What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Main/BEARSAreBadNews

 

R.G.
topic
11:18:13 AM Sep 25th 2013
I'm surprised there haven't been movies with bears the size of King Kong or Godzilla.
primeyandereheika
06:10:04 AM Feb 11th 2014
I believe Son of Kong had a giant bear in it at some point.
MrMediaGuy
topic
07:06:18 PM Jun 20th 2012
All right, who changed the name? I thought it was Everything's Worse With Bears!
Telcontar
moderator
12:25:39 AM Jun 21st 2012
The thing is, it was a snowclone and that's not good. The current name is clear and not a snowclone.
MadCat221
03:05:55 PM Jun 28th 2012
Well, at least the name change wasn't Trope Name Blandification...
painocus
06:46:15 PM Sep 9th 2012
As I understood it a snowclone is only bad if it a) does not work as a title independently of what it clones, or b) is unrelated to what it clones and thus cause confusion. How was "Everything's worse with bears" guilty of either of these? Most of the rest of Everything's Better With Indexes consists of this kind of snowclones, so why was this one singled out? Also someone has to rename and at-least edit the Everything's Worse With Snowclones article now that it's second example (itself) is no longer an example... this all seams to me to be so much work and discord for so little benefit.
kraas
08:23:44 AM Sep 18th 2012
edited by kraas
Everything's Lamer with Name Changes. Furthermore...there should be a Site News link on the front page with a list of tropes up for name changes so everyone can at least go in and voice their complaints before the names are inevitably changed to something Captain Obvious would say.
mjijm
06:48:16 PM Nov 28th 2012
Especially where snowclones are actually only a problem if, as said on the administrivia page, "If your trope title completely relies on the idea that "surely, everyone read that other page- I just have to make a pun with it"," it seems like the funny name (and crazy-overdosed link) would be perfectly fine at connotating that everything is worse with bears.

(also I think it was the first "everything's worse" title, so it wouldn't be a snowclone anyhow)
TheArchitectWriterXIII
10:03:39 PM Dec 3rd 2012
Everything's Worse with Bears > Bears Are Bad News. Seriously, there's no need to change them. They both imply the same thing so function is irrelevant. If we go purely on which sounds better, it's the original title because it's funny and an in-joke of the Everything's Better/Worse With Tropes.
IndirectActiveTransport
08:13:08 PM Mar 9th 2014
Yeah, I have to agree. Not only was it first (thus not a snowclone, everything that came after was at fault) but completely understandable on its own. The only one that needed changing was Everything Is Even Worse With Sharks, just because it was one word longer than the others.
SeptimusHeap
moderator
11:40:57 PM Mar 9th 2014
The first name according to the forum thread was actually the Monkeys one. Plus, the other side of the problem with the Everythings Better With X tropes is that they were using the snowclone differently.
back to Main/BEARSAreBadNews

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy