be correct if the film took place a year or so later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassGrandpa: Col. Ludlow, who was already a RetiredBadass, comes to help his son Tristan while facing O'Banion and the sheriff. [[spoiler:He hides a shotgun under his coat and kills O'Banion]]. All while recovering from a stroke.

to:

* BadassGrandpa: Col. Ludlow, who was already a RetiredBadass, comes to help his son Tristan while facing O'Banion and the sheriff. Adding to the coolness is the combination of his BadassBeard and BadassLongcoat. [[spoiler:He hides a shotgun under his coat and kills O'Banion]]. All while recovering from a stroke.

Added: 967

Removed: 843

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The First World War scenes are set in the Second Battle of Ypres which occurred in April 1915. A title card proclaims the date as February. (At that time the Canadian Division, depicted in the film, had not yet fought a major battle.) Weapons and equipment worn by the extras are more correct for 1916 or later - in February-April 1915, the Canadians in France were wearing Canadian pattern uniforms, leather Oliver pattern web gear, and using the Ross rifle. The film shows them in British uniforms, gear and with Lee Enfield weapons, which would all be correct if the film took place a year or so later.
* AwesomeMcCoolName: ''One Stab''. That being said, he's not the most blatant example of this with only a claim from Tristan implying he was quite the badass in his time to attest the appropriateness of his name.



* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The First World War scenes are set in the Second Battle of Ypres which occurred in April 1915. A title card proclaims the date as February. (At that time the Canadian Division, depicted in the film, had not yet fought a major battle.) Weapons and equipment worn by the extras are more correct for 1916 or later - in February-April 1915, the Canadians in France were wearing Canadian pattern uniforms, leather Oliver pattern web gear, and using the Ross rifle. The film shows them in British uniforms, gear and with Lee Enfield weapons, which would all be correct if the film took place a year or so later.
* AwesomeMcCoolName: ''One Stab''. That being said, he's not the most blatant example of this with only a claim from Tristan implying he was quite the badass in his time to attest the appropriateness of his name.


Added DiffLines:

* BookEnds: The film begins and ends with Tristan [[spoiler:getting attacked by a bear]], both as a child and as an old man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


%% ZeroContextExample entries are not allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out. Add context to the entries before uncommenting them.

to:

%% ZeroContextExample Administrivia/ZeroContextExample entries are not allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out. Add context to the entries before uncommenting them.

Added: 118

Changed: 430

Removed: 120

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* BadassGrandpa: Col. Ludlow, after recovering from his stroke.

to:

%%* * BadassGrandpa: Col. Ludlow, after who was already a RetiredBadass, comes to help his son Tristan while facing O'Banion and the sheriff. [[spoiler:He hides a shotgun under his coat and kills O'Banion]]. All while recovering from his a stroke.



* BeardOfSorrow: Creator/BradPitt doesn't shave when he's depressed.

to:

* BeardOfSorrow: Creator/BradPitt Creator/BradPitt's Tristan doesn't shave when he's depressed.



** Tristan is highly protective of Samuel.

to:

** Tristan is highly protective of Samuel. [[spoiler:Which is what causes Tristan his HeroicBSOD after Samuel dies]].



* CallToAdventure: Samuel feels he has a duty to go off to fight in World War I, and Alfred seems to agree. Tristan joins them, likely [[{{Protectorate}] because Samuel's there]] (this could have affected Alfred as well). [[spoiler:Tristan watches Samuel die after being riddled with bullets, Alfred is discharged due to an injured leg, and Tristan is discharged before the war ends.]]

to:

* CallToAdventure: Samuel feels he has a duty to go off to fight in World War I, and Alfred seems to agree. Tristan joins them, likely [[{{Protectorate}] [[{{Protectorate}} because Samuel's there]] (this could have affected Alfred as well). [[spoiler:Tristan watches Samuel die after being riddled with bullets, Alfred is discharged due to an injured leg, and Tristan is discharged before the war ends.]]



* DiesWideOpen: [[spoiler:This is the way Isaebl II dies this way after being accidentally shot by a police officer]].



* MagicalNativeAmerican: One Stab to an extent, who doesn't have a lot of characterization himself and mostly just narrates mystically with statements stepped in Cree culture.
** He also manages to outlive everyone, which probably puts him in the vicinity of 100 years old when telling the story.

to:

* MagicalNativeAmerican: One Stab to an extent, who doesn't have a lot of characterization himself and mostly just narrates mystically with statements stepped in Cree culture.
**
culture. He also manages to outlive everyone, which probably puts him in the vicinity of 100 years old when telling the story.



%%* NeverFoundTheBody: [[spoiler: Tristan, according to One Stab.]]
%%* NiceGirl: Susannah.

to:

%%* * NeverFoundTheBody: [[spoiler: Tristan, [[spoiler:Tristan after his fatal encounter with the bear, according to One Stab.]]
%%* NiceGirl: Susannah.



* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: Tristan [[spoiler: is none too pleased when Isabel II is killed.]]

to:

* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: Tristan [[spoiler: is [[spoiler:is none too pleased when Isabel II is killed.]]



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The Sheriff and the O'Bannions arrive at the ranch looking for someone, who's picture resembles ranch hand Decker. Decker even leaves upon seeing them coming up, before they can get a good look at him. The Colonel and Albert make up a story about the man in the picture having been there years earlier, but left to go overseas. We never find out why the O'Bannions are looking for Decker, nor why they show no interest when he's in the car when Isabel II is shot. It's entirely about having an excuse to introduce the villains and corrupt Sheriff.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The Sheriff and the O'Bannions O'Banions arrive at the ranch looking for someone, who's picture resembles ranch hand Decker. Decker even leaves upon seeing them coming up, before they can get a good look at him. The Colonel and Albert make up a story about the man in the picture having been there years earlier, but left to go overseas. We never find out why the O'Bannions O'Banions are looking for Decker, nor why they show no interest when he's in the car when Isabel II is shot. It's entirely about having an excuse to introduce the villains and corrupt Sheriff.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The Sheriff and the O'Bannions arrive at the ranch looking for someone, who's picture resembles ranch hand Decker. Decker even leaves upon seeing them come to up before they can get a good look at him. The Colonel and Albert make up a story about the man in the picture having been there years earlier, but left to go oversees. We never find out why the O'Bannions are looking for Decker, nor why they show no interest when he's in the car when Isabel II is shot. It's entirely about having an excuse to introduce the villains and corrupt Sheriff.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The Sheriff and the O'Bannions arrive at the ranch looking for someone, who's picture resembles ranch hand Decker. Decker even leaves upon seeing them come to up coming up, before they can get a good look at him. The Colonel and Albert make up a story about the man in the picture having been there years earlier, but left to go oversees.overseas. We never find out why the O'Bannions are looking for Decker, nor why they show no interest when he's in the car when Isabel II is shot. It's entirely about having an excuse to introduce the villains and corrupt Sheriff.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InformedAbility - We're told early on that Susannah has many ideas and political opinions about the topics of the day. We never hear her speak about any of them. She at least feigns no understanding of business and, as the wife of a congressman, doesn't give her first speech until years after he's been in office.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Made more awesome by the fact that he was probably around 75 at the time.


Added DiffLines:

** He also manages to outlive everyone, which probably puts him in the vicinity of 100 years old when telling the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UnbalancedByRivalsKid: Susannah practically collapses upon reading a letter telling her of the birth of Tristan and Isabel 2's son. When she meets the boy several years later, she's almost in tears.

Added: 271

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigNo: Tristan, repeatedly. [[spoiler:When he's failed to save Samuel from being killed by Kaiser soldiers, which leads to his RoaringRampageOfRevenge. He lets out several when he sees that Isabel II has been shot. [[RuleOfThree And a third]] while he gets in from of Colonel Ludlow after Colonel Ludlow shot the last O'Banion and the corrupt officer with him, but the sheriff is left standing to take a shot at them.]]

to:

* BigNo: Tristan, repeatedly. [[spoiler:When he's failed to save Samuel from being killed by Kaiser soldiers, which leads to his RoaringRampageOfRevenge. He lets out several when he sees that Isabel II has been shot. [[RuleOfThree And a third]] while he gets in from front of Colonel Ludlow after Colonel Ludlow shot the last O'Banion and the corrupt officer with him, but the sheriff is left standing to take a shot at them.]]


Added DiffLines:

* PlotTriggeringDeath: There's obviously problems waiting to happen with Susannah being a fiancee to Samuel and his brothers also clearly being love-struck with her, but [[spoiler:it's Samuel's death that causes things to get truly rocky among the entire Ludlow family.]]

Added: 667

Changed: 301

Removed: 65

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeMcCoolName: ''One Stab''. That being said, he's not the most blatant example of this with only a claim from Tristan implying he was quite the badass in his time to attest the appropriateness of his him.

to:

* AwesomeMcCoolName: ''One Stab''. That being said, he's not the most blatant example of this with only a claim from Tristan implying he was quite the badass in his time to attest the appropriateness of his him.name.



* BigNo: [[spoiler:When Tristan failed to save Samuel from being killed by Kaiser soldiers, which leads to his RoaringRampageOfRevenge.]]
** He lets out several when he sees that Isabel II has been shot.

to:

* BigNo: Tristan, repeatedly. [[spoiler:When Tristan he's failed to save Samuel from being killed by Kaiser soldiers, which leads to his RoaringRampageOfRevenge.]]
**
RoaringRampageOfRevenge. He lets out several when he sees that Isabel II has been shot.shot. [[RuleOfThree And a third]] while he gets in from of Colonel Ludlow after Colonel Ludlow shot the last O'Banion and the corrupt officer with him, but the sheriff is left standing to take a shot at them.]]


Added DiffLines:

* CallToAdventure: Samuel feels he has a duty to go off to fight in World War I, and Alfred seems to agree. Tristan joins them, likely [[{{Protectorate}] because Samuel's there]] (this could have affected Alfred as well). [[spoiler:Tristan watches Samuel die after being riddled with bullets, Alfred is discharged due to an injured leg, and Tristan is discharged before the war ends.]]


Added DiffLines:

* GlorySeeker: Samuel speaks of having some yearning for personal glory in the war in a letter to Susannah. [[spoiler:So he joins a reconnaissance once he gets a chance to dodge Tristan keeping him safe, and gets killed by a German machine-gun after being blinded in a gas attack.]]

Added: 554

Changed: 223

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigDamnHeroes: Alfred [[spoiler:saves Tristan from being shot at by a corrupt sheriff with the last O'Banion brother with a shot ]]



* InstantDeathBullet: In some places - Isabel II [[spoiler:is killed by a bullet in somewhere between her breast and shoulder. No one noticed until her mother did and began screaming about it, and Isabel was already dead by that time. Ludlow and Alfred also kill their targets with little fuss when the last O'Banion comes by for, though Ludlow was using a double-barreled shotgun. Averted in other places - [[spoiler:Samuel manages to seem conscious up until dying despite being riddled by machine-gun bullets for about ten seconds, and Roscoe kills one of the O'Banions by shooting him in the right shoulder, watching him get up, and then shooting him in the left]].

to:

* InstantDeathBullet: In some places - Isabel II [[spoiler:is killed by a bullet in somewhere between her breast and shoulder. No one noticed until her mother did and began screaming about it, and Isabel was already dead by that time. Ludlow and Alfred also kill have their targets fall with little fuss when the last O'Banion comes by for, for revenge, though Ludlow was using a double-barreled shotgun. Averted in other places - [[spoiler:Samuel Samuel manages to seem conscious up until dying despite being riddled by machine-gun bullets for about ten seconds, and Roscoe Decker kills one of the O'Banions by shooting him in the right shoulder, watching him get up, and then shooting him in the left]].gut]].



* RegalRinglets: Susannah. She is long, curly hair.

to:

* ReformedCriminal: Roscoe Decker. He's clearly wanted by the authorities for ''something'', but no one in the Ludlow family ever mention that or gives it any mind.
* RegalRinglets: Susannah. She is has long, curly hair.


Added DiffLines:

** Colonel Ludlow also clearly held something over from his military days when [[spoiler:he fearlessly fires a double-barreled shotgun at the last O'Banion brother's group of three once he sees them distracted for a moment looking at One Stab calming a testy horse. Since those weapons only hold two shells, [[BigDamnHeroes it's Alfred who has to kill the last one]].]]

Added: 2204

Changed: 498

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeMcCoolName: ''One Stab''. That being said, he's not the most blatant example of this with only a claim from Tristan implying he was quite the badass in his time to attest the appropriateness of his him.



** Many elements occur twice in the film. Tristan's guilt over [[spoiler:Samuel dying being shot up while trapped in barbed wire]] gets shown by Tristan being very affected by helping a suffering cow that got tangled in barbed wire which he puts down. The beginning narration from One Stab (mentioning letting a kill's spirit free by cutting out its heart, painting lines on Tristan's forehead, and saying a warrior hopes a good death will find him) happens again with [[spoiler:Tristan cutting out Samuel's heart to bring home after he's killed by Germans and being horrified watching another hunter holding an animal's cut-out heart, One Stab being shown painting lines on Tristan's son as well, and One Stab stating of Tristan dying to a bear as "a good death".]]



* DisposableWoman: Isabel II doesn't get much screentime [[spoiler:until her death. And even the sole purpose of that appears to be to send Tristan off the deep end again]]

to:

* DefectorFromDecadence: Colonel Ludlow, sorta. He lives in his ranch to keep far away from politics, and makes obvious his disgust of the American government when Alfred says he's going to run for Congress while implying he's seen children shot and a village slaughtered in its sleep from government orders.
* DisposableWoman: Isabel II doesn't get much screentime [[spoiler:until her death. And even the sole purpose of that appears to be to send Tristan off the deep end again]] again.]]



* InstantDeathBullet: In some places - Isabel II [[spoiler:is killed by a bullet in somewhere between her breast and shoulder. No one noticed until her mother did and began screaming about it, and Isabel was already dead by that time. Ludlow and Alfred also kill their targets with little fuss when the last O'Banion comes by for, though Ludlow was using a double-barreled shotgun. Averted in other places - [[spoiler:Samuel manages to seem conscious up until dying despite being riddled by machine-gun bullets for about ten seconds, and Roscoe kills one of the O'Banions by shooting him in the right shoulder, watching him get up, and then shooting him in the left]].



* MagicalNativeAmerican: One Stab to an extent, who doesn't have a lot of characterization himself and mostly just narrates mystically with statements stepped in Cree culture.



* ParentalFavoritism: Col. Ludlow seemed to show favoritism towards Tristan.

to:

* ParentalFavoritism: Col. Ludlow seemed to show favoritism towards Tristan. Alfred expressed it as much, and Ludlow had a stroke once he read a letter from Tristan which made his return to the ranch seem dubious.



* PleaseDontLeaveMe: As Tristan was leaving the Ludlow Ranch to [[LeavingYouToFindMyself find himself]], Susannah begged him to stay. Despite her best efforts, Tristan was adamant. She responded, "IWillWaitForYou. Even if it takes forever."

to:

* PleaseDontLeaveMe: As Tristan was leaving the Ludlow Ranch to [[LeavingYouToFindMyself find himself]], Susannah begged him to stay. Despite her best efforts, Tristan was adamant. She responded, "IWillWaitForYou. Even if it takes forever."" [[spoiler:She doesn't.]]


Added DiffLines:

* RetiredBadass: One Stab, as Tristan claims [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counting_coup he had counted coup]] hundreds of times but by that point, One Stab just lives peacefully with the Colonel and his sons.

Added: 67

Changed: 100

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SheIsAllGrownUp: Tristan' s reaction to Isabel II when he returns.

to:

* SettleForSibling: Susannah marrying Alfred after giving up on Tristan returning.
* SheIsAllGrownUp: Tristan' s Tristan's reaction to Isabel II when he returns.

Added: 126

Changed: 196

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshadowing}} - Mrs. Ludlow left because of bears. [[spoiler: A bear is what kills her last surviving son years later]].

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}} - Mrs. Ludlow left because of bears. [[spoiler: A bear FaceDeathWithDignity: Tristan's only request is what kills her last surviving son years later]].that he be taken to the woods because, "I don't want my boy to see. [[GetItOverWith Let's get on with it]]."


Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}} - Mrs. Ludlow left because of bears. [[spoiler: A bear is what kills her last surviving son years later]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Nor when Samuel was killed earlier. He'd actually already killed the Germans who killed Samuel during his rescue attempt. The ones he scalped were just another set of enemy soldiers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The Sheriff and the O'Bannions arrive at the ranch looking for someone, who's picture resembles ranch hand Decker. Decker even leaves upon seeing them come to up before they can get a good look at him. The Colonel and Albert make up a story about the man in the picture having been there years earlier, but left to go oversees. We never find out why the O'Bannions are looking for Decker, nor why they show no interest when he's in the car when Isabel II is shot. It's entirely about having an excuse to introduce the villains and corrupt Sheriff.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And again when he nearly beats the cop to death with his own machine gun after he inadvertantly killed Isabel II
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmicDeath: Tristan is killed by the bear he maimed.

to:

* KarmicDeath: Tristan [[spoiler:Tristan is killed by the bear he maimed.]]

Added: 287

Changed: 20

Removed: 148

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Invoked InUniverse by the narrator on elderly Tristan's DefiantToTheEnd death [[spoiler:fighting with the bear he'd maimed when he was young.]]

to:

* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Invoked InUniverse by the narrator on elderly [[spoiler:elderly Tristan's DefiantToTheEnd death [[spoiler:fighting fighting with the bear he'd maimed when he was young.]]



* IWillWaitForYou: Susannah says this to Tristan before he leaves. [[spoiler: Subverted in that Susannah didn't wait and ended up marrying Alfred.]]



* IWillWaitForYou: Susannah says this to Tristan before he leaves. [[spoiler: Subverted in that Susannah didn't wait and ended up marrying Alfred.]]


Added DiffLines:

* ItsPersonal: [[spoiler:Implied heavily by the narrator at the end that the bear Tristan had maimed decades ago was looking for payback.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WellDoneSonGuy: Alfred's decisions constantly alienate him from his father. When he compromises his ethics in a BigDamnHero moment, he finally reconciles with the Colonel, giving each other a long, heartfelt hug.

Top