Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Comicbook / JusticeSocietyOfAmerica

Go To

OR

Changed: 347

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActionGirl: Wonder Woman, when she was allowed to go on missions. Black Canary was always an ActionGirl. Red Tornado... not so much.

to:

* ActionGirl: Wonder Woman, when she was allowed to go on missions. Her participation was rare in the early years of the series, but when the editor and writer changed in the late 40s, Wonder Woman became an active member of the team out in the field as well as at headquarters. Black Canary was always an ActionGirl. Red Tornado... not so much.ActionGirl who started as a guest character and then was officially invited to join after proving invaluable to the team on several cases.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The CrisisCrossover ''ComicBook/ZeroHourCrisisInTime'' [[RocksFallEveryoneDies brutally killed off]] members Doctor Mid-Nite, Hourman, and the Atom (an act meant to both [[ExecutiveMeddling get rid of "embarrassing" older heroes and create some epic deaths for the big story]]), and wrote out Carter and Shiera Hall, the Golden Age Hawkman and Hawkgirl, by merging them with the Silver Age Hawkman, Katar Hol. Several other members were also aged to such an extent that they were forced to retire, most notably Doctor Fate (leading to the introduction of a new bearer of the mantle in the ''Fate'' series), Sandman and Johnny Thunder. The second revival, simply entitled ''JSA'', brought the team back together with numerous new members, [[BackFromTheDead resurrected]] Hourman (who retired and entrusted the mantle to his son) and the Carter Hall version of Hawkman, and eventually fizzled after 87 issues and yet another CrisisCrossover. It was initially written by James Robinson (and included his ComicBook/{{Starman}} in the lineup) and David Goyer. Robinson was later replaced by Creator/GeoffJohns, whose run on the book is generally considered the team's peak and is regarded as one of his best works to this day.

to:

The CrisisCrossover ''ComicBook/ZeroHourCrisisInTime'' [[RocksFallEveryoneDies brutally killed off]] members Doctor Mid-Nite, Hourman, and the Atom (an act meant to both [[ExecutiveMeddling get rid of "embarrassing" older heroes and create some epic deaths for the big story]]), and wrote out Carter and Shiera Hall, the Golden Age Hawkman and Hawkgirl, by merging them with the Silver Age Hawkman, Katar Hol. Several other members were also aged to such an extent that they were forced to retire, most notably Doctor Fate (leading to the introduction of a new bearer of the mantle in the ''Fate'' series), Sandman and Johnny Thunder. The second revival, simply entitled ''JSA'', brought the team back together with numerous new members, [[BackFromTheDead resurrected]] Hourman (who retired and entrusted the mantle to his son) and the Carter Hall version of Hawkman, and eventually fizzled after 87 issues and yet another CrisisCrossover. It was initially written by James Robinson (and included his ComicBook/{{Starman}} in the lineup) and David Goyer.Creator/DavidSGoyer. Robinson was later replaced by Creator/GeoffJohns, whose run on the book is generally considered the team's peak and is regarded as one of his best works to this day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Over a decade later, superheroes were on the rise again and Franchise/TheFlash (the [[UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks Silver Age]] Flash, a totally different guy than the one in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII) discovered another Earth inhabited by the older [[UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks Golden Age]] characters. Continuity had been invented by this point, so the explanation was, "All those JSA stories took place on [[AlternateUniverse Earth-2]], which has its own version of Superman, and everything from, uh, [[UsefulNotes/TheInterregnum circa-1955]] on is from Earth-1, which has the Franchise/JusticeLeagueOfAmerica. Superman versus aliens? That was Earth-1. Superman versus [[ThoseWackyNazis Nazis]]? Earth-2." Thus, every summer, the JLA and the JSA would [[{{Crossover}} team up]], in some of the few multi-part storylines of UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks. These were often titled "Crisis on Earth-Something", and involved the two teams responding to multidimensional disasters.

to:

Over a decade later, superheroes were on the rise again and Franchise/TheFlash (the [[UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks Silver Age]] Flash, a totally different guy than the one in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII) discovered another Earth inhabited by the older [[UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks Golden Age]] characters. Continuity had been invented by this point, so the explanation was, "All those JSA stories took place on [[AlternateUniverse Earth-2]], which has its own version of Superman, and everything from, uh, [[UsefulNotes/TheInterregnum circa-1955]] on is from Earth-1, which has the Franchise/JusticeLeagueOfAmerica. Superman versus aliens? That was Earth-1. Superman versus [[ThoseWackyNazis Nazis]]? Earth-2." Earth-2". Thus, every summer, the JLA and the JSA would [[{{Crossover}} team up]], in some of the few multi-part storylines of UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks. These were often titled "Crisis on Earth-Something", and involved the two teams responding to multidimensional disasters.



The ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths left the JSA relatively untouched (except that there was now only one Earth, where all the heroes lived), but [[ExecutiveMeddling DC Editorial wanted]] to get rid of the JSA. So, in the best tradition of the AssPull: "Suddenly, the JSA were attacked by a spell [[{{Ghostapo}} cast by Hitler]] in the last days of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII, which summoned the [[TheLegionsOfHell demons of Ragnarok]] to [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt destroy the world]]. The JSA had no choice but to create a [[TimeyWimeyBall hole in time and space]], and all go [[PutOnABus through the hole]] to fight demons." The JSA were caught up in a time loop fighting demons from 1986 to 1992, when they were released during the ''Armageddon: Inferno'' crossover. They had a flashback miniseries in 1991 and a short series in 1992 that was cancelled even before its first issue by more ExecutiveMeddling.

to:

The ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths left the JSA relatively untouched (except that there was now only one Earth, where all the heroes lived), but [[ExecutiveMeddling DC Editorial wanted]] to get rid of the JSA. So, in the best tradition of the AssPull: "Suddenly, the JSA were attacked by a spell [[{{Ghostapo}} cast by Hitler]] in the last days of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII, which summoned the [[TheLegionsOfHell demons of Ragnarok]] to [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt destroy the world]]. The JSA had no choice but to create a [[TimeyWimeyBall hole in time and space]], and all go [[PutOnABus through the hole]] to fight demons." demons". The JSA were caught up in a time loop fighting demons from 1986 to 1992, when they were released during the ''Armageddon: Inferno'' crossover. They had a flashback miniseries in 1991 and a short series in 1992 that was cancelled even before its first issue by more ExecutiveMeddling.



** The original members of the Justice Society included Franchise/WonderWoman and Comicbook/BlackCanary, but when the group reformed decades later, it included the daughters of both as replacements. (Wonder Woman was retroactively stated to be Diana's mother, Hippolyta.) Many of the men returned despite having aged (such as Jay Garrick, [[Franchise/TheFlash the original Flash]]). Some, like Alan Scott (Franchise/GreenLantern) and Carter Hall (Comicbook/{{Hawkman}}) had either de-aged or were immortal.

to:

** The original members of the Justice Society included Franchise/WonderWoman and Comicbook/BlackCanary, but when the group reformed decades later, it included the daughters of both as replacements. replacements (Wonder Woman was retroactively stated to be Diana's mother, Hippolyta.) Hippolyta). Many of the men returned despite having aged (such as Jay Garrick, [[Franchise/TheFlash the original Flash]]). Some, like Alan Scott (Franchise/GreenLantern) and Carter Hall (Comicbook/{{Hawkman}}) had either de-aged or were immortal.



* MamaBear: Power Girl starts to become this to Stargirl sometimes, once absolutely ''snapping'' at Captain Marvel for butting in on their conversation about Atom Smasher's potential defection, coldly telling him "Whatever it is, Big Red. I think you better save it."

to:

* MamaBear: Power Girl starts to become this to Stargirl sometimes, once absolutely ''snapping'' at Captain Marvel for butting in on their conversation about Atom Smasher's potential defection, coldly telling him "Whatever it is, Big Red. I think you better save it."it".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleting redundant text.


* EvilCannotComprehendGood: The Wizard's first appearance. He'd been out of touch for years learning his magical powers. When he returned to civilization, he learned of the JSA. He could not conceive of intelligent super-powered people using their powers for good for altruistic reasons, and assumed the heroes were actually [[VillainWithGoodPublicity running an enormous scam]], and he demanded to be cut in.

to:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: The Wizard's first appearance. He'd been out of touch for years learning his magical powers. When he returned to civilization, he learned of the JSA. He could not conceive of intelligent super-powered people using their powers for good for altruistic reasons, and assumed the heroes were actually [[VillainWithGoodPublicity running an enormous scam]], and he demanded to be cut in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MagicVersusScience: One issue had the team visiting the world where all the famous fairytale characters exist. Because magic's so powerful there, the team members who got their powers from scientific sources, like the Flash and the Atom, found themselves BroughtDownToNormal. While the others whose powers had magical or other supernatural sources, like Green Lantern, Wonder Woman or Johnny Thunder, were fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
zce


* ShipSinking: Stargirl & Billy Batson (thanks to different editors) and Stargirl & Atom Smasher (thanks to a plot twist that toyed with Stargirl's emotions, and later a RomanticFalseLead in Anna Fortune).
* SickeninglySweethearts: Hourman and Liberty Belle.

to:

* %%* ShipSinking: Stargirl & Billy Batson (thanks to different editors) and Stargirl & Atom Smasher (thanks to a plot twist that toyed with Stargirl's emotions, and later a RomanticFalseLead in Anna Fortune).
* %%* SickeninglySweethearts: Hourman and Liberty Belle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TemporalAbortion: Per Degaton once went back in time and killed Rex Tyler's best friend in his crib, just so that Rex would have a lonely childhood.

Removed: 565

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Overprotective Dad has been disambiguated


* OverprotectiveDad: Jay Garrick tends to be this around Stargirl -- he confronts the "is sixteen, but in an adult's body" Captain Marvel about his relationship with her, and suggests that a firefighter talking her up in another issue consider the age difference. The whole elder trio later forces Atom Smasher to let Stargirl down once and for all. Courtney does not appreciate any of these moments.
** Justified in-story: Jay's only (adopted) child died very young, and so he sees all of the young heroes on the team as his children, with Courtney as the youngest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BadassInCharge: Hawkman, once he became the chairman of the JSA in All-Star #8. Green Lantern was no slouch either during his one issue as chairman. He had the team raising funds for war orphans after going on a solo scouting mission over Axis-occupied territory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanService: Power Girl's huge bustline makes her a recurring subject of "focus on bustline while she's flying towards us" angled shots, and she often suffers ClothingDamage. Kendra tends to get lots of ass shots and rocks a BareYourMidriff outfit and pants with a plunging waistline. Unusually, however, the entire rest of the female cast tends to be either modestly-endowed (the teenage characters) and/or full-clothed without even the form-fitting wardrobe normal for comics (Cyclone and Liberty Belle).

to:

* FanService: Power Girl's huge bustline makes her a recurring subject of "focus on bustline while she's flying towards us" angled shots, and she often suffers ClothingDamage. Kendra tends to get lots of ass shots and rocks a BareYourMidriff midriff-exposing outfit and pants with a plunging waistline. Unusually, however, the entire rest of the female cast tends to be either modestly-endowed (the teenage characters) and/or full-clothed without even the form-fitting wardrobe normal for comics (Cyclone and Liberty Belle).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The team made their cinematic debut in the ''Film/BlackAdam'' live action film set in the Franchise/DCExtendedUniverse and starring Wrestling/DwayneJohnson, with Creator/AldisHodge as Hawkman, Creator/PierceBrosnan as Doctor Fate, Creator/NoahCentineo as Atom Smasher and Quintessa Swindell as Cyclone. The team had its own AnimatedAdaptation in the WesternAnimation/DCUniverseAnimatedOriginalMovies line, ''WesternAnimation/JusticeSocietyWorldWarII'' in 2021.

to:

The team made their cinematic debut in the ''Film/BlackAdam'' ''Film/BlackAdam2022'' live action film set in the Franchise/DCExtendedUniverse and starring Wrestling/DwayneJohnson, with Creator/AldisHodge as Hawkman, Creator/PierceBrosnan as Doctor Fate, Creator/NoahCentineo as Atom Smasher and Quintessa Swindell as Cyclone. The team had its own AnimatedAdaptation in the WesternAnimation/DCUniverseAnimatedOriginalMovies line, ''WesternAnimation/JusticeSocietyWorldWarII'' in 2021.

Changed: 669

Removed: 424

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ArchivedArmy: A comic has the JSA fighting what appears to be a band of villains out of history: UsefulNotes/{{Nero}}, Goliath, Captain Kidd, Cesare Borgia, UsefulNotes/GenghisKhan and UsefulNotes/AttilaTheHun. It turns out to be one guy (a guard at a wax museum) masquerading as all these figures. However he succeeds in killing the entire male membership of the Society in that issue. [[ComicBookDeath They get better]].



* HistorysCrimeWave: The Trope Namer is in ''All-Star Comics'' #38 where the Justice Society of America investigate Gotham City murders claimed to be performed by historical villains. Though they turn out to be the disguises of an insane wax museum guard, he succeeds in killing every member in the issue except Wonder Woman, who has to use the purple ray to bring them back to life. The villains are Nero, Goliath, Captain Kidd, Cesare Borgia, Genghis Khan and Attila the Hun.

to:

* HistorysCrimeWave: The Trope Namer is in ''All-Star Comics'' #38 where HistoricalDomainCrossover: A comic has the Justice Society of America investigate Gotham City murders claimed JSA fighting what appears to be performed by historical villains. Though they turn out to be the disguises a band of an insane wax museum guard, he succeeds in killing every member in the issue except Wonder Woman, who has to use the purple ray to bring them back to life. The villains are Nero, out of history: UsefulNotes/{{Nero}}, Goliath, Captain Kidd, Cesare Borgia, Genghis Khan UsefulNotes/GenghisKhan and Attila UsefulNotes/AttilaTheHun. It turns out to be one guy (a guard at a wax museum) masquerading as all these figures. However he succeeds in killing the Hun. entire male membership of the Society in that issue. [[ComicBookDeath They get better]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ambiguous Disorder is not a trope anymore, but a redirect to a YMMV entry.


* AmbiguousDisorder: Cyclone is described as having atypical depression, but what we actually see of her personality she hides this well. Still, her [[MotorMouth overly talkative nature]], hyper-focus on her fandoms, social anxiety, GenkiGirl nature, and tendency to overthink things strongly point to possibly also having ADHD.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added a link


* '''''Justice Society of America''''' Vol 4 (2022-)

to:

* '''''Justice '''''ComicBook/{{Justice Society of America''''' America|2022}}''''' Vol 4 (2022-)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The team is set to appear in the upcoming ''Film/BlackAdam'' live action film set in the Franchise/DCExtendedUniverse and starring Wrestling/DwayneJohnson, with Creator/AldisHodge as Hawkman, Creator/NoahCentineo as Atom Smasher and Quintessa Swindell as Cyclone for the confirmed JSA members. The team had its own AnimatedAdaptation in the WesternAnimation/DCUniverseAnimatedOriginalMovies line, ''WesternAnimation/JusticeSocietyWorldWarII'' in 2021.

to:

The team is set to appear made their cinematic debut in the upcoming ''Film/BlackAdam'' live action film set in the Franchise/DCExtendedUniverse and starring Wrestling/DwayneJohnson, with Creator/AldisHodge as Hawkman, Creator/PierceBrosnan as Doctor Fate, Creator/NoahCentineo as Atom Smasher and Quintessa Swindell as Cyclone for the confirmed JSA members.Cyclone. The team had its own AnimatedAdaptation in the WesternAnimation/DCUniverseAnimatedOriginalMovies line, ''WesternAnimation/JusticeSocietyWorldWarII'' in 2021.



* ''ComicBook/TheGoldenAge''

to:

* ''ComicBook/TheGoldenAge''''ComicBook/TheGoldenAge'' [[note]]While not in regular DC continuity, elements from this series were imported into regular continuity[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/BlackAdam'' (2022)

to:

* ''Film/BlackAdam'' ''Film/{{Black Adam|2022}}'' (2022)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* '''''Justice Society of America''''' Vol 4 (2022-)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The team is set to appear in the upcoming ComicBook/BlackAdam live action film set in the Franchise/DCExtendedUniverse and starring Wrestling/DwayneJohnson, with Creator/AldisHodge as Hawkman, Creator/NoahCentineo as Atom Smasher and Quintessa Swindell as Cyclone for the confirmed JSA members. The team had its own AnimatedAdaptation in the WesternAnimation/DCUniverseAnimatedOriginalMovies line, ''WesternAnimation/JusticeSocietyWorldWarII'' in 2021.

to:

The team is set to appear in the upcoming ComicBook/BlackAdam ''Film/BlackAdam'' live action film set in the Franchise/DCExtendedUniverse and starring Wrestling/DwayneJohnson, with Creator/AldisHodge as Hawkman, Creator/NoahCentineo as Atom Smasher and Quintessa Swindell as Cyclone for the confirmed JSA members. The team had its own AnimatedAdaptation in the WesternAnimation/DCUniverseAnimatedOriginalMovies line, ''WesternAnimation/JusticeSocietyWorldWarII'' in 2021.



* ''Black Adam'' (2022)

to:

* ''Black Adam'' ''Film/BlackAdam'' (2022)

Changed: 27

Removed: 942

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Loads And Loads Of Characters is no longer a trope


** Hourman was initially an action-loving hero with many aspects, who took major issue with Atom Smasher's betrayal, and had feelings for Jesse Chambers. Fast-forward one year, and his entire personality seemed based around fawning over his wife Jesse, or screaming at Atom Smasher for betraying the team. Thanks to LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters, his few appearances in the book could only consist of just that.

to:

** Hourman was initially an action-loving hero with many aspects, who took major issue with Atom Smasher's betrayal, and had feelings for Jesse Chambers. Fast-forward one year, and his entire personality seemed based around fawning over his wife Jesse, or screaming at Atom Smasher for betraying the team. Thanks to LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters, a large cast, his few appearances in the book could only consist of just that.



* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Membership includes all the Golden Age heroes, and all their descendants, and all their {{Sidekick}}s, and all their ''sidekicks''' descendants... and that's not even getting into all the ''reserve'' members.
** This got more and more derided by fans, who were practically ''begging'' the new writing team to drop the roster by several characters by the time Johns left the book. Of course, the new writers promised to not only keep most of the team around, but ''add'' one new character each.
*** The team split with ''JSA All-Stars'' sought to avert this, but each team still had one new character on it, with a standard plus-size team roster still fighting for space. Once ''All-Stars'' was cancelled, the cast of that series (minus Damage, who was killed during ''ComicBook/BlackestNight'', and ComicBook/PowerGirl, who left to join the new [[ComicBook/JusticeLeagueInternational JLI]]) rejoined the JSA proper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


The JSA, therefore, basically became a team of veterans and mentors for other heroes, as well as the starting point for many heroes in training. This gave the team excellent dynamics: young vs. old, cynical vs. idealist, etc. While its heroes were not as popular as those who form the Justice League, they were respected and admired by all proper heroes in Franchise/TheDCU as [[UrExample pioneers of the principles they stood for]]. After adding LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters in the form of other [[LegacyHero Legacy Heroes]], Johns finalized his decade-long run on the book.

to:

The JSA, therefore, basically became a team of veterans and mentors for other heroes, as well as the starting point for many heroes in training. This gave the team excellent dynamics: young vs. old, cynical vs. idealist, etc. While its heroes were not as popular as those who form the Justice League, they were respected and admired by all proper heroes in Franchise/TheDCU as [[UrExample pioneers of the principles they stood for]]. After adding LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters tons of characters in the form of other [[LegacyHero Legacy Heroes]], Johns finalized his decade-long run on the book.



* ThisLooksLikeAJobForAquaman: It sure is a good thing that Dr. Mid-Nite, a licensed physician, is on the team, because they seem to be the only team in comics that regularly has somebody suffer a near-fatal injury in every event. Averted with the ReTool with LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters later.

to:

* ThisLooksLikeAJobForAquaman: It sure is a good thing that Dr. Mid-Nite, a licensed physician, is on the team, because they seem to be the only team in comics that regularly has somebody suffer a near-fatal injury in every event. Averted with the ReTool with LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters numerous characters later.

Added: 3997

Changed: 1378

Removed: 76

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassNormal: This role is filled by Mister Terrific, the third-smartest man in the world (and therefore smart enough to know that "Working Out = Good"), Hawkman (who graduated to Franchise/ConanTheBarbarian with wings), and Wildcat, advertised as the man who taught self-defense classes to the JLA.

to:

* BadassNormal: This role BackFromTheDead:
** Hector Hall
is filled by reincarnated in a newborn infant at the beginning of JSA.
** Extant resurrects the Dawn Granger Dove, she of ComicBook/HawkAndDove fame.
* BadassNormal:
**
Mister Terrific, the third-smartest man in the world (and therefore smart enough to know that "Working Out = Good"), Good")
**
Hawkman (who graduated to Franchise/ConanTheBarbarian with wings), and wings)
**
Wildcat, advertised as the man who taught self-defense classes to the JLA.JLA.
** Black Canary at the beginning of JSA, since she'd been depowered at the time. Since she's Black Canary, this means she's BroughtDownToBadass.



* BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: The Thy Kingdom Come storyline had [[spoiler: Doctor Mid-Nite regain his eyesight at the cost of being able to diagnosis medical conditions at a glance, ComicBook/{{Starman}} regained his sanity when [[InsanityImmunity he needed to be crazy]], ComicBook/PowerGirl learned the hard way that the ComicBook/InfiniteCrisis had [[YouCantGoHomeAgain caused her to be replaced with a double on Earth 2]], and Damage's face was fixed and he became increasingly vain.]] Luckily because StatusQuoIsGod most of those issues were resolved.

to:

* BadPowersGoodPeople: Obsidian gets here... eventually. Decidedly not the case the first time he appears, though.
* BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: The Thy "Thy Kingdom Come storyline Come" had [[spoiler: Doctor Mid-Nite regain his eyesight at the cost of being able to diagnosis medical conditions at a glance, ComicBook/{{Starman}} regained his sanity when [[InsanityImmunity he needed to be crazy]], ComicBook/PowerGirl learned the hard way that the ComicBook/InfiniteCrisis had [[YouCantGoHomeAgain caused her to be replaced with a double on Earth 2]], and Damage's face was fixed and he became increasingly vain.]] Luckily because StatusQuoIsGod most of those issues were resolved.resolved.
* BetterToDieThanBeKilled: Wesley Dodds commits suicide rather than let Mordru kill him (or [[FateWorseThanDeath worse]]). He also figures wherever he ends up, Dian Belmont will be waiting for him.



* BigScrewedUpFamily: Most of the inner turmoil in the JSA was caused by the original Atom, Al Pratt's, kids. Atom-Smasher was Pratt's godchild, and later, Pratt's son Damage (it's a [[ItMakesSenseInContext complicated story]]) betrayed the team by siding with Gog.
* BlessedWithSuck: Citizen Steel had superhuman strength... he also can't feel ''anything'', and has to wear a special suit because he can't control his strength.

to:

* BigScrewedUpFamily: Most of the inner turmoil in the JSA was caused by the original Atom, Al Pratt's, kids. Atom-Smasher was Pratt's godchild, and later, Pratt's son Damage (it's a [[ItMakesSenseInContext complicated story]]) betrayed betrays the team by siding with Gog.
* BlessedWithSuck: Citizen Steel had has superhuman strength... he also can't feel ''anything'', and has to wear a special suit because he can't control his strength.



* CameBackStrong: Lance-Corporal David Reid had some mild superpowers, but nothing flashy. After Gog resurrects him, he gets super-strength strong enough to send Superman flying, and the ability to teleport.



* TheDarkSideWillMakeYouForget: Hank Hall went mad and became Monarch and then Extant because his soul mate Holly Granger died. He does eventually get the power to revive Holly, and then does just that... only to immediately lock her up in a dungeon and then accidentally kill her all over again, thanks to several ''billion'' years of being alone and insane.



* DivergentCharacterEvolution: Even though the Justice Society came first and the Franchise/JusticeLeagueOfAmerica was just a [[UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks Silver Age]] update of the Justice Society, because the Justice League was more popular, it was decided that the Justice Society needed to find a new core concept to differentiate it from the Justice League. Several different ideas were tried such as being an AlternateUniverse equivalent to the Justice League, being a group of middle-aged superheroes, and being a group of senior citizen superheroes, until finally, they found a concept that worked sales-wise: a multigenerational family of superheroes training the next generation.
** This concept behind the team was explicitly abandoned by Marc Guggenheim.

to:

* DivergentCharacterEvolution: Even though the Justice Society came first and the Franchise/JusticeLeagueOfAmerica was just a [[UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks Silver Age]] update of the Justice Society, because the Justice League was more popular, it was decided that the Justice Society needed to find a new core concept to differentiate it from the Justice League. Several different ideas were tried such as being an AlternateUniverse equivalent to the Justice League, being a group of middle-aged superheroes, and being a group of senior citizen superheroes, until finally, they found a concept that worked sales-wise: a multigenerational family of superheroes training the next generation.
**
generation. This concept behind the team was explicitly abandoned by Marc Guggenheim.



* FamilyExtermination: The first arc of ''Justice Society'' vol 3 has Vandal Savage sending killers after the families of heroes. He succeeds in a few cases.



* {{Flanderization}}: Hourman was initially an action-loving hero with many aspects, who took major issue with Atom Smasher's betrayal, and had feelings for Jesse Chambers. Fast-forward one year, and his entire personality seemed based around fawning over his wife Jesse, or screaming at Atom Smasher for betraying the team. Thanks to LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters, his few appearances in the book could only consist of just that.

to:

* {{Flanderization}}: {{Flanderization}}:
**
Hourman was initially an action-loving hero with many aspects, who took major issue with Atom Smasher's betrayal, and had feelings for Jesse Chambers. Fast-forward one year, and his entire personality seemed based around fawning over his wife Jesse, or screaming at Atom Smasher for betraying the team. Thanks to LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters, his few appearances in the book could only consist of just that.that.
** Under Geoff Johns, Magog is an anti-hero, but is respectful and polite towards the JSA. It's just his enemies he's not nice toward. Once Willingham takes over, he becomes a total arsehole who attacks his teammates by mistake and refuses to admit fault, and never stops talking about how he was a US marine.



* GogglesDoSomethingUnusual: Doctor Midnight's special goggles give him x-ray vision when he's normally blind.



* InTheBlood: Obsidian's mother was a schizophrenic with a split personality. Poor Todd's inherited some of the madness, though Ian Karkull's powers and a hideously abusive foster father did a lot of the work as well. Funnily, no-one treats his sister Jade like a ticking timebomb...



* KickTheSonOfABitch: Obsidian's first act on going evil and nuts is to go after his foster father for those years of drunken abuse.



* PayEvilUntoEvil: Atom-Smasher and Metron dump Extant in a plane blown up by King Cobra in place of Al's mom. It's hinted the entire JSA know full well what they did, but aren't doing anything because Extant has tried to destroy the universe ''and'' killed several of their friends by that point.



** Starman (Jack Knight, that is) is part of the team in the first few issues, but soon leaves for reasons related to his own retirement over in his title. He stays gone, because James Robinson asked DC nicely not to use him again, and they actually stuck to it.



* RetiredBadass: All of them.

to:

* RetiredBadass: All of them.them, except for the "retired" part.



* TimeCrash: Mildly. Due to Extant's meddling with time, Star-Spangled Kid (who's been dead since the end of ''Infinity, Inc.'') gets brought to the future.



Added: 3380

Changed: 725

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcquiredSituationalNarcissism: Damage, after Gog fixes up his face. He becomes incapable of crowing about it, assumes Stargirl is hitting on him (she's really not), and when Atom Smasher tries talking to him he spends the entire conversation not listening because he's too busy stealing glances at a mirror. Al even accuses him of having "turned into Vanity Smurf".



* ArtShift: The end of "Thy Kingdom Come" has the art change to Alex Ross's art whenever it depicts Earth-22.



* BlessedWithSuck: Citizen Steel had superhuman strength... he also can't feel ''anything'', and has to wear a special suit because he can't control his strength.
* CanonImmigrant: Vol 3 introduces Magog from ''ComicBook/KingdomCome'' into regular continuity.



** When the teen supervillain Kid Karnevil attempted to infiltrate the Justice Society Of America, he did so by posing as a patriotic superhero named the All-American Kid. All-American Kid's costume and backstory were extremely similar to those of Bucky, the sidekick of ComicBook/CaptainAmerica.

to:

** When the teen supervillain Kid Karnevil attempted attempts to infiltrate the Justice Society Of America, he did does so by posing as a patriotic superhero named the All-American Kid. All-American Kid's costume and backstory were extremely similar to those of Bucky, the sidekick of ComicBook/CaptainAmerica.



* EyeScream: During a fight with Eclipso, Hawkgirl gets fed up of her monologuing and stabs her through the eye with an arrow. Doesn't shut her up, though.



* ForWantOfANail: The Michael Holt on the new Earth-2 isn't a superhero, but a college professor, and a devout Christian, unlike regular Michael, who's completely atheist. Also, his wife is still alive.
* FutureBadass: One story-arc has Stargirl meeting the future Starwoman, an older version of her baby sister Patricia. Who, at the beginning of the story, had just been killed by time-travelling assassins.



* GirlsNightOutEpisode

to:

* %%* GirlsNightOutEpisode



* HeroicSacrifice: This one doesn't get used as often, but we've seen a few. Wesley Dodds committed suicide because his long-time girlfriend Dianne had died the year before, and because he knew that with the knowledge he had obtained, he was as good as dead anyway. Worse than dead, if Mordru's threats to him carried any weight. Before the end, he sent a warning to his old teammates about Mordru.

to:

* HeroicSacrifice: HeroicSacrifice:
**
This one doesn't get used as often, but we've seen a few. Wesley Dodds committed suicide because his long-time girlfriend Dianne had died the year before, and because he knew that with the knowledge he had obtained, he was as good as dead anyway. Worse than dead, if Mordru's threats to him carried any weight. Before the end, he sent a warning to his old teammates about Mordru.



* MoodWhiplash: One issue begins with Stargirl having breakfast after a hard night's crime fighting, talking with her step-dad, arguing with her brother and saying hi to her little sister. Then a bunch of assassins burst into the room and kill everyone but Courtney.



* OtherMeAnnoysMe: "Thy Kingdom Come" has PG run into another version of her who believes our Karen is an impostor out to perform KillAndReplace, and nothing Karen can say will convince her otherwise. She even goes as far as to ''torture'' Karen to get her to "confess". And she never apologizes for it, even after the truth is revealed.



* ThePowerOfLegacy: A major theme. The opening storyline of Vol 3 is all about the villain targeting the families of heroes specifically because of this.



* PowerIncontinence: During "Black Reign", Power Girl's heat vision reasserts itself in the middle of a fight. Karen didn't even remember she ''had'' heat vision, and spends several minutes stumbling around blind. Not a good mix with a city of panicking Khandaqi seeing one of the hated JSA in their midst.



* PutOnABus: Doctor Fate in the previous run would vanish constantly searching for his wife, both to reduce the ponderous roster and to bring a major powerhouse out of the fight. Hawkman, Hawkgirl, Amazing Man, Magog and others have all done the same over time. Amazing Man has now finally been fully put there to clear out the roster a bit.

to:

* PutOnABus: PutOnABus:
**
Doctor Fate in the previous run would vanish constantly searching for his wife, both to reduce the ponderous roster and to bring a major powerhouse out of the fight. Hawkman, Hawkgirl, Amazing Man, Magog and others have all done the same over time.
**
Amazing Man has now finally been fully put there to clear out the roster a bit.left after Geoff Johns' run.



* {{Retcon}}: the team's various changes inflicted on it after ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths forced the removal of the Earth-2 Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman from the roster retroactively, among other changes.

to:

* {{Retcon}}: the The team's various changes inflicted on it after ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths forced the removal of the Earth-2 Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman from the roster retroactively, among other changes.


Added DiffLines:

** Judomaster's fluency with English. In her first appearance in ''Birds of Prey'', she was perfectly fluent. Come her appearance here, she suddenly knows no English whatsoever.


Added DiffLines:

* UnusuallyUninterestingSight: During a time-travel story, Stargirl's locked up in a mental asylum. None of the staff seem particularly alarmed by her tech, and just confiscate it from her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:Ain't no school like the [[UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks old school.]]]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Ain't no school like the [[UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks old school.]]]]
school]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not accurate discription


** The original roster was Franchise/TheFlash, Franchise/GreenLantern, ComicBook/{{Hourman}}, Sandman, ComicBook/{{Hawkman}}, [[ComicBook/TheAtom Atom]], ComicBook/{{the Spectre}} and ComicBook/DoctorFate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StarterVillain: Fritz Klaver, a Nazi spymaster plotting to subvert various elements of the US war effort, and is captured by the end of his issue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The CrisisCrossover ''ComicBook/ZeroHour'' [[RocksFallEveryoneDies brutally killed off]] members Doctor Mid-Nite, Hourman, and the Atom (an act meant to both [[ExecutiveMeddling get rid of "embarrassing" older heroes and create some epic deaths for the big story]]), and wrote out Carter and Shiera Hall, the Golden Age Hawkman and Hawkgirl, by merging them with the Silver Age Hawkman, Katar Hol. Several other members were also aged to such an extent that they were forced to retire, most notably Doctor Fate (leading to the introduction of a new bearer of the mantle in the ''Fate'' series), Sandman and Johnny Thunder. The second revival, simply entitled ''JSA'', brought the team back together with numerous new members, [[BackFromTheDead resurrected]] Hourman (who retired and entrusted the mantle to his son) and the Carter Hall version of Hawkman, and eventually fizzled after 87 issues and yet another CrisisCrossover. It was initially written by James Robinson (and included his ComicBook/{{Starman}} in the lineup) and David Goyer. Robinson was later replaced by Creator/GeoffJohns, whose run on the book is generally considered the team's peak and is regarded as one of his best works to this day.

to:

The CrisisCrossover ''ComicBook/ZeroHour'' ''ComicBook/ZeroHourCrisisInTime'' [[RocksFallEveryoneDies brutally killed off]] members Doctor Mid-Nite, Hourman, and the Atom (an act meant to both [[ExecutiveMeddling get rid of "embarrassing" older heroes and create some epic deaths for the big story]]), and wrote out Carter and Shiera Hall, the Golden Age Hawkman and Hawkgirl, by merging them with the Silver Age Hawkman, Katar Hol. Several other members were also aged to such an extent that they were forced to retire, most notably Doctor Fate (leading to the introduction of a new bearer of the mantle in the ''Fate'' series), Sandman and Johnny Thunder. The second revival, simply entitled ''JSA'', brought the team back together with numerous new members, [[BackFromTheDead resurrected]] Hourman (who retired and entrusted the mantle to his son) and the Carter Hall version of Hawkman, and eventually fizzled after 87 issues and yet another CrisisCrossover. It was initially written by James Robinson (and included his ComicBook/{{Starman}} in the lineup) and David Goyer. Robinson was later replaced by Creator/GeoffJohns, whose run on the book is generally considered the team's peak and is regarded as one of his best works to this day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The comic book ''ComicBook/AllStarComics'', in 1940, was introduced as a standard anthology title featuring characters from other anthologies. However in the third issue (Winter, 1940), writer Gardner Fox introduced the Justice Society of America, teaming up the characters. '''Thus was born the world's first superhero team'''. The Justice Society was the TropeMaker for SuperTeam and because it was mostly for less-used characters, any character who got his own series would have minimal appearances, so [[Franchise/TheFlash Flash]] and Franchise/GreenLantern left when they got solo comics, Franchise/{{Superman}} and Franchise/{{Batman}} rarely appeared[[note]]They had their own books, and the publisher believed that including them would cannibalize sales[[/note]], and Franchise/WonderWoman was the JSA's [[StayInTheKitchen secretary]] and didn't go on missions until late in the Golden Age ''All-Star'' run. The team had a roster that changed from time to time, with characters leaving the team and others replacing them, until finally the lineup stabilized for the last two years of the book's run. The comic was canceled with issue #57 (February-March, 1951) at the end of UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks, with ''All-Star Western'' continuing the numbering.

to:

The comic book ''ComicBook/AllStarComics'', in 1940, was introduced as a standard anthology title featuring characters from other anthologies. However in the third issue (Winter, 1940), writer Gardner Fox introduced the Justice Society of America, teaming up the characters. '''Thus was born the world's first superhero team'''. The As the TropeMaker for SuperTeam, the Justice Society was the TropeMaker for SuperTeam and because it was mostly reserved for less-used characters, lesser-used characters and any character who got his own series would have minimal appearances, so [[Franchise/TheFlash Flash]] and Franchise/GreenLantern left when they got solo comics, Franchise/{{Superman}} and Franchise/{{Batman}} rarely appeared[[note]]They had their own books, and the publisher believed that including them would cannibalize sales[[/note]], and Franchise/WonderWoman was the JSA's [[StayInTheKitchen secretary]] and didn't go on missions until late in the Golden Age ''All-Star'' run. The team had a roster that changed from time to time, with characters leaving the team and others replacing them, until finally the lineup stabilized for the last two years of the book's run. The comic was canceled with issue #57 (February-March, 1951) at the end of UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks, with ''All-Star Western'' continuing the numbering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The comic book ''ComicBook/AllStarComics'', in 1940, was introduced as a standard anthology title featuring characters from other anthologies. However in the third issue (Winter, 1940), writer Gardner Fox introduced the Justice Society of America, teaming up the characters. '''Thus was born the first superhero team'''. Because it was mostly for less-used characters, any character who got his own series would have minimal appearances, so [[Franchise/TheFlash Flash]] and Franchise/GreenLantern left when they got solo comics, Franchise/{{Superman}} and Franchise/{{Batman}} rarely appeared[[note]]They had their own books, and the publisher believed that including them would cannibalize sales[[/note]], and Franchise/WonderWoman was the JSA's [[StayInTheKitchen secretary]] and didn't go on missions until late in the Golden Age ''All-Star'' run. The team had a roster that changed from time to time, with characters leaving the team and others replacing them, until finally the lineup stabilized for the last two years of the book's run. The comic was canceled with issue #57 (February-March, 1951) at the end of UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks, with ''All-Star Western'' continuing the numbering.

to:

The comic book ''ComicBook/AllStarComics'', in 1940, was introduced as a standard anthology title featuring characters from other anthologies. However in the third issue (Winter, 1940), writer Gardner Fox introduced the Justice Society of America, teaming up the characters. '''Thus was born the world's first superhero team'''. Because The Justice Society was the TropeMaker for SuperTeam and because it was mostly for less-used characters, any character who got his own series would have minimal appearances, so [[Franchise/TheFlash Flash]] and Franchise/GreenLantern left when they got solo comics, Franchise/{{Superman}} and Franchise/{{Batman}} rarely appeared[[note]]They had their own books, and the publisher believed that including them would cannibalize sales[[/note]], and Franchise/WonderWoman was the JSA's [[StayInTheKitchen secretary]] and didn't go on missions until late in the Golden Age ''All-Star'' run. The team had a roster that changed from time to time, with characters leaving the team and others replacing them, until finally the lineup stabilized for the last two years of the book's run. The comic was canceled with issue #57 (February-March, 1951) at the end of UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks, with ''All-Star Western'' continuing the numbering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The team is set to appear in the upcoming ComicBook/BlackAdam live action film set in the Franchise/DCExtendedUniverse and starring Wrestling/DwayneJohnson, with Creator/AldisHodge as Hawkman, Creator/NoahCentineo as Atom Smasher and Quintessa Swindell as Cyclone for the confirmed JSA members. The team will also get its own AnimatedAdaptation in the WesternAnimation/DCUniverseAnimatedOriginalMovies line, ''WesternAnimation/JusticeSocietyWorldWarII'' in 2021.

to:

The team is set to appear in the upcoming ComicBook/BlackAdam live action film set in the Franchise/DCExtendedUniverse and starring Wrestling/DwayneJohnson, with Creator/AldisHodge as Hawkman, Creator/NoahCentineo as Atom Smasher and Quintessa Swindell as Cyclone for the confirmed JSA members. The team will also get had its own AnimatedAdaptation in the WesternAnimation/DCUniverseAnimatedOriginalMovies line, ''WesternAnimation/JusticeSocietyWorldWarII'' in 2021.

Added: 23

Changed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Justice Society is mentioned by [[ComicBook/{{Hourman}} Rex Tyler]] in the first season finale of ''Series/LegendsOfTomorrow'', and makes a full appearance in the second season. The JSA also plays a prominent role in the live action ''Series/{{Stargirl}}'' series (which takes place on Earth-2 of the ''Franchise/DCLiveActionMultiverse'').

to:

The Justice Society is mentioned by [[ComicBook/{{Hourman}} Rex Tyler]] in the first season finale of ''Series/LegendsOfTomorrow'', and makes a full appearance in the second season. The JSA also plays a prominent role in the live action ''Series/{{Stargirl}}'' series (which takes place on Earth-2 of the ''Franchise/DCLiveActionMultiverse'').Earth-2).


Added DiffLines:

* ''Black Adam'' (2022)

Top