Discussion History Horrible / Music

Go To

[003] Analyzing Current Version

Changed line(s) 1 from:

The issue with the statement Audience Reaction Trope is that we are generalizing how the audience reacts? It certainly isn't in a protective attribute, she's never put to that effect by the author in the manga.

to:

The issue with the statement Audience Reaction Trope is that we are generalizing how the audience reacts, and even this generalization does not work. It certainly isn\'t in a protective attribute, she\'s never put to that effect by the author in the manga. If she is moe, then it is in a functionaly meaningless definition of the word, rather than the intention of the meaning is. A lot of examples here have that issue, and I\'d curb them out if I had time.

Changed line(s) 3 from:

Maybe the anime, but I don't believe the anime is getting discussed.

to:

Maybe in the anime, but I don\'t believe the anime is getting discussed.

[002] JHM

7th Apr '17 at 09:20:20 AM

Changed line(s) 1 from:

Two years on and this still hasn't been dealt with? Seriously. This entry is almost entirely founded on Erlewine's review and Joel's regrets about the album, while completely ignoring the fact that not only does the album have a fanbase, as attested to by the Head Heritage column, but seems to be regarded by most modern listeners as... [[http://ultimateclassicrock.com/billy-joel-attila/ not that bad, honestly.]] On Allmusic itself, [[http://www.allmusic.com/album/attila-mw0000815795/user-reviews the mean score across 47 user reviews is 3/5, solidly average,]] with about half of the people on the page disliking it overall and half having enjoyed it. What this indicates to me is not a dreadful album, but a rather polarising one—as one might expect, given the circumstances.

to:

Two years on and this still hasn\'t been dealt with? Seriously. This entry is almost entirely founded on Erlewine\'s review and Joel\'s regrets about the album, while completely ignoring the fact that not only does the album have a fanbase, as attested to by the Head Heritage column, but seems to be regarded by most modern listeners as... [[http://ultimateclassicrock.com/billy-joel-attila/ not that bad, honestly.]] On Allmusic itself, [[http://www.allmusic.com/album/attila-mw0000815795/user-reviews the mean score across 47 user reviews is 3/5, solidly average,]] with about half of the people on the page disliking it overall and half having enjoyed it. What this indicates to me is not a dreadful album, but a rather polarising one—as one might expect, given the circumstances.

P.S. On top of that, the cited video review basically declares it a gem of pure NarmCharm, so...

[001] JHM

7th Apr '17 at 09:05:10 AM

Changed line(s) 1 from:

Two years on and this still hasn't been dealt with? Seriously. This entry is almost entirely founded on Erlewine's review and Joel's regrets about the album, while completely ignoring the fact that not only does the album have a fanbase, as attested to by the Head Heritage column, but seems to be regarded by most modern listeners as... [[http://ultimateclassicrock.com/billy-joel-attila/ not that bad, honestly.]] On Allmusic itself, the mean score across 47 user reviews is 3/5, solidly average, with about half of the people on the page disliking it overall and half having enjoyed it. What this indicates to me is not a dreadful album, but a rather polarising one—as one might expect, given the circumstances.

to:

Top