Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / ASongOfIceAndFireTheKingsguard

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Hypocrite}}: When he accuses Brienne of murdering Renly to Jaime, he argues that Brienne had no place in the Rainbow Guard and only beat him through trickery. But Jaime shoots back that Loras himself used trickery to beat Gregor Clegane in the joust, to which Loras could not make a retort.


Added DiffLines:

* JerkassHasAPoint: He argues that Sansa is guilty of [[spoiler:Joffrey's]] murder because she had the motive, and her abrupt disappearance from the scene of the crime only attests to her guilt. Jaime himself notes that Loras makes valid points.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* TheAce: Considered one of the best knights in Westeros at the moment, he is also known for his courtly manners and valor. When reflecting on Ser Balon's skills after he is appointed, Tyrion Lannister notes that he is "good with a lance, [[CarryABigStick better with a morningstar]], [[ArcherArchetype superb with a bow]]." Even Jaime tells him that the Kingsguard is honored to have him as a member, with his only issue being the question of how he will handle the possibility of ConflictingLoyalty should it arise.

to:

* TheAce: Considered one of the best knights in Westeros at the moment, he is also known for his courtly manners and valor. When reflecting on Ser Balon's skills after he is appointed, Tyrion Lannister notes that he is "good with a lance, [[CarryABigStick better with a morningstar]], [[ArcherArchetype superb with a bow]].bow." Even Jaime tells him that the Kingsguard is honored to have him as a member, with his only issue being the question of how he will handle the possibility of ConflictingLoyalty should it arise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FatBastard: Very much. To the point he actually comes across as sickly (possibly diabetic?). As well as annoying.

to:

* FatBastard: Very much. To the point he actually comes across as sickly (possibly diabetic?). As diabetic?) as well as annoying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even the function of the Kingsguard has caveats. Oh, it's packaged as being the best of the best knights of the realm being chosen to serve the king (and by extension, the kingdom) as both bodyguards and loyal advisors with vows that reflect those of the Night's Watch... But, this hides an often ugly truth in plain sight beyond the usually politely glossed-over issues reality vs ideals throws into the ring: seven knights, ones usually picked from the Great Houses (or other important factions) get bonded to the throne by vows supposed to be more binding than those of most knights. Not unlike, say, ''those of marriage''. Targaryens may not have married outsiders as often as they, perhaps, should have, but using vows sworn on the Seven this way is still a form AltarDiplomacy (for men!). With all the politics, bargaining and threats that entails.

to:

** Even the function of the Kingsguard has caveats. Oh, it's packaged as being the best of the best knights of the realm being chosen to serve the king (and by extension, the kingdom) as both bodyguards and loyal advisors with vows that reflect those of the Night's Watch... But, this hides an often ugly truth in plain sight beyond the usually politely glossed-over issues reality vs ideals throws into the ring: seven knights, ones usually picked from the Great Houses (or other important factions) get bonded to the throne by vows supposed to be more binding than those of most knights. Not unlike, say, ''those of marriage''. Targaryens may not have married outsiders as often as they, perhaps, should have, but using vows sworn on the Seven this way is still a form of AltarDiplomacy (for men!). With men!) with all the politics, bargaining and threats that entails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DirtyCoward: During the riot in King's Landing, he refuses to go find Sansa and bring her to safety, making a lame excuse that his white cloak might enrage the mob. Later, he is ordered to guard Prince Tommen by Cersei but immediately gives the boy up to Tyrion's forces when they ambush his own. He is temporarily stripped of rank, before being reinstated eventually. The only reason he probably isn't executed was that Tyrion would never hurt his nephew, and the Kingsguard needed a new member after the desertion of Sandor Clegane. Jaime eventually makes him Tommen's food taster to repay the man for his disgrace. When Blount protests this, Jaime retorts Blount is welcome to try and kill him if he doesn't like the Lord Commander's decision: Boros doesn't have the courage to try.

to:

* DirtyCoward: During the riot in King's Landing, he refuses to go find Sansa and bring her to safety, making a lame excuse that his white cloak might enrage the mob. Later, he is ordered to guard Prince Tommen by Cersei but immediately gives the boy up to Tyrion's forces when they ambush his own. He is temporarily stripped of rank, before being reinstated eventually. The only reason he probably isn't executed was that Tyrion would never hurt his nephew, and the Kingsguard needed a new member after the desertion of Sandor Clegane. Jaime eventually makes him Tommen's food taster to repay the man for his disgrace. When Blount protests this, Jaime retorts Blount is welcome to try and kill him if he doesn't like the Lord Commander's decision: even with Jaime down his sword hand, Boros doesn't have the courage to try.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheAlcoholic: Osmund Kettleblack describes him as "half-drunk half the time, fat even when he's sober."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNondescript: He's a bit handsome, but not stunningly so (good-looking enough for Arianne to take into her bed, at least). His face is described as "not unpleasant to look upon".

to:

* TheNondescript: He's a bit handsome, but not stunningly jaw-droppingly so (good-looking enough for Arianne to take into her bed, at least). His face is described as "not unpleasant to look upon".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustFollowingOrders: His excuse to Jaime when asked why he beat Sansa at Joffrey's command. Jaime tells him that they also have a duty to protect the King from their own silly decisions, and to only carry out reasonable commands from Tommen and come to him if he ever orders something cruel.

to:

* JustFollowingOrders: His excuse to Jaime when asked why he beat Sansa at Joffrey's command. Jaime tells him that since Tommen is an eight-year-old boy, they also have a duty to protect the King him from their his own silly decisions, and to only carry out reasonable commands from Tommen and come to him if he ever orders something cruel.

Added: 599

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RiddleForTheAges: It is a wonder how someone as useless, cowardly, and unpleasant as him get into the Kingsguard in the first place. At best it may have been a combination of the sheer number of spots that needed to be filled after the fall of Aerys and the implication that Boros was a pretty decent tourney knight in his youth. (Which would prove that there really is a world of difference between a tourney knight who specializes in jousting and a knight who fights in real battles or has to fulfill the bodyguard duties of the Kingsguard.) At worst he may have been a political appointment from the start, and the appointment made either to please some lord or so Blount would be the pawn of someone in the court.

to:

* RiddleForTheAges: It is a wonder how someone as useless, cowardly, and unpleasant as him get into the Kingsguard in the first place. At best it may have been a combination of the sheer number of spots that needed to be filled after the fall of Aerys and the implication that Boros was a pretty decent tourney knight in his youth. (Which would prove that there really is a world of difference between a tourney knight who specializes in the sport of jousting and a knight who fights in real battles or has to fulfill the bodyguard duties of the Kingsguard.) At worst he may have been a political appointment from the start, and the appointment made either to please some lord or so Blount would be the pawn of someone in the court.


Added DiffLines:

* FearlessFool: Trying to fight his way through a murderous and violent riot to try to save the High Septon was certainly brave, but not very smart. Being the sort of series that this is, it just leads to a messy and gruesome death for Ser Preston.


Added DiffLines:

* VillainousValor: When you get down to it, Ser Preston is the bodyguard of a young psychopath and as seen under his entry for Jerkass, he's not the nicest guy around. Unlike some of his compatriots like Ser Boros, however, he doesn't lack guts, and he dies in a brave (but foolish and futile) effort to try to save the High Septon from a violent mob.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LousyLoversAreLosers: When Arianne Martell takes Arys Oakheart as her lover (to [[ManipulativeBitch manipulative him]]) she was actually surprised by how bad in bed he was. She even recalls how their first time having sex ended with him [[SpeedSex climaxing on her thighs before he could even insert himself into her]]. She mentions she spent a long time 'training' and 'instructing' him about lovemaking so she wouldn't be bored and unsatisfied while having him as a lover. Somewhat {{Justified|Trope}} since he's part of the Kingsguard who all take an oath of [[CelibateHero celibacy]], so he's very inexperienced while Arianne is a SexGoddess.

to:

* LousyLoversAreLosers: When Arianne Martell takes Arys Oakheart as her lover (to [[ManipulativeBitch manipulative manipulate him]]) she was actually surprised by how bad in bed he was. She even recalls how their first time having sex ended with him [[SpeedSex climaxing on her thighs before he could even insert himself into her]]. She mentions she spent a long time 'training' and 'instructing' him about lovemaking so she wouldn't be bored and unsatisfied while having him as a lover. Somewhat {{Justified|Trope}} since he's part of the Kingsguard who all take an oath of [[CelibateHero celibacy]], so he's very inexperienced while Arianne is a SexGoddess.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EmptyShell: How Sansa views him. She realizes that unlike sadists like Joffrey or rage-fueled killers like the Hound, he doesn't feel any pleasure from hitting her... but he feels no guilt either. He carries out all orders dispassionately and seems ''confused'' as to why anybody would object.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvenTheGuysWantHim: That's how pretty he is.

to:

* EvenTheGuysWantHim: That's how pretty he is. And he wants them back, [[LoverAndBeloved or at least, he did one specific guy...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ButtMonkey: Despite being an elite kingsguard, he doesn't get a lot of respect. His greatest moment is killing the First Sword of Braavos, who was armed with only a stick and out-numbered 5-1. Jaime thinks he is adequate at best [[spoiler: while Cersei, Taena and Margaery all believe he doesn't stand a chance against Osmund Kettleblack, who may or may not be a real knight.]]

to:

* ButtMonkey: Despite being an elite kingsguard, he doesn't get a lot of respect. His greatest moment is killing the First Sword of Braavos, who was armed with only a stick and out-numbered 5-1.5-1, while Meryn himself had plate mail and a real metal sword. Jaime thinks he is adequate at best [[spoiler: while Cersei, Taena and Margaery all believe he doesn't stand a chance against Osmund Kettleblack, who may or may not be a real knight.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ButtMonkey: Despite being an elite kingsguard, he doesn't get a lot of respect. Sandor tells Arya that any boy with a soldier could defeat three Meryn Trants at once, Tyrion and Bronn (a sellsword at the time) humiliate him in sequence at court ("If Sr. Meryn speaks again, kill him.") and Jaime thinks he is adequate at best [[spoiler: while Cersei, Taena and Margaery all believe he doesn't stand a chance against Osmund Kettleblack.]]

to:

* ButtMonkey: Despite being an elite kingsguard, he doesn't get a lot of respect. Sandor tells Arya that any boy His greatest moment is killing the First Sword of Braavos, who was armed with only a soldier could defeat three Meryn Trants at once, Tyrion stick and Bronn (a sellsword at the time) humiliate him in sequence at court ("If Sr. Meryn speaks again, kill him.") and out-numbered 5-1. Jaime thinks he is adequate at best [[spoiler: while Cersei, Taena and Margaery all believe he doesn't stand a chance against Osmund Kettleblack.Kettleblack, who may or may not be a real knight.]]



* WouldHitAGirl[=/=]WouldHurtAChild: On Joffrey's orders.

to:

* WouldHitAGirl[=/=]WouldHurtAChild: On Joffrey's orders.orders, he'll beat up anyone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ButtMonkey: Despite being an elite kinsguard, he doesn't get a lot of respect. Sandor tells Arya that any boy with a soldier could defeat three Meryn Trants at once, Tyrion and Bron ( a sellsword at the time) hmuliate him in sequence at court ("If Sr. Meryn speaks again, kill him.") and Jaime thinks he is adequate at best [[spoiler: while Cersei, Taena and Margaery all believe he doesn't stand a chance against Osmund Kettleblack.]]

to:

* ButtMonkey: Despite being an elite kinsguard, kingsguard, he doesn't get a lot of respect. Sandor tells Arya that any boy with a soldier could defeat three Meryn Trants at once, Tyrion and Bron ( a Bronn (a sellsword at the time) hmuliate humiliate him in sequence at court ("If Sr. Meryn speaks again, kill him.") and Jaime thinks he is adequate at best [[spoiler: while Cersei, Taena and Margaery all believe he doesn't stand a chance against Osmund Kettleblack.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*ButtMonkey: Despite being an elite kinsguard, he doesn't get a lot of respect. Sandor tells Arya that any boy with a soldier could defeat three Meryn Trants at once, Tyrion and Bron ( a sellsword at the time) hmuliate him in sequence at court ("If Sr. Meryn speaks again, kill him.") and Jaime thinks he is adequate at best [[spoiler: while Cersei, Taena and Margaery all believe he doesn't stand a chance against Osmund Kettleblack.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RiddleForTheAges: It is a wonder how someone as useless, cowardly, and unpleasant as him get into the Kingsguard in the first place.

to:

* RiddleForTheAges: It is a wonder how someone as useless, cowardly, and unpleasant as him get into the Kingsguard in the first place. At best it may have been a combination of the sheer number of spots that needed to be filled after the fall of Aerys and the implication that Boros was a pretty decent tourney knight in his youth. (Which would prove that there really is a world of difference between a tourney knight who specializes in jousting and a knight who fights in real battles or has to fulfill the bodyguard duties of the Kingsguard.) At worst he may have been a political appointment from the start, and the appointment made either to please some lord or so Blount would be the pawn of someone in the court.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


For the Kingsguard members who served Aerys II, see [[Characters/ASongOfIceAndFireAerysKingsguard here]]. For historical kingsguard before that, see [[Characters/ASongOfIceAndFireHistoricalKingsguard here]].

to:

For the Kingsguard members who served Aerys II, see [[Characters/ASongOfIceAndFireAerysKingsguard here]]. For historical kingsguard Kingsguard before that, see [[Characters/ASongOfIceAndFireHistoricalKingsguard here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


For the Kingsguard members before the Baratheon Kings, see [[Characters/ASongOfIceAndFireHistoricalKingsguard here]].

to:

For the Kingsguard members who served Aerys II, see [[Characters/ASongOfIceAndFireAerysKingsguard here]]. For historical kingsguard before the Baratheon Kings, that, see [[Characters/ASongOfIceAndFireHistoricalKingsguard here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Tragically {{Subverted|Trope}}; he charges single-handedly into the face of overwhelming numbers (including many crossbowmen) rather than surrender Myrcella to them, shrugging off crossbow bolts even as they rip through his armour like paper and managing to slay three men even as his horse is killed beneath him before he is finally cut down. But it's [[SenselessSacrifice a pointless and unnecessary death]] and implied to be motivated more by [[DeathSeeker his shame and despair driving him over the edge]] than courage or duty, so that it ends up more tragic and pathetic than awesome

to:

* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Tragically {{Subverted|Trope}}; he charges single-handedly into the face of overwhelming numbers (including many crossbowmen) rather than surrender Myrcella to them, shrugging off crossbow bolts even as they rip through his armour like paper and managing to slay three men even as his horse is killed beneath him before he is finally cut down. But it's [[SenselessSacrifice a pointless and unnecessary death]] and implied to be motivated more by [[DeathSeeker his shame and despair driving him over the edge]] than courage or duty, so that it ends up more tragic and pathetic than awesomeawesome. Even more tragically, it also causes him to fail in his duty at the last second, as [[spoiler:he leaves Myrcella exposed to being attacked and nearly killed by Darkstar]].



** To Myrcella Baratheon, whom he is charged to protect while she is in Dorne. It's a purely platonic example since Arys views her as a surrogate daughter and [[spoiler:throws his life to protect her]].

to:

** To Myrcella Baratheon, whom he is charged to protect while she is in Dorne. It's a purely platonic example since Arys views her as a surrogate daughter and [[spoiler:throws his life away to protect her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TokenGoodTeammate: After Ser Barristan is removed from the Kingsguard, Arys is the only even half-decent person in it until Ser Balon Swann joins.

to:

* TokenGoodTeammate: After Ser Barristan is removed from the Kingsguard, Arys is the only even half-decent person in it until Ser Balon Swann joins. He's the only member of the Kingsguard who seems to feel any real shame over beating Sansa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MyMasterRightOrWrong: Enforced. Ser Balon has a brother, Donnel, who sided with first Stannis, then Renly, and now serves House Lannister. Tyrion, noting this at an unrelated time, is impressed with House Swann's pragmatism, but Jaime sees only potential holes in the Kingsguard.

to:

* MyMasterRightOrWrong: Enforced. Ser Balon has a brother, Donnel, who sided with first Renly, then Stannis, then Renly, and now serves House Lannister. Tyrion, noting this at an unrelated time, is impressed with House Swann's pragmatism, but Jaime sees only potential holes in the Kingsguard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Tragically {{Subverted|Trope}}; he charges single-handedly into the face of overwhelming numbers (including many crossbowmen) rather than surrender Myrcella to them, shrugging off crossbow bolts even as they rip through his armour like paper and managing to slay three men even as his horse is killed beneath him before he is finally cut down. But it's [[SenselessSacrifice a pointless and unnecessary death]] and implied to be motivated more by [[DeathSeeker his shame and despair driving him over the edge]] than courage or duty that it's more tragic and pathetic than awesome

to:

* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Tragically {{Subverted|Trope}}; he charges single-handedly into the face of overwhelming numbers (including many crossbowmen) rather than surrender Myrcella to them, shrugging off crossbow bolts even as they rip through his armour like paper and managing to slay three men even as his horse is killed beneath him before he is finally cut down. But it's [[SenselessSacrifice a pointless and unnecessary death]] and implied to be motivated more by [[DeathSeeker his shame and despair driving him over the edge]] than courage or duty duty, so that it's it ends up more tragic and pathetic than awesome
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DyingMomentOfAwesome: Tragically {{Subverted|Trope}}; he charges single-handedly into the face of overwhelming numbers (including many crossbowmen) rather than surrender Myrcella to them, shrugging off crossbow bolts even as they rip through his armour like paper and managing to slay three men even as his horse is killed beneath him before he is finally cut down. But it's [[SenselessSacrifice a pointless and unnecessary death]] and implied to be motivated more by [[DeathSeeker his shame and despair driving him over the edge]] than courage or duty that it's more tragic and pathetic than awesome
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAce: Considered one of the best knights in Westeros at the moment, he is also known for his courtly manners and valor. When reflecting on Ser Balon's skills after he is appointed, Tyrion Lannister notes that he is "good with a lance, [[CarryABigStick better with a morningstar]], [[ArcherArchetype superb with a bow]]."

to:

* TheAce: Considered one of the best knights in Westeros at the moment, he is also known for his courtly manners and valor. When reflecting on Ser Balon's skills after he is appointed, Tyrion Lannister notes that he is "good with a lance, [[CarryABigStick better with a morningstar]], [[ArcherArchetype superb with a bow]]."" Even Jaime tells him that the Kingsguard is honored to have him as a member, with his only issue being the question of how he will handle the possibility of ConflictingLoyalty should it arise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Additionally to the Night's Watch, [[InvokedTrope who they were originally modelled on.]] Night's Watch members are sworn to protect "the realms of men", the Kingsguard are sworn only to protect the king and his immediate family. There are almost a thousand Black Brothers even at the lowest point in the Watch's history, there are only seven Kingsguard members at a time. The Night's Watch was founded in TheTimeOfMyths by the first Stark king, the Kingsguard only a few hundred years ago by the first Targaryen king. The Night's Watch wears all black, the Kingsguard wears all white. Both are a shadow of their former selves, the Night's Watch because it lost its prestige, forcing them to recruit criminals rather than skilled warriors, the Kingsguard because it became incredibly prestigious, causing the recruitment process to be corrupted by {{Nepotism}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[quoteright:244:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/balon_swann.jpg]]



** For good or ill, Ser Balon appears to be taking this seriously. In ''A Dance With Dragons'' [[spoiler:he's under orders by Cersei to stage an ambush while bringing Myrcella back to King's Landing which would end in Prince Trystane Martell's death and Tyrion being framed for the deed. Doran Martell notes that though Ser Balon obviously hates the orders, he plans to obey]].

to:

** For good or ill, Ser Balon appears to be taking this seriously. In ''A Dance With Dragons'' [[spoiler:he's under orders by Cersei to stage an ambush while bringing Myrcella back to King's Landing which would end in Prince Trystane Martell's death and Tyrion being framed for the deed. Doran Martell notes that though Ser Balon obviously hates the orders, he plans to obey]].obey. He even seems mildly sympathetic, stating that Balon's position is no different from that of his own bodyguard, Areo Hotah]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GossipyHens: He's fond of gossip, but only when he's sure no one is listening.

Added: 97

Changed: 34

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KnightsInShiningArmour: Who they're supposed to be. Unfortunately, this isn't always the case.



* ToBeLawfulOrGood: Some of the members face this issue.

to:

* ToBeLawfulOrGood: Some of the members face this issue.Every single member.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PunchClockVillain: Under Joffrey, Aerys II and Maegor the cruel.

to:

* PunchClockVillain: Under Joffrey, Aerys II II, and Maegor the cruel.

Top