Follow TV Tropes

Following

History BreakTheCutie / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Aaaand... now he's homeless.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Aaaand... now he's homeless.]]]]
* The critiques, especially from Randy Jackson, after Haley Reinhart's first performance in Top 4 week of ''{{American Idol}}'' Season 10. ItGotWorse after the round was over and Ryan Seacrest called the four finalists out for an overall Round 1 assessment. To top it off, they ruined the surprise of what she was wearing for her second performance (which epitomized CrowningMusicOfAwesome and showed that the "breaking" didn't quite work). Nigel Lythgoe couldn't have scripted it better...oh, wait...he admitted that he DID script it that way!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The new series Miracle Day will also be using this, it seems. [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qv7iZy7TJz8&feature=relmfu This trailer]] gives away that most, if not all, of the characters will be broken by the end, but the cutie in question, Esther Drummond, gets the worst of it, seemingly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** A madcap [[BowtiesAreCool bow-tie]]-wearing, [[NiceHat hat-loving]] [[TheWoobie perma-Woobie]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: Amber Canardo]] from the episode "The Perfect Storm" comes pre-broken. She was [[spoiler: beaten and raped by both her father and her brother throughout her childhood, and her mother covered it up for them and even told the police she was lying when she went to them.]] She ends up becoming [[spoiler: a serial killer herself who does what she suffered to other women, presumably to achieve a sense of fairness.]] Then there's Samantha Malcolm from "The Uncanny Valley" who was [[spoiler: also raped by her father, who bribed her with toys to keep her quiet and tortured her with electric shocks, with Samantha finally snapping after walking in on her father, a psychiatrist, giving away her toys to a patient.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Master of ''DoctorWho'' does this a ''lot'' in the season finale. By the beginning of the final episode, [[spoiler:he's done heavily implied squicky things to Jack and chained him up in the basement of his airship, which is only made more disturbing by the fact that Jack's immortal; done heavily implied squicky things to Martha's family to the point that, just before the cavalry arrives, they're sitting in a circle ''fighting over who gets to kill him''; aged the Doctor's body, done heavily implied squicky things to him, aged his body again, and locked him in a birdcage; and turned his formerly happy (albeit mostly trigger-happy) wife into a battered slave.]]. Fortunately, everybody gets better [[spoiler:except for Lucy]] by the end of the episode.

to:

* The Master of ''DoctorWho'' ''Series/DoctorWho'' does this a ''lot'' in the season finale. By the beginning of the final episode, [[spoiler:he's done heavily implied squicky things to Jack and chained him up in the basement of his airship, which is only made more disturbing by the fact that Jack's immortal; done heavily implied squicky things to Martha's family to the point that, just before the cavalry arrives, they're sitting in a circle ''fighting over who gets to kill him''; aged the Doctor's body, done heavily implied squicky things to him, aged his body again, and locked him in a birdcage; and turned his formerly happy (albeit mostly trigger-happy) wife into a battered slave.]]. Fortunately, everybody gets better [[spoiler:except for Lucy]] by the end of the episode.

Added: 399

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Midnight.'' When a mysterious unseen creature strikes his transport, the Doctor watches helplessly as his "listen to me, I'm clever and I can help" attitude not only fails miserably but starts to turn the rest of the passengers ''against'' him and leaves him open to immobilizing MindRape, resulting in one of the most intense cases of HumansAreBastards in the whole series. If you don't find yourself wanting very desperately to [[TheWoobie give him a hug]] when it all ends and he's lying sprawled on the floor and clutching his chest gasping "It's gone...it's gone...it's gone..." then I don't know what to do with you.

to:

** ''Midnight.'' When a mysterious unseen creature strikes his transport, the Doctor watches helplessly as his "listen to me, I'm clever and I can help" attitude not only fails miserably but starts to turn the rest of the passengers ''against'' him and leaves him open to immobilizing MindRape, resulting in one of the most intense cases of HumansAreBastards in the whole series. If you don't find yourself wanting very desperately to [[TheWoobie give him a hug]] when it all ends and he's lying sprawled on the floor and clutching his chest gasping "It's gone... it's gone... it's gone...it's gone..." then I don't know what to do with you.


Added DiffLines:

** The Fifth Doctor was the nicest, mildest, friendliest, most trusting and most pacific of all the Doctors. The death toll in his adventures was horrific and frequently claimed all the non-regular cast; Adric, a long-running companion and only a boy, was killed; Tegan ran away because she'd seen enough death. He eventually sacrificed himself to prevent yet another person dying on him. Poor soul.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''A Good Man Goes To War'', both Amy and the Doctor get pretty broken. First, [[spoiler:Amy gets her baby taken away, the baby she hadn't even known she was pregnant with until a month before; then, the Doctor saves her and Melody, only to realize that his entire plan has led them all into a massive trap. Melody is not really Melody but is Flesh!Melody, who then dissolves in Amy's arms. Amy, understandably, freaks out. The Doctor tries to hug her, but she won't let him. [[TearJerker That broke him, hard.]] And then, just to pour salt into his open wound, River shows up and gives him an interestingly inverted version of a TheReasonYouSuckSpeech in which she tells him he's getting too good at what he does and becoming a mighty warrior, exactly the opposite of what he wanted, and because of this, it's his fault that Melody was taken. Ouch.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sam from {{Glee}} seems to be headed this way, due to [[spoiler: Quinn cheating on him with Finn]], Santana's consistent insults about his mouth and dorkyness, and just general pressure.

to:

* Sam from {{Glee}} seems to be headed this way, due to [[spoiler: Quinn cheating on him with Finn]], Santana's consistent insults about his mouth and dorkyness, and just general pressure.pressure.
** [[spoiler: Aaaand... now he's homeless.]]

Added: 306

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One Name: Cally. Shown as the cute deck hand and gofer girl to the chief, she stays cute and relatively innocent (like Kaylee from Firefly) up to Kobol and from there takes worse. [[spoiler: It wasn't too bad untill Nikki started playing up, her marriage was falling apart (like all bsg ones seem to) Then she tried to commit suicide but was murdered instead. This was one uber woobie moment.]]
* Happens in a completely mundane, underplayed, and painful way to Peggy Olsen on ''MadMen''. In the pilot, she's tiny, wide-eyed, hopeful, and naive; since then, she's had a disastrous affair with a {{Jerkass}} coworker (which he initiated just days before his wedding), been mocked and sexually harassed on an hourly basis, and [[spoiler: gotten pregnant, denied it ''until she went into labor'', been declared an unfit mother, and been forced to hand the kid over. Then her boss came and told her to just go on pretending it'd never happened. Yeah, that'll work.]]. Granted,she's made some great strides on the career front, and become miles more confident than she was in the pilot, but... to sum it up in one heartbreaking word? Playgrounds.

to:

** One Name: Cally. Shown as the cute deck hand and gofer girl to the chief, she stays cute and relatively innocent (like Kaylee from Firefly) up to Kobol and from there takes worse. [[spoiler: It wasn't too bad untill until Nikki started playing up, her marriage was falling apart (like all bsg ones seem to) Then she tried to commit suicide but was murdered instead. This was one uber woobie moment.]]
* Happens in a completely mundane, underplayed, and painful way to Peggy Olsen on ''MadMen''. In the pilot, she's tiny, wide-eyed, hopeful, and naive; since then, she's had a disastrous affair with a {{Jerkass}} coworker (which he initiated just days before his wedding), wedding), been mocked and sexually harassed on an hourly basis, and [[spoiler: gotten pregnant, denied it ''until she went into labor'', been declared an unfit mother, and been forced to hand the kid over. Then her boss came and told her to just go on pretending it'd never happened. Yeah, that'll work.]]. Granted,she's ]] Granted, she's made some great strides on the career front, and become miles more confident than she was in the pilot, but... to sum it up in one heartbreaking word? Playgrounds.Playgrounds.
*** Not to mention, [[DaddysGirl her dad]] [[DarkAndTroubledPast died right in front of her]], her mother and sister will never think she's good enough, and then there's the pesky priest who won't stop bugging her to confess her sins and feel guilty like a [[RaisedCatholic proper]] [[SexIsEvil Catholic]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Happens in a completely mundane, underplayed, and painful way to Peggy Olsen on ''MadMen''. In the pilot, she's tiny, wide-eyed, hopeful, and naive; since then, she's had a disastrous affair with a {{Jerkass}} coworker (which he initiated on the night before his wedding), been mocked and sexually harassed on an hourly basis, and [[spoiler: gotten pregnant, denied it ''until she went into labor'', been declared an unfit mother, and been forced to hand the kid over to her bitchy, controlling sister to raise]]. Granted, she's had a few lucky breaks on the career front, but she's looking a lot more tense these days.

to:

* Happens in a completely mundane, underplayed, and painful way to Peggy Olsen on ''MadMen''. In the pilot, she's tiny, wide-eyed, hopeful, and naive; since then, she's had a disastrous affair with a {{Jerkass}} coworker (which he initiated on the night just days before his wedding), been mocked and sexually harassed on an hourly basis, and [[spoiler: gotten pregnant, denied it ''until she went into labor'', been declared an unfit mother, and been forced to hand the kid over to over. Then her bitchy, controlling sister boss came and told her to raise]]. Granted, she's had a few lucky breaks just go on pretending it'd never happened. Yeah, that'll work.]]. Granted,she's made some great strides on the career front, but she's looking a lot and become miles more tense these days.confident than she was in the pilot, but... to sum it up in one heartbreaking word? Playgrounds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Over seven seasons Willow loses her first lover to the curse of lycanthropy, loses her new lover to a brainwipe, gets her lover back, watches her best friend die, loses her lover to her obsession with magic, gets her lover back, and just as they've finally reconciled loses her lover to a random gunshot that wasn't even intended for her. Bad Things ensue.

to:

** Over seven seasons Willow loses her first lover to the curse of lycanthropy, loses her new lover to a brainwipe, gets her lover back, watches her best friend die, loses her lover to her obsession with magic, gets her lover back, and just as they've finally reconciled loses her lover to a random gunshot that wasn't even intended for her. Bad Things ensue.ensue, and the primary focus of her arc in the next season is just putting her back together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Over seven seasons Willow loses her first lover to the curse of lycanthropy, loses her new lover to a brainwipe, gets her lover back, watches her best friend die, loses her lover to her obsession with magic, gets her lover back, and just as they've finally reconciled loses her lover to a random gunshot that wasn't even intended for her. Bad Things ensue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even before that, the script writers decided to pile the abuse on Elliot, [[DeusAngstMachina culminating with her being sued by a]] JerkAss [[DeusAngstMachina patient, causing her to get kicked out of her house and live in her moving van,]] ''[[DeusAngstMachina which then gets stolen with all of her stuff.]]''

to:

** Even before that, the script writers decided to pile the abuse on Elliot, [[DeusAngstMachina culminating with her being sued by a]] JerkAss [[DeusAngstMachina patient, causing her to get kicked out of her house and live in her moving van,]] ''[[DeusAngstMachina which then gets stolen with all of her stuff.]]'']]'' And none of her friends seem to care.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding example


** Don't forget Anya, who spends most of her time on the show as the perky and bubbly comic relief. Then [[spoiler:Xander leaves her at the altar]] late in season 6. She reacts to this by [[spoiler: returning to vengeance. She finds herself unable to do it properly at first, but when she does get back into the swing by slaughtering ten frat boys who humiliated a girl, she suddenly realises what she's done and plunges into [[DeathSeeker Death Seekerdom]] To top that off, when she begs D'Hoffryn to undo it (the price of which would be her life and soul), he instead kills her friend Halfrek in front of her as the payment. He then follows this up with, "Haven't I taught you anything, Anya? Never go for the kill when you can go for the pain."]]. She survives, and is still comic relief, but she's a little less perky now.

to:

** Don't forget Anya, who spends most of her time on the show as the perky and bubbly comic relief. Then [[spoiler:Xander leaves her at the altar]] late in season 6. She reacts to this by [[spoiler: returning to vengeance. She finds herself unable to do it properly at first, but when she does get back into the swing by slaughtering ten frat boys who humiliated a girl, she suddenly realises what she's done and plunges into [[DeathSeeker Death Seekerdom]] To top that off, when she begs D'Hoffryn to undo it (the price of which would be her life and soul), he instead kills her friend Halfrek in front of her as the payment. He then follows this up with, "Haven't I taught you anything, Anya? Never go for the kill when you can go for the pain."]]. She survives, and is still comic relief, but she's a little less perky now. [[spoiler: And then she gets cut in half.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sam from [[Glee Glee]] seems to be headed this way, due to [[spoiler: Quinn cheating on him with Finn]], Santana's consistent insults about his mouth and dorkyness, and just general pressure.

to:

* Sam from [[Glee Glee]] {{Glee}} seems to be headed this way, due to [[spoiler: Quinn cheating on him with Finn]], Santana's consistent insults about his mouth and dorkyness, and just general pressure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It took more effort to type out that sentence than it would have taken to just fucking remove the entry.


* The FatalFrame series ''lives by'' this trope.
** Wait shouldn't this go in the video game section???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** YourMileageMayVary, some of these don't really qualify. Just because someone is cute doesn't make them TheCutie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wellard in the second [[HoratioHornblower Horatio Hornblower]] series. Also Archie Kennedy, though in his case the breaking took place mostly off-screen (first before the series even started, at the hands of Jack Simpson, and then after he was imprisoned for an indeterminate amount of time, including a month in an oubliette.). Archie at least seems to have recovered from most of his torments by the second series, but [[spoiler: Wellard is shot and dies before he has the chance.]] Additionally, Simpson tries to do this to Horatio in the first instalment, which is what results in the titular duel. (Well, technically a game of cards was what caused the duel -- but Horatio wouldn't have made the challenge if it hadn't been for everything else that had gone on.)

to:

* Wellard in the second [[HoratioHornblower Horatio Hornblower]] series. Also Archie Kennedy, though in his case the breaking took place mostly off-screen (first before the series even started, at the hands of Jack Simpson, and then after he was imprisoned for an indeterminate amount of time, including a month in an oubliette.). Archie at least seems to have recovered from most of his torments by the second series, but [[spoiler: Wellard is shot and dies before he has the chance.]] Additionally, Simpson tries to do this to Horatio in the first instalment, which is what results in the titular duel. (Well, technically a game of cards was what caused the duel -- but Horatio wouldn't have made the challenge if it hadn't been for everything else that had gone on.))
* Sam from [[Glee Glee]] seems to be headed this way, due to [[spoiler: Quinn cheating on him with Finn]], Santana's consistent insults about his mouth and dorkyness, and just general pressure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** YourMileageMayVary, some of these don't really qualify. Just because someone is cute doesn't make them TheCutie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Wait shouldn't this go in the video game section???

to:

** Wait shouldn't this go in the video game section???section???
* Wellard in the second [[HoratioHornblower Horatio Hornblower]] series. Also Archie Kennedy, though in his case the breaking took place mostly off-screen (first before the series even started, at the hands of Jack Simpson, and then after he was imprisoned for an indeterminate amount of time, including a month in an oubliette.). Archie at least seems to have recovered from most of his torments by the second series, but [[spoiler: Wellard is shot and dies before he has the chance.]] Additionally, Simpson tries to do this to Horatio in the first instalment, which is what results in the titular duel. (Well, technically a game of cards was what caused the duel -- but Horatio wouldn't have made the challenge if it hadn't been for everything else that had gone on.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Throughout the 4 seasons of ''{{LOST}}'' so far, Hurley, the series' comic relief and all-around nice guy, [[spoiler: has been revealed to be cursed with bad luck by the mysterious Numbers, which he used to win the lottery. Also, he's not quite right in the head, believes himself responsible for the death of some people in an accident years ago as well as for the crash of Oceanic 815. When he starts controlling his eating habits, a whole lot of food just pops out of nowhere, leading him to believe the island is inside his head, and almost commits suicide. He meets a girl on the island who is interested in him, but she turns out to secretly be another mental patient from the same institution he was at. Then she dies. Then he has to kill a bad guy to save his friends. Then his best friend dies. Then the camp divides and he picks the side that gets massacred, but survives, and starts being haunted by Jacob's cabin. Finally he leaves the island, but not before watching the freighter where some of his friends were explode. On the outside world, his family unintentionally tortures him, so he leaves them, gets arrested and thrown back into a mental institution, and becomes haunted by the people who died on the island, including his best friend.]] Not so nice anymore.

to:

* Throughout the first 4 seasons of ''{{LOST}}'' so far, Hurley, Hurley was the series' comic relief and all-around nice guy, even though he believes he is cursed and still struggles with his food addiction on the island. Once he [[spoiler: has been revealed to be cursed with bad luck by gets off the mysterious Numbers, which he used to win the lottery. Also, he's not quite right in the head, believes himself responsible for the death of some people in an accident years ago as well as for the crash of Oceanic 815. When island]], however, he starts controlling his eating habits, a whole lot of food just pops out of nowhere, leading him to believe the island is inside his head, and almost commits suicide. He meets a girl on the island who is interested in him, but she turns out to secretly be another mental patient from the same institution he was at. Then she dies. Then he has to kill a bad guy to save his friends. Then his best friend dies. Then the camp divides and he picks the side that gets massacred, but survives, and starts being haunted by Jacob's cabin. Finally he leaves the island, but not before watching the freighter where some of his friends were explode. On the outside world, his family unintentionally tortures him, so he leaves them, gets arrested and thrown back into a mental institution, and becomes become haunted by the ghosts of people who died on from the island, including his best friend.]] Not so nice anymore.and by the end of season four, he's far from the happy-go-lucky Hurley of earlier seasons. He gets better [[spoiler: once he returns to the island]], however.



** Season 6 [[spoiler:Claire]], anyone? Granted, it all happens off screen, but still.

to:

** Season 6 [[spoiler:Claire]], anyone? who's become a bit insane after being alone in the jungle for three years. Granted, it all happens off screen, but still.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Randy Wagstaff of [[TheWire The Wire]]. [[spoiler: Starts out as a sweet, likeable kid trying to make the best of life in his surroundings but gets fucked over by Herc, causing him to be wrongfully branded a snitch. His house is burned down and his foster mother badly burned such that he has to go back to the group home, where takes numerous beatings from the other kids. By the next time he's seen, he become mean and violent just to survive.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** During the more [[FoeYay "serious"]] scenes between the Doctor and the Master, you can see the Master himself suffers this because of the drums.

to:

**** During the more [[FoeYay "serious"]] scenes between the Doctor and the Master, you can see the Master himself suffers this because of the drums. Suffers it horribly, in fact. Which means that ''everything the Master has ever done'' was the fault of [[spoiler: Rassilon and the Council]]; he started out as a completely normal child. Poor mad Master.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[StoicWoobie Who was already severely broken before those events]].


Added DiffLines:

** Really [[DysfunctionJunction every single character was already broken at the beginning]]. ItGotWorse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The FatalFrame series ''lives by'' this trope.

to:

* The FatalFrame series ''lives by'' this trope.trope.
** Wait shouldn't this go in the video game section???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Zack, from {{Bones}}, anyone? He was an {{Adorkable}} kid who was very socially awkward, but overall well liked and definitely a cutie. Then, we find out that he's the apprentice to a cannibalistic murderer, and he confesses to murdering somebody (although we find out later that he didn't actually kill the guy). He is then sent to a mental institution. Definitely qualifies as breaking the cutie.

to:

* Zack, from {{Bones}}, anyone? He was an {{Adorkable}} kid who was very socially awkward, but overall well liked and definitely a cutie. Then, we find out that he's the apprentice to a cannibalistic murderer, and he confesses to murdering somebody (although we find out later that he didn't actually kill the guy). He is then sent to a mental institution. Definitely qualifies as breaking the cutie.cutie.
* The FatalFrame series ''lives by'' this trope.

Added: 330

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Don't forget Anya, who spends most of her time on the show as the perky and bubbly comic relief. Then [[spoiler:Xander leaves her at the altar]] late in season 6. She reacts to this by [[spoiler: returning to vengeance. She finds herself unable to do it properly at first, but when she does get back into the swing by slaughtering ten frat boys who humiliated a girl, she suddenly realises what she's done and plunges into [[DeathSeeker Death Seekerdom]] To top that off, when she begs D'Hoffryn to undo it (the price of which would be her life and soul), he instead kills Halfrek in front of her as the payment. He then follows this up with, "Haven't I taught you anything, Anya? Never go for the kill when you can go for the pain."]]. She survives, and is still comic relief, but she's a little less perky now.

to:

** Don't forget Anya, who spends most of her time on the show as the perky and bubbly comic relief. Then [[spoiler:Xander leaves her at the altar]] late in season 6. She reacts to this by [[spoiler: returning to vengeance. She finds herself unable to do it properly at first, but when she does get back into the swing by slaughtering ten frat boys who humiliated a girl, she suddenly realises what she's done and plunges into [[DeathSeeker Death Seekerdom]] To top that off, when she begs D'Hoffryn to undo it (the price of which would be her life and soul), he instead kills her friend Halfrek in front of her as the payment. He then follows this up with, "Haven't I taught you anything, Anya? Never go for the kill when you can go for the pain."]]. She survives, and is still comic relief, but she's a little less perky now.now.
** None of these hold a candle to Buffy. A summary of her suffering would be a synopsis of the entire series. Highlights include her boyfriend losing his soul and becoming a CompleteMonster after sleeping with her, losing her mother to an aneurysm, being pulled out of heaven, and spending seven years fighting a war against evil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Zack, from "Bones", anyone? He was [[Adorkable an adorable little science nerd]] who was very socially awkward, but overall well liked and definitely a cutie. Then, we find out that he's the apprentice to a cannibalistic murderer, and he confesses to murdering somebody (although we find out later that he didn't actually kill the guy). He is then sent to a mental institution. Definitely qualifies as breaking the cutie.

to:

* Zack, from "Bones", {{Bones}}, anyone? He was [[Adorkable an adorable little science nerd]] {{Adorkable}} kid who was very socially awkward, but overall well liked and definitely a cutie. Then, we find out that he's the apprentice to a cannibalistic murderer, and he confesses to murdering somebody (although we find out later that he didn't actually kill the guy). He is then sent to a mental institution. Definitely qualifies as breaking the cutie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Michael:''' She's sweet. At least she was until today. Today we drain her of her soul.

to:

-->'''Michael:''' She's sweet. At least she was until today. Today we drain her of her soul.soul.
*Zack, from "Bones", anyone? He was [[Adorkable an adorable little science nerd]] who was very socially awkward, but overall well liked and definitely a cutie. Then, we find out that he's the apprentice to a cannibalistic murderer, and he confesses to murdering somebody (although we find out later that he didn't actually kill the guy). He is then sent to a mental institution. Definitely qualifies as breaking the cutie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Alternatively, he was trying to rationalize his breaking moment as a malfunction on ''his'' part.

Top