History Film / GiveMyRegardsToBroadStreet

14th Nov '15 11:12:09 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of [[Music/TheBeatles Beatles]] songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself. RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.

to:

When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert (Creator/RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of [[Music/TheBeatles Beatles]] songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself. RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.
25th Jul '15 4:15:17 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: there is an ersatz MichaelJackson in the "Silly Love Songs" scene.

to:

* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: there is an ersatz MichaelJackson Music/MichaelJackson in the "Silly Love Songs" scene.
7th Nov '12 2:26:25 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of {{Beatles}} songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself. RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.

to:

When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of {{Beatles}} [[Music/TheBeatles Beatles]] songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself. RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.



----

to:

----
10th Aug '12 1:32:21 PM AnonymousMcCartneyfan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AntiHero

to:

* AntiHeroAntiHero -- Paul



* AuthorAvatar

to:

* AuthorAvatarAuthorAvatar -- Paul. This is one reason why the film is of interest.



* CreatorInJoke

to:

* CreatorInJokeCreatorInJoke -- as noted in the ViewersAreGeniuses entry.



* DeusExMachina

to:

* DeusExMachinaDeusExMachina: Or pure luck.



* HeroicBSOD

to:

* HeroicBSODHeroicBSOD: Several, most notably during and after the "Eleanor's Dream" segment.



* InevitableWaterfall
* JourneyToTheCenterOfTheMind

to:

* InevitableWaterfall
InevitableWaterfall -- at a critical point of the "Eleanor's Dream" segment.
* JourneyToTheCenterOfTheMindJourneyToTheCenterOfTheMind -- WordOfGod at the time of the film's release stated that dreams are related to the inner life of the dreamer.



* MacGuffin
* MindScrew

to:

* MacGuffin
MacGuffin -- the tapes.
* MindScrewMindScrew -- especially if watching this unspoiled.



* TheMusical
* NeckLift
* NestedStory

to:

* TheMusical
TheMusical -- natural in a film with PaulMcCartney about a DayInTheLife of a musician.
* NeckLift
NeckLift -- Big Bob to Tom the Roadie.
* NestedStoryNestedStory -- Starts with Paul awake but sleepy in a limo trapped in a traffic jam. Ends after Paul is awakened at his destination. There are inner nests as well.



* PowerGlows

to:

* PowerGlowsPowerGlows -- the tape case.



* SelfDeprecation

to:

* SelfDeprecationSelfDeprecation: Paul, several times.
19th Jul '12 7:07:07 PM AnonymousMcCartneyfan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[quoteright:329: And to spice up the bet, they are not seriously looking for him...]]

to:

[[quoteright:329: And to spice up the bet, they are not seriously looking for him...music never stops.]]
19th Jul '12 7:05:20 PM AnonymousMcCartneyfan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of {{Beatles}} songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself, [[spoiler: mostly set within that character's dreamscape]]! Or maybe he could--but RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.

to:

When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of {{Beatles}} songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself, [[spoiler: mostly set within that character's dreamscape]]! Or maybe he could--but himself. RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.
29th Jun '12 6:53:24 PM AnonymousMcCartneyfan
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

[[quoteright:329: And to spice up the bet, they are not seriously looking for him...]]
12th Jan '12 12:19:55 PM MarkLungo
Is there an issue? Send a Message


When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of [[TheBeatles Beatles]] songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself, [[spoiler: mostly set within that character's dreamscape]]! Or maybe he could--but RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.

to:

When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of [[TheBeatles Beatles]] {{Beatles}} songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself, [[spoiler: mostly set within that character's dreamscape]]! Or maybe he could--but RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.intended.

Oh, and Music/RingoStarr [[MyFriendsAndZoidberg is in it too.]]



* BreakawayPopHit: casual fans are, or were in the 1990s at least, far more likely to know and care about "No More Lonely Nights" (with its great guitar solo provided by [[PinkFloyd David Gilmour]]) than about the film it's a theme for.

to:

* BreakawayPopHit: casual fans are, or were in the 1990s at least, far more likely to know and care about "No More Lonely Nights" (with its great guitar solo provided by [[PinkFloyd [[Music/PinkFloyd David Gilmour]]) than about the film it's a theme for.
12th Jan '12 12:18:08 PM MarkLungo
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:329:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Give_My_Regards_to_Broad_Street_poster_2374.jpg]]

->''"It's going to be one of those days..."''

This is the only fictional live-action film Music/PaulMcCartney as solo artist truly stars in, and perhaps the ultimate vanity film. It is a musical about an unusually bad DayInTheLife of a character loosely based on Paul [=McCartney=]--but the story continually shifts through different levels of reality.

When it came out in 1984, it was critically panned (RogerEbert gave it one star) and commercially invisible. The reputation of the film [[GuiltyPleasure has been]] [[SoBadItsGood ameliorated]] for [[FanService fans of his]] by [[VindicatedByHistory time]]; acceptance of Paul's {{Cover Version}}s of [[TheBeatles Beatles]] songs -- it was considered sacrilege in 1984, but we're used to it now -- and slow recognition that, while it violates WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief for most human beings to behave like the protagonist does, it ''is'' in character for someone based on Paul [=McCartney=]. Even if the screenwriter (possibly) gets humanity in general wrong, he cannot be completely out of characters writing a character loosely based on himself, [[spoiler: mostly set within that character's dreamscape]]! Or maybe he could--but RealLife incidents from the last decade or so suggest that he was closer to reality than he intended.
----
Credits:
Director: Peter Wells. Since he was new to film, and since Paul is something of a ControlFreak, it is uncertain how much directing Mr. Wells did.

Screenwriter: Paul [=McCartney=].
----
!!''Tropes:''
* TheAllegedCar: Tom the roadie's van.
* AllJustADream: Paul falls asleep during a bad traffic jam, and then we get this movie.
* [[DigitalPiracyIsEvil Analog Piracy Is Evil]] -- both played straight and subverted. The tape being stolen is a big deal, not just because of its causing problems for the legit release, but because there may be an illegit release. Paul himself gets along with Big Bob the bootlegger but doesn't want to do business with him...
* AntiHero
* AsHimself -- not just Paul, either. Everyone who plays an instrument or is seen messing with a recording console is playing who they are.
* AsYouKnow -- complete with lampshading.
* AuthorAvatar
* BreakawayPopHit: casual fans are, or were in the 1990s at least, far more likely to know and care about "No More Lonely Nights" (with its great guitar solo provided by [[PinkFloyd David Gilmour]]) than about the film it's a theme for.
* ClearMyName: Our protagonist must clear both that of the employee who our protagonist gave the tape to, and himself for trusting that tape to that employee.
* ConceptVideo: "Silly Love Songs," and the "Eleanor Rigby/Eleanor's Dream" dream sequence.
* ContemptibleCover (several versions)
* CoolCar -- at least one -- the one Paul drives.
* CreatorInJoke
* DayInTheLife -- Specifically, 9 am to midnight.
* DeusExMachina
* DisneyAcidSequence (on more than one level)
* DreamWithinADream: Possibly even Dream within a Dream within a Dream.
* EnforcedMethodActing -- any time you ''[[RuleOfPerception see]]'' music being played, that music was being played ''as it was filmed.''
* FlashBack: There are several of these in the main body of the film; in the first viewing, they make it trickier to figure out what level of reality the film is on at any given moment.
* FloatingHeadSyndrome (on the most recent {{DVD}} packaging)
* HeroicBSOD
* ImplausibleDeniability -- but Paul accepts Harry's explanations anyway.
* InevitableWaterfall
* JourneyToTheCenterOfTheMind
* LawOfConservationOfNormality: With the fate of his music empire at stake, Paul ''still'' keeps his long schedule as if nothing has happened. Unusual, since this law doesn't normally apply to films.
* LifeEmbellished: Maybe not by much, but it was--both from life and inside the film.
* {{Masquerade}} Our protagonist ''is'' hiding what's going on from outsiders.
* MacGuffin
* MindScrew
* {{Mondegreen}}: [[{{In-Universe}} The]] [[EvenTheSubtitlerIsStumped subtitles]] on the most recent {{DVD}} of this film and the liner notes in the soundtrack CD (original printing) are at odds with each other.
* TheMusical
* NeckLift
* NestedStory
* NiceJobBreakingItHero -- the impetus of the plot.
* NightmareSequence (several)
* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: there is an ersatz MichaelJackson in the "Silly Love Songs" scene.
* PerformanceVideo: There are several points where Paul and various back-up bands can be seen performing, and a couple of in-story music videos.
* PowerGlows
* TheQuest: to retrieve a certain master tape...
* SelfDeprecation
* SmokingIsCool: Ringo can really rock a cigarette.
* ThrowItIn: Perhaps half of Ringo's lines, and possibly some of Paul's responses.
* TitleDrop: silliness that proves plot-critical
* ViewersAreGeniuses. This film has references to fine art, clever wordplay, multiple allusions, and assumptions of rockstar life (in general) and [=McCartney's=] life (in particular)--and almost no one outside of the screenwriter's inner circle could get even half of these. Even the real MPL of the era missed some of the references in the {{Novelization}}.
* WagTheDirector - Okay, we don't ''know'' this happened. But we suspect Paul may have done this.
----
This list shows the last 9 events of 9. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Film.GiveMyRegardsToBroadStreet