Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / YamatoNadeshiko

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Bear in mind, however, that when Urubuchi said that, it\'s very unlikely he\'ll be talking about the SMT, and thus the Pantheon\'s incarnation of Lucifer. The one from Christian mythology is the whiny, human-hating, \
to:
Bear in mind, however, that when Urubuchi said that, it\\\'s very unlikely he\\\'ll be talking about the SMT, and thus the Pantheon\\\'s incarnation of Lucifer. The one from Christian mythology is the whiny, human-hating, \\\"I\\\'m-so-awesome-that-I\\\'m-better-than-god-and-I-deserve-to-rule-everything\\\" douchenozzle we\\\'d see in Series/{{Supernatural}} or VideoGame/CastlevaniaLordsOfShadow. From that perspective, yes: Homura isn\\\'t like Lucifer. But from that perspective neither is, well...[[Franchise/{{ShinMegamiTensei}} Lucifer.]]

As long as it has to do with overthrowing an established order, he\\\'s liable to have a hand in it. Already it\\\'s been established in the Gaiden chapter that Lucifer is preying on her fears of Madoka being hurt, which is really how Vader got HIS start as well. Besides, Vader has no way of stealing Madoka\\\'s power, while Lucifer gave her a magatama (the contents of the box) that would end up doing so. While Lucifer gave her the means, Vader\\\'s role could be the tipping point: Homura is arguing with herself over what to do after the Fear Toxin incident and the realization that Kyubey can bring back the witch system (Lucifer was the one who told him the truth in order to put the squeeze on Homura), and Vader\\\'s talk with her is the one who tips the scale and makes her mind up. A Duumvirate could be a good compromise. Everyone gets something out of it, even us: re-writing everything from scratch would be a pain.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I\'m not sure they have to be mutually exclusive. Just because Homura isn\'t a direct analogue to the guy doesn\'t mean we should throw out Lucifer\'s involvement entirely. As long as it has to do with overthrowing an established order, he\'s liable to have a hand in it. Already it\'s been established in the Gaiden chapter that Lucifer is preying on her fears of Madoka being hurt. Besides, Vader has no way of stealing Madoka\'s power, while Lucifer gave her a magatama (the contents of the box) that would end up doing so. While Lucifer gave her the means, Vader\'s role could be the tipping point: Homura is arguing with herself over what to do after the Fear Toxin incident and the realization that Kyubey can bring back the witch system (Lucifer was the one who told him the truth in order to put the squeeze on Homura), and Vader is the one who tips the scale and makes her mind up. A Duumvirate could be a good compromise. Everyone gets something out of it, even us: re-writing everything from scratch would be a pain.
to:
Bear in mind, however, that when Urubuchi said that, it\\\'s very unlikely he\\\'ll be talking about the SMT, and thus the Pantheon\\\'s incarnation of Lucifer. The one from Christian mythology is the whiny, human-hating, \\\"I\\\'m-so-awesome-that-I\\\'m-better-than-god-and-I-deserve-to-rule-everything\\\" douchenozzle we\\\'d see in Series/{{Supernatural}} or [[VideoGame/CastlevaniaLordsOfShadow]]. From that perspective, yes: Homura isn\\\'t like Lucifer. But from that perspective neither is, well...[[Franchise/{{ShinMegamiTensei}} Lucifer.]]

As long as it has to do with overthrowing an established order, he\\\'s liable to have a hand in it. Already it\\\'s been established in the Gaiden chapter that Lucifer is preying on her fears of Madoka being hurt, which is really how Vader got HIS start as well. Besides, Vader has no way of stealing Madoka\\\'s power, while Lucifer gave her a magatama (the contents of the box) that would end up doing so. While Lucifer gave her the means, Vader\\\'s role could be the tipping point: Homura is arguing with herself over what to do after the Fear Toxin incident and the realization that Kyubey can bring back the witch system (Lucifer was the one who told him the truth in order to put the squeeze on Homura), and Vader\\\'s talk with her is the one who tips the scale and makes her mind up. A Duumvirate could be a good compromise. Everyone gets something out of it, even us: re-writing everything from scratch would be a pain.
Top