RLNice on Sep 9th 2012 at 10:27:21 AM
Last Edited By:
Discar on Feb 6th 2018 at 2:13:55 PM
Page Type: Trope
When you have a young and/or inexperienced (and often idealistic) character who is eager to join a group of warriors or adventurers on a big battle or other dangerous undertaking, but they are refused by their older, more experienced (and sometimes more cynical) peers for a variety of reasons, usually out of concern for their safety, because they don't want the younger character descending down the same dangerous life that the older character leads, of if the character is a female who wants to be an Action Girl, plain old sexism.
One common plot element: after being denied, the rookie sneaks out and gets involved in the fighting anyway, leading to:
- Having to be rescued by the protagonists.
- Getting killed by the enemy.
- Succeeding, thus showing that he did have what it takes.
- DOOM: Repercussions of Evil: This is the motivation for why protagonist John Stalvern wanted to join the marines, despite his father dissuading him by saying he would be killed by demons.
- Peter Jackson's remake of King Kong: Jimmy wants to help on the expedition to save Ann Darrow, but his father figure Hayes doesn't let him.
- The Lord of the Rings: Merry and Eowyn both want to join the battle of Minas Tirith but have to sneak in with the rest of the Rohirrim, since them joining the fight is met with disapproval from the others due to being a hobbit and a woman, respectively.
- The Matrix Revolutions. The Kid is only 16 years old but joins the Corps to fight the Machines. Captain Mifune tells him he can't serve because the minimum age is 18, but relents when the Kid points out that the Machines won't care how old he is, they'll kill him whether he fights them or not.
- Another example pops up in the 2001 remake of Planet of the Apes. ZCE
- Elenium: Played with. Sparhawk told a young knight to guard Sephrenia, but agreed to let him take part in the battle (his first) when Sephrenia said she didn't need a guard. The knight was then killed by Adus.
- Reflections of Eterna: Lampshaded, deconstructed, and reconstructed again in a short succession in book one. A young officer under First Marshall Roque Alva's command is eager to take on the enemy and eventually defies his orders to give battle. The attack goes bad, so Alva brings his troops to flank and rout the enemy, saving the young officer, only to have him court-marshaled for insubordination later. When other officers point out that Alva used him as a bait intentionally, he just shrugs and tells him that had the rookie obeyed his orders, he would still be alive—but if he disobeyed them and WON, he'd be made a Marshall someday.
- Warrior Cats: All new apprentices are eager to go into battle but their mentors won't allow them till they've had proper battle training.
- When Roy Harper is first introduced he wants to be a vigilante just like The Hood. Despite not having superpowers or any formal fight training, he kept putting himself in dangerous situations in attempt to stop the bad guys. Eventually, Oliver has to actually shoot him in the thigh with an arrow just to keep him from confronting the bad guys on his own. Eventually, once Oliver feels comfortable revealing his alter ego, he takes Roy under his wing and trains him as a sidekick.
- When Laurel takes up the mantle of Black Canary, she routinely gets beat up by the bad guys she's pursuing and has to be rescued. She accuses Oliver of treating her differently because she's a girl, but he reminds her that he fought as equals with the original Black Canary, Sarah, and he only babies Laurel because she literally has no fight training or the necessary skills to protect herself. Once she starts training with Ted Grant, Oliver is more accepting of her in the field.
- The new recruits (Wild Dog, Black Canary- Dinah Drake, Mister Terrific, Artemis, and Ragman) are brought on as replacement members of Team Arrow. Oliver and Diggle work to train them but they eventually complain of being babied. Oliver challenges them to a challenge to fight their way past him and ring a bell he put on a table. Five on one? Easy enough, right? He summarily puts everyone of them on their asses and isn't even breathing hard afterwards. Afterward, they decide maybe they're not actually ready to be in the field.
- Dexter: Dexter takes on a mentee, Miguel, and teaches him the tricks and trade of being a vigilante serial killer. Miguel really enjoys it and is eager to kill, but is not very good at vetting his targets. Miguel and Dexter eventually have a falling out when Miguel murders a victim who is not a criminal and has a personal, easily traced connection to Miguel.
- Happens to Tom Mason's son Matt a lot in Falling Skies. ZCE
- The Flash (2014): When Wally got his powers, he immediately wanted to go out with Barry and fight crime. Part of his impatience stemmed from his girlfriend Jesse getting her powers first even though they were hit by the particle blast at the same time. He was jealous of her powers and afraid he would never gain any. Despite his enthusiasm, he was benched by Barry, Iris, and Joe who were afraid that he'd get hurt like Barry often did when he had to learn on the job. They also had trouble accepting the fact that he was no longer just the baby of the family, but would eventually be in the field fighting along side the rest of Team Flash.
- Supernatural: The season 2 episode "No Exit" centers around Jo Harvelle who wants to be a hunter like her deceased father, Bill. Her mother, Ellen, doesn't want her to be in the field. Jo finds a case and her mother gives it to Sam and Dean instead. Jo sneaks out to work the case anyway. Jo is irritated when Sam and Dean insist on helping her work the case, but on more than one occasion Dean has to point something out that Jo doesn't know. Eventually, Jo accuses Dean of being sexist and treating her like less than a hunter because she's a woman. Dean insists women can be hunters and that he's treating her like a rookie with no experience. Sure enough, Jo is kidnapped by the Monster of the Week and has to be rescued although she does ultimately assist in defeating the baddie.
- Dreamfall: The Longest Journey: Brynn is very eager to prove his worth to the rebel cause but his more experienced commanders Chawan and April keep him on a short leash, much to his frustration.
- Final Fantasy X: The NPC Gatta is a young Crusader who is very eager to get into battle, particularly because he believes 100% that the current Crusader operation is sure to destroy Sin, the Eldritch Abomination that has ravaged the world for the last thousand years. As such, Gatta sees the upcoming battle as essentially the last chance at glory before bringing peace to the world. Gatta's superior officer and mentor, Luzzu, has a much more realistic assessment and knows the battle could easily go wrong, so he puts Gatta on guard duty safely away from the front lines. You can influence Gatta into leaving his post and going to fight... which will result in him being killed.
- Gears of War: The first two Carmine brothers, though their big brother Clayton is a bit more experienced and lives a lot longer.
- You can do this in Mass Effect 2, if you stop the very young, very obviously inexperienced boy from signing up as a mercenary to fight Archangel. If you do, he'll eventually send you an email and thank you for saving his life.
- The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt: Ciri, Geralt's unexpected child, is being trained at Kahr Mohren to be a Witcher. She's very anxious to get out on The Path and irritated that neither Geralt nor Vessimir consider her ready. However, it's because she's a) still a kid b) doesn't have the mutations that make a Witcher very hard to kill, so she's needs to be as prepared as they can humanly make her.
- Schlock Mercenary has Toughs running into this problem and promptly extracting the solution out of it:
Tagon: You said most of the new recruits went charging down the hall, right? That's great! Enthusiastic cannon fodder like that just needs cautious leadership.Shodan: And where do I find that?Tagon: Promote everyone who hung back to corporal.
- Transformers Prime: Smokescreen, who was most excited to fight the 'cons when they attacked his station at Iacon.
Feedback: 40 replies