It turns out that people have opinions about just how well works of fiction turn out. Go figure.
We figured we had better give folks a place to talk about those opinions, since we don't want that sort of judgement in the Main articles. So here we are. This is a list of the most recently edited reviews. Opinions belong to the writers. TVTropes itself obviously doesn't have an opinion about good or bad storytelling. We leave all that to these folks.
|
Work / Review Title Troper |
Date/ Comments |
|---|---|
|
Allen Gregory /
Stay away from this show, period.
MelancholyUtopia |
04/24/2014 12:00:23 1 |
|
The Walking Dead /
A Middling Soap Opera for Dudes.
morninglight |
04/23/2014 05:56:15 |
|
Transformers /
Sin City by itsu-sual, a quick fun fanfic
DreadPirateCat |
04/23/2014 02:23:50 |
|
Deadpool Kills The Marvel Universe /
All downhill from here...
Asger |
03/19/2015 22:36:45 17 |
|
Wasta Est /
Very Dark and Seriously Good
NinjaMarshwiggle |
04/22/2014 22:33:41 |
|
The Beauty of Scarlet /
On How Meiling Became Hong Meiling
Materioptikon |
04/22/2014 19:08:05 |
|
Dredd /
A Dredd film done right.
TuefelHundenIV |
04/22/2014 17:24:11 1 |
|
Leonardo Di Caprio /
Shutter Island
caladgo |
04/22/2014 16:17:40 |
|
Pippins Diary /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/23/2014 10:48:30 1 |
|
Of Archery And Stuff /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 13:55:21 |
|
Whats Up Doc /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 13:53:12 |
|
Chronicles Of The Going Home Club /
Spread the Joy.
christopherweebling1 |
04/22/2014 13:52:44 |
|
Shouldve Thought Of That One Bori /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 13:52:20 |
|
How To Save Your Marriage /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 13:48:30 |
|
The Mushroom Middle Earths Finest News Source /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 13:47:20 |
|
Malcolm Of The Rings /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 13:22:59 |
|
Never Leave Fanfiction Lying Around /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 13:05:37 |
|
Diary Of The Trials And Tribulations Of Saruman /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 13:00:16 |
|
How To Write A Lord Of The Rings Badfic /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/22/2014 12:58:09 |
|
Yu Gi Oh Arc V /
Patience...
raptyr |
04/22/2014 03:26:53 |
|
Tape 407 /
Not bad...until the last 5 seconds
Hyrin |
04/21/2014 22:10:43 |
|
Brave New World /
A Book to Change Perspectives
Biblius |
09/09/2018 18:13:11 4 |
|
Nine Men And A Little Lady /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 14:18:13 |
|
The Game Of The Gods /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 14:17:06 |
|
The Very Secret Diaries /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 14:13:15 |
|
Walt Disney Presents The Lord Of The Rings /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 14:11:11 |
|
Thundera Tiger /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 11:03:28 |
|
Nili /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 10:59:12 |
|
The Fourth Age Total War /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 10:57:29 |
|
Shirebound /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 10:55:11 |
|
Baylor /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 10:53:30 |
|
Morwen Tindomerel /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 10:51:19 |
|
Policing Middle Earth /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/21/2014 10:47:06 |
|
Slowflake /
Entertaining to some people, just not to me
magictoaster |
04/21/2014 07:13:32 |
|
Any Wish /
Genuinely Creepy.
jarxon6 |
04/20/2014 20:19:33 |
|
Thunder Cats 2011 /
Starts strong, ends badly
Beatman1 |
05/16/2014 21:29:57 3 |
|
Splint /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/20/2014 17:09:53 |
|
The Ugly Duckling Of Dol Amroth /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/20/2014 17:08:30 |
|
The Healer And The Warrior /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/20/2014 17:06:51 |
|
Snowdrops And Bluebells /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/20/2014 17:03:06 |
|
The Price Of Freedom /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/20/2014 16:00:34 |
|
All That I Had /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/20/2014 15:57:22 |
|
The Heads Of One Thousand Goblins A Love Story /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/20/2014 15:55:28 |
|
The Kings Surgeon /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/20/2014 15:50:27 |
|
Moribito Guardian Of The Spirit /
It's Got it all... Except an Audience
MiinU |
04/20/2014 14:40:25 |
|
Super Mario 3 D World /
A fantastic distillation of everything Mario should be about
ElectricNova |
12/11/2014 18:31:26 2 |
|
Transcendence /
An insult to both science and sci-fi
Massimo |
05/03/2014 12:56:06 2 |
|
Kill La Kill /
Magical Girl Told as Shonen Action
Wryte |
04/20/2014 01:17:26 |
|
Noah /
Good, but not without its problems
somerandomdude |
04/19/2014 22:17:04 |
|
The Black Company In Middle Earth /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/19/2014 20:30:05 |
|
Final Fantasy Tactics /
Final Fantasy Tactics -- save early, save often
Audobonible |
04/19/2014 15:29:52 |
|
Enders Game /
Good Film Burdened By Unanswered Questions And Mary Tzu
Mr.Movie |
04/14/2016 09:18:24 6 |
|
Captain America The Winter Soldier /
Complete And Utter Dross
TheAussieBlue |
09/14/2014 20:14:14 27 |
|
Son Of Batman /
pretty good overall.
darkrage6 |
06/30/2014 08:25:22 6 |
|
Captain America The Winter Soldier /
The cast is great and the effects are good, but the story leaves a lot to be desired.
KMA10k |
04/19/2014 23:30:34 2 |
|
Persona The Connection /
2 out of 5 stars
Dman163 |
04/18/2014 17:30:34 |
|
The Green Knight /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/18/2014 17:24:50 |
|
Death Seeker /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/18/2014 17:24:00 |
|
Where The Grass Grows Green I We May Yet Stand /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/18/2014 17:22:09 |
|
The Measure Of A Man /
Moved comments
Kernigh |
04/18/2014 17:21:04 |
