This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.
Working Title: The House: From YKTTW
Are we sure about the House example?- because it seems a lot like House is always wrong for his first two guesses in any given episode. Doesn't really seem to fit the trope.
Grimace: As the quote says though, he's always eventually right, which is all a TV Series can be expected to remember in the end (sure, he biopsies the shit out of the patient first, but that never seems to cause any real damage).