[001]
magnum12
Current Version
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
3. Eva\'s journal, which is confirmed to have the truth. The contents of that truth are indeed knowable. Since Eva hates Shannon, if Shkannontrice is the culprit, then WHY does Eva keep the truth of the murders and allow herself to be believed to be the culprit even on her death bed. Major plot hole there. It makes more sense to cover up that truth Eva had a more personal attachment i.e George is one of the culprits.
to:
3. Eva\\\'s journal, which is confirmed to have the truth. The contents of that truth are indeed knowable. Since Eva hates Shannon, if Shkannontrice is the culprit, then WHY does Eva keep the truth of the murders hidden and allow herself to be believed to be the culprit even on her death bed. Major plot hole there. It makes more sense to cover up that truth if Eva had a more personal attachment i.e George is one of the culprits.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
4. Maria\'s connections to Beatrice. If Beatrice is Shannon, what is staying her hand from personally murdering Maria, especially in the parlor in the 1st game? Maria is ALWAYS one of the last casualties in games where Beatrice is in control. In addition, she tends to die almost IMMEDIATELY after Rosa dies in games where Beatrice is not in control. There\'s also Maria\'s comments about the \
to:
4. Maria\\\'s connections to Beatrice. If Beatrice is Shannon, what is staying her hand from personally murdering Maria, especially in the parlor in the 1st game? Maria is ALWAYS one of the last casualties in games where Beatrice is in control. In addition, she tends to die almost IMMEDIATELY after Rosa dies in games where Beatrice is not in control. There\\\'s also Maria\\\'s comments about the \\\"white witch\\\" and \\\"black witch\\\" in Rosa along with Maria\\\'s own larval split personality issues. As seen in the 7th game, Maria can recognize \\\"Beatrice\\\" by how she acts and in fact is the only person to have met Beatrice outside the island (4th game). Yes this scene is from the magical perspective, there is some important symbolic meaning in all of this. Rosa always tries to make up with Maria shortly after doing something bad to her, and on the island, \\\"Beatrice\\\" shows up shorty after Maria is abused. In the case of the Sakutaro incident, what this represents is Rosa \\\"breaking the rules\\\" regarding Beatrice because she\\\'s realized that she\\\'s truly crossed a line that should never have been crossed and right now \\\"Beatrice\\\" is the only person that will be able to get through to Maria.
5. Beatrice being obscessed with the rules (seen in the meta world and in the 6th game). It\\\'s interesting that Rosa has aspects of this in her as well, showing itself in the 5th game when she was getting pissed when the siblings weren\\\'t honoring the rules of the witch\\\'s epitaph. In addition, since Shannon knows the legend of Beatrice very well, if she is indeed the culprit, then in the 3rd game, Shkannontrice is BREAKING HER OWN RULES, which is inconsistent with the character of Beatrice.
6. Erika actually sees Shannon and Kanon at the same time in the 5th game.
7. \\\"Yasu\\\" supposedly falling down a cliff as an infant and suffering mere reproductive harm is medically impossible. I should know, my background is in biological studies. Upon the slim chance that \\\"Yasu\\\" would even survive (those odds are infinitely small at best), that infant would have broken bones everywhere (even being generous this does not take the especially vunreble \\\"fontenel\\\" region at the top of an infant\\\'s skull into account), likely brain damage, resulting in someone who is pretty much permanately disabled.
5. Beatrice being obscessed with the rules (seen in the meta world and in the 6th game). It\\\'s interesting that Rosa has aspects of this in her as well, showing itself in the 5th game when she was getting pissed when the siblings weren\\\'t honoring the rules of the witch\\\'s epitaph. In addition, since Shannon knows the legend of Beatrice very well, if she is indeed the culprit, then in the 3rd game, Shkannontrice is BREAKING HER OWN RULES, which is inconsistent with the character of Beatrice.
6. Erika actually sees Shannon and Kanon at the same time in the 5th game.
7. \\\"Yasu\\\" supposedly falling down a cliff as an infant and suffering mere reproductive harm is medically impossible. I should know, my background is in biological studies. Upon the slim chance that \\\"Yasu\\\" would even survive (those odds are infinitely small at best), that infant would have broken bones everywhere (even being generous this does not take the especially vunreble \\\"fontenel\\\" region at the top of an infant\\\'s skull into account), likely brain damage, resulting in someone who is pretty much permanately disabled.
