Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Administrivia / NoNewStockphrases

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Either stock phrases are okay, or they\'re not. If they\'re not, then all previous stock phrase pages should be discarded. I just stumbled upon ButThisIsRidiculous, which seems to be a prime example of why no more such pages were wanted. Shouldn\'t the vast majority of stock phrase pages be discarded (keeping the few that really work, of course)?
to:
Either stock phrases are okay, or they\\\'re not. If they\\\'re not, then all previous stock phrase pages should be discarded. I just stumbled upon ButThisIsRidiculous, which seems to be a prime example of why no more such pages were wanted. Shouldn\\\'t the vast majority of stock phrase pages be discarded (keeping the few that really work, of course)?

PS. I\\\'m in the camp of keeping the pages, but if so then new pages should be allowed to be created. This category of pages just doesn\\\'t seem worthy of a GrandfatherClause \\\'\\\'just\\\'\\\' because they predate the rule.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
BaseBreaker: Aang...and Katara...and Azula...and Suki...and Mai... and Ty Lee... and Zuko. Name a character, really.

I think this entry deserves a better rewritte because like this, it\'s [[ZeroContextExample vague and non indicative]].
Putting DieForOurShip aside, I only see Katara (whether she\'s a role model or a hypocrite) and Zuko (whether he\'s a badass or an emo) as major BaseBreakers (I personnaly like them but this is what I constate on discussions).
What do you think?
to:
Edit: sorry it tried to open a new thread.
Top